Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this overt racism totally shocking in 2022

162 replies

DownToTheSeaAgain · 04/06/2022 11:01

With the extended in-laws yesterday. Had a conversation about society and the role of state vs individual. All good and better than the usual run of the mill smalltalk. However in the middle of it SIL made a comment so outrageous and racist that shocked all of us in the room.

She kept on repeating it. This is an educated woman in her late 50s.

For full disclosure no one was drinking.

My AIBU is that I can't let it go. Is that normal?I woke up this morning feeling quite unsettled. I can't now see her as anything other than a racist bigot.

I can't go low contact as one of her adult DC lives with my family so for the sake of the DC (who is great) I have to suck it up.

Coping strategies?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jewel1968 · 05/06/2022 10:43

I don't think there is much more you could have done. You say you challenged them a lot. If you feel there was anything you wished you had said, pop it into an email to them..

I think racism can often surprise especially if you think you know the person. But, you challenge in a way that hopefully makes them think...

The insidious racism is the one that's hard to deal with as it lurked in the shadows. The overt racism should be easier to address.

In terms of coping more broadly I think you are asking how do you navigate these relationships. I think you continue to challenge and recognise that the person is not who you thought they were. Minimise contact too - as much as is feasible.

DownToTheSeaAgain · 05/06/2022 10:29

This thread has been very interesting. With reference to my MIL who is now in her late 80s and has been slightly senile ever since I met her I couldn't see the value in aggressively pulling her up on her views every time. I see from this thread that some think that this is hypocritical. You'd have to know her and understand that a full on attack would have been and continues to be the wrong tactic for her. She would be upset and confused in the short term and absolutely nothing would change because it wouldn't really go in.

However my thread was more about coping with racism from unexpected sources and I've had lots of great suggestions for further reading so thanks for all of that.

OP posts:
Bednobsbroomsticks · 05/06/2022 09:56

Giraffesandbottoms · 05/06/2022 09:48

@Bednobsbroomsticks

it didn’t bother her for 25 years when her MIL was being openly racist.

Yes saw that but was referring to asking for advice generally on how to handle racism x

Giraffesandbottoms · 05/06/2022 09:48

@Bednobsbroomsticks

it didn’t bother her for 25 years when her MIL was being openly racist.

Bednobsbroomsticks · 05/06/2022 09:22

Re op asking for support on how to handle it i don't see that as a bad thing . My daughter who is white has a lot of black and Asian friends . When she hears a white person at uni saying derogatory things she stands up to them but does get upset and asks for ways to manage these people. She always acts as though she would if her friends could hear even if they aren't there . The fact that these things are even said upsets her to point where she feels guilty for being in that person's presence and she doesn't know what to do with that emotion. She isn't trying to be a saviour to act offended she's just hurt that people can be so cruel. I don't see it as she's taking it as her place to speak for people who experience racism but if she wasn't offended it would be more concerning. Her friends are lovely and say as long as she challenges it that's all they'd expect her to do. If we don't come together to support each other to fight bigotry what else can we do.

Bednobsbroomsticks · 05/06/2022 09:07

BigOldBlobber · 04/06/2022 13:38

This is a depressing thread for a black woman to be reading. So many are happy to say: just ignore/use humour/stop being so sensitive.

OP, my (and my DHs) reaction to similar things has been;

  • client I worked with said N**word brown to describe something. I told him that was an incredibly offensive thing to say. He was surprised. Will probably continue to say it but at least I know I said something.
  • in a pub some middle aged couples were talking about a load of p*kis who had moved it next door. DH asked them to kindly refrain from using that language as it was so offensive to us both. The white couple we were with said nothing - suffice to say we are no longer friends with them.

We are both mixed Asian and black.

I had a client describe that kind of brown to me also. I almost fell over told her that's not the kind of word she should be using at all if she wanted the item I was selling. Unbelievable what people will say.

Giraffesandbottoms · 05/06/2022 08:38

This thread has annoyed me so much. You have come on here complaining about your own feelings in relation to racism (do you want a badge for being offended - that’s normal) and then you tell everyone you have been laughing at your MIL FOR 25 YEARS when she has been racist. It’s disgusting. So after 25 years and because SIL is younger you are suddenly offended enough to do something?

because you have overlooked the racism for 25 YEARS (honestly wtf) then you, I think, need to actually sit down and say “I’ve had enough of this racist household. Next time someone spouts anything racist I'm
off/not coming back”. What does your husband say?! His mother and his sister?! Why hasn’t HE said anything?

