Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think you tell someone pre going on a date

642 replies

floralarrangement · 04/06/2022 11:42

that you have a 2 year old and a 4 year old?!

Just got back from a brunch date and this was casually brought up. I feel like this is a HUGE deal, especially due to the ages. I don't have children and don't want to date someone who does. I'm 28 so maybe I'll change my mind on this later in life.

I feel like he didn't tell me (and probably other women) in advance as a way of getting dates from people who otherwise would've said no. Is this too harsh? For those of you who do OLD, do you tell people in advance/put it on your profile?

We work together (huge organisation - didn't know of him before & none of my friends do) which meant I felt pressured have a good date with him because I hate awkwardness. I already have one ex-boyfriend at work which I find stressful, I'd rather not make it a pattern with multiple people I have to avoid for one reason or another Grin

OP posts:
WisherWood · 05/06/2022 10:49

Most adults over 30 DO have kids. Assume they have kids and ask the question pre date...

Well with an aging population, the majority of adults are over 30, because that includes everyone from 30 to 100+. So it may well be that most adults over 30 do have kids. But most adults of around 30 do not. You can read a bit more on the stats here yougov.co.uk/topics/lifestyle/articles-reports/2021/06/21/what-ideal-age-have-children but the majority of 30 year old women and 30 year old men do not have children.

Tandora · 05/06/2022 10:44

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 10:35

Who made you Queen of what people have to disclose before a first date and what they don’t?

You can tell posters are running out of rational things to say when you resort to personal attacks!

@Tandora
I'm not sure why it needs explaining, but children or another partner are people. You are not just in a relationship with your partner in these situations. You aren't just building and having to consider a relationship with your partner, but with his children (or other partner) too.

You seem to think being a step-parent is something a woman should just blithely go into without thinking about what a huge responisbility it is.

It is not comparable to being disabled.

Of course I don’t think women are obliged to blithely walk into step parenting without thinking about it, how absurd! what makes you think I think that?

SmiledWtherisingsun · 05/06/2022 10:42

But sure, it's the woman's fault, why not How dare I go on a date with someone I work with & assume he doesn't have children with no evidence to the contrary

Oh give over op.
Ask the question if it's important next time.

Tandora · 05/06/2022 10:40

*in a situation

Tandora · 05/06/2022 10:40

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 10:37

I think again, you're bringing your own personal experiences into it and getting triggered by something which isn't yours to be offended by.

Not the PP, but it is not unreasoable to state that for a 28 year old woman (which the thread is about), having a partner who already has children is more likely to be undesireable than it is to be desireable.

There you are again making your own assumptions about others. This has nothing to do with me! I have never personally been in a station where I was or needed to OLD with kids, nor have I ever ended up on a date with a man who unexpectedly had them.
so no, not triggered.

ReachersAbs · 05/06/2022 10:39

pixie5121 · 05/06/2022 10:26

But where does that end?

Most people have huge lists of dealbreakers. Are they supposed to ask them all?

I went on a date years ago with a man who had omitted the fact he wasn't actually single. Are you seriously suggesting I should have to ask if someone is single if they're on a dating app, with a profile making no mention of a partner?

That’s a bit daft isn’t it and sort of undermines any relevant point you might have wanted to make.

A closer equivalent would be someone who’s a member of a particular political party or takes part in blood sports, that would be a deal breaker for me but it’s my responsibility to ask in advance if I wouldn’t even want to go on a date with them or chalk it up to experience if I found out on the first date that they fell in that category. They probably wouldn’t think to mention it if that’s the circles they moved in, so if it’s important to me then I need to take responsibility for it.

However, if the OP has said that the man deliberately withheld the information that is a different issue entirely. He’s a weasel.

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 10:37

Tandora · 05/06/2022 10:34

So now all people with children are to assume they are less desirable, and be morally required to pre disclose that undesirability in advance?
How rude! (and narrow minded of you).

I think again, you're bringing your own personal experiences into it and getting triggered by something which isn't yours to be offended by.

Not the PP, but it is not unreasoable to state that for a 28 year old woman (which the thread is about), having a partner who already has children is more likely to be undesireable than it is to be desireable.

OP posts:
floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 10:35

Who made you Queen of what people have to disclose before a first date and what they don’t?

You can tell posters are running out of rational things to say when you resort to personal attacks!

@Tandora
I'm not sure why it needs explaining, but children or another partner are people. You are not just in a relationship with your partner in these situations. You aren't just building and having to consider a relationship with your partner, but with his children (or other partner) too.

You seem to think being a step-parent is something a woman should just blithely go into without thinking about what a huge responisbility it is.

It is not comparable to being disabled.

OP posts:
Tandora · 05/06/2022 10:34

CRbear · 05/06/2022 09:36

@tandora - this would be true if being childless vs having children was equally desirable- I.e. roughly half of people would like it one way or the other. Having children is much less desirable and therefore not the default assumption. Many people on here have even said someone wanting to date you because you gave children is a red flag!

So now all people with children are to assume they are less desirable, and be morally required to pre disclose that undesirability in advance?
How rude! (and narrow minded of you).

Tandora · 05/06/2022 10:30

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 10:16

Being disabled is not the same thing as having children.

I've said in PPs that the two things that should be disclosed if you've got your settings to looking for a relationship is whether they already have a partner (and are looking for a polyamory type setup) or if they have children. They're both huge things which would impact greatly on a relationship and you should only go into if you've really considered it.

It isn't about whether you like children or not, it's thinking about the things that are involved with helping raise someone else's kids and all the potential issues that could arise.

Being disabled could also potentially hugely impact on a relationship (as could a multitude of other things).

You are correct, being disabled is not the same as having children; just as having an partner and looking for a non monogamous relationship is not the same as having children. Who made you Queen of what people have to disclose before a first date and what they don’t?

Rather than setting your own rules and demanding others conform to them (even though you have no means of enforcing that) , if you don’t want to go on a first date with a man who has children, then say so and / or ask.

pixie5121 · 05/06/2022 10:26

Sirzy · 05/06/2022 10:17

They are the things important to you. What you aren’t getting in not everyone feels the same as you! If something is a deal breaker for you then surely you would broach the subject early on?

But where does that end?

Most people have huge lists of dealbreakers. Are they supposed to ask them all?

I went on a date years ago with a man who had omitted the fact he wasn't actually single. Are you seriously suggesting I should have to ask if someone is single if they're on a dating app, with a profile making no mention of a partner?

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 10:24

How was he being disingenuous exactly?. Just because you had talked for a week or so before meeting doesn't mean for one minute he was hiding the fact he has children.

@Inthesameboatatmo

It is disengous to chat about the minutiate of your day/weekend and deliberately omit all details about your kids who live with you.

He knows this, I know this, and I do suspect most posters know it too. A lie by omission is the same as any other.

It's merely the fact that you as a person he hadn't even met yet in real life wasn't important enough to him to disclose HIS personal information to. You are coming across as very entitled tbh. Because you think you actually matter enough to be told something when you haven't even met in real life.

He has said he didn't want to be honest about having kids because he thought I would be less likely to meet up with him. It was nothing to do with "disclosing peronal information".

OP posts:
pixie5121 · 05/06/2022 10:23

Inthesameboatatmo · 05/06/2022 10:19

@floralarrangement.

How was he being disingenuous exactly?. Just because you had talked for a week or so before meeting doesn't mean for one minute he was hiding the fact he has children. It's merely the fact that you as a person he hadn't even met yet in real life wasn't important enough to him to disclose HIS personal information to. You are coming across as very entitled tbh. Because you think you actually matter enough to be told something when you haven't even met in real life.

Entitled delusion.

It's an effort to deliberately omit that you have kids. OP says they had been chatting about what they'd been doing, and all the stuff he'd done had been with his very young kids, but he somehow 'forgot' to mention them?

Bullshit.

pixie5121 · 05/06/2022 10:22

Tandora · 05/06/2022 10:09

If you're in the much less common situation, it's on YOU to inform

Interesting. Why are they obliged to thought?
if someone has a disability do you think they are obligated to disclose that before the first date?

Yes, I do.

I think people are ethically obliged not to deliberately conceal information that is very likely to be a dealbreaker to someone else.

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 10:20

Imo, @floralarrangement the man wasn't unreasonable

@ChoiceMummy

The man himself thinks he was, in retrospect.

I did not specifically say anything to him on the date (about feeling like he should be more upfront), but he has since updated his profile & sent me a long message explaining why he wasn't honest.

As I said many posts ago, kudos to him, and I wish him all the best in finding a woman that will make him and his kids happy.

OP posts:
Inthesameboatatmo · 05/06/2022 10:19

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 09:06

You don't find it strange, or odd, or clearly a mark of someone being disengenous, that you would have two weeks worth of conversation about the minutiae of your day, where he was living with his 2 and 4 year old, and omit all details of them from their life? Including telling me all about a weekend trips in retrospect was specifically for the kids?

I'm glad he agrees with me, but not sure why some posters are bending over backwards to defend something that was clearly him trying to hide that he has children.

@floralarrangement.

How was he being disingenuous exactly?. Just because you had talked for a week or so before meeting doesn't mean for one minute he was hiding the fact he has children. It's merely the fact that you as a person he hadn't even met yet in real life wasn't important enough to him to disclose HIS personal information to. You are coming across as very entitled tbh. Because you think you actually matter enough to be told something when you haven't even met in real life.

