Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think you tell someone pre going on a date

642 replies

floralarrangement · 04/06/2022 11:42

that you have a 2 year old and a 4 year old?!

Just got back from a brunch date and this was casually brought up. I feel like this is a HUGE deal, especially due to the ages. I don't have children and don't want to date someone who does. I'm 28 so maybe I'll change my mind on this later in life.

I feel like he didn't tell me (and probably other women) in advance as a way of getting dates from people who otherwise would've said no. Is this too harsh? For those of you who do OLD, do you tell people in advance/put it on your profile?

We work together (huge organisation - didn't know of him before & none of my friends do) which meant I felt pressured have a good date with him because I hate awkwardness. I already have one ex-boyfriend at work which I find stressful, I'd rather not make it a pattern with multiple people I have to avoid for one reason or another Grin

OP posts:
floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 16:33

why can’t your pride allow you to consider it might be proudest next time just to ask??

@LicoricePizza

Fifth time and counting.....

As I've said a couple of times now if this becomes a trend then of course I'll start asking and obviously couldn't really complain it has happened twice! However, it's the first time it's happened, he's apologised, and I'm putting it down as a blip.

OP posts:
LicoricePizza · 05/06/2022 16:31

Prudent

LicoricePizza · 05/06/2022 16:29

@floralarrangement

This is the problem with your argument.

You are perfectly entitled to not want to date a man with kids. But your refusal to acknowledge any part in the responsibility for information finding about each other is what is making you appear as others have said “entitled” or “narrow minded” or “immature”.

You’re saying that in your socio- demographic professional circle nobody has kids or are on their second marriages.

It is socially unacceptable, awkward & unusual to even ask such a question upfront because it would seem so out of left field because it is so at odds with the norms of that social group.

Therefore anyone transgressing this code by a) being an outlier & actually having kids
is responsible for sharing this at the outset so as not to inconvenience you when your time could be better spent concentrating meeting someone who does fit these universally acknowledged criteria (for this particular social group).

And because he knows this to be true too - because he himself subscribes to this social group & its rules, broke the code by not telling you upfront.

He, despite being a total stranger, innately knew that you being from this homogenous group, would

knew I would not have gone on a date with him if I'd known this advanced

because* *
This man works in my field (and in my company), he can see my dating profile.

and

He knew I wouldn't have met up with him had I known.

Your reliance on others, complete strangers, sharing your expectations of what is socially acceptable for a group of supposedly homogeneous individuals has been shown to have proved unreliable, however because you have encountered an outlier, who whilst subscribing to many of the facets of this homogenous group of people, is different, in as much as he does have kids.

Nothing in your chat with him prior to meeting, or in your profile suggests that you are not ok with meeting someone with kids, bar your membership to this social group.

Your steadfast reliance on
He knew I wouldn't have met up with him had I known.

Is what people are saying is problematic.

How could he have known that? How could he have 100% known that you aren’t one of those people, who whilst subscribing to the many values & practises of said social group, wouldn’t mind it if he had kids?

I have personally always maintained that he should have mentioned his kids to you! But like so many daters you will probably encounter, he was trying to present himself in the best possible light to you. (And yes it backfired on him).

My & a lot of PP’s point is your refusal to adapt your (actually quite) rigid stance & belief that your approach is fail safe - when it patently isn’t.

Hopefully you will go on to select truthful people from the sane homogenous group who by virtue of being in this group will have exactly the same values as you on things like children etc.

But you are in for an interesting ride if you make the somewhat erroneous assumption that all 30something professional London living people on a dating app will subscribe to the same unspoken & universally acknowledged rules that you do.

Of course you can’t screen out everything in advance - but given that it is tiresome to invest in someone only to realise something fundamental about them that is a dealbreaker - why can’t your pride allow you to consider it might be proudest next time just to ask??

pixie5121 · 05/06/2022 16:23

SmiledWtherisingsun · 05/06/2022 14:23

You are being incredibly narrow minded at your age op.

Why not just put "no parents" on your own profile?

Also, I find it very self involved to be moaning about this on a parenting website. Just imo.

Because maybe it's not a blanket thing? Maybe there could be a situation in which she'd consider dating a parent? Maybe she quite rightly and understandably doesn't want that to appear as if she never wants kids of her own? Why is it on OP to change her profile and not on the people being deliberately deceptive?

lifecanbehardattimes · 05/06/2022 16:19

If you spoke to him before meeting up, can't you simply ask him if he has children?

