Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would it be such a bad thing to set your children up financially so that they never have to work?

185 replies

wonderingWallaby · 04/06/2022 10:49

Let’s assume from the age of 21 you provide them with a monthly/annual allowance of x amount (a substantial figure), and they will receive this for the remainder of their life. Obviously I wouldn’t be happy if they spent all day sleeping, playing video games etc. But if the money allowed them to avoid the rat race that is work, maybe that’s not such a bad thing? I know there are a lot of positives to working, but my thought process is that life is short. And if you’re in a position where you don’t have to work or you can ensure your children don’t have to work, is that really such a bad thing?

OP posts:
MindYourHeadDoggy · 04/06/2022 11:21

What If the money dries-up unexpectedly and you’ve left your child totally devoid of skills, ambition, and ability?

I think it’s wrong to create a person who is 100% financially dependent on another for their life.

(And I say this as someone who does not have to work, but I choose to).

Schoolchoicesucks · 04/06/2022 11:20

I worked for a very wealthy family who considered this really carefully.

Their approach was to have a family trust that would pay for private education for their grandchildren plus future generations (and also to pay their way through university so they wouldn't need to use loans).

They had a small monthly allowance from age 21. Not enough to live on, but enough that it would help them not have to scrape by - they could live somewhere nicer than may otherwise afford, they could take holidays, they wouldn't neccessarily have to choose a career based totally on earning vast amounts.

There was an amount to be paid between 25 and 30 that would buy them a 2 bed flat in a nice part of London.

If they started a business, there was a lump sum investment and a higher monthly allowance, so they wouldn't need to draw a salary from the start. They were keen to encourage entrepreneurship.

At 35 there was another lump sum that would buy a 3-4 bed house in a nice part of London.

Their thoughts were that they could take away many of the money stresses, while still requiring their children to do some form of paid work. They had financial stability and it encouraged them to start their own businesses, employing others. Their children wouldn't need to chase high paying corporate jobs to maintain the lifestyle they grew up in and could choose something that (they felt was) more rewarding/gave back etc.

Jalisco · 04/06/2022 11:20

Not quite the same thing as you are asking, but a friend of mine made a mint selling his computer company to Microsoft in the 1980's - he'd got into the field before home computers were a thing. Anyway, he made £millions, and then made even more investing it well. He didn't set his children up financially - quite the opposite.

His children grew up with good parents, the best opportunities that money could buy, but definitely not spoiled - so no excesses etc. But by the time they were teenagers every single one of them (3) started to go off the rails and become, frankly, nasty selfish louts (at best) with appalling attitudes and serious issues - sex, drugs and rock 'n' roll doesn't really cover it. Expelled from multiple schools. Why - because they "knew" that their parents were so wealthy that they didn't need an education, didn't need to work, and didn't need to make anything of themselves. Even when the parents threatened to cut them off and out of the will, they "knew" their parents would never do that.

They have all been disinherited and all their parents money is being left to charity. The children know, but it hasn't made a jot of a difference to their behaviour because they are now pretty much useless for anything - 2 have multiple convictions for drug dealing. Their parents set up an "emergency trust" which will be managed independently and which will allow for certain support if the children want it - but that is restricted to things such as medical interventions, counselling, and things that will either prevent harm or enable them to turn their lives around if they choose to do so; they will never receive allowances or money directly. It broke their parents hearts to do this.

Both parents wish they had never made the money. They were both aspirational and hard working, but none of that has rubbed off on the children because they treated an easy life as an entitlement. So no - having seen this over the decades, I do not think setting up your children to never have to work is a good idea. Humans need motivation and goals. There are ways of easing the path to help children to grow and develop, but too much is, in my opinion, worse than not enough.

DisforDarkChocolate · 04/06/2022 11:19

I think life has to have meaning. If it's not going to be providing for your self and your family it can leave you prey to vices like drugs. That's been much simplified but without a way of demonstrating our worth to ourselves most people aren't happy.

