Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at partner's seeming obsession with money?!

134 replies

anonljs · 05/06/2022 09:36

NC for this.

Title is probably not the best but I don't know how else to express what I'm trying to say, and it honestly feels this way to me...

Partner and I want to book holiday for August. He will need to work some overtime shifts between now and then for us to afford to save for it. We've worked out the minimum number of shifts we need him to work in order to comfortably pay the bills and have extra for holiday - it will include working an extra weekend every month (we have worked out that if he works just one extra weekend plus extends other mid week shifts, we can meet the target we need for holiday). His contracted hours already include EOW, so we only have 2 weekends a month as a family anyway. With the overtime we would have just one weekend a month, but we accepted this as a short term sacrifice for the holiday.

He now wants to work all weekends a month including extending mid week shifts until 9pm in some instances. I also work almost FT hours, so this already adds pressure to me in terms of all childcare falling to me after work until 9pm, on top of losing every weekend of family time for 2 months. I'm not happy with this and I think he's taking it too far. We need some sort of balance. If he does this we won't have a day off together at all in the next 10 weeks until the holiday.

For context, from our approximate calculations, we are talking about the difference between a take home pay of around £2,900 versus £3,300. If he took home the lower amount, added to my salary too, we would still be well on target for holiday plus a little bit extra. I think he's lost sight of the goal and is now just trying to bring home as much as possible, but at the expense of family time and our relationship, which is equally if not more important to me than money.

AIBU??

OP posts:
anonljs · 05/06/2022 16:11

@Discovereads

I take your point but I disagree with this part:

You’ve been on this slippery slope a long time of deprioritising his family/parenting time in favour of working more than FT

We haven't really, because our child is only 1 and I was on maternity leave until quite recently. So I didn't notice until very recently how little time we get all together as a family and how stressful it is trying to keep everything running at home by myself a lot of the time, whilst also working myself. It's only come to light in recent months how hard it is to have him home so little, and I've tried to tell him this on multiple occasions but it results in arguments about us "needing the money" (even if we are Ok on fewer hours of his OT). I've tried to get him to see my POV in terms of how hard it is to have him absent so often at work, and he doesn't see it - he remains focused on us "needing the money".

In other words, we may be at the start of the slippery slope you describe, but it's not for want of trying on my part. Essentially, I want him home more than he wants to be home. If we were less financially "comfortable", well... it's something I'd have to accept if it meant he was home more and we had family time.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 05/06/2022 15:58

anonljs · 05/06/2022 15:43

@Discovereads

You'll also note that I say "zero parenting". I was never happy with "zero parenting". I was happy with reduced parenting, yes - I accepted I'd be doing slightly more at home on the agreed overtime shifts. But to be doing absolutely everything single-handedly at home for 2 entire months, all evenings and weekends, around my own job? No. I was never happy with that. That's why I simply don't agree at all that I've given mixed messages.

Im probably not being clear and I apologise for that. By “mixed messages” I mean that you both have a partnership which has always prioritised his work over family/parenting time. You talk about balance, but a true balance where work and family time are of equal priority is generally FT work vs Substantial evening and weekend parenting/family time.

Under normal circumstances, you both have agreed on FT + some overtime vs less parenting/family time. This fundamentally prioritises work over family time/parenting. It’s not balanced despite you calling it a balance and the sweet spot. It’s unbalanced in favour of him earning more money for the family.

Then you’ve both agreed to unbalance things even further by him working FT + more overtime vs hardly any family time/parenting for the holiday.

I agree you were never happy with his suggestion to unbalance things even further where family time/parenting goes to zero. I’m not saying you were ever happy with this extreme end result. It’s just that his working OT has been a constant pattern of being higher priority than his family/parenting time in the relationship. You’ve been on this slippery slope a long time of deprioritising his family/parenting time in favour of working more than FT and his suggestion, while the illogical extreme was almost inevitably going to happen at some point because wants (unlike needs) tend to mushroom.

anonljs · 05/06/2022 15:49

@Solmum1964

Thank you for the tip. 😊

OP posts:
anonljs · 05/06/2022 15:43

@Discovereads

You'll also note that I say "zero parenting". I was never happy with "zero parenting". I was happy with reduced parenting, yes - I accepted I'd be doing slightly more at home on the agreed overtime shifts. But to be doing absolutely everything single-handedly at home for 2 entire months, all evenings and weekends, around my own job? No. I was never happy with that. That's why I simply don't agree at all that I've given mixed messages.

OP posts:
Solmum1964 · 05/06/2022 15:42

Be careful if booking your holiday through a travel agent on your credit card - I think there's something about the section 75 protection not being valid if booked through a third party.
Also make sure you take out travel insurance as soon as you book. Things can easily go wrong before you travel.

anonljs · 05/06/2022 15:32

@Discovereads

That's not true, not even close.

From my point of view it's always been a priority to have him home for family time as much as possible. There is a minimum number of hours overtime that would enable us to be comfortable each month - both of us have always been on board with that. But I'm the only one of the two of us who sees the need for balance, ie. yes, I accept the need for some^^ overtime, but I also see the need for him to be home so we can be a family, too. In other words I value both the money and his time and presence at home. There's a "sweet spot" where that balance us struck each month, and thus far we've been able to find it.

