Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think you tell someone pre going on a date

642 replies

floralarrangement · 04/06/2022 11:42

that you have a 2 year old and a 4 year old?!

Just got back from a brunch date and this was casually brought up. I feel like this is a HUGE deal, especially due to the ages. I don't have children and don't want to date someone who does. I'm 28 so maybe I'll change my mind on this later in life.

I feel like he didn't tell me (and probably other women) in advance as a way of getting dates from people who otherwise would've said no. Is this too harsh? For those of you who do OLD, do you tell people in advance/put it on your profile?

We work together (huge organisation - didn't know of him before & none of my friends do) which meant I felt pressured have a good date with him because I hate awkwardness. I already have one ex-boyfriend at work which I find stressful, I'd rather not make it a pattern with multiple people I have to avoid for one reason or another Grin

OP posts:
Cattenberg · 06/06/2022 09:14

A good guide is to disclose anything pre-date that appears on a public register.

Marriage, divorce, children, criminal record...

How many people would declare a divorce or criminal record before the first date? Some might mention the divorce, but many wouldn’t.

aSofaNearYou · 06/06/2022 09:12

Frankola · 06/06/2022 02:45

If you don't want to date someone with kids I suggest you ask the person if they have kids prior to agreeing any dates.

I wouldnt put my dd on my OLD profile. She has a right to privacy. I also wouldn't just "announce" I have a child. I have quite a lot of other things going for me!

If its your dealbreaker then you should be asking people yourself. Not expecting them to tell you.

I don't think anyone would say this about any other obvious dealbreakers, such as expecting people to ask if their potential date is polyamorous or lives overseas half the time. You'd expect the person who has something in their life which is an obvious dealbreaker, to mention it, and if they didn't mention it you'd assume they didn't.

Having a lot going for you doesn't mean anything when you have kids, that suggests you really underestimate how much of an impact they will have on any potential relationship. You shouldn't want someone that doesn't want to date someone with kids but has been persuaded by your other qualities, believe me I was that person!

Frankola · 06/06/2022 02:45

If you don't want to date someone with kids I suggest you ask the person if they have kids prior to agreeing any dates.

I wouldnt put my dd on my OLD profile. She has a right to privacy. I also wouldn't just "announce" I have a child. I have quite a lot of other things going for me!

If its your dealbreaker then you should be asking people yourself. Not expecting them to tell you.

ringalingling · 06/06/2022 00:35

@AchatAVendre to be fair I always would (and do) bring up having kids and I usually add in the fact I'm pretty set on moving out of the city, so I agree with you on a personal level.

However it's mostly done during the "so what are you looking for on here?" stage. Sometimes the other person will ask that Q first but if not I tend to make sure it happens before a date because I don't want to meet someone seeking casual. Meeting them won't change my mind. Tom Hardy wouldn't change my mind 😂. It's at the "real talk" point that it's pretty easy to mention the common dealbreakers because it's an actual discussion and not just slotted in or blurted out or whatever. It gives both people a point to bow out gracefully, or ask stuff if it's negotiable, or be reassured it's not a problem etc.

So while I agree in principle that anyone looking for a serious relationship should bring it up, the fact is not everyone sees the need to do so (and if they're not looking for serious that's probably valid) so avoiding any "real talk" in the spirit of keeping things light and fun before meeting might lead to situations where you're dating people who aren't right for you. Some people might just want to have fun and are happy to save the "real talk" moment for the first date, or the third date, or 3 months in, in which case the onus is on the other person to instigate that if they want to vet before dates and save time and effort.

It's clearly complicated and like everything it's a balance.

pixie5121 · 06/06/2022 00:12

RobynNora · 06/06/2022 00:05

@pixie5121 that’s a brilliant experiment! And he gave exactly the sort of response we’d expected.

I’d add that even if 50% of parents in OPs area were parents by 30, surely only a small percentage of them would be online dating following so soon after kids. Usually relationship breakdowns etc come a bit later on. Statistically, I mean. So it would still be a tiny portion of her dating pool.

Exactly, and that in itself is a massive red flag. Why did the relationship break down so soon after having the second child? I can think of several possible scenarios and not a single one of them is good.

RobynNora · 06/06/2022 00:05

@pixie5121 that’s a brilliant experiment! And he gave exactly the sort of response we’d expected.