Gadzookerykookery · 04/06/2022 23:04

@DownToTheSeaAgain you’re welcome. I’ve been in a similar place to where you are, shocked at an overtly racist behaviour from someone I loved.

It shook me out of my complacency and the sort of coasting along mostly ignoring and thinking not joining in was enough, and that racism had gone away or would go away on its own or at least without me needing to do anything uncomfortable.

So many of the comments on this thread are hurtful and harmful to Black women. Mumsnet needs to do better at setting the tone and being actively anti-racist.

Gadzookerykookery · 04/06/2022 22:58

Silence, ignoring, leaving the room, & frowning are not effective in reducing the harm caused by racism.

Shame is also not helpful.

I get it. It feels shameful to realise that you’ve been unintentionally adding to the harm caused by racism in our society. Been there, felt the burn.

We white people are capable of moving past the shame and denial, and getting to the part where we do better, and do things that reduce the harm, and help it stop hurting Black and Brown women, children and men so very very badly.

It can start with reading a book, or following a few anti-racism writers and speakers on your socials.

Nova Reid
Reni Eddo-Lodge
Akala
Afua Hirsch
David Olusoga

Add any one of those, on your Fb, insta or twitter, and just listen with an open heart and mind, and an intention to do less harm, even unintentional harm.

That will start filling in the gaps where the National Curriculum and our education system missed out a shit ton of important stuff.

DownToTheSeaAgain · 04/06/2022 22:45

Gadzookerykookery · 04/06/2022 22:26

@DownToTheSeaAgain there are books around that will help you with how to challenge racism from your family members.

The Good Ally by Nova Reid is brilliant, and has real useable advice on what to say and how to behave in situations like this.

It will help you, and you’re not unreasonable to ask for support in how to respond.

As white people we don’t get taught how to be proactively anti-racist. What we do get taught is how to minimise, deny, ignore, or “joke” in the presence of racism from overt to covert. As evidenced by a lot of comments on this thread.

We can do better. Go get a copy of The Good Ally and read it with an open mind.

Thank you

OP posts:
Gadzookerykookery · 04/06/2022 22:26

@DownToTheSeaAgain there are books around that will help you with how to challenge racism from your family members.

The Good Ally by Nova Reid is brilliant, and has real useable advice on what to say and how to behave in situations like this.

It will help you, and you’re not unreasonable to ask for support in how to respond.

As white people we don’t get taught how to be proactively anti-racist. What we do get taught is how to minimise, deny, ignore, or “joke” in the presence of racism from overt to covert. As evidenced by a lot of comments on this thread.

We can do better. Go get a copy of The Good Ally and read it with an open mind.

IDreamOfTheMoors · 04/06/2022 22:08

I’m never surprised.
I’m continually appalled.

NorthernLights5 · 04/06/2022 22:06

YABU to be shocked by it unless you live under a rock. I'm black and encounter overt racism pretty much daily.

LondonWolf · 04/06/2022 21:59

Sitting with your black and Asian 'friends' and saying nothing when they challenge racism is not in any way legitimate or ok.

I didn't suggest it was though. I am addressing OP's situation. Not the one you just made up.

RepublicOfNarnia · 04/06/2022 21:20

This is probably in the top 10 of worst ever Mumsnet threads and that takes some doing.

CorpseReviver · 04/06/2022 20:47

@theobligatorynamechange
Solidarity and sympathy.

It is horrendous how many apologists there are on this thread.

theobligatorynamechange · 04/06/2022 20:24

CorpseReviver · 04/06/2022 20:18

Sitting with your black and Asian 'friends' and saying nothing when they challenge racism is not in any way legitimate or ok.

I'm Jewish so have occasionally had the... interesting experience of someone making extremely antisemitic remarks without realising they apply to me. That's always fun.🙄

I'm sometimes "white passing", depending on the crowd. I feel your fun.