With the holiday talk, he's tipped the balance too far imo. We again found the new "sweet spot" (it means more hours at work of course and less at home which has been accepted by both of us as necessary), but he has unilaterally decided he is going to work more than that.

I'm not sure how I've given mixed messages. My message has always been : "I accept that you need to work extra on some weekends and evenings, but please can we ensure it doesn't reach a point of you never being home and us never having family time". My message is still the same as that, regardless of the holiday.

OP posts:
AntarcticTern · 05/06/2022 15:25

Personally I wouldn't book a holiday without having enough in savings to pay for it in full at the time of booking (even if I still paid on a credit card to get the added protection).

I get that we all make different financial decisions, but as you asked.

Discovereads · 05/06/2022 15:16

Yes I've pointed out that this plan involves him doing zero parenting and funnily enough he doesn't see that as a problem. 🙄

To be fair you are giving him mixed messages. You currently live with the agreement that he regularly work a few overtime shifts to pay day to day bills, causing less family time and less parenting, so that you are living “comfortably” and not struggling. Then you’ve mutually agreed he should work even more overtime to fund a holiday abroad (objectively a luxury), resulting in hardly any family time and hardly any parenting by him.

You’ve reached your limit when he now has suggested he temporarily work for two months as much overtime as humanely possible resulting in no family time and zero parenting. That’s ok you’ve reached your limit, but it’s been a pattern in your partnership that he is the one expected to work more than FT to fund the family’s extra wants. In this situation, he wants the holiday abroad, you’re happy with a cheaper U.K. holiday. So, from his perspective he may feel that it’s ok with you to have him work all this overtime to fund something you want for yourself or the DC, but not when it’s something he really wants. That’s a bit unfair tbh.

Since he really wants a holiday abroad, I’d not dismiss that but instead defer to say next year and have a realistic plan in place to save up for it. I think too that you might want to wean yourselves off depending on him regularly working overtime to fund life’s extras. You’ve both not prioritised him spending time with the family or parenting before, so it is understandable that he thinks its not his priority either.

anonljs · 05/06/2022 15:15

@Octomore

I'd honestly be happy with a campsite / caravan type U.K. holiday. Just need to convince DP that this would be equally as lovely!

OP posts:
Octomore · 05/06/2022 15:14

Honestly, right now feels like a time to be tightening belts and accruing any savings possible. Spending on things that you can just about scrape to afford does not seem like a good idea.

Cost of living is going up, interest rates are going up, most informed commentary is saying a recession is likely, which will mean companies folding and jobs going..... It's not a time to be 'just about managing'

If it were me, I'd work the medium level of overtime, but put it in savings rather than spend it now. Keep it (and keep saving) until next year when you will hopefully be able to plan something affordable with a financial cushion.

anonljs · 05/06/2022 15:14

@Discovereads

Point taken. I agree it's not the smartest plan. We could definitely have planned this whole thing much better.

OP posts:
Octomore · 05/06/2022 15:10

anonljs · 05/06/2022 14:51

Do some nice days out, visit family, live cheaply and save up for a holiday once you have at least 3-6 months income saved as a rainy day fund.

This seems sensible but ... do people only plan holidays when they have significant savings behind them? Genuinely asking.

I can only speak for myself, but I've never taken out any kind of debt to pay for a holiday, or taken a holiday that totally wiped out all our savings.

When we were skint, this meant all holidays consisted of UK camping, and cooking meals at the campsite rather than eating out. Still had a wonderful time though. (And now we have more money we still go UK camping a lot, but in a campervan and we'll have the odd pub meal.)

anonljs · 05/06/2022 15:06

@HundredMilesAnHour

No one has been "told" anything.

He has agreed to do it on the basis that he also wants the holiday abroad, despite the fact that I've suggested cheaper alternatives in this country which he has poo pooed.

He can "win" (if you want to use that sort of terminology). He can win by sticking to our mutually agreed plan which strikes a balance between him doing enough OT to make our holiday affordable whilst also being home enough to pitch in with home life and childcare. That's the win, right there. He's choosing to follow his own plan, however, which takes him further away from family life than is ideal.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 05/06/2022 15:05

anonljs · 05/06/2022 14:51

Do some nice days out, visit family, live cheaply and save up for a holiday once you have at least 3-6 months income saved as a rainy day fund.

This seems sensible but ... do people only plan holidays when they have significant savings behind them? Genuinely asking.

I do save up the full cost of a holiday before going. It’s not a smart financial move to go into any kind of debt to pay for a holiday even if you have a plan to work overtime to pay off that debt quickly. It creates financial pressure on you both to ensure the overtime is there and is worked and that in turn generates money anxiety that touch wood no unexpected expenses happen to derail the plan to pay off the debt.

I know you’re much better than his spendthrift fraudster ex, but that a very low bar to exceed. I don’t think the original plan you both came up with is financially smart to be honest.

anonljs · 05/06/2022 15:01

@LorenzoVonMatterhorn

Only just seen your comment, sorry.

