Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Never to drive with my husband again

109 replies

FrankReynolds · 05/06/2022 13:32

Learning to drive, pay for my own lessons. Because of Covid backlog, instructor has recommended an hour of practice driving a week between lessons because lessons aren't as regular as they would be under normal circumstances.

So husband got me insured on car, bought L plates and said he'd take me for some practice. I am anxious by nature, hence only just learning now. We've been put together 3 or 4 times for some practice and today has been the worst session yet. As soon as I get in the driving seat, he's white-knuckle clutching the door handle every time. We had gone to a supermarket and I was going to drive us home. We live fairly rurally, and it's an uncomplicated drive home that I've done a few times with my instructor. So at almost deserted end of supermarket car park, I needed to reverse out of parking bay around to the right and then steer round to the left. About 8 meters behind us there was a parked car at a right angle to ours. I start the engine, he's already chanting "sloooowwwwlly" so I reverse slowly, steadily steering right when suddenly he bellows "BRRRRAAAAAAAKKKKEEE!!". Rattled, I smoothly but quickly stop. I look behind us, parked car is still 3 meters away. I ask him what on Earth the matter is, he says I wasn't steering quickly enough. So I say "well you said slowly, so that's what I did. Which is it that you want?!" He then shoves open passenger door, rips off L plates, rips open driver door and orders me to get out immediately. I comply and we sit in silence all the way home.

He's like this each time, bellowing and holding on for dear life and snatching the steering wheel. This is on 30/40 mph flat and non-windy roads but he acts like we're in GTA and I'm driving like a maniac. I'm not, I'm always below speed limit and am getting really smooth with gear changes. I'm tired of being treated this way and he's now said I'm being taken off the insurance. I was driving for less than 30 seconds today before he lost it. He did the same to me on a corner once in front of a crowded pub because I stalled when trying a hill start. I was so embarrassed.

I suggested my dad take me instead in our car but he said no, we'd be breaking the law because me and Dad "wouldn't have the owners permission". He turns into this repugnant person that I don't know and he talks to me the same way he does our two young children. I've been trying not to take his help for granted but he's such a control freak and I come home from our practice with aching arms from tensed muscles.

OP posts:
Clymene · 05/06/2022 14:03

FrankReynolds · 05/06/2022 13:50

Tbf I haven't contributed financially to the car at all so far because he's the only driver. I'm a SAHM and get an allowance along with child benefit and some UC. I'm studying atm as well as full time mum so maybe it'll be a shared asset once I'm earning and a valid member of society (this is how I feel quite a lot of the time)

You've got a bigger problem than just driving lessons.

SunshineLollipopsAndRainbows · 05/06/2022 14:03

I was going to add something similar to Babdoc - it sounds like there’s more going on with how your DH treats you & your DC. Maybe time for a serious chat.

iklboo · 05/06/2022 14:01

DH is a driving instructor. He can always tell when a pupil has been out with a parent / partner as they do quite a few things wrong (or not on the current test) or ask him if he's sure something as 'X said you do it like this'. He says 'would you be happy with X performing surgery on you? No? Well, since this is my trained profession and not X's, who do you think is giving you the right instructions?'

One pupil came to him after her dad had been teaching her and she failed her test because she had been taught stuff so out of date and not learned any of the things (manoeuvres & questions, following sat nav etc) that are on the current one.

Babdoc · 05/06/2022 13:59

Do you have any calm, laid back friends, who could take you out for practice sessions in their own car? My DD used to get v nervous and failed 3 driving tests, but her current partner is an absolute sweetie who got her driving all over central Edinburgh in his new mini without once raising his voice! She passed her test with no bother.
As a separate issue, you need to consider whether your DH is bordering on coercive control territory - the power balance in your marriage seems skewed all one way. Giving you an “allowance” and forbidding you the use of the family car for lessons, really sounds deeply unpleasant and worrying.

user1497787065 · 05/06/2022 13:58

I was a bit like this with my DC. My DDs instructor suggested I accompanied her on a lesson. Just sitting quietly in the back of the car. Maybe this would be good for your DH. It did help.

