Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend upset I stopped her from watching me

232 replies

WhatWouldHillaryDo · 04/06/2022 21:30

My first post, though been here years. I can be a bit of a push over with some friends. I let a lot of stuff slide rather than be confrontational so I think maybe in this situation my friend wasn’t expecting my reaction and has overreacted. Interested to hear replies.

Anyway, I sometimes pop in to friend’s house to feed her pets when she’s away for a night or two. She has two lovely cats and I enjoy going round and fussing them. All good, no issues with helping out. But the other week she mentioned something in passing that seemed odd - she said she sometimes speaks to her cats when she’s away. Well, after some gentle questioning, it seems she has a camera in her home by the cat bowls so she can see and talk to her pets. But she didn’t tell me this and I don’t think was going to either. She seemed a bit sheepish when I asked, like I’d caught her out.

Now, before she mentioned the webcam, i’d agreed to go round last weekend and feed the girls. Evening and morning, I was happy to. But I didn’t feel comfortable knowing I was being watched, so I spotted the camera and blocked the view while I was there, and unblocked it when I left. Now friend is upset with me and said she can’t understand what the big deal is and I should have said if I didn’t want to be watched so she could find someone else to feed the cats.

I feel like I’m going mad. Surely it’s my choice to be watched or not. I didn’t think I needed to let her know upfront. The more I think about it, the more annoyed I’m getting and I just need a sanity check.

OP posts:
CandleSchtick · 04/06/2022 22:58

It's pretty normal nowadays to have a cat cam when you go away. It works by movement, so you can see the cats are coming and going as normal and not stuck halfway up a curtain or something. It's just a reassurance.
I don't have any cats but I do holiday feeding for 3 of my friends (different households). They all have cameras but I only knew that eventually when I spotted the first one so then took to looking around for a camera. I just don't think they thought to tell me, pretty sure they're not interested in watching me feed them. One of them said to cover it up while I'm there if I want but I'm not that bothered. Just saying it's not that unusual.

MidwichCuckoo · 04/06/2022 22:57

Yanbu. How silly she said you should have let her know you didn't want to be watched. How were you to know it was a possibility if she didn't tell you. It's weird to spy on someone without their knowledge. She should have let you know and given you the choice whether to cover it

nettie434 · 04/06/2022 22:56

I cat sit for friends and would be so angry if I was recorded without my knowledge. I actually wouldn't even be that happy about going in knowing I'd be recorded! I can see how your friend might want to see her cats while she's away but she has no right to complain that you don't want to be recorded.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 04/06/2022 22:53

She should have warned you but equally pet cams are totally normal and not as weird as some on this thread are making out.

The cameras aren't to watch you and to make sure you're feeding the cats properly, they're to make sure the cats are happy, healthy and eating as normal while the owners are away.

I'm a dog walker/pet sitter and several clients use pet-cams - I can't say that it bothers me in the slightest.

FawnFrenchieMum · 04/06/2022 22:53

I’m a bit on the fence with this one, we have a camera in our kitchen so I can see the dog when I’m at work. I’ve never thought to tell anyone entering my house that it’s there but we don’t have it on record (you can set it to record each time there is motion), we just use it to live view the dog. In theory my DH ‘could’ be watching me and / or any visitors and same for me when he has visitors but that would just be fucking weird. On this basis I don’t think your friend was unreasonable to not tell you it was there. However assuming you definitely remembered to uncover it when you left then it’s weird to be upset by this. My only thought would be, does she maybe think your doing something to the animals you wouldn’t want her to see. A bit like why would anyone be bothered they could be seen if they have nothing to hide?! It’s a hard one.

Breakfastofmilk · 04/06/2022 22:51

YANBU. We have a catcam and our neighbour catsits for us. The first time she did I explained where the camera was and how to turn it off if she wanted to, which she did, and put it back on when she left. All fine, we can check in on the cat when she's not there, she doesn't feel watched or self conscious and she's not being recorded without her knowledge or against her will, we don't need to watch her because we trust her to feed the cat, everyone is happy.

Your friend should have warned you about the camera and either made sure you had the option to turn it off or found a catsitter who was happy to have it on if she absolutely can't stand it being switched off while the person she trusted to feed her cat's is doing it.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 04/06/2022 22:50

Spot on @Triffid1

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 04/06/2022 22:49

If you are informed that there cameras, you make a conscious decision to use cash machines/shopping centres etc, you can’t do so if you aren’t informed. Added to this, you have no controls in place regarding what the ‘friend’ may or may not do with any footage. the ‘friend’ evidently has control and trust issues. A person to be avoided.

TheNoonBell · 04/06/2022 22:46

Next time wear a balaclava when you go in to feed the pusses. Just for giggles.

Haus1234 · 04/06/2022 22:44

We have one of those cameras to watch the cats eat while we’re away (our paid cat sitter is aware though!), and I find it very helpful to know they are coming home as expected and eating etc. I can see her being annoyed if she was worried you might forget to unblock it maybe?

Triffid1 · 04/06/2022 22:44

Not sure what the underlining was about.

