Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The government actually IS doing a consultation on bringing back imperial measurements!

454 replies

Kendodd · 04/06/2022 22:04

I thought it was a joke.
AIBU to think this is a complete load of bollocks waste of money?

The questions don't even give you the option of saying just keep metric.
Example question -
For Consumers,

a) If you had a choice, would you want to purchase items:

(i) in imperial units?

(ii) in imperial units alongside a metric equivalent?

www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1079711/choice-on-units-of-measurement-markings-and-sales-consultation.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjchIqM1pT4AhXIPsAKHWSZBW0QFnoECAUQAQ&usg=AOvVaw05usEgoqbR2NHfgE3SzAYH

OP posts:
L353A1 · 05/03/2023 13:34

"But businesses were allowed to use only metric. But not only imperial."

There has to be legal clarity in weights and measures . That principle goes back to Magna Carta.
The metric price was the real, legal price and the Imperial price was merely supplementary information for the benefit of the customer. It was allowed, but only if it was not more prominent than the real price. If a conversion error occurred the metric price was the actual price.

Trading Standards had been preparing for years and had replaced all their calibration equipment with metric ones, costing tens of thousands of pounds, and the manufacturers stopped making them. If Imperial becomes legal TS will (at least initially) have no capability to detect and prosecute fraud. If they do manage to source Imperial calibration equipment it will cost a lot to buy and the ratepayers may not be pleased.

tommika · 05/03/2023 13:24

Florenz · 05/03/2023 13:10

What is wrong with giving people the freedom to choose whether they want to use metric or imperial?

The same question could be asked when threads are about paying by cash or by card.

A retailer has the choice to accept either a single method, the option for both and also the option for other methods
The law sees no problem with this

The law does see a problem in restricting the methods of paying a debt and therefore will not allow debt to be pursed in court if the denominations specified under legal tender have been refused

So why does the law interfere in the metrics used in sale?
Because of deliberate deception and short measures throughout history, and therefore laws have existed for over 1000 years controlling what metrics businesses must use in trade.
These do not prevent a business from using any metric that they choose provided the industry standard metric is clearly displayed

Florenz · 05/03/2023 13:19

We didn't have it both ways, that's the point. Businesses were allowed to use solely metric, but not solely imperial.

pointythings · 05/03/2023 13:13

Florenz · 05/03/2023 13:10

What is wrong with giving people the freedom to choose whether they want to use metric or imperial?

What's wrong with just having it both ways? Freedom isn't everything, there's consideration for your fellow human beings as well.
Anyway, the consultation is so beautifully rigged that we're bound to get your 'freedom'. The UK now has the freedom to shoot itself in the foot at every turn. It's going so well.

Florenz · 05/03/2023 13:10

What is wrong with giving people the freedom to choose whether they want to use metric or imperial?

pointythings · 05/03/2023 12:56

But businesses were allowed to use only metric. But not only imperial.

@Florenz given that the UK has been fully metric for many decades, why would using both be a problem? How many people are there who are intellectually unable to handle both things side by side and work out how much things cost/weigh? Only imperial would have made life difficult for the majority of people. The demand for it would have come only from the above mentioned Brexit headbangers with delusions of Empire. Who would have died off in a couple more decades anyway.

Brexit came about because of decades of propaganda from the right wing press coupled with a complete lack of political and economic literacy among the electorate. And an absolutely dire Remain campaign.

tommika · 05/03/2023 12:38

Florenz · 05/03/2023 12:33

But businesses were allowed to use only metric. But not only imperial. This was wrong. And it was things like this that allowed resentment to build up and eventually to Brexit.

I'd happily go back to imperial currency.

Correction
It was rhetoric that allowed resentment to build up and lead to Brexit

Florenz · 05/03/2023 12:33

But businesses were allowed to use only metric. But not only imperial. This was wrong. And it was things like this that allowed resentment to build up and eventually to Brexit.

I'd happily go back to imperial currency.

tommika · 05/03/2023 12:30

Florenz · 04/03/2023 22:15

The EU did ban businesses from only using the imperial system.

Private businesses should be able to sell in any measuring system they want, they should be able to invent their own. Treat people like adults and let them choose what they want to use. If people don't want to use imperial (or metric), they will spend their money elsewhere. I strongly suspect that given the choice, most business would label their products in both metric and imperial. But this should be their choice to make.