SunshineLollipopsAndRainbows · 05/06/2022 13:56

Hi OP - my DH is a driving instructor. He’s suggesting that your DH sits in the back of the car when you have a lesson. He might be acting like he is out of fear. I had huge rows with my Dad when he took me out & ended up in tears then getting out of the car at a busy junction & refusing to go any further! If your DH hears how your instructor speaks to you & how he/she anticipates possible dodgy situations then nips them in the bud, it might help your DH when he takes you out.

prettyteapotsplease · 05/06/2022 13:56

Just because someone can drive it doesn't follow that they can impart that knowledge expertly, which is why a good instructor is always best. If your horrible DH behaves like that I'd stick with the proper lessons and refuse to go out with him until you get to test standard.

An old friend of mine passed her test but her DH still behaved like he was instructing her when they went out. She stopped the car and told him that she'd passed the test now and if he didn't shut up he could jolly well walk home. I hope your DH doesn't follow suit OP but I have my doubts.

ImAvingOops · 05/06/2022 13:56

I'd love to witness the conversation he'd be having with the police, if you were able to put your dad on the insurance without his consent and used your shared marital asset!
The registered keeper of a car is not necessarily the same as the legal owner, so worth looking. Years ago I bought our family car, even though I couldn't drive at the time. First car I paid for with my money and another time DH was working and I went to look at cars with my dad and ended up getting one and paying from our shared money. But it was my name on the paperwork because I had physically purchased it.
Either way though, he'd struggle to get the police to take him seriously and he'd totally blow up his own life. He's a prick for even going there though!

KettrickenSmiled · 05/06/2022 13:55

Initially I was thinking of the old adage about NEVER being taught to drive by a family member or spouse. But ... this problem isn't limited to driving practice, is it? I think your H has form for being a bit of a sergeant major.

I suggested my dad take me instead in our car but he said no, we'd be breaking the law because me and Dad "wouldn't have the owners permission"

He then shoves open passenger door, rips off L plates, rips open driver door and orders me to get out immediately. I comply

He's like this each time, bellowing ...

What would have happened, when he lost his temper & "ordered" you out of the car, if you has chosen not to comply?
And where TF does he get the notion that he is sole owner of the car, & it's within his gift to refuse your dad permission? You are married, so the car belongs to you equally. I know there has to be one legal named owner, but your H making a song & dance about this is ridiculous - he's creating obstructions, almost as if he doesn't WANT to have anyone else teach you.

Does he enjoy making you tense & unhappy?
I come home from our practice with aching arms from tensed muscles.

And why the hell are you allowing him to get away with this?
He turns into this repugnant person that I don't know and he talks to me the same way he does our two young children.
I'm not asking about how he speaks to you. I'm asking about why you feel it's unacceptable to be spoken to like this - but it's ok for him to do it to your DC?
Who is sticking up for those children?
Who is telling their father to stop being horrible to them?

Vapeyvapevape · 05/06/2022 13:52

I was the same with my daughter 😳. I just couldn't help but do a sharp intake of breath every time she braked sharply or got too close to the car in front. Even though she was doing the speed limit it seemed much too fast and I kept telling her to slow down. Driving instructors have nerves of steel and quite often dual controls so they at least can take over if necessary.

SpacePotato · 05/06/2022 13:51

What happens when you pass your test? Will ge refuse to allow you to drive HIS car?

iRun2eatCake · 05/06/2022 13:51

FrankReynolds · 05/06/2022 13:47

Dad has van which doesn't have a back window and I'm nowhere near ready for that yet. That's why I suggested ours, because in theory I'd be driving it on days he's not using it

That's the issue.... he doesn't want you gaining your independence and driving "his" car.

FrankReynolds · 05/06/2022 13:50

Tbf I haven't contributed financially to the car at all so far because he's the only driver. I'm a SAHM and get an allowance along with child benefit and some UC. I'm studying atm as well as full time mum so maybe it'll be a shared asset once I'm earning and a valid member of society (this is how I feel quite a lot of the time)

OP posts:
OneForTheRoadThen · 05/06/2022 13:50

Wow you poor thing, he sounds awful and no help whatsoever. I passed my test a couple of weeks ago and DP let me practice regularly in his car, in London and often with my 2 small children in the back and he never once showed any inpatients let alone shouted. I wouldn't have been able to continue if he acted like your husband as it's nerve wracking enough.

