Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Never to drive with my husband again

109 replies

FrankReynolds · 05/06/2022 13:32

Learning to drive, pay for my own lessons. Because of Covid backlog, instructor has recommended an hour of practice driving a week between lessons because lessons aren't as regular as they would be under normal circumstances.

So husband got me insured on car, bought L plates and said he'd take me for some practice. I am anxious by nature, hence only just learning now. We've been put together 3 or 4 times for some practice and today has been the worst session yet. As soon as I get in the driving seat, he's white-knuckle clutching the door handle every time. We had gone to a supermarket and I was going to drive us home. We live fairly rurally, and it's an uncomplicated drive home that I've done a few times with my instructor. So at almost deserted end of supermarket car park, I needed to reverse out of parking bay around to the right and then steer round to the left. About 8 meters behind us there was a parked car at a right angle to ours. I start the engine, he's already chanting "sloooowwwwlly" so I reverse slowly, steadily steering right when suddenly he bellows "BRRRRAAAAAAAKKKKEEE!!". Rattled, I smoothly but quickly stop. I look behind us, parked car is still 3 meters away. I ask him what on Earth the matter is, he says I wasn't steering quickly enough. So I say "well you said slowly, so that's what I did. Which is it that you want?!" He then shoves open passenger door, rips off L plates, rips open driver door and orders me to get out immediately. I comply and we sit in silence all the way home.

He's like this each time, bellowing and holding on for dear life and snatching the steering wheel. This is on 30/40 mph flat and non-windy roads but he acts like we're in GTA and I'm driving like a maniac. I'm not, I'm always below speed limit and am getting really smooth with gear changes. I'm tired of being treated this way and he's now said I'm being taken off the insurance. I was driving for less than 30 seconds today before he lost it. He did the same to me on a corner once in front of a crowded pub because I stalled when trying a hill start. I was so embarrassed.

I suggested my dad take me instead in our car but he said no, we'd be breaking the law because me and Dad "wouldn't have the owners permission". He turns into this repugnant person that I don't know and he talks to me the same way he does our two young children. I've been trying not to take his help for granted but he's such a control freak and I come home from our practice with aching arms from tensed muscles.

OP posts:
Zingy123 · 06/06/2022 08:08

It is so stressful supervising driving. I have supervised my husband and DD when they were having lessons. Not everyone can do it.

BigFatLiar · 06/06/2022 07:59

PinkButtercups · 05/06/2022 22:06

Sounds like FA.

Depends on how they arrange their finances. We have pooled family money and we each get an allowance (pocket money as OH would say). Not much its just for odds and ends. We all sort our finances out different.

PinkButtercups · 05/06/2022 22:06

EVHead · 05/06/2022 19:33

You get an allowance?!

Sounds like FA.

Momicrone · 05/06/2022 21:56

Vivio - I did

MrsEthelMorningtonCrescent · 05/06/2022 21:34

Tbf I haven't contributed financially to the car at all so far because he's the only driver. I'm a SAHM and get an allowance along with child benefit and some UC. I'm studying atm as well as full time mum so maybe it'll be a shared asset once I'm earning and a valid member of society (this is how I feel quite a lot of the time)

I feel that this is probably yet another of those financial abuse situations where the studying SAHM is not considered a fully paid-up member of the team despite her contribution to the childcare and running of the household, and whose financial situation is controlled and in the long term likely to be damaged. OP, if you are married, it is already a shared asset even though it is in his name, his legal possession, and he does have to be the one who adds people to the insurance etc. unless he's given permission with the insurance company for you to do so as well. If you are not married, your situation is more precarious. OP, get advice and plan carefully so that you are not dependent on this man for longer than is absolutely necessary, and so that you don't end up in low paid/part time work with low savings and poor pension prospects while he's fine. This happens too often. If he thinks this now, he is unlikely to change and you may find yourself screwed over in 1, 5, 10 or 25 years' time.

EVHead · 05/06/2022 19:33

You get an allowance?!

Pyewhacket · 05/06/2022 19:25

I think that's quite common. It was my grandmother who taught me to drive both a tractor and a Land Rover.

