Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this overt racism totally shocking in 2022

162 replies

DownToTheSeaAgain · 04/06/2022 11:01

With the extended in-laws yesterday. Had a conversation about society and the role of state vs individual. All good and better than the usual run of the mill smalltalk. However in the middle of it SIL made a comment so outrageous and racist that shocked all of us in the room.

She kept on repeating it. This is an educated woman in her late 50s.

For full disclosure no one was drinking.

My AIBU is that I can't let it go. Is that normal?I woke up this morning feeling quite unsettled. I can't now see her as anything other than a racist bigot.

I can't go low contact as one of her adult DC lives with my family so for the sake of the DC (who is great) I have to suck it up.

Coping strategies?

OP posts:
Tania64 · 04/06/2022 14:05

BrioNotBiro · 04/06/2022 11:08

Why is 'late-50s' relevant? Not all older people are racist, nor younger blameless.

I think the OP meant that a person of that age should be mature enough to know better. You seem to have read this as the oposite to what was intended.

CPL593H · 04/06/2022 14:04

Kris02 · 04/06/2022 13:45

The reality is, not everyone likes everyone else! It would be weird if they did. As a society, it’s time we grew up and accepted this.

The world isn’t divided into goodies and baddies. Pretty much everyone holds some unpleasant view or other, often up mixed with humane and liberals ones. For example, I’ve heard people rant about racism one minute then defend date rape the next. My African neighbour, a fundamentalist Christian, took part in the BLM protests. But she will also tell you that homosexuality and abortion are ‘sins’ and ought to be illegal. I know a sanctimonious socialist, who always bangs on about poverty and inequality, yet makes disgusting jokes about eating animals (‘whenever I see a baby lamb my mouth waters’, etc). As a vegan I find that pretty ‘offensive’.

My point is, before getting on your high horse and indulging in that warm, tingly feeling of moral superiority, take a look at your own life and your own views.

Can you honestly not see the lack of equivalence between racism and making a joke about eating meat?

Incredible.

Andouillette · 04/06/2022 14:01

Quincythequince · 04/06/2022 13:55

You being offended is your problem. And being a vegan is completely different to someone being on the receiving end of someone else spouting discriminatory language, and potentially inciting hate based on certain physical traits.

Don’t be so bloody ridiculous.

Jesus, this thread is depressing.

Isn't it just? With regard to the post you quote I will point out that being a vegan is a choice, being of a different ethnicity, having skin of a different tone, being gay, disabled etc? those are not choices.

2bazookas · 04/06/2022 14:00

My experience among the racists /xenophobes/ religious bigots I've encountered, is that they were all very conventional people hooked on social status (theirs). Which leaves them dreadfully vulnerable to social embarassment. And it doesn't take much to let them experience being on the receiving end.

I don't flatter myself that I ever changed their mindsets. But nobody who made a racist/xenophobic remark to me, has ever done it twice.

From that I conclude they re-considered their behaviour . It's a start.

Ncwinc · 04/06/2022 14:00

You can’t change what’s in their heads but you could make it very clear that it’s not acceptable for them make racist comments in your presence and then either leave or ask them to leave if they do it again.

It sounds like you’ve brushed it off for years with your MIL. It’s still happening and your SIL has joined in. Instead of ‘coping strategies’ why not treat it as the serious issue it is? If she were screaming obscenities or shitting on your carpet would you ask for ‘coping strategies’ or would you draw a line?

She’s family and you’ve said you can’t go low contact so keep seeing her and inviting her round but every time she crosses that line, walk away or ask her to leave.

Quincythequince · 04/06/2022 13:55

Kris02 · 04/06/2022 13:45

The reality is, not everyone likes everyone else! It would be weird if they did. As a society, it’s time we grew up and accepted this.

The world isn’t divided into goodies and baddies. Pretty much everyone holds some unpleasant view or other, often up mixed with humane and liberals ones. For example, I’ve heard people rant about racism one minute then defend date rape the next. My African neighbour, a fundamentalist Christian, took part in the BLM protests. But she will also tell you that homosexuality and abortion are ‘sins’ and ought to be illegal. I know a sanctimonious socialist, who always bangs on about poverty and inequality, yet makes disgusting jokes about eating animals (‘whenever I see a baby lamb my mouth waters’, etc). As a vegan I find that pretty ‘offensive’.

My point is, before getting on your high horse and indulging in that warm, tingly feeling of moral superiority, take a look at your own life and your own views.

You being offended is your problem. And being a vegan is completely different to someone being on the receiving end of someone else spouting discriminatory language, and potentially inciting hate based on certain physical traits.

Don’t be so bloody ridiculous.

Jesus, this thread is depressing.

MissyB1 · 04/06/2022 13:55

Kris02 · 04/06/2022 13:45

The reality is, not everyone likes everyone else! It would be weird if they did. As a society, it’s time we grew up and accepted this.

