Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at partner's seeming obsession with money?!

134 replies

anonljs · 05/06/2022 09:36

NC for this.

Title is probably not the best but I don't know how else to express what I'm trying to say, and it honestly feels this way to me...

Partner and I want to book holiday for August. He will need to work some overtime shifts between now and then for us to afford to save for it. We've worked out the minimum number of shifts we need him to work in order to comfortably pay the bills and have extra for holiday - it will include working an extra weekend every month (we have worked out that if he works just one extra weekend plus extends other mid week shifts, we can meet the target we need for holiday). His contracted hours already include EOW, so we only have 2 weekends a month as a family anyway. With the overtime we would have just one weekend a month, but we accepted this as a short term sacrifice for the holiday.

He now wants to work all weekends a month including extending mid week shifts until 9pm in some instances. I also work almost FT hours, so this already adds pressure to me in terms of all childcare falling to me after work until 9pm, on top of losing every weekend of family time for 2 months. I'm not happy with this and I think he's taking it too far. We need some sort of balance. If he does this we won't have a day off together at all in the next 10 weeks until the holiday.

For context, from our approximate calculations, we are talking about the difference between a take home pay of around £2,900 versus £3,300. If he took home the lower amount, added to my salary too, we would still be well on target for holiday plus a little bit extra. I think he's lost sight of the goal and is now just trying to bring home as much as possible, but at the expense of family time and our relationship, which is equally if not more important to me than money.

AIBU??

OP posts:
Colourmeclear · 05/06/2022 11:23

Sell some things if it's about the money?

If it's not about the money then it's much harder to solve.

Deadringer · 05/06/2022 11:23

I disagree with most pps. You have a good plan in place that won't over burden your dp work wise and means you will have enough money to cover the holiday without getting into debt. I think he ibu and should stick to said plan. I know what it's like to live week to week but family holidays are important, and as we really don't know what state the world will be in next year, between wars, pandemics and every other shit that can be thrown at us, I think you should go in August as planned.

anonljs · 05/06/2022 11:19

@AppleBirdBrush

I haven't laid out "rules". That sounds odd and controlling.

We had a two way discussion about it, like adults do in a relationship. We worked out a required minimum amount of money each month to make this affordable and have it paid off within reasonable timeframe, and save holiday spending money. We calculated the difference between that amount and the amount we take home currently, and used that to work out that we need x number of hours of extra overtime on top of the usual overtime.

We both went "ok, that's do able. It takes DP out for the equation for helping at home on x and y days, it takes our family time on that particular weekend, but we will make that sacrifice for the holiday".

Since that discussion, DP has proposed to me that he plans to work extra weekends / evenings on top of those we mutually agreed as per the above discussion.

I'm annoyed because this wasn't the agreement. It leaves me alone with childcare and home life more often than I was comfortable with originally. It's also not strictly necessary to meet our financial needs. So it feels as though DP has taken it to an extreme.

OP posts:
druto · 05/06/2022 11:18

I would go on a UK break & do the abroad holiday next year.

ryankbk · 05/06/2022 11:17

You only have a few grand saved for a house deposit and yet you are looking to spend a few grand on a holiday in two months time that you currently do not have the money for. That doesn't make financial sense.

AppleBirdBrush · 05/06/2022 11:15

Sorry but I think you are being a little bit unreasonable, not for wanting a holiday but for laying out the overtime 'rules' on your terms.
He could say to you that to afford the holiday you had to get an evening job but make sure you only work 2 evenings a week (or whatever...). I don't think you can ask him to bring in more money then criticise him for doing what you asked.

namechange30455 · 05/06/2022 11:13

namechange30455 · 05/06/2022 11:11

So you have a take home pay of about £5,000pm between you and you're still having to put a holiday on a credit card? We earn about half that and we're still having a holiday this year that we've saved up for! How much is your holiday costing? Are you/he overspending in other areas or do you have an enormous mortgage/childcare bill that's eating up a lot of your income?!

Sorry just seen you've answered how much the holiday is costing!

Aquamarine1029 · 05/06/2022 11:12

Sorry, but this is bonkers. You can't afford this holiday. Having to work all of those extra hours just to be able to afford a holiday is madness.

Wingedharpy · 05/06/2022 11:11

I'm with @Discovereads .
Much as you may want this holiday OP, you really can't afford it.
It's a very financially precarious way to live as the slightest thing could scupper the payback plan and before you know it a spiralling debt situation occurs.
It just is not worth that risk for a 1 or 2 week holiday.

namechange30455 · 05/06/2022 11:11

So you have a take home pay of about £5,000pm between you and you're still having to put a holiday on a credit card? We earn about half that and we're still having a holiday this year that we've saved up for! How much is your holiday costing? Are you/he overspending in other areas or do you have an enormous mortgage/childcare bill that's eating up a lot of your income?!

anonljs · 05/06/2022 11:10

@druto

Yes we have a small amount of savings towards a deposit for buying a house. It's not much, a few grand. We don't want to touch that ideally.

We pay childcare for the youngest too so that eats a big chuck each month.