I’d add that even if 50% of parents in OPs area were parents by 30, surely only a small percentage of them would be online dating following so soon after kids. Usually relationship breakdowns etc come a bit later on. Statistically, I mean. So it would still be a tiny portion of her dating pool.

AchatAVendre · 06/06/2022 00:05

ringalingling · 05/06/2022 23:58

Its really not going to limit the "dating pool" of 28 year old professional women with any statistical significance, unless they want to date older men.

Agreed - I didn't think it would either to be honest (and if it did then good, they weren't for you anyway) but it has been given as the reason why women can't outright state their non-negotiables and therefore must rely on potential dates bringing them up before a date occurs so they don't waste their time.

I didn't suggest it, merely using that thought process to highlight the double standard.

Thats not a "double standard", thats expecting women to run around policing the ability of men to date.

I would think the same of any man of that age who asked me if I had children. I would think them weird, probably not from the same professional background as myself and more used to dating women who have children very early in life. Again, I would expect to disclose that information early on myself, without needing to be asked, therefore I would be surprised if someone asked me.

In fact, if a man had asked me that when I was only 28, I'd possibly assume that he was the type of man who thought women weren't "proper women" unless they had children. There are some men who are very um lets say traditional who think that sort of thing. I certainly wouldn't be very keen to date a man who asked questions like that.

pixie5121 · 06/06/2022 00:03

AchatAVendre · 06/06/2022 00:00

A good guide is to disclose anything pre-date that appears on a public register.

Marriage, divorce, children, criminal record...

Indeed.

This thread has shown that common sense really isn't that common.

People equating having two small human beings relying on you to shagging a few people or not liking cats. The mind boggles.

AchatAVendre · 06/06/2022 00:00

SaveMePlease · 05/06/2022 23:55

@pixie5121 - absolutely agree. The thing is, whilst Brexit or hating cats could influence who people date, it's really not material to the majority of people which is why it's not something you would expect to see on a profile. If those type of things are material to someone, then one would expect them to raise it with prospective dates when messaging.

Kids on the other hand clearly is a material issue to a relationship so in that instance it is incumbent on the person with kids to raise it prior to the date. It's really not a matter of opinion...

A good guide is to disclose anything pre-date that appears on a public register.

Marriage, divorce, children, criminal record...

ringalingling · 05/06/2022 23:58

Its really not going to limit the "dating pool" of 28 year old professional women with any statistical significance, unless they want to date older men.

Agreed - I didn't think it would either to be honest (and if it did then good, they weren't for you anyway) but it has been given as the reason why women can't outright state their non-negotiables and therefore must rely on potential dates bringing them up before a date occurs so they don't waste their time.

I didn't suggest it, merely using that thought process to highlight the double standard.

pixie5121 · 05/06/2022 23:55

@ringalingling you seem to think it's common for 30-something city professionals to have children, and this is what you're basing your entire argument on. It really isn't. Nowhere near 50% of people in the circles OP and I run in are parents. I'd be surprised if it were even 5%.

There's really no way to casually enquire about whether someone has kids or not. It's a weird, jarring question that comes out of left field if they haven't mentioned it or referred to any kids. I'm chatting to a man on Hinge right now and asked him just to see what he would say. Not that into him so nothing to lose. This is what he said:

"Ehhh....well I'd be a bit of a shit dad if I had kids, given that I've just told you how I spent most of the bank hol on a bender...! Why do you ask...seems a bit random? Do you have some secret kids?!"

In other words, he's quite surprised and offended by the question, just as most normal, decent people would be, and he's also now suspicious of me. Weirdly enough, basically accusing someone of being a liar and a sneak doesn't exactly go down very well and makes them wonder what kind of person YOU are.

If I'm chatting to someone from another country, I do ask what their plans are re staying or going, because it's something you can very easily segue into from general chat. For example, they say they're from Portugal, boom, ask them if they go back a lot, and then if they see themselves going back for good anytime soon. You can never segue into 'so do you have kids?' from general back and forth banter.

You don't understand what a pickme is if you think having emotional intelligence, social skills, and a basic understanding of how humans work makes you one.