AvocadoOnToastt · 05/06/2022 16:19

I think you need to start asking early on before meeting if it's a deal breaker for you. Fool me once...

pixie5121 · 05/06/2022 16:18

Tandora · 05/06/2022 12:46

Maybe he too wanted to seem “fun and breezy” and didn’t want to mention his kids for fear you’d make some judgements about him , solely on the basis of that, before you’d got to know him?

Are you able to acknowledge at least that your perspective / experience is not universal ? Even to your particular “social circle” / “social demographic group”.

When you have kids, you give up the privilege of being 'fun and breezy' on dating apps. You put your kids first, and that includes being honest about their existence and not lying in an attempt to get laid. If you can't manage that, then don't fucking have kids in your twenties. It's not hard.

KatherineJaneway · 05/06/2022 16:18

MissNothing1991 · 05/06/2022 15:53

Think it's shallow to choose whether to date someone based on whether or not they have kids. I find it hurtful when men turn me down because of my one child.

Of course it isn't shallow. What a ridiculous thing to say.

pixie5121 · 05/06/2022 16:16

RobynNora · 05/06/2022 12:17

@ReachersAbs if a fella phrased the question in the direct way you did I’d be put off. I’d wonder why they were asking if I have children when I’ve never been asked that before in dating chats. I’d probably wonder if he thinks I look ‘mumsy’ and why I’d give those vibes. Not the greatest reaction from me (esp now I’m a mum!) but I know lots of men would feel the same on a dating scene where childless is default. It’s understandable.

I also wouldn’t love your transactional style of questions generally. Why do you ask so formally about my job? You say you’re a bit older and it shows a little. Online dating is all quite fun and light in the early stages as you’re both talking to lots of different people and have to be witty in your approach conveying/gathering info else you’ll both forget about each other. I’m assuming OP is on something like Hinge rather than eHarmony.

100% this. I think some people commenting have trouble comprehending that there might be a very different world outside their tiny little bubble.

It would just be fucking weird to randomly ask someone if they have kids if they haven't mentioned it at all on their profile and you've been having casual chats about what you've been up to. It would offend, or at the very least confuse, far more people than it would weed out those who are deliberately hiding their kids.

I'm nearly 37 and have been using apps on and off for about a decade. I have never, literally never, not once, been asked if I have children. The default is that you don't. Even at my age. This is how it is in professional London circles. You don't shoehorn in 'BTW do you have any kids?' when someone is telling you about the film shorts programme they've just seen or the craft beer place they went to.

pixie5121 · 05/06/2022 16:10

floralarrangement · 05/06/2022 11:47

Yup @Quincythequince

This is what led to me being annoyed. All this chat where he had omitted details that would have made it clear he had a two and four year old living with him!

For example, he told me all about a trip he took to a local tourist destination with his buddy Pete.

He and Pete got ice cream, he and Pete walked the trail etc etc. On the date when we were talking about it, he gave a lot more details where it turned out of course his two little boys had been with him too (ice cream had been dropped, short trail took 40 mins to walk etc etc Grin ).

He'd deliberately not mentioned them.

This is so hugely, enormously dishonest that it's a total no brainer. Anyone defending this behaviour needs to have a long hard look at their own morals and ethics. It is not OK to just edit your kids out of stories about what you did at the weekend and to purposely give the impression of being a young, free, single, childless guy because you're afraid you won't get dates otherwise.

What a fucking arsehole.

pixie5121 · 05/06/2022 16:07

ReachersAbs · 05/06/2022 10:39

That’s a bit daft isn’t it and sort of undermines any relevant point you might have wanted to make.

A closer equivalent would be someone who’s a member of a particular political party or takes part in blood sports, that would be a deal breaker for me but it’s my responsibility to ask in advance if I wouldn’t even want to go on a date with them or chalk it up to experience if I found out on the first date that they fell in that category. They probably wouldn’t think to mention it if that’s the circles they moved in, so if it’s important to me then I need to take responsibility for it.

However, if the OP has said that the man deliberately withheld the information that is a different issue entirely. He’s a weasel.

No, it's not remotely daft.

Having a partner is in exactly the same category as having kids, in terms of huge, important life things that need to be mentioned. In fact, your example is daft. How can you compare a hobby or a political party to being responsible for two human beings?

Someone might love hunting but be prepared to give it up if they met a partner who really hated it. Someone might be a meat eater but be prepared to go vegetarian if the love of their life couldn't stomach meat.