Over 1000 years of British laws disagree with you that any business should be able to sell in any measuring system they like

Trading Standards enforce weights and measures legislation ensuring that businesses are clear & honest to customers with the ability to understand and compare

The EU didn’t even ban the use of only imperial units in UK business.

www.gov.uk/weights-measures-and-packaging-the-law

Draught beer & cider sold by pints
Milk in returnable containers by pint
(eg milk bottles from the milkman but not supermarket jugs - unless the supermarket introduced a returns process)
Precious metals in troy ounces

Under weights and measures certain commodities retained imperial measures.
Businesses have been able to deviate from the norm if they clearly show the ‘official’ metric as well as their chosen metric

SerendipityJane · 05/03/2023 11:31

pointythings · 05/03/2023 11:16

@Florenz but the rule was never that it had to be metric only. It just had to be both, not Imperial only. I repeat: you'd have to be a Brexit headbanger with delusions of Empire to object to that. It was a simple, pragmatic solution. It's not the EU's fault so many people in the UK are hard of thinking.

Also, why is metrication the devils work, but decimalisation never mentioned ? Why aren't we going back to "good old" Pounds Shilling and Pence ? Get rid of this suspiciously French "decimal" thing.

If we're going to kill our trade dead, we may as well put a stake in it's heart and make sure it can't get up again.

(now, you're just being silly, Jane)

pointythings · 05/03/2023 11:16

@Florenz but the rule was never that it had to be metric only. It just had to be both, not Imperial only. I repeat: you'd have to be a Brexit headbanger with delusions of Empire to object to that. It was a simple, pragmatic solution. It's not the EU's fault so many people in the UK are hard of thinking.

SerendipityJane · 05/03/2023 11:15

Florenz · 05/03/2023 10:59

"@Florenz in a world where the norm is metric, a manufacturer would have to be stupid to use anything else. Or a Brexit headbanger."
I agree but it should not be illegal for them to do so. People would be a lot more accepting of Metric measures (and other EU meddling) if it wasn't opposed on them at gunpoint, but they were given a choice of which to use, and over time, metric won out and the businesses that used imperial either failed or were forced to change to metric by their own volition.

I can personally guarantee that if the UK scrapped requirements to measure in accepted systems, within 5 onoseconds, there would be a post on MN about it being unfair that kumquats are now sold by the unicorn fart so you can't compare Waitrose with Tescos who sell them by the snowflake squared. Meanwhile this isn't just a beetles turd, it's an M&S beetles turd, as you weigh out the quinoa.

Metrology - the science of measuring - is probably one of the oldest known to man. They've found fine scales buried with pharaohs from over 5,000 years ago. And it went hand in hand with very strict laws about what units you use. I men very strict laws. Like, laws you probably need to read about before a meal.

Florenz · 05/03/2023 10:59

"@Florenz in a world where the norm is metric, a manufacturer would have to be stupid to use anything else. Or a Brexit headbanger."
I agree but it should not be illegal for them to do so. People would be a lot more accepting of Metric measures (and other EU meddling) if it wasn't opposed on them at gunpoint, but they were given a choice of which to use, and over time, metric won out and the businesses that used imperial either failed or were forced to change to metric by their own volition.

SerendipityJane · 05/03/2023 10:55

VeniVidiWeeWee · 04/03/2023 23:35

@pointythings

"Well, no. Because there are such things as international common standards. And they are essential, because without them safety is compromised. Car manufacturers are private businesses. Should they be allowed to make up their own engine capacity measurements? What an utterly ridiculous idea."

Well, American vehicles' engines are measured in cubic inches.

How is that utterly ridiculous?

Knock yourself out

www.theregister.com/Design/page/reg-standards-converter.html

engines should - of course - be measured in gf - grapefruits.

pointythings · 05/03/2023 09:00

@VeniVidiWeeWee it isn't, of course. Way to miss my point. American manufacturers all use cubic inches. There isn't one that uses the Smurf, another that uses the Caffeine Index and yet another that measures its engine sizes in cats. Because that would be a problem. The more different systems you have, the more potential for serious error.

@Florenz in a world where the norm is metric, a manufacturer would have to be stupid to use anything else. Or a Brexit headbanger.

UK retailers were always allowed to display in both metric and Imperial. I don't understand why you have a problem with this (actually I really do).

L353A1 · 05/03/2023 08:50

'Metric isn't inherently "safer" than imperial.'

True, neither system is inherently safer, but conversion errors are a safety risk. SI metric units are the international standard used almost everywhere. British Imperial units differ in some respects from American Customary Units. While American miles are the same, American gallons, pints and fluid ounces are different. A British owner of an American-made Cessna light aircraft ran out of fuel because of a mix-up between US gallons and Imperial gallons.