SaveMePlease · 05/06/2022 23:55

@pixie5121 - absolutely agree. The thing is, whilst Brexit or hating cats could influence who people date, it's really not material to the majority of people which is why it's not something you would expect to see on a profile. If those type of things are material to someone, then one would expect them to raise it with prospective dates when messaging.

Kids on the other hand clearly is a material issue to a relationship so in that instance it is incumbent on the person with kids to raise it prior to the date. It's really not a matter of opinion...

AchatAVendre · 05/06/2022 23:52

Ringalingaling Surely its just common sense when looking for a partner (and not a casual fling) to check that you have the same broad life goals? It's pretty basic compatibility stuff.

Well, exactly. If you have kids, mention that you have kids at some point in the 2 weeks you have been chatting to someone before you meet up for a date...don't expect someone else to chase around you seeking out information like a sleuth.

I agree with a pp that specifically checking if someone has kids would come across as odd and out of place amongst a broad demographic. The onus has to be on the parent to reveal it. Not necessarily on their dating profile but at least before meeting up.

Wasn't there a post on here a while back about a woman who didn't reveal that she was pregnant before going on a date, and still hadn't revealed it 2 dates in or something?

The onus has to be on the possessor of the material fact to reveal it. Ditto smoking, doing drugs, being married or divorced or separated. But having kids and marital status are two such important facts that they need to be revealed, and any decent person would mention them.

Being secretive and choosing what important things to reveal or not to reveal are horrible traits.

ringalingling · 05/06/2022 23:51

I, and others, have painstakingly explained why it would be weird, after all this chit chat, to suddenly ask someone if they have children, because anyone with an ounce of emotional intelligence would have already mentioned it, unless they were deliberately trying to hide it.

Completely agree which is why it's better, IN GENERAL, to either communicate any dealbreakers OR vet potential dates for dealbreakers as early as possible, so it doesn't sound weird bringing up a dealbreaker two weeks into something.

Generally! General advice for future and anyone who wants to avoid similar happening Grin

As I've said before I think he was wrong to purposely hide them from your conversations. I suspect he is very new to this and hasn't yet come to the realisation that it's one of those things people who are looking for serious relationships would want to know about early on. Either that or he is genuinely looking for no strings casual in which case kids etc are irrelevant (but I assume that wasn't the case since he has changed his profile now and learned his lesson)

pixie5121 · 05/06/2022 23:43

Cattenberg · 05/06/2022 23:41

Any decent man would disclose any material fact that would affect somone's decision to date them or not.

That would make dating profiles quite comprehensive e.g.

DISCLAIMER

I have slept with more than 50 women.

I have a £30,000 credit card debt and am only paying the minimum payment each month.

I voted for Brexit.

I am estranged from my brother.

I have nine points on my driving licence, all for speeding on the M5.

I hate cats.

Why would most of those affect someone's decision to date them or not? None of them are in the same league as being responsible for two very young children. The Brexit thing is often mentioned on profiles and/or comes up in conversation.

ringalingling · 05/06/2022 23:42

@pixie5121 While I applaud your own personal open-minded dating stance we weren't talking about that? You were arguing from the POV of someone with a blanket ban, for whom kids are a non-negotiable that must be made known because it's non-negotiable and would waste the person with the blanket ban's time? Clearly it was hypothetical as you don't have a blanket ban however you appeared to be making those arguments and replying to me when I countered those arguments from you and others.

I don't think women have to state it on their profile, but they should be upfront about a blanket ban that's not uncommon or at the very least proactive about vetting for it. Wether that's via their profile or the initial messages or during a phone call or at the initial date is entirely up to the woman and how much time she wants to sink into something that might never work. Surely its just common sense when looking for a partner (and not a casual fling) to check that you have the same broad life goals? It's pretty basic compatibility stuff. Do it on the first day or on the tenth date, but the longer you leave it the more time you've spent and if you're late twenties and definitely want kids you don't exactly have all the time in the world.

Married, deaf, wheelchair, terminally ill etc (plus the trans and hiv examples brought up multiple times) while being valid dealbreakers are all fairly uncommon in comparison to other dealbreakers like parents, students, people who aren't settled in an area, people who are only looking for casual, people who work shifts. If you happen to end up on a date with one of the 0.00012% of people with whom you'd need to learn BSL to communicate with and that's a dealbreaker for you then that's pretty unfortunate but also statistically very unlikely. If you happen to end up on a date with one of the 50% of people who are already parents by their early thirties, or the 14% of shiftworkers, or the 14% of people born abroad who might want to return to settle down, and they are dealbreakers, it would save you wasting your time if you happened to enquire casually about kids / work / major life plans.