Triffid1 · 04/06/2022 22:44

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 04/06/2022 22:38

You should know they also have cameras on cash machines. In train stations. Shops. Buses...
Couldn't get worked up about someone having a camera in their own home to film their own pet, and if I was her, I'd find someone else because you could have been robbing the place for all she knew from your massive overreaction and covering the camera like that. Your reaction is bizarre. It's not like she's filming you in your own house.

True, but I'm aware of those cameras, or rather, aware that they exist. In a private residence, where I am alone, I have an expectation of privacy. What if she had a sudden itch in an embarrassing spot and, thinking she was alone and invisible to the world, did some enthusiastic scratching? Or chatted to the cat or on the phone about something private/confidential/inappropriate? Or had just had a fight with her boyfriend and was crying in what she assumed was a private place?

Also, not only was she unaware of the camera's existence, once you know it's there, you also know there's a 100% chance of being watched. All those ATM/Sainsbury etc cameras I assume are largely unwatched and that I am not particularly interesting to whoever is tasked with monitoring them. But in this case, her friend absolutely was 100% watching her, probably live.

It's creepy an inappropriate from OPs friend.

Thelnebriati · 04/06/2022 22:43

AFAIK if you use cameras you are supposed to put up a sign to inform people. Doing it secretly is weird and controlling, as you could tell from her reaction when you took that away from her.

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 04/06/2022 22:38

You should know they also have cameras on cash machines. In train stations. Shops. Buses...
Couldn't get worked up about someone having a camera in their own home to film their own pet, and if I was her, I'd find someone else because you could have been robbing the place for all she knew from your massive overreaction and covering the camera like that. Your reaction is bizarre. It's not like she's filming you in your own house.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 04/06/2022 22:38

It’s not a small thing @WhatWouldHillaryDo it’s a violation of your privacy. Privacy is something we all have a right to make an informed choice to either maintain or relinquish. Your ‘friend’ took that choice from you.

MushyPeasPrincess · 04/06/2022 22:37

WhatWouldHillaryDo · 04/06/2022 21:48

I don’t know why I feel so annoyed about it. I think it’s because on past visits I had no choice but this time I did and when I chose not to be watched, she was nasty. Why did this make her so angry?

Because she's a control freak who likes to feel superior. That's my guess.

DDivaStar · 04/06/2022 22:37

Its not that you're unreasonable for blocking it, it just seems a bit unnecessary. Assuming you'd not do anything too embarrassing if you know the camera is there......

FarFarFarAndAway · 04/06/2022 22:34

I wouldn't want to be watched as I always talk in a stupid voice to cats and would be chatting away to them unless someone was watching! Anyway, it's her choice to be arsey about the camera and your choice not to be watched, just don't help with her cats again, after all, you are doing her the favour.

WhatWouldHillaryDo · 04/06/2022 22:31

A bit of a mix of responses here but most see to agree it’s odd. I’m baffled at the idea I was unreasonable to cover the camera. If there has been a power cut or something had fallen on the camera, my friend wouldn’t have been able to see me either. But because I made the choice not to be seen, somehow that’s an issue. I don’t get it

OP posts:
Triffid1 · 04/06/2022 22:31

I think she was being completely unreasonable to be filming you previously without you knowing when you're doing her a favour. is there sound too? I mean, you could have been on a private call while in her home and then what, she just listened to it? So I'd have been livid.

Knowing there was a camera though, I'm not sure I'd have bothered to block it. But I do get it - you don't want your image out of your control. And the fact that she kept it from you all this time certainly doesn't suggest that she's using the camera in an entirely benign way.

Luredbyapomegranate · 04/06/2022 22:29

You are both being odd - her for not telling you in the first place, you for blocking the camera - why does it matter if she sees you put food in bowls.

She’s angry because she was caught out, and you are angry with her condoling behaviour hence you blocking.

You could just let the friendship go, or leave it to her if she asks you to come again knowing you will block the camera.

Either way, do start standing up for yourself

rnsaslkih · 04/06/2022 22:29

It’s weird not to have told you upfront. People might lift up their top and have a scratch or whatever if they think they’re in private. Tell her to get someone else to feed her cats.

LarGoo · 04/06/2022 22:24

YANBU. I’d see this as a huge invasion of privacy, and you did nothing wrong by blocking the camera. Essentially this is all you could do to ensure that you were not filmed, which you have every right to do. Anyone who doesn’t respect this is frankly a bit creepy…

Seaweasel · 04/06/2022 22:20

I look after a friend's cat when she is away, have a chat to it, feed it, play with it etc. I would be very unhappy if I later found out I was being filmed. I am doing nothing wrong but I am under the impression that it is just me and the cat. If I am being filmed in a private home, I would want to know about it. This goes for garden cameras too. How depressing.

henkon · 04/06/2022 22:19

I think yanbu to feel uncomfortable about not knowing you was previously being filmed but if alls you are doing is feeding the cats then it really isn't much of an issue. Yabu to cover up the camera when you're meant to just be feeding them, why did you need to cover it? Would you tell your friend to look away whilst you fed her cats if she was home? Your friend isn't unreasonable to have a camera to watch her cats but she should have told you it was there. If shes actively sat watching you in her house whilst you are there i would think she doesn't trust you whilst you're in her house alone.
Honestly if i was you i would just stop feeding them for her as it clearly makes you uncomfortable and she doesn't fully trust you if shes watching the camera back when you are there.