Probably not a good idea to go out with him again so try and find somebody else or just stick with your instructor.

Once you have passed you can tell him to sit in the back and face the window.

ImAvingOops · 05/06/2022 18:24

They are both liable for repairs though, since it is a marital asset and his money is her money too since she is a sahp looking after their kids. That's kind of the deal when a couple decide that one of them should sah and withholding access to money/car is financial abuse.
But the problem isn't that he thinks it's risky or doesn't feel comfortable - not one person on this thread thinks he should take her out practicing if he doesn't feel confident to do so. The problem is the way he is speaking to her and treating her like a child who has no right to an equal say. He very much views it as his car alone, his money etc and that's not right.

Vivi0 · 05/06/2022 17:51

Momicrone · 05/06/2022 17:32

One car in the house should be a family car

It may technically be a “family” car, but that doesn’t mean that any member of the family gets to use the car to do whatever they please. As the only driver in the household, the person who relies on the car for work, the person who drives the family around, the person who bought the car, is liable for any repairs, pays the insurance etc, it’s not outrageous to consider the car as DH’s, but used for the overall benefit of the family.

Any accidents could affect his insurance premiums, no claims bonus, leave him without a car for work, leave the family without a “family” car to get around in. Of course he gets the final say in whether he is willing to take the risk of using the car for driving lessons.

How many of you would seriously take the risk of allowing a non driver to use your (non dual controlled) car to learn to drive in? Not me!

MMMarmite · 05/06/2022 17:46

He turns into this repugnant person that I don't know and he talks to me the same way he does our two young children

I'm worried that your two young children have to put up with this twatish behaviour too. At least you have a choice in the matter.

Topseyt123 · 05/06/2022 17:45

I also agree with @LittleOwl153 and I had no hand at all in teaching our DDs to drive. Mostly neither did DH, although he did take DD1 out a couple of times and they were still on speaking terms when they came back. Neither of them liked it though.

DH and I both had bad experiences being taught to drive by parents and both were adamant that we would not teach our own children as we would rather continue to get on well with them.

Momicrone · 05/06/2022 17:38

It would be a shame to have to own 2 cars just because your dh was being so possessive over a lump of metal

Notanotherwindow · 05/06/2022 17:38

Drivers make the worst passengers. I can't drive with my mum. I make her sit in the back. Even years since I passed she braces against the dashboard at every corner.

Going on the motorway is a special kind of hell.

MIND THAT LORRY!!!!!

Mother, it's FOUR fucking lanes away!

LittleOwl153 · 05/06/2022 17:34

Tbh I think there are 2 different things going on here.

  1. Your husband is not a good passenger for you - before or after your test. I get it I am a terrible passenger. My DH has been driving for 35yrs and I still do the white knuckle thing... the other day I ended up in tears I was so scared. That is not normal its my issue not his. I usually drive so not an issue I've dealt with. BUT my kids know I'm not the person to take them our between lessons - and they are years away yet!!
  1. Your husband is horrible! I would not be happy with him treating me or the kids like that - what happened to basic respect. I've been a SAHM for longer than many as I have disabled child. There is no way I'd put up with being made to feel like that or dh would treat me like that.

Personally I think you need to plan to get rid and get him out of your kids lives before he does some real damage.

Momicrone · 05/06/2022 17:32

One car in the house should be a family car

Topseyt123 · 05/06/2022 17:32

You are a valid member of society. Full time parents are valid members of society.

It may be that your DH is an arse (sounds like it). In which case getting him to supervise you on driving practice while you are learning (and even having him as a passenger when you have passed) is a doubly bad idea.

Personally, I am not convinced parents and husbands/ wives teaching each other or their children to drive is a great idea, but I am probably projecting a fair bit because it really didn't work all that well when my Dad was teaching me. We were both always tense and just couldn't get on over it. I hated learning and until I got myself a professional driving instructor (my Dad had wanted to teach it all himself) I came back in tears from every lesson, and lessons were usually daily when going out with my Dad. Getting myself an instructor made a huge difference, even though I still went out with my Dad. The instructor had a lot more patience and built my confidence in myself much more. My Dad had the opposite effect to that, despite being a good man and having the very best of intentions.

