Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This picture shows a perfect example of women cast aside because of the patriarchal world we live in

285 replies

flashbac · 04/06/2022 14:15

Winner's podium of an 'inclusive' 'women's' cycling race.
Biological woman is third.

This picture shows a perfect example of women cast aside because of the patriarchal world we live in
OP posts:
lightand · 08/06/2022 21:49

They would need to do it en masse. Else they would get picked off, one by one.

lightand · 08/06/2022 21:49

I am not involved in sport. If I was, I would be kicking up a right rumpus.
But women competitors just are not doing so. Perhaps they actually are not all that bothered, at the end of the day. In which case, well no point doing anything.

lightand · 08/06/2022 21:46

Unless women stop competing[pretty sure I have written this before somewhere], it is not going to change. Is it. The coaches and all other people involved with it, kick up a fuss to.

I was on a thread the other day, think it was this forum, where a woman in a casual fun run I think it was, was not that fussed about the whole issue, until it directly affected her.

That is what has happened. People are not doing something[and that is doing something about something, as opposed to merely talking] until it comes all the way down to themselves or someone they care about.

Ithoughtsummerwascoming · 08/06/2022 21:42

Peonies I'm very grateful this isn't hidden away on a sub board!
People like me who don't really know what's going on but trying to raise daughters need to know this!

Ithoughtsummerwascoming · 08/06/2022 21:41

I'm not up with all of this but I also was confused because I saw men's legs?

I'm aghast! What the hell is going on??

TheKeatingFive · 08/06/2022 21:07

Ultimately, female specific sport was established for very good reason. If we're going to simply piss all over that because biological males want to have their cake and eat it, then let's at least be honest about it. If it's just about subsets of bodies, then why did we segregate sport in the first place?

SameSkyDifferentPlanet · 08/06/2022 20:50

@BetsyBigNose Thank you, yes, I did write this, I sometimes struggle with posting on this board because most of the women on here are such amazing wordsmiths, that I feel a bit inadequate. This poem just came to me because I know the emotion involved with being told that a girl can’t play football, cycle fast etc.

user30 · 05/06/2022 16:27

Peoniesandpeaches · 04/06/2022 14:40

And where is your AIBU? If there is no question or poll why couldn’t you post this on the feminism board? I’m really sick of all this crap being on the front page.

I'm sick of boring threads about weddings and school admissions when women are being treated with contempt

BatDuck · 05/06/2022 16:02

Perhaps the TW are just another subset of body type.

Yes they are. They are male, a subset of male people. They are not, in any shape or form, female. Unless you count nail varnish and long hair as a signifier of womanhood?

In which case, why does my uterus not make me a woman but a TW’s clothes and make up make them one?

BatDuck · 05/06/2022 16:02

Perhaps the TW are just another subset of body type.

Yes they are. They are male, a subset of male people. They are not, in any shape or form, female. Unless you count nail varnish and long hair as a signifier of womanhood?

In which case, why does my uterus not make me a woman but a TW’s clothes and make up make them one?

Attractinglife · 05/06/2022 13:46

onlytea · 05/06/2022 12:21

@WarriorN
I'm not sure what you think appropriating means but anyway. You seem to have missed the point of her video, Sabine, a world re-renowned physicist, makes some interesting points about sports in general and how body types play such a massive part in outcomes regardless of any trans questions.
Perhaps the TW are just another subset of body type.

I thought the application of some unemotional logic to some key points in this issue to be interesting. Especially if you accept that a solution that is fair to all should be found and if you consider trans people to be the gender that they identify as then what can be done?
Perhaps some kind of weight and height classes need to be determined rather than gender.

Yes we all know that body types make a big difference. And the most striking difference in body types is between male and female bodies. That is why if you look at the top performing sports people, across sports, the top performers are male.

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/06/2022 13:17

*Also - Lia is strutting

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/06/2022 13:14

Sorry = bold fail at height and weight bit

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/06/2022 13:12

onlytea · 05/06/2022 12:21

@WarriorN
I'm not sure what you think appropriating means but anyway. You seem to have missed the point of her video, Sabine, a world re-renowned physicist, makes some interesting points about sports in general and how body types play such a massive part in outcomes regardless of any trans questions.
Perhaps the TW are just another subset of body type.

I thought the application of some unemotional logic to some key points in this issue to be interesting. Especially if you accept that a solution that is fair to all should be found and if you consider trans people to be the gender that they identify as then what can be done?
Perhaps some kind of weight and height classes need to be determined rather than gender.

a world re-renowned physicist, makes some interesting points about sports in general and how body types play such a massive part in outcomes regardless of any trans questions.

Agreed - body types do play a massive part in outcomes in sport. That's why basketball is dominated by very tall people, and wrestling by stocky ones, and gymnastics by flexible ones and so forth

Perhaps the TW are just another subset of body type

We both know that's not true. If they are a "subset" of anything, then they are a "subset" of males - but not of male body type; of male "feelings"

Especially if you accept that a solution that is fair to all should be found and if you consider trans people to be the gender that they identify as then what can be done?

What can be done? Well - what about remember that "gender" (a social construct of stereotypes which varies between cultures and over history) is NOT the same as SEX (a biological fact which is immutable, is the same in every culture and has been so throughout history). That's a start.