Solidarity!

theobligatorynamechange · 04/06/2022 20:23

DownToTheSeaAgain · 04/06/2022 18:04

Yes this is helpful. With MIL I have always thought she is too old to really challenge but she is deeply disappointed in her life so it makes sense although it doesn't make it ok.

With SIL I just didn't realise she was like that. On the face of it she has a great life.

Let's say someone makes a racist comment about black people. You think the person making the comment 'doesn't know any better' or 'that's just how people of their generation think.'

Now, imagine there's a black person standing next to you both, and they've overheard that comment. How would they feel? And how would they feel if you - someone who they thought was better than that - didn't speak up in their defence?

Use that an acid test. TBH, it works for any kind of offensive or mean comment, not just racist ones. If the person targeted by the comment was there, would you be horrified and speak up? If so, speak up even if they aren't there. It's how you become an ally - it's when you speak up, even though no one is 'watching' or 'listening' to observe you being 'decent'. You just be decent for decency's sake.

Hope that helps a bit with reframing it in your head. I do think like most others that you've overreacted a little, especially given what you've tolerated from your MIL, but I do also appreciate that it can be upsetting/shocking when someone shows you to be a different person to the one you imagined in your head.

CorpseReviver · 04/06/2022 20:18

LondonWolf · 04/06/2022 19:23

No it doesn't. Silence and withdrawal - ie exclusion - is a legitimate tactic to show disgust at such views.

Sitting with your black and Asian 'friends' and saying nothing when they challenge racism is not in any way legitimate or ok.

I'm Jewish so have occasionally had the... interesting experience of someone making extremely antisemitic remarks without realising they apply to me. That's always fun.🙄

LondonWolf · 04/06/2022 19:23

Ncwinc · 04/06/2022 15:57

’silence doesn't mean agreement.’

Silence is aiding and abetting racism. Not challenging racism isn’t a passive action. It encourages the racist to believe that it’s ok to say that in public.

No it doesn't. Silence and withdrawal - ie exclusion - is a legitimate tactic to show disgust at such views.

ImpulsiveFlake · 04/06/2022 18:53

Also be very sure that you correctly understood the meaning of what she said. For example, sometimes my adult DD says something that I consider to outrageously offensive. I jump on what she has said and we have a huge row. I am doubly wounded because she has said something that I find offensive, and I can't believe I have raised an adult who thinks these things,

Ten times out of ten, when the dust settles, it turns out that I have misunderstood what DD is trying to say. This is not because I am dim, but because she has an unfortunate way of expressing things. She thinks she is being clever by using 'sarcasm' - but actually she just has a really muddled way of making her point. When we actually break down the conversation we find we are in agreement. Could this be the case with your SIL?

xxxGirlCrushxxx · 04/06/2022 18:43

You said her ADULT dc lives with you so yes, you absolutely can go no contact!!!

DownToTheSeaAgain · 04/06/2022 18:04

Onwards22 · 04/06/2022 17:48

Racist, homophobic, sexist etc views are often associated with some very deep issues and unhappiness.

You can and should challenge it but most of the time you’d be wasting your breath as they can’t see beyond their own pain/anger.

It’s hard to not be angry or sad but you just have to pity these people who aren’t very intelligent and need someone to blame.

Yes this is helpful. With MIL I have always thought she is too old to really challenge but she is deeply disappointed in her life so it makes sense although it doesn't make it ok.

With SIL I just didn't realise she was like that. On the face of it she has a great life.

OP posts:
Onwards22 · 04/06/2022 17:48

Racist, homophobic, sexist etc views are often associated with some very deep issues and unhappiness.

You can and should challenge it but most of the time you’d be wasting your breath as they can’t see beyond their own pain/anger.

It’s hard to not be angry or sad but you just have to pity these people who aren’t very intelligent and need someone to blame.

LakieLady · 04/06/2022 17:38

DownToTheSeaAgain · 04/06/2022 13:33

With MIL I don't say 'you're funny' I say that's ridiculous or equivalent and laugh.

This, from SIL was unexpected and therefore a shock.

That makes it difficult. You can't really challenge your SIL's racism when you haven't challenged MIL's racism. It will look personal, as though you have it in for SIL.

But I'm gobsmacked that you've been tacitly accepting or laughing at MIL's racism for all those years.

Swipe left for the next trending thread