The credit card is in my name because he has poor credit from the financial fuck ups in his marriage (see previous post).

Yes I've pointed out that this plan involves him doing zero parenting and funnily enough he doesn't see that as a problem. 🙄

OP posts:
HundredMilesAnHour · 05/06/2022 14:58

LorenzoVonMatterhorn · 05/06/2022 10:58

Have you pointed out he plan would involve him doing absolutely no parenting and that obviously wasn't acceptable?

and op, he has decided to check out of family life for two months. He might get a taste for it. Why on earth is the credit card going in your name?!

How about giving the guy a break? He's been told to do more overtime so they can have a holiday (that they clearly can't afford) and now he's getting it in the neck for wanting to do too much overtime? Seems he can't win whatever he does.

anonljs · 05/06/2022 14:51

Do some nice days out, visit family, live cheaply and save up for a holiday once you have at least 3-6 months income saved as a rainy day fund.

This seems sensible but ... do people only plan holidays when they have significant savings behind them? Genuinely asking.

OP posts:
anonljs · 05/06/2022 14:46

ittakes2 · 05/06/2022 14:40

Are you married? Is there a chance he is thinking this holiday is a good time to propose to you and he is working extra to save for a ring?

No we aren't married, and I honestly hadn't thought of this. 😮

I'll feel totally shit if this is the reason.....!

OP posts:
anonljs · 05/06/2022 14:44

Do you know what's funny, too...

We had a (rare) day off together on bank holiday Friday just gone and we went out to a nearby town to take DC to a park and for some ice cream etc.

We had been having a conversation about the overtime arrangement and he had floated this idea of working more than the agreed number of shifts. I was expressing that I would really rather he didn't do this, as it would impact on our already very limited family time. He was saying "I don't think I work as much as you think I do..." etc etc.

Anyway about 10 mins later we saw his mate from work with his family, and there was a brief exchange between him and DP that was roughly as follows:

Mate: "Hi mate, fancy seeing you here, you having a nice day with the family?"
DP: "yeah, lovely thanks. I see you are too?"
Mate: "yeah. Not like you to take a day off, though?!"

Laughter between them... etc

I just marvelled at the perfect timing of it all and was like "thank you!!" 🤣 Even his work mates comment on the fact that he's always there, ffs. If that doesn't back up my point I don't know what does!

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 05/06/2022 14:40

Are you married? Is there a chance he is thinking this holiday is a good time to propose to you and he is working extra to save for a ring?

BattenburgDonkey · 05/06/2022 14:31

Be fair to him though OP, it’s a holiday you can’t afford, need him to do overtime for because you can’t, and is going on a credit card so you are putting yourselves in debt to do it. So yes it may be a bit of a hangover, but also he has learnt from
being complacent about money in the past and wants to make sure this is covered.

anonljs · 05/06/2022 14:22

@Pixiedust1234

Yes he probably does have "money anxiety" but if so, it will be because of his previous marriage and the multiple financial fuck ups therein rather than anything to do with me.

He told me that he experienced significant financial pressures in his marriage because: his ex wife earned nothing and was entirely financially dependent on him, she got them into unsustainable debt on multiple occasions without his knowledge, and she committed benefit fraud (also without his knowledge).

But he needs to stop projecting that experience into our situation and realise that this is very different. I earn good money, I haven't got us into debt without his knowledge, and I haven't committed fraud of any type (nor do I have any plans to do so).

A lot of his anxiety around money is, I feel, a hangover from his previous marriage.

OP posts:
Pixiedust1234 · 05/06/2022 14:05

OK I did add "just about" but that was to emphasise that not paying a good chunk off the cc is a red flag to banks, debt agencies etc , its not good considering the amount you have coming in. Even in normal times it seems as though you are spending above your means bc you need overtime to pay for it but now is not normal. So I repeat, no wonder he has money anxiety.

anonljs · 05/06/2022 13:39

MagicTurtle · 05/06/2022 13:06

I agree with you OP.

I would be really cross with DH if he decided to work every weekend and leave me with all the childcare unless it was absolutely necessary (and you've explained that this isn't).

As it's him who's keener to go on holiday, surely it's easy for you to put your foot down? Just say you refuse to go on holiday unless he sticks to the planned overtime agreement and no more.

I am planning on doing exactly this and putting my foot down when he gets home from work today. It's not fair at all - we agreed one thing and he's unilaterally decided another. The more I think about it, I don't think it's any coincidence that it gets him out of childcare and home life responsibilities more often, either!

OP posts:
anonljs · 05/06/2022 13:31

lifecanbehardattimes · 05/06/2022 13:25

If be brings home £2,900 a month without overtime and you earn more than him, you've got to be bringing home around £6,000 a month or more.

I know we all live up to our means, but I'm surprised you need to be doing lots of overtime to pay for a holiday!

Ok people aren't reading and are making up their own version here.

Without any overtime at all he brings home £1,800.

On an average month of overtime he brings home in the region of 2,100-2,300, depending on how much OT is available that month.

With the plan to do extra OT over the coming months he would be bringing home 2,900 ish.

His proposal (which I don't agree with) is to work every single hour under the sun and bring home closer to 3,300.

OP posts: