Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think you tell someone pre going on a date

642 replies

floralarrangement · 04/06/2022 11:42

that you have a 2 year old and a 4 year old?!

Just got back from a brunch date and this was casually brought up. I feel like this is a HUGE deal, especially due to the ages. I don't have children and don't want to date someone who does. I'm 28 so maybe I'll change my mind on this later in life.

I feel like he didn't tell me (and probably other women) in advance as a way of getting dates from people who otherwise would've said no. Is this too harsh? For those of you who do OLD, do you tell people in advance/put it on your profile?

We work together (huge organisation - didn't know of him before & none of my friends do) which meant I felt pressured have a good date with him because I hate awkwardness. I already have one ex-boyfriend at work which I find stressful, I'd rather not make it a pattern with multiple people I have to avoid for one reason or another Grin

OP posts:
Gwenhwyfar · 05/06/2022 12:58

LuckySantangelo35 · 05/06/2022 12:54

@Tandora

oh come on, most child free women do not want a man who already has kids given the choice. Let’s not be disingenuous.

Exactly.
As you get older you realise you may have to accept it because there are more and more people with children, but at 28? Why would anyone want that rather than have their own children?

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 12:58

LuckySantangelo35 · 05/06/2022 12:54

@Tandora

oh come on, most child free women do not want a man who already has kids given the choice. Let’s not be disingenuous.

Aye.

I expect this changes above a certain age, but it's crazy to debate the idea that a professional woman in her 20s without kids probably isn't looking for a partner who already has them!

OP posts:
Gwenhwyfar · 05/06/2022 12:57

"@ReachersAbs I think, as a woman, all sorts of different issues can arise if you specify ‘no kids please’ in your dating profile or ask outright.
Men might think you dislike children and don’t want your own when this isn’t necessarily the case. You might also be placed in the one night stand category, which you might not necessarily want."

Interesting because I experimented with a dating site once - never actually joined - and putting 'don't want children' made me see the profiles only of men who already had children so the opposite of what OP wants. I think that's because it's only men who already have children who choose that.

LuckySantangelo35 · 05/06/2022 12:54

@Tandora

oh come on, most child free women do not want a man who already has kids given the choice. Let’s not be disingenuous.

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 12:53

Maybe he too wanted to seem “fun and breezy” and didn’t want to mention his kids for fear you’d make some judgements about him , solely on the basis of that, before you’d got to know him?

Yes that's exactly what he was doing @Tandora and I'm not sure why you don't see the issue with it?

He knew I wouldn't have met up with him had I known, so pretended he didn't have children.

He has since apologised, why continue to bend backwards defend him?

OP posts:
Tandora · 05/06/2022 12:46

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 11:43

No it's not ironic @Tandora and you seem to have ignored most of the post.

You have a couple of lines to write a fun and breezy intro to yourself. I don't want one of the lines to be taken up with "not interested in men with children", when a) this has never happened to me before, b) i see many men who do list children on their profile, and 3) it's obvious that it's a huge thing that the majority of 28 year old women would not find desireable

Maybe he too wanted to seem “fun and breezy” and didn’t want to mention his kids for fear you’d make some judgements about him , solely on the basis of that, before you’d got to know him?

Are you able to acknowledge at least that your perspective / experience is not universal ? Even to your particular “social circle” / “social demographic group”.

Matildahoney · 05/06/2022 12:39

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 09:06

You don't find it strange, or odd, or clearly a mark of someone being disengenous, that you would have two weeks worth of conversation about the minutiae of your day, where he was living with his 2 and 4 year old, and omit all details of them from their life? Including telling me all about a weekend trips in retrospect was specifically for the kids?

I'm glad he agrees with me, but not sure why some posters are bending over backwards to defend something that was clearly him trying to hide that he has children.

No, when I was OLD I didn't want to date anyone with kids so generally it was one of the first questions I asked because it was a big deal to me. You're as equally to blame for not asking the question! Why should people with children be expected to put it on their profile, there's a much of an argument for someone who doesn't want to date a parent to state that on theirs.

MinglingFlamingo · 05/06/2022 12:31

Op sounds like you and I are in a similar boat

I think it's a balancing act. On one hand I don't want to see your kids on your OLD profile and the phrase "my dc are my world " or words to that effect make me want to scream. Not expecting to be priority number one but it's hard enough to organise a date or whatever without putting kids into the mix as well

However, if you get to the stage of chatting and organising a date then maybe something could be mentioned.

LuckySantangelo35 · 05/06/2022 12:22

I’d have been pissed off too Op

when I was online dating there was no way I would have wanted to date men with kids.

you only have to look at the appalling way step mothers are treated on mumsnet to know why!!

RobynNora · 05/06/2022 12:17

@ReachersAbs if a fella phrased the question in the direct way you did I’d be put off. I’d wonder why they were asking if I have children when I’ve never been asked that before in dating chats. I’d probably wonder if he thinks I look ‘mumsy’ and why I’d give those vibes. Not the greatest reaction from me (esp now I’m a mum!) but I know lots of men would feel the same on a dating scene where childless is default. It’s understandable.

I also wouldn’t love your transactional style of questions generally. Why do you ask so formally about my job? You say you’re a bit older and it shows a little. Online dating is all quite fun and light in the early stages as you’re both talking to lots of different people and have to be witty in your approach conveying/gathering info else you’ll both forget about each other. I’m assuming OP is on something like Hinge rather than eHarmony.

Mumoblue · 05/06/2022 12:12

YANBU.
I understand why people wouldn’t put it on their profile but it just makes sense to mention it before springing it on someone halfway through a first date.

I’m a single parent at 32 and I wouldn’t want to have to invest my time into a date when I haven’t even established if they’re compatible with a major and non negotiable part of my life. Just seems sensible to me.

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 12:07

@ChoiceMummy

Nope, I never said that. I have been very very clear in my posts this is dependent on sociodemographic factors.

In my social circle, where I live, and in my profession the average age of first child is mid 30s. It is incredibly unusual to have children at my age, to be a stepmother, or to be divorced with kids.

This man works in my field (and in my company), he can see my dating profile. He knew I would not have gone on a date with him if I'd known this advanced, and has since apologised for not being upfront about it and has updated his profile. He said he wanted to meet in person so I could get to know him first, and that knew I probably wouldn't have done if I'd known in advance.

OP posts:
ChoiceMummy · 05/06/2022 12:01

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 11:43

No it's not ironic @Tandora and you seem to have ignored most of the post.

You have a couple of lines to write a fun and breezy intro to yourself. I don't want one of the lines to be taken up with "not interested in men with children", when a) this has never happened to me before, b) i see many men who do list children on their profile, and 3) it's obvious that it's a huge thing that the majority of 28 year old women would not find desireable

@floralarrangement
You are still assuming that the majority of 28yo women don't want to date a man with young children! Many people do enter relationships at that age and younger with someone who has children.
You don't want. That's fine. But don't assume that all don't.

Quincythequince · 05/06/2022 11:57

WisherWood · 05/06/2022 11:52

If you think they're the same thing, then I suggest you try saying to someone important at work "you wasted my time" rather than "my time is important too"

Neither I nor Tandora said they were the same thing. We both used the words 'clearly implied'. To imply = 'to communicate an idea or feeling without saying it directly' (Cambridge Dictionary). So no, they're not the same, one is a less direct way of saying it than the other.

Mind you, I have a feeling that this discussion is indeed a waste of time, so I'll leave it there.

Your phraseology is uncomplimentary hyperbole and the OP has the right to question it.

She said it the way she meant it.
You read into that if you like, but it’s ridiculous to put words in her mouth and then get annoyed when she objects.

And so what if she did feel it a waste of time? What of it?

Quincythequince · 05/06/2022 11:54

He'd deliberately not mentioned them

Yep, so it seems.

That’s not on.

WisherWood · 05/06/2022 11:52

If you think they're the same thing, then I suggest you try saying to someone important at work "you wasted my time" rather than "my time is important too"

Neither I nor Tandora said they were the same thing. We both used the words 'clearly implied'. To imply = 'to communicate an idea or feeling without saying it directly' (Cambridge Dictionary). So no, they're not the same, one is a less direct way of saying it than the other.

Mind you, I have a feeling that this discussion is indeed a waste of time, so I'll leave it there.

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 11:47

Quincythequince · 05/06/2022 11:43

I have three kids.
Nobody would come near me - they are massive teenage boys 😂
Only joking.

However in the run up to dating, I fail to see how they wouldn’t have come up in conversation (assuming you spoke before you met) if he’s an involved dad.

How’s that possible?

Ot does sound like he was hiding it until a face to face date which is sneaky; and to be honest a bit pointless because look at what OP has said.

I wouldn’t date a man with younger kids, no way. And many wouldn’t date a woman with three teenage boys.

Such is life.

Yup @Quincythequince

This is what led to me being annoyed. All this chat where he had omitted details that would have made it clear he had a two and four year old living with him!

For example, he told me all about a trip he took to a local tourist destination with his buddy Pete.

He and Pete got ice cream, he and Pete walked the trail etc etc. On the date when we were talking about it, he gave a lot more details where it turned out of course his two little boys had been with him too (ice cream had been dropped, short trail took 40 mins to walk etc etc Grin ).

He'd deliberately not mentioned them.

OP posts:
floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 11:43

Tandora · 05/06/2022 11:41

I think this is the real issue tbh. OP doesn’t want to write that on her profile for fear of how it might look (despite the fact that it is honest). Ironic perhaps?

No it's not ironic @Tandora and you seem to have ignored most of the post.

You have a couple of lines to write a fun and breezy intro to yourself. I don't want one of the lines to be taken up with "not interested in men with children", when a) this has never happened to me before, b) i see many men who do list children on their profile, and 3) it's obvious that it's a huge thing that the majority of 28 year old women would not find desireable

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 05/06/2022 11:43

I have three kids.
Nobody would come near me - they are massive teenage boys 😂
Only joking.

However in the run up to dating, I fail to see how they wouldn’t have come up in conversation (assuming you spoke before you met) if he’s an involved dad.

How’s that possible?

Ot does sound like he was hiding it until a face to face date which is sneaky; and to be honest a bit pointless because look at what OP has said.

I wouldn’t date a man with younger kids, no way. And many wouldn’t date a woman with three teenage boys.

Such is life.

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 11:41

RobynNora · 05/06/2022 11:36

@ReachersAbs I think, as a woman, all sorts of different issues can arise if you specify ‘no kids please’ in your dating profile or ask outright.

Men might think you dislike children and don’t want your own when this isn’t necessarily the case. You might also be placed in the one night stand category, which you might not necessarily want.

It also reads as quite prickly/heavy (a checklist, if you like) or like you’ve had a previous negative experience. Fun and breezy is the name of the game when online dating in your 20s - especially if people are flicking through profiles quickly - so this isn’t great

I dated in my 30s in a city and nobody ever asked about kids as it’s such a given that people on the market are single and generally too young to be on second marriages/relationships involving children. My younger sister dates in a more regional area where people settle down earlier and so more likely to have children but even there, they always disclose this

Yes, exactly to all of this @RobynNora !

OP posts:
Tandora · 05/06/2022 11:41

RobynNora · 05/06/2022 11:36

@ReachersAbs I think, as a woman, all sorts of different issues can arise if you specify ‘no kids please’ in your dating profile or ask outright.

Men might think you dislike children and don’t want your own when this isn’t necessarily the case. You might also be placed in the one night stand category, which you might not necessarily want.

It also reads as quite prickly/heavy (a checklist, if you like) or like you’ve had a previous negative experience. Fun and breezy is the name of the game when online dating in your 20s - especially if people are flicking through profiles quickly - so this isn’t great

I dated in my 30s in a city and nobody ever asked about kids as it’s such a given that people on the market are single and generally too young to be on second marriages/relationships involving children. My younger sister dates in a more regional area where people settle down earlier and so more likely to have children but even there, they always disclose this

I think this is the real issue tbh. OP doesn’t want to write that on her profile for fear of how it might look (despite the fact that it is honest). Ironic perhaps?

ReachersAbs · 05/06/2022 11:40

RobynNora · 05/06/2022 11:36

@ReachersAbs I think, as a woman, all sorts of different issues can arise if you specify ‘no kids please’ in your dating profile or ask outright.

Men might think you dislike children and don’t want your own when this isn’t necessarily the case. You might also be placed in the one night stand category, which you might not necessarily want.

It also reads as quite prickly/heavy (a checklist, if you like) or like you’ve had a previous negative experience. Fun and breezy is the name of the game when online dating in your 20s - especially if people are flicking through profiles quickly - so this isn’t great

I dated in my 30s in a city and nobody ever asked about kids as it’s such a given that people on the market are single and generally too young to be on second marriages/relationships involving children. My younger sister dates in a more regional area where people settle down earlier and so more likely to have children but even there, they always disclose this

Of course it doesn’t!

What do you do for a living? Oh you like rugby? What team do you support? Have you got any kids?

ReachersAbs · 05/06/2022 11:38

Honestly, because I’m much older than you and can see that life is much less stressful and more straightforward when you just get over yourself, take responsibility for what you want in life and be up front about it rather than expecting other people to behave in the way you think is acceptable.

Your insistence on continuing to do the same thing when a simple question would get rid of any risk, seems pretty immature, especially when the potential outcome seems so dramatic for you.

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 11:37

@Tandora you seem to be not replying to any questions people ask you, just attempting to contradict all my statements.

I have said many many many times now

As I've said a couple of times now if this becomes a trend then of course I'll start asking and obviously couldn't really complain it has happened twice! However, it's the first time it's happened, he's apologised, and I'm putting it down as a blip.

It is ridiculous for someone to read that and take it as me not "taking responsibility for your own needs and desires" or me refusing to ask the question, as the PP said.

OP posts:
RobynNora · 05/06/2022 11:36

@ReachersAbs I think, as a woman, all sorts of different issues can arise if you specify ‘no kids please’ in your dating profile or ask outright.

Men might think you dislike children and don’t want your own when this isn’t necessarily the case. You might also be placed in the one night stand category, which you might not necessarily want.

It also reads as quite prickly/heavy (a checklist, if you like) or like you’ve had a previous negative experience. Fun and breezy is the name of the game when online dating in your 20s - especially if people are flicking through profiles quickly - so this isn’t great

I dated in my 30s in a city and nobody ever asked about kids as it’s such a given that people on the market are single and generally too young to be on second marriages/relationships involving children. My younger sister dates in a more regional area where people settle down earlier and so more likely to have children but even there, they always disclose this