The world isn’t divided into goodies and baddies. Pretty much everyone holds some unpleasant view or other, often up mixed with humane and liberals ones. For example, I’ve heard people rant about racism one minute then defend date rape the next. My African neighbour, a fundamentalist Christian, took part in the BLM protests. But she will also tell you that homosexuality and abortion are ‘sins’ and ought to be illegal. I know a sanctimonious socialist, who always bangs on about poverty and inequality, yet makes disgusting jokes about eating animals (‘whenever I see a baby lamb my mouth waters’, etc). As a vegan I find that pretty ‘offensive’.

My point is, before getting on your high horse and indulging in that warm, tingly feeling of moral superiority, take a look at your own life and your own views.

A very fair point. It is right to challenge racism, however we may hold some other potentially offensive views that we should be prepared to be challenged on ourselves.

theworldhas · 04/06/2022 13:53

@Kris02
People calling out and standing up against racism and bigotry is how society has become more civilised.

Quincythequince · 04/06/2022 13:53

Kris02 · 04/06/2022 13:45

The reality is, not everyone likes everyone else! It would be weird if they did. As a society, it’s time we grew up and accepted this.

The world isn’t divided into goodies and baddies. Pretty much everyone holds some unpleasant view or other, often up mixed with humane and liberals ones. For example, I’ve heard people rant about racism one minute then defend date rape the next. My African neighbour, a fundamentalist Christian, took part in the BLM protests. But she will also tell you that homosexuality and abortion are ‘sins’ and ought to be illegal. I know a sanctimonious socialist, who always bangs on about poverty and inequality, yet makes disgusting jokes about eating animals (‘whenever I see a baby lamb my mouth waters’, etc). As a vegan I find that pretty ‘offensive’.

My point is, before getting on your high horse and indulging in that warm, tingly feeling of moral superiority, take a look at your own life and your own views.

What utter shite!
You Racist apologist.

It is not ok to say horrible things about someone purely because of their skin colour!

Sure you can dislike any person because of something they’ve done irrespective of their colour, but that’s not what’s being discussed here.

Your post is a pile of crap, honestly.

theobligatorynamechange · 04/06/2022 13:52

BigOldBlobber · 04/06/2022 13:38

This is a depressing thread for a black woman to be reading. So many are happy to say: just ignore/use humour/stop being so sensitive.

OP, my (and my DHs) reaction to similar things has been;

  • client I worked with said N**word brown to describe something. I told him that was an incredibly offensive thing to say. He was surprised. Will probably continue to say it but at least I know I said something.
  • in a pub some middle aged couples were talking about a load of p*kis who had moved it next door. DH asked them to kindly refrain from using that language as it was so offensive to us both. The white couple we were with said nothing - suffice to say we are no longer friends with them.

We are both mixed Asian and black.

Well, your examples are clearly examples of awful behaviour. Without knowing what was said here, we can't comment. As someone who is also not white, I do come across a lot of white people getting offended at inoffensive things, which winds me up, because not only are they inoffensive, they get so strung up on the stuff that isn't stuff, that they let the real racism slide by like it's acceptable.

People need to be speaking up against actual racism, such as the examples you've described. I'm really sorry that couple let you down so badly - sometimes it's not witnessing racism from strangers that's so upsetting, it's when our friends and acquaintances show themselves for who they are, and it's not who we hoped.

Anyway, back to to the OP. Is SIL the daughter of MIL? In which case, if they're both racists, it's hardly surprising?

You say you can't go NC because of SIL's DC, but also that SIL's DC is an adult. If that's the case, why do you need to speak to SIL? Surely as long as the DC is talking to the mother, you don't have to?

And if you can't go NC, can't you go low contact?

I think if you've indulged your MIL though thus far, it's going to look odd at you suddenly coming down against your SIL. You should really be treating all racist views the same, not hand out free passes because of who's saying them.

Quincythequince · 04/06/2022 13:50

BigOldBlobber · 04/06/2022 13:38

This is a depressing thread for a black woman to be reading. So many are happy to say: just ignore/use humour/stop being so sensitive.

OP, my (and my DHs) reaction to similar things has been;

  • client I worked with said N**word brown to describe something. I told him that was an incredibly offensive thing to say. He was surprised. Will probably continue to say it but at least I know I said something.
  • in a pub some middle aged couples were talking about a load of p*kis who had moved it next door. DH asked them to kindly refrain from using that language as it was so offensive to us both. The white couple we were with said nothing - suffice to say we are no longer friends with them.

We are both mixed Asian and black.

I completely agree with this.

My parents are both racist, and I hate it.

I robustly challenge them and tell them how horribly offensive and disgusting it is, as do my brothers.

They continue to spout racist shit, and I continue to challenge. Alf Garnet and wife at their finest and I really dislike them for it.

Kris02 · 04/06/2022 13:45

The reality is, not everyone likes everyone else! It would be weird if they did. As a society, it’s time we grew up and accepted this.

The world isn’t divided into goodies and baddies. Pretty much everyone holds some unpleasant view or other, often up mixed with humane and liberals ones. For example, I’ve heard people rant about racism one minute then defend date rape the next. My African neighbour, a fundamentalist Christian, took part in the BLM protests. But she will also tell you that homosexuality and abortion are ‘sins’ and ought to be illegal. I know a sanctimonious socialist, who always bangs on about poverty and inequality, yet makes disgusting jokes about eating animals (‘whenever I see a baby lamb my mouth waters’, etc). As a vegan I find that pretty ‘offensive’.

My point is, before getting on your high horse and indulging in that warm, tingly feeling of moral superiority, take a look at your own life and your own views.

MissyB1 · 04/06/2022 13:41

OP you know damn well what your choices are.
Speak up or tolerate.
“Coping strategies” indeed 🙄

Meraas · 04/06/2022 13:40

With MIL I don't say 'you're funny' I say that's ridiculous or equivalent and laugh.

Wow, you’re a real ally, OP. 🙄

BigOldBlobber · 04/06/2022 13:38

This is a depressing thread for a black woman to be reading. So many are happy to say: just ignore/use humour/stop being so sensitive.

OP, my (and my DHs) reaction to similar things has been;

  • client I worked with said N**word brown to describe something. I told him that was an incredibly offensive thing to say. He was surprised. Will probably continue to say it but at least I know I said something.
  • in a pub some middle aged couples were talking about a load of p*kis who had moved it next door. DH asked them to kindly refrain from using that language as it was so offensive to us both. The white couple we were with said nothing - suffice to say we are no longer friends with them.

We are both mixed Asian and black.

Quincythequince · 04/06/2022 13:37

DownToTheSeaAgain · 04/06/2022 13:33

With MIL I don't say 'you're funny' I say that's ridiculous or equivalent and laugh.

This, from SIL was unexpected and therefore a shock.

So it transpires you laugh at somebody dishing out racist comments then?

Which is why it probably continues.

🙄

DownToTheSeaAgain · 04/06/2022 13:33

CatsAreCrackers · 04/06/2022 13:27

Although to be fair my MIL is hugely and serially racist but I joke at it or ignore it depending on the context and have done for the last 25 years.

So you have coped by joking about it or ignoring it for the last 25 years? Racism is racism, it's always awful and unacceptable, what was so different about this comment that you now need a coping mechanism?! Why haven't you been loudly pulling her up for 25 years? Maybe she'd have seen the error of her ways by now.

With MIL I don't say 'you're funny' I say that's ridiculous or equivalent and laugh.

This, from SIL was unexpected and therefore a shock.

OP posts:
CatsAreCrackers · 04/06/2022 13:27

Although to be fair my MIL is hugely and serially racist but I joke at it or ignore it depending on the context and have done for the last 25 years.

So you have coped by joking about it or ignoring it for the last 25 years? Racism is racism, it's always awful and unacceptable, what was so different about this comment that you now need a coping mechanism?! Why haven't you been loudly pulling her up for 25 years? Maybe she'd have seen the error of her ways by now.

Quincythequince · 04/06/2022 13:27

DownToTheSeaAgain · 04/06/2022 11:15

Coping strategies are strategies to enable one to cope with a particular situation.

I can't go NC because one of their DC lives with me.

One strategy is to directly say ‘your disgusting racist rhetoric is just that, disgusting. And every single time you mention anything like it, I will directly challenge you, publicly if need be on your language and appalling prejudice. In the meantime, don’t speak to me directly, ever unless it is to do with the needs of xxxxxx. I find your behaviour intolerable and want nothing to do with you’

And then just ignore her, or simply remove yourself and your children from any conversation she becomes involved in that you are also a part of, and make it clear why you are doing so.

Behaviour like hers continues because it’s not robustly challenged enough and there are no consequences for it. Make both did these things happen and hopefully she’ll stop, around you at least.

FriendlyPineapple · 04/06/2022 13:21

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 04/06/2022 12:21

some of the comments are upsetting to
me, like fake faint- wtf, that insults me as a woman or colour.

Although to be fair my MIL is hugely and serially racist but I joke at it or ignore it depending on the context and have done for the last 25 years.

@DownToTheSeaAgain sorry when your mil is racist you joke?!!!!!!!!!!!!!! How is that ok?

I need to leave this depressing thread before it ruins my day

Now it's very very obvious from my posts that I was taking a gentle potshot at the OP about asking for 'coping strategies' for something so obvious - either challenge or ignore. Quite clearly nobody went 'racist comments? Fine, what's the problem'

Oscarthedog · 04/06/2022 13:19

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 04/06/2022 12:59

@Staynow

why do you think it’s ok to state a racist statement ?

The op stated a sexist statement as an example. And we regularly hear sexist (against men) and racist against white people views on Mumsnet.

It should be one rule for everyone.

PickySlackTastic · 04/06/2022 13:10

You want coping strategies? A quick heads up - framing yourself as a victim in this situation isn't a good look.

Fraaahnces · 04/06/2022 13:10

Does her kid live with you because his mum’s a racist a-hole?

Daisypod · 04/06/2022 13:06

I dont understand why you won't say what was said, it would make it a lot easier for people to advise.

Mally100 · 04/06/2022 13:03

So you have challenged it, you could go very LC and only if it's necessary. But ridiculously dramatic on needing coping strategies.