This is about much more than driving with you though, is it not? You need to work out whether or not there is a future for your relationship anyway, but in the meantime I would just rely on your driving lessons. It otherwise isn't worth the tension and the hassle, plus your "D" H sounds like the type who will use it to belittle you.

FrankReynolds · 05/06/2022 17:24

It's not a particularly expensive car but I get that he'd have to pay for any repairs. I think until I'm test-ready, I'll stick to my lessons. It's a shame my instructor doesn't do double lessons or the availability to do a couple a week.

As for the independence thing, I'll have finished my course, have qualified and be job-ready in Jan 24. I'm told that most people walk into a job from their placement so I'm very excited to get independence, my youngest will be at school by then. I can have my own car (which H won't be allowed to use Smile)

OP posts:
BigFatLiar · 05/06/2022 16:48

Full time mums are valid members of society as well.

As for 'an allowance' we've been married 30+ years, both good careers and we both have 'an allowance' for odds and ends. Nothing wrong with having an allowance provided you both realise your a couple and the joint money is for you both. Learning to drive would have been an household expense. It was when the girls learned as was when they got their cars.

Sirzy · 05/06/2022 16:44

I don’t think it’s a male/female thing just a personality thing when it comes to teaching to drive. You can be the best driver but still not comfy teaching someone.

but I agree in this case it sounds like the OPs husband is just an arse

Acheyknees · 05/06/2022 16:36

I think some men are just not able to control their emotions when teaching family members to drive. My father was like this, he took me out once, he was swearing and shouting making out I was really bad at driving - I was a learner!! I came back a wreck with neither of us talking to each other.
Now I'm a parent, I took both mine out to learn to drive which I found stressful but I never swore, shouted or critised. I took them to quiet industrial estates at the weekends to build their confidence. I would never behave like my father did, he was awful.

FOJN · 05/06/2022 16:28

You live quite rurally and he's such a control freak? He gives you an allowance and you don't feel like a valid member of society because you are not currently employed outside the home.

Hmm I can imagine a control freak who treats you like that being quite unsettled at the prospect of you becoming independent with transport and earning money.

If it was simply that he's not cut out to supervise you during driving practice then he wouldn't actively try to prevent you practising with someone else. A decent person would accept they lack the attributes necessary to make the practice productive and be glad there was someone else to help you.

I think he prefers you to be dependent on him for transport and money which is why you must make sure you are not.

RuthsAndEsthersSpindles · 05/06/2022 16:25

He doesn't sound very nice, @FrankReynolds

How did you get together with him?

godmum56 · 05/06/2022 16:15

Babdoc · 05/06/2022 13:59

Do you have any calm, laid back friends, who could take you out for practice sessions in their own car? My DD used to get v nervous and failed 3 driving tests, but her current partner is an absolute sweetie who got her driving all over central Edinburgh in his new mini without once raising his voice! She passed her test with no bother.
As a separate issue, you need to consider whether your DH is bordering on coercive control territory - the power balance in your marriage seems skewed all one way. Giving you an “allowance” and forbidding you the use of the family car for lessons, really sounds deeply unpleasant and worrying.

yes that's what hit me...the car is not the issue here....you care for him and raise his kids and you get an ALLOWANCE????? what the actual Fuck?

Vivi0 · 05/06/2022 16:11

Calling the OP’s DH a knob is a bit much.

Teaching someone to drive is obviously outwith his skill set. I can’t imagine how stressful it would be without dual controls, proper training etc.

I also don’t see the issue with him not allowing you to use his car to learn with your dad. I wouldn’t let someone learn how to drive in my car either! And the car is his. He bought and paid for it. The OP can’t even drive yet!

LadyGardenersQuestionTime · 05/06/2022 16:05

My kids have both been driving safely for over 10 years and I still have to concentrate very hard to look relaxed and normal when they are driving me (inside I’m your husband 100%/screaming in terror).

When you pass your test don’t drive him anywhere unless he’s drunk and you’re sober, I found I was much more relaxed about the kids’ driving when I’d had a few and the taxi tables were turned 😝

Swipe left for the next trending thread