And to address Tppl as the gender they identify is a courtesy - it doesn't mean that I have accepted they have "changed sex"- just that they have adopted the gender stereotypes associated with the opposite sex. I don't accept that any of these men are really women. Nor are TiFs men. Everyone remains he sex they were born, and which is observed and identified at birth - not "assigned".

*Perhaps some kind of weight and height classes need to be determined rather than gender."

Not the "gotcha" you might think - a 5'5, 9st man is considerably stronger and faster (on average) than a 5'5 9 st woman. He has greater bone density, more fast twitch muscles, larger heart greater lung capacity . . . and more.

Plus there is the changing room situation. 98% of TiMs do not have any surgery and many don't have hormone treatment either. Male trans athletes tend to have just enough hormone therapy to "qualify" as women. And they want to be validated as female by using women's facilities.

Lia Thomas, for instance, refused separate changing and showering facilities and demanded to use the same room as the girls on Lia's team. They aren't comfortable with this, but that's obviously just because they are transphobic bigots.

They have complained that Lia's towel often "slips" to reveal Lia's genitals - and that Lia is "obviously attracted to women" - ie he is strutting around the changing room and shower with an erection.

Do you think this is acceptable? Apart from unfairness in competition, where is the dignity and privacy for the women on Lia's team? Do you think it is even safe?

TangyTangerine · 05/06/2022 13:01

I'm confused. Why does the t shirt of the first and second winner say thunder. Are you sure this isn't the thunder category?

SpindleForTheWorld · 05/06/2022 12:30

Perhaps some kind of weight and height classes need to be determined rather than gender.

Like men's boxing, and women's boxing? Yes, I agree, sex-based, with weight classes where appropriate. Doesn't something like that already exist?

BetsyBigNose · 05/06/2022 12:25

SameSkyDifferentPlanet · 04/06/2022 16:16

Get out of the pool,
Take off that strip,
Pick up your ball,
Go Home!

Get off the court,
Leave the Green,
Put down the kit,
Go alone!

Here’s a ‘man’ to take your place,
So victory will be easy,
Whats with the all tears, the frustration and the fury?
What? You actually believed you were being taken seriously?

Go home. Go alone. Go now.
Theres a dearie.

@SameSkyDifferentPlanet - did you write this? I think it's excellent!

onlytea · 05/06/2022 12:21

@WarriorN
I'm not sure what you think appropriating means but anyway. You seem to have missed the point of her video, Sabine, a world re-renowned physicist, makes some interesting points about sports in general and how body types play such a massive part in outcomes regardless of any trans questions.
Perhaps the TW are just another subset of body type.

I thought the application of some unemotional logic to some key points in this issue to be interesting. Especially if you accept that a solution that is fair to all should be found and if you consider trans people to be the gender that they identify as then what can be done?
Perhaps some kind of weight and height classes need to be determined rather than gender.

JudgeJ · 05/06/2022 12:09

Surely the solution is to have three races, male female and trans. I knew the Germans were on to something with their der, die and das.

TheFoxAndTheStar · 05/06/2022 11:59

@CupidStunt22 I am sorry but that is literally not true. There were trans-men in the Thunder category. They just didn’t place well (unsurprisingly).

I don’t believe in the premise of the race, but let’s not pretend it was worse than what it actual was.

jacintaq · 05/06/2022 11:42

It's that it failed to be inclusive or fair.

Emily Bridges competed and won on a mens cycling team recently. Yet was out in a race as aligning like a woman.

Which is it? She cannot be both physically male and female in alignment.

Aside from anything else this should be challenged, and questioned, as the organisers own rules weren't followed.
Baffled that Jo would be ok with that, unless she thought it didn't matter as it was a one-off inclusive event not to be taken seriously, which is patronising at least and does nobody any favours.

CupidStunt22 · 05/06/2022 11:39

TheFoxAndTheStar · 05/06/2022 11:37

Actually @CupidStunt22 that’s not true.

The two available races were 1. Biological men only and anyone who wants to compete as a man and .2. Biological woman and anyone who wants to compete as a woman.

The issue is that few if any trans-men would compete against men, and if they did they certainly wouldn’t win, whereas trans-women are far, far more likely to win against women.

But it is true, because everyone in the male race was a biological man. There' aren't ever women trying to race against men, there are only ever men trying to race against women.

TheFoxAndTheStar · 05/06/2022 11:37

Actually @CupidStunt22 that’s not true.

The two available races were 1. Biological men only and anyone who wants to compete as a man and .2. Biological woman and anyone who wants to compete as a woman.

The issue is that few if any trans-men would compete against men, and if they did they certainly wouldn’t win, whereas trans-women are far, far more likely to win against women.

itsgettingweird · 05/06/2022 11:36

You all call for spaces where trans people can compete, someone created one, and that's still not good enough

The space for trans people to race is a trans category.

It is not the woman's category that was set up after a hard won fight for woman to have the same opportunities as men in sport.

It's not right to have woman's single sex sport eradicated for the rights of transgender athletes.

Even on the most basic level that sex and gender are not the same thing.

Sex is defined by XY and XX chromosomes.

Gender is defined by an individual deciding they are a man or woman based on a non defined set of gender stereotypes they have self decided exist and self decided make them a male or female.

WarriorN · 05/06/2022 11:35

And OMG this person says some sports body says it's ok to include TW who were on pb from pre teens.

Fucking hell.

Their bones won't be strong enough to cope with the rigours of training and their Hearts will be small.

Swipe left for the next trending thread