Without him doing any overtime at all, we would "get by" but have hardly any disposable income. He always does some overtime so we have at least a few hundred on top of his baseline salary, that means we are comfortable. To get this holiday paid off ASAP, we've worked out that we need more overtime on top of that. We both agreed to this amount. But what he's proposing is even extra on top of the extra, if that makes sense. Making the situation so that he is barely home.

We won't have even one full day home together in June if we work to his proposal. I think that's going to impact on our relationship and family to the point I'll feel like I'm going on holiday with a stranger by time August arrives!

OP posts:
ChanceNorman · 05/06/2022 11:10

Op I totally understand the need to work overtime to afford the extras, with an unfortunate reduction in family time. I'm also in the same position - I have a decent, 'safe' income but no chance of OT so any extras come from DH doing OT.

Dh is a taxi driver. It works brilliantly for us most of the time and he earns well - but he's just spent the whole BH working nights because its just way too lucrative to turn down. His best earning opportunities come from him working weekends, bank Holidays, nights or big events - all the family times. It's a constant juggle between work/life balance but bank Holidays usually win because he'd be mad to turn down that kind of £...but we try and plan as best as we can so that he's off completely at least one or two weekends a month.

However we're putting the extra money he'll take this week as a substantial deposit towards NEXT August's 'big' holiday...and if there's some left we'll do a cheapie camping trip this August.

I agree with a pp, I think you've left it too late for this August. If you need all of the OT money to afford it then one bout of sickness in DH or an unexpected car repair or whatever is going to eat that money and leave you short. It's too much pressure.

D0lphine · 05/06/2022 11:06

I think you need to speak to him again and say 1 - we can't afford an abroad holiday (show him numbers 2 - there is a cost of living crisis / recession on 3 - you want him home on weekends to help with family things.

Make a plan to go abroad august 2023?

druto · 05/06/2022 11:04

When you say you need to save for it is that so you don't touch other savings? How much short would you be with him not working overtime?

anonljs · 05/06/2022 11:03

ryankbk · 05/06/2022 11:01

Could you look at
October instead

No, his holidays are set by work, he gets no say in them.

OP posts:
Heronwatcher · 05/06/2022 11:03

Yes and absolutely don’t book an expensive holiday on a credit card in your name when you’d be happy with a resort in the uk- madness.

anonljs · 05/06/2022 11:02

@druto

We are honestly looking at the cheapest options for a family of 4 in places like Spain/the Balearics etc. We are still looking around £2,800-3k all inclusive. I haven't found anything cheaper. If someone can find me something in this sort of destination for August time for a family of 4 coming in at cheaper than that, I'd be very grateful! 🙂

OP posts:
ncerer · 05/06/2022 11:01

OP, it sounds to me like you've both gone off on one about a holiday you can't quite afford. Only you could afford it - if only he earned slightly more. Like you do. Is it possible that you have (inadvertently) made him feel inadequate and this 'holiday target' has shone a light on the fact he is the lower earner. So now he wants to "show you" as it were by maxing out his earning potential? Even though it means he gets virtually no time at home. But then, he's criticised for not pulling his weight at home. In a sense, he can't win, can he?

I may be off track here, but it just seemed like a possibility, from what you've written?

ryankbk · 05/06/2022 11:01

Could you look at
October instead

Heronwatcher · 05/06/2022 11:01

I think you have a choice, either go on a cheaper holiday and share parenting or go on a more expensive holiday and you have to bear the brunt of the parenting. Maybe he’s not happy with just about covering the holiday and wants some money in reserve, either for extras or for the upcoming shitstorm in October when energy prices rise again. That’s not really unreasonable. Either way if I were you I’d be looking at the holiday and working out how to do it more cheaply, if you’re thinking of booking a package for example try Airbnb/ booking.com and separate flights.

anonljs · 05/06/2022 10:59

@D0lphine

I suggested to him a week in a caravan in the U.K. in Cornwall or South Wales for example only last week - I sent him links to lovely little resorts. He said he'd rather we went abroad and he doesn't want to spend a week in a cramped caravan. It's him who isn't keen on a cheaper U.K. option.

OP posts:
druto · 05/06/2022 10:59

Could you go for a cheaper holiday?

Discovereads · 05/06/2022 10:59

Nothappyatwork · 05/06/2022 10:55

That’s how most people afford holidays and big purchases lovely as it would be to save up and have it all in advance that’s just not how life works for the majority of people. my concern is that it’s all in your name OP can you not split it between two cards ?

I don’t agree most people go into credit card debt for holidays. Yes for necessary large purchases like a new fridge freezer because your current one breaks, or to unexpectedly have to repair your car because you need transport. But no, most people save up for a holiday and even if they use a credit card for various consumer protections or cash back benefits, they usually have the funds saved up for it in advance so the card is paid off in full that month.

DoubleGauze · 05/06/2022 10:59

It might be a standard family holiday op , but you can't afford it without exhausting yourselves. Is it really worth it?

LorenzoVonMatterhorn · 05/06/2022 10:58

Have you pointed out he plan would involve him doing absolutely no parenting and that obviously wasn't acceptable?

and op, he has decided to check out of family life for two months. He might get a taste for it. Why on earth is the credit card going in your name?!