Do you have someone else who can help? I got learner insurance with Veygo and you can insure yourself temporarily on any car. I do understand about not wanting to buy extra lesson as they're so expensive. I hope you manage to find someone who could help. It's definitely worth it.

ElenaSt · 05/06/2022 13:49

I'm laid back but when I took my son out to let him practise driving in my car I became like your husband!

It's not a good idea to let someone emotionally close to you learn to drive.

FrankReynolds · 05/06/2022 13:48

Hiimblahblah · 05/06/2022 13:42

I feel so sorry for you. "Wouldn't have the owners permission"? Wtf is that? Is he trying to say you'd be stealing the car or something?

Yep, I'd be a car thief ffs

OP posts:
ImAvingOops · 05/06/2022 13:47

I'm very concerned that he views the family car as his, rather than a shared asset. He's treating you like a child, telling you that you can't put your dad on the insurance, as if all decisions regarding the car are his to make alone. I'd be having serious words about his attitude because that's seriously not on and would be making me re-evaluate the relationship.
Fair enough for him not to be comfortable taking you out, but shouting at you and stropping is bullying behaviour. A husband who isn't comfortable taking you out, can still manage to speak to you respectfully and encourage you in other ways, not destroy your confidence like this.
Honestly, if my husband spoke to me like that he'd be living elsewhere for the foreseeable future

FrankReynolds · 05/06/2022 13:47

Blowyourowntrumpet · 05/06/2022 13:42

Trying to teach someone to drive in a car without dual controls, when you aren't a qualified instructor, is really stressful. He shouldn't be shouting at you though. Does your dad have a car that he could take you out in?

Dad has van which doesn't have a back window and I'm nowhere near ready for that yet. That's why I suggested ours, because in theory I'd be driving it on days he's not using it

OP posts:
Onlyforcake · 05/06/2022 13:46

My Dad was completely incapable of supporting my mother to learn to drive. Its outside some people's skill set.

FrankReynolds · 05/06/2022 13:45

Georgeskitchen · 05/06/2022 13:40

My driving instructor always said that family shouldn't teach family to drive, or take them out practicing. Foolishly I ignored this and went out practicing with my Dad.
He was a total nightmare, everything the professional instructor was teaching me was wrong, in my dad's opinion.
After one particularly awful practice session when I almost ran over 3 dogs, an old lady and a lamppost, I got out of the car and swore to never set foot in a car with him ever again 😁😁

I would understand my husband's reaction if i was close to running over cats etc but it's been uneventful and just reinforcing what I've learned

OP posts:
LuaDipa · 05/06/2022 13:44

5foot5 · 05/06/2022 13:39

Wow what a git ! Does he consider the car his, then, not the family car?

Could you get your Dad to put you on his insurance so you can practice in his car?

He turns into this repugnant person that I don't know and he talks to me the same way he does our two young children

Does he often behave like an obnoxious bully? It strikes me that he is someone who like to exert control and you learning to drive will in some way challenge this control and help you assert your independence, hence his behaviour designed to discourage you

Exactly what I thought tbh. Why else would he prevent your df taking you out.

Blowyourowntrumpet · 05/06/2022 13:42

Trying to teach someone to drive in a car without dual controls, when you aren't a qualified instructor, is really stressful. He shouldn't be shouting at you though. Does your dad have a car that he could take you out in?

Hiimblahblah · 05/06/2022 13:42

I feel so sorry for you. "Wouldn't have the owners permission"? Wtf is that? Is he trying to say you'd be stealing the car or something?

iklboo · 05/06/2022 13:40

Is he trying to put you off so you don't actually learn to drive? Scared a taste of freedom and independence will have you running for the hills? Sounds like it to me.

Georgeskitchen · 05/06/2022 13:40

My driving instructor always said that family shouldn't teach family to drive, or take them out practicing. Foolishly I ignored this and went out practicing with my Dad.
He was a total nightmare, everything the professional instructor was teaching me was wrong, in my dad's opinion.
After one particularly awful practice session when I almost ran over 3 dogs, an old lady and a lamppost, I got out of the car and swore to never set foot in a car with him ever again 😁😁

Swipe left for the next trending thread