You can't just make your kids disappear.

BiscoffSundae · 05/06/2022 15:59

MissNothing1991 · 05/06/2022 15:53

Think it's shallow to choose whether to date someone based on whether or not they have kids. I find it hurtful when men turn me down because of my one child.

Shallow really? For not wanting to be a step parent?!

MissNothing1991 · 05/06/2022 15:53

Think it's shallow to choose whether to date someone based on whether or not they have kids. I find it hurtful when men turn me down because of my one child.

2bazookas · 05/06/2022 15:32

Any thing that's a complete deal breaker for you,, you have the choice to mention it BEFORE the first date, to save wasting everybody's time.

If kids are a N0 NO, you should have said so before the date.

ringalingling · 05/06/2022 15:30

Not the PP, but it is not unreasoable to state that for a 28 year old woman (which the thread is about), having a partner who already has children is more likely to be undesireable than it is to be desireable.

IME that's a bit of a nonsense assumption though? Early twenties and I might have agreed with you, but by late twenties I think a fair amount of women are thinking about children and wanting to settle down (and the ones who aren't but definitely want children at some point probably should be, as sadly evidenced by the vast amounts of threads on here from mid-30s women who either can't find a partner because the dating pool is at its smallest or are have found a partner but now struggling to conceive because they're years past peak fertility).

If I was 28 and knew I wanted children in the near future and there was two 30 year old men to choose from, I think I'd be more inclined to choose the single dad with his own house / car, a steady job, and a life already set up where weekends are family time and socialising is a Tuesday night 5aSide or Sunday morning at the golf range over the single guy who is flat sharing with 3 other people in a city centre and plans to spend next summer in Thailand.

I know my ex is in the first boat and has never struggled finding dates, but I guess they are probably not the type who want to have another 5-10 years building their career and living in short term lets between flat shares.

And I still maintain those types of women are getting less common in their late 20s and early 30s. What you tend to find is a lot of single women around 30 who want to settle down but can't because the male early 30s dating pool is made up of the two types I listed above (the single dads and the peter pans who don't have biological clocks). They're holding out for the rare unicorn who is living the life of the responsible single dad type (with the job and house and settled lifestyle) but without the children.

It's totally fair enough if you don't want to date single dads because you are years away from settling down yourself / don't want children / don't want somebody else's children / whatever reason you damn well please, but I totally disagree that the default for 28 year women is to find single father's undesirable. I can however see how someone who lives in London and is building their career as a lawyer for whom children are a far-off pipedream might definitely think that, but that's not the reality for most women.

Giraffesandbottoms · 05/06/2022 15:19

I bet if you put on your dating profile “not interested in dating men with children” you would still get a number of men who either didn’t bother to read it properly or are arrogant enough to assume you’ll change your mind once they have dazzled you with their sparkling personalities!

Inthesameboatatmo · 05/06/2022 15:05

SaveMePlease · 05/06/2022 14:29

Can’t believe the people defending the guy. It sounds like those people are justifying on the basis that it’s ok because it keeps their options open if they were or are in a similar situation. Going into a relationship which could result in step kids and dealing with children’s mother is massive and the OP is late 20’s so would be even more entitled to assume the guy had no kids if he didn’t say anything to the contrary.

@Savemeplease.

Nobody is defending the guy. Pp like myself are merely stating that he doesn't have to disclose that information before a first date. A first date is hardly entering into a relationship is it.

ringalingling · 05/06/2022 14:50

They're both huge things which would impact greatly on a relationship and you should only go into if you've really considered it.

It isn't about whether you like children or not, it's thinking about the things that are involved with helping raise someone else's kids and all the potential issues that could arise.

I feel like this is where the disagreement is though. You believe this would impact greatly on a relationship, but not everyone does. I've been a single parent since I was a teenager so I've done my fair share of OLD at various points and there has a been a vast array of potential partners with various circumstances for whom it just hasn't been an issue at all. The pool is undeniably smaller especially if you want a partner in their early twenties, but I've dated people at that age who like children but have no intention of having their own (or cannot physically have their own) and either don't mind / like / actively seek out the prospect of 'the best of both worlds' type situations where the home is already established, the partner with kids has all their shit together already, and they can slot themselves into that without 100% of the responsibility and every weekend free to do couple things together. I've dated people from their early twenties to mid forties, and parents and non parents who haven't batted an eyelid at it. My stepdad met my mum in their early 30s and the fact she had children made minuscule difference considering we were teens who'd already moved out and she was happy to have the additional children he really wanted with him. It was not a huge thing that greatly impacted a relationship at all.