PS The US car industry is now metric. Cars are designed and manufactured in metric units and require metric-standard tools to service them.

Florenz · 05/03/2023 02:09

If car manufacturers want to get together and agree to use metric in the name of safety, they should absolutely be able to. But if another manufacturer wants to use imperial, they should absolutely be able to do this as well. Metric isn't inherently "safer" than imperial.

VeniVidiWeeWee · 04/03/2023 23:35

@pointythings

"Well, no. Because there are such things as international common standards. And they are essential, because without them safety is compromised. Car manufacturers are private businesses. Should they be allowed to make up their own engine capacity measurements? What an utterly ridiculous idea."

Well, American vehicles' engines are measured in cubic inches.

How is that utterly ridiculous?

Eleganz · 04/03/2023 22:55

Old thread from last year.

I suspect this was punted into the very long grass the moment the ghost pencil Rees-Mogg left government. Haven't heard a bean about it since.

Fucking bananas idea anyway.

pointythings · 04/03/2023 22:18

Well, no. Because there are such things as international common standards. And they are essential, because without them safety is compromised. Car manufacturers are private businesses. Should they be allowed to make up their own engine capacity measurements? What an utterly ridiculous idea.

The EU allowed Imperial measures to be displayed alongside metric. Metric has been taught in schools for decades. This fetishisation of imperial measures is more of the great British delusion of Empire.

It isn't coming back, guys. Get over it.

Florenz · 04/03/2023 22:15

jc12689 · 31/12/2022 21:11

The EU don't ban anyone from using the imperial system. That's was just Brexit bullshit propaganda for thick people.

The EU did ban businesses from only using the imperial system.

Private businesses should be able to sell in any measuring system they want, they should be able to invent their own. Treat people like adults and let them choose what they want to use. If people don't want to use imperial (or metric), they will spend their money elsewhere. I strongly suspect that given the choice, most business would label their products in both metric and imperial. But this should be their choice to make.

SerendipityJane · 04/03/2023 20:19

The UK started its metrication programme in 1965

Metrication was first proposed in 1863

L353A1 · 04/03/2023 19:27

Weights and measures is one of those areas where giving people a choice is a bad idea. Trying to run two systems at the same time leads to confusion and error. In the NHS at least two people have died because they have been given an incorrect dose due to a conversion error. One was a newborn who died of an overdose of a drug and the other was a teenage cancer patient given too much radiation. An airliner ran out of fuel because the pilot thought he had 22 000 kg of fuel when he only had 22 000 pounds.

The UK started its metrication programme in 1965, with an intended finish date of 1975. The UK government was happy to agree to metrication as part of its entry to the European Community as this was already government policy. The 1981 EU directive required the UK to produce metrication legislation itself, which was duly passed by Westminster. So, the EU did not ban us from using Imperial units - that was done by our own elected MPs (for good reason).

Your baby was weighed in kg for the NHS records but it was reported to you in Imperial. Someone was trying to be helpful. The fact that our road signs are still Imperial is a disgrace and it has consequences. Foreign lorry drivers, unfamiliar with Imperial, have been hitting low bridges for years and it is only recently that bridges have been dual-marked. Foreign vehicles have no requirement to have dual-marked speedometers and unless we plan to cease all foreign trade this will lead to accidents.

jc12689 · 31/12/2022 21:11

NancyDrooo · 04/06/2022 22:58

Calm down people. They’re just wanting to give a choice, none of it is going to mandatory. We were not happy when the EU banned us from using imperial measures, now people are not happy we might revert and allow either or both.

I’ll still buy a pint of beer, thanks. I’m 5’5”. My baby was weighed in lbs and oz. No idea what I weigh in kg. Our road signs are in miles, not kilometres. It’s surely not beyond us to use whichever suits.

The EU don't ban anyone from using the imperial system. That's was just Brexit bullshit propaganda for thick people.

L353A1 · 31/12/2022 20:38

Chemenger · 05/06/2022 11:37

If we went fully metric there would presumably be nothing to stop pubs selling beer in measures of 569 ml, giving everyone around an extra 0.74 ml extra over the pint they used to buy. That’s about a seventh of a teaspoon. Or 11.4 grains in weight, approximately.

It was tried in the 1970s and found to be illegal by the courts. Carpet sellers didn't like the fact that selling by the square metre leads to a bigger number than selling by the square yard, so they tried to sell by the "0.84 m²"