Sirzy · 05/06/2022 10:17

They are the things important to you. What you aren’t getting in not everyone feels the same as you! If something is a deal breaker for you then surely you would broach the subject early on?

ChoiceMummy · 05/06/2022 10:16

floralarrangement · 04/06/2022 18:46

Asking if someone has kids if they haven't mentioned any in days of chat is fucking weird and borderline offensive. It would get a lot of people's backs up to have it implied they would conceal something like that, and it would make them wonder what you're hiding, IMO.

Yes @pixie5121 !

Have been struggling to articulate this. I feel like it's a weird thing to do, and I've never asked anyone before and never have this issue come up.

A poster questioned if he had asked me if I had children. I would've found it weird & assumed he'd had a bad previous experience if he had done, given the context of my childfree profile & weeks of chat.

@floralarrangement
I learned long ago, if you have real preferences or non negotiables, when OLD it's your responsibility to ensure that these are met.

I'm a parent, don't think children of the same age would ever work for my child, so I ask the ages in conversation if they say they have children. If not divorced, I ask if they now live separately. If they don't suggest they work, I ask what they do! It's not an interrogation, it's a conversation. And given these are areas that are of relevance to me, it is my responsibility to find these responses. It's not their responsibility to offer all of the information that I would like on their profile or when chatting; I accept they're not mind readers nor do they know what is important to me!

Imo, @floralarrangement the man wasn't unreasonable. Its also not about demographic circles because there are always outliers. The majority of my social circle at your age were unmarried and not parents, but there still was the married young with 2 children and divorced member, the single parent etc. They were a minority but existed.

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 10:16

Tandora · 05/06/2022 10:09

If you're in the much less common situation, it's on YOU to inform

Interesting. Why are they obliged to thought?
if someone has a disability do you think they are obligated to disclose that before the first date?

Being disabled is not the same thing as having children.

I've said in PPs that the two things that should be disclosed if you've got your settings to looking for a relationship is whether they already have a partner (and are looking for a polyamory type setup) or if they have children. They're both huge things which would impact greatly on a relationship and you should only go into if you've really considered it.

It isn't about whether you like children or not, it's thinking about the things that are involved with helping raise someone else's kids and all the potential issues that could arise.

OP posts:
Tandora · 05/06/2022 10:11

ReachersAbs · 05/06/2022 10:09

You don’t know that, you suspect it unless I’ve missed it and you asked and he told you.

This whole thread seems to be about who’s fault and responsibility it is to bring it up. Maybe it’s an age / life experience thing but it seems clear to me that you can’t account for other people’s behaviour so if something is important enough to be still thinking about it after the event you need to be proactive rather than rely on someone else - this is not specific to this thread but any situation.

This

ReachersAbs · 05/06/2022 10:09

You don’t know that, you suspect it unless I’ve missed it and you asked and he told you.

This whole thread seems to be about who’s fault and responsibility it is to bring it up. Maybe it’s an age / life experience thing but it seems clear to me that you can’t account for other people’s behaviour so if something is important enough to be still thinking about it after the event you need to be proactive rather than rely on someone else - this is not specific to this thread but any situation.

Tandora · 05/06/2022 10:09

If you're in the much less common situation, it's on YOU to inform

Interesting. Why are they obliged to thought?
if someone has a disability do you think they are obligated to disclose that before the first date?

seaUrchinOne · 05/06/2022 10:07

I find most people are upfront about children, even if not on profile but chatting before the date. I think you got unlucky. I would always mention I have children and most men are upfront about it, I don't think I've come across a man I've dated that's hidden it. Only that one guy I dated worked away for the whole week, every week, in a different part of the country, was a bit annoyed about because he wasted my time, I wouldn't of dated him if I'd known.
Ask questions on children before you date, as it's a big deal.

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 10:01

ReachersAbs · 05/06/2022 09:58

Seemingly that would be far too straightforward and not worthy of all this overthinking and blaming.

You literally found out something on a first date which means you won’t see them again, that’s the whole point of dating. Does it really matter in the grand scheme of things?

I would argue that 90% of the AIBU threads are based on the premise of overthinking and blaming @SmiledWtherisingsun, seems to be what the forum is for Grin

I didn't like the fact he deliberately concealed it because he knew I would be less likely to go on a date with him if he was upfront. So I started a thread on it!

OP posts:
ReachersAbs · 05/06/2022 09:58

SmiledWtherisingsun · 05/06/2022 09:49

Why don't you just ask before going on a date in future op?

Seemingly that would be far too straightforward and not worthy of all this overthinking and blaming.

You literally found out something on a first date which means you won’t see them again, that’s the whole point of dating. Does it really matter in the grand scheme of things?