A huge thing which would greatly impact a relationship for many people would be someone who works offshore / abroad for weeks at a time, but for me I wouldn't bat an eyelid as I generally have my own life and wouldn't mind it all. This directly contradicts your assumption that potential partners have to think about helping to raise someone else's kids. I have never and would never want or expect that. If a potential partner did (because he couldn't have his own children) then that would be discussed the same as if they wanted to move to Australia. I'm sure some single parents are looking for a partner to take on that responsibility, which is totally fine and again something that needs to be discussed and considered.

We're all different which is why I maintain that if something - anything - that's not incredibly rare (like trans or HIV or poly) is a dealbreaker for you then you should just ask and save yourself the bother of getting to know someone who it's never going to work with. Do you have children is more on par with are you looking for a relationship or casual or do you plan to stay in Glasgow or move back to Spain than do you already have a wife or do you have HIV lol Grin.

That said I don't actually think you are being unreasonable OP. I agree with you that the guy could have said something at any point and the fact you had a couple of weeks conversation and he didn't mention it is odd and not something I would ever do. I don't think many people are disagreeing with that (I'm certainly not!) more just saying it would be easier for you (and anyone else with dealbreakers that aren't totally obscure) to ask.

My major disagreement on this thread is the people saying having children is this obscure / extremely rare thing that's a straight up dealbreaker for most people and must be explicitly stated ASAP. As I said, early 30s is the average so 50% of people who will be parents already are. It's no different than any other getting to know you / vetting situation where you find out their job / living situation / life goals / hobbies / seriousness whatever other factors you are looking for (or avoiding) in a potential partner.

whumpthereitis · 05/06/2022 14:50

I’d be annoyed too, he’s wasted your time as well as his own. Kids are a pretty major part of someone’s life, and imo it’s information that should be shared before a first date even if you don’t mention it in your profile. That said, it’s best to mention you’re not interested in men with kids too.

A lot of 28 year old men don’t have children, but even if they did, that doesn’t mean you’re obliged to compromise.

Kids were a dealbreaker for me when I was single in my mid to late 20s and I never had trouble meeting men that didn’t have them.

Tandora · 05/06/2022 14:41

Quincythequince · 05/06/2022 14:38

The emoji is a troll.
👹

But Seriously though 🕊

Have a good day

😊

Oh I see. I only glanced at it briefly on my phone and thought it was a lion 🤣. Yes- peace. Hope you have a good day too x

Quincythequince · 05/06/2022 14:38

Tandora · 05/06/2022 14:33

The capitalisations, cursing, use of exclamation marks, red lion emoji, and personal attacked on my character sincerely gave me that impression (that you were angry), it certainly was by no means a manipulative tactic on my part. It can be hard to read emotional intent through text.

The emoji is a troll.
👹

But Seriously though 🕊

Have a good day

😊

Tandora · 05/06/2022 14:36

Quincythequince · 05/06/2022 14:24

I have “bizarre views”, yet 46% of voters said YABU? 🤔

46% of people who are in one half
of the respondents camp here, don’t necessarily agree with your rationale here.

Yes that is true

Tandora · 05/06/2022 14:33

Quincythequince · 05/06/2022 14:23

Am not angry at all Tandora, nothing about my posts indicates that. Incredulous, yes.

I see what you’re doing and You really must stop reading into people’s posts so much, with a view to casting a negative shadow on them to further support your position.

The capitalisations, cursing, use of exclamation marks, red lion emoji, and personal attacked on my character sincerely gave me that impression (that you were angry), it certainly was by no means a manipulative tactic on my part. It can be hard to read emotional intent through text.

SaveMePlease · 05/06/2022 14:29

Can’t believe the people defending the guy. It sounds like those people are justifying on the basis that it’s ok because it keeps their options open if they were or are in a similar situation. Going into a relationship which could result in step kids and dealing with children’s mother is massive and the OP is late 20’s so would be even more entitled to assume the guy had no kids if he didn’t say anything to the contrary.

Quincythequince · 05/06/2022 14:24

I have “bizarre views”, yet 46% of voters said YABU? 🤔

46% of people who are in one half
of the respondents camp here, don’t necessarily agree with your rationale here.