Or don't, and run the statistically common chance of going on dates with people who failed to mention these things because they assumed you wouldn't care. Or because they wanted to meet you before mentioning it. Or because they're not even looking for anything serious so why the hell would they mention kids / work / 5 year goals when it has no bearing on a casual fling.

All I've ever said is if you want to save yourself the hassle, then save yourself the hassle by being clear about what you want or don't want!!

All of this not being able to say what you want or don't want in a relationship because you want to keep things light or don't want them to judge you or make assumptions or you're scared of being written off as a one night stand sounds an awful lot like what the kids are calling Pick Me behaviour. Could be totally wrong but anyone saying these things just sound like they're still at the stage where they think acting like that will get them the guy. I'm sure it works some of the time, but why waste time on someone you don't actually want because you can't or won't communicate the standards you've set?

I speak from experience as a former Pickmeisha by the way. Hence why I'm a single parent now facing a more limited dating pool with limited time to waste. If you want an actual relationship with the potential for a future DON'T BE LIKE ME Grin

Cattenberg · 05/06/2022 23:41

Any decent man would disclose any material fact that would affect somone's decision to date them or not.

That would make dating profiles quite comprehensive e.g.

DISCLAIMER

I have slept with more than 50 women.

I have a £30,000 credit card debt and am only paying the minimum payment each month.

I voted for Brexit.

I am estranged from my brother.

I have nine points on my driving licence, all for speeding on the M5.

I hate cats.

pixie5121 · 05/06/2022 23:32

@AchatAVendre I wonder if he'll disclose at the low key dinner that he's actually married and 'forgot' to mention his wife when talking about what he did at the weekend 😂

LicoricePizza · 05/06/2022 23:29

@floralarrangement

As I’ve painstakingly maintained throughout!!* *

Yes he should have said it & wrong he didn’t after chatting for 2 weeks. But as people tend to lie in order to get a date it’s a bit silly to refuse to do her part in checking out who she’s actually meeting.

AchatAVendre · 05/06/2022 23:14

pixie5121 · 05/06/2022 22:51

LOL who does he think he is?

What's a 'low key dinner'? Cheap Nandos while he continues trying to reel you in and manipulate you into 'giving him a chance'?

"A low key dinner" is the sort of dinner that men who lie by omission on OLD have. They use special terms so that no-one can turn around and accuse them of lying/seeing other women/whatever because it was all "low key".

Ringalingaling According to pps both of these things, when disclaimed, can limit your dating pool because people make assumptions based on them and might put you into categories i.e one night stand category, swipe left category, unmatch category.

Its really not going to limit the "dating pool" of 28 year old professional women with any statistical significance, unless they want to date older men. It is this particular man who bucks the statistical trend, since he had his first kid at 26, 7 years younger than the average British man. And that age will be higher for professional men, so he really does buck all trends.

Any decent man would disclose any material fact that would affect somone's decision to date them or not.

Its all to do with boundaries and standards. If you have no problem with men who behave like this, then thats fine for you, go and date them. No-one is stopping you. But most people wouldn't be happy with their time being wasted.

RobynNora · 05/06/2022 23:13

He’s been reading mumsnet and has come back with renewed confidence.

He probably wants to take you to the soft play place with burgers!

mmmmmmghturep · 05/06/2022 23:05

I bet hes hoping OP will have to accept to prove shes not a child hater

Herejustforthisone · 05/06/2022 22:56

I wonder if his band of cheerleaders will be back.

Herejustforthisone · 05/06/2022 22:56

Ha, so he admits he’s a liar. And then asks for dinner. Wow. What a peach.

pixie5121 · 05/06/2022 22:51

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 22:45

oh and second update:

He has messaged again as he would like to do a "low key dinner"

have to admire the confidence, will reply in the morning

LOL who does he think he is?

What's a 'low key dinner'? Cheap Nandos while he continues trying to reel you in and manipulate you into 'giving him a chance'?

Swipe left for the next trending thread