Tormundsbeard · 04/06/2022 11:18

Is work such a bad thing? A lot of people enjoy their jobs / have a vocation etc..
I think it would be great to be able to provide housing/holidays, but let 21 year olds find their own path.

cheekyfucker101 · 04/06/2022 11:16

I wouldn't do this.

I have two kids at private school and I work bloody hard to send them there. I was raised on a council estate so its took me hard graft to get where I am now.

The school is fab but there are mums there that have never had to work are still funded by mummy and daddy who are now paying for their kids school fees. These women are not grounded in reality and I honestly feel pity for their kids.

A free loader is a free loader no matter what side of society you live on and these people can never have self worth or esteem if they rely on other people to feed them even as an adult.

I will help my kids with a deposit for a house but they are and will be encouraged to go in to professions that helps them live life.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 04/06/2022 11:15

I'd do it for DS if I could. I don't feel like working has made me a better person in any way.

I certainly can't afford to though! Unless I win a huge lottery jackpot.

Louise0701 · 04/06/2022 11:14

I don’t work (31) and probably never will as I am in an incredibly fortunate financial position. It would bring nothing to my life at all.
I do lots of meaningful things and have the time to experience things I wouldn’t be able to if I was working.
I would do it.

Kimmy567 · 04/06/2022 11:13

Warren Buffet said "Leave your children enough money so they can do anything, but not enough that they don't have to do anything.” I like the idea of helping them become capable, brilliant individuals, avoiding facilitating learned helplessness!

Namenic · 04/06/2022 11:13

Sounds terrible. I don’t mind helping my kids out if I can, but this does not incentivise hard work, living within means, dealing with unexpected hardship. Helping them develop skills to deal with difficult situations would be one of my aims.

Womencanlift · 04/06/2022 11:12

This feels like a journalist feeder type post but fine I will bite

What happens after you pass will you leave them with a lifetime allowance? What happens if your own circumstances change? Would you put any conditions around it e.g. they need to spend x time working for charity rather than just having a life on Instagram?

I really like pp suggestions of salary matching or waiting until later in life so they get a skill and contribute something to society

I would caveat all this by saying if it is go support someone who cannot work for medical reasons then I completely agree with your idea but get from your OP this isn’t the case and it’s just so they miss the rat race

Testina · 04/06/2022 11:12

I think subsidising just enough to enable wide choices, but not enough to remove any sense of personal achievement, is the right balance.

I did one year work placement during uni. My best friend there did something fascinating but as a volunteer - she worked just as hard as me. I didn’t do the thing I wanted as it was unpaid too. As it happens, no regrets… but, for my children that’s the sort of thing I’d like to have the money to do. Not replace the need to work, but allow them to work on a business idea for a year with no income, or take a low paid job for love. Not avoid work altogether.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 04/06/2022 11:12

This has Hans Rausing written all over it.

starlingdarling · 04/06/2022 11:11

I'd probably wait until they had several years work experience under their belts. You can't fully appreciate what a privilege it is not to work unless you've actually worked.

FranklySonImTheGaffer · 04/06/2022 11:10

I think you only have to look at the entitled, arrogant, useless, out of touch children of some celebrities to see how this could be a bad idea.

I think for some people who are naturally motivated to do something with their time, it would be fine because they could pour their energy into charity work or something but for the overwhelming majority, you're basically making them lazy and denying them the chance to gain important skills.

I would love to not work / be able to work PT now, but I'm mid 30s and have picked up a lot of life skills in my 20 years of working.
I think if I were in that position I'd consider helping when they're in their 30s providing they had worked for a good few years.

Testina · 04/06/2022 11:08

I’d keep money away from my child to avoid them becoming that walking cliché of caring for injured animals!

JennyAct3 · 04/06/2022 11:06

I have a friend who has several billion (on the UK rich list) and their children are either at university or at senior school sitting exams now. The children are expected to get qualifications and jobs albeit at some point they will presumably take board positions in the family firm. They are very discreet (discrete?) and there is no flashiness whatsoever. Of course they have the massive safety net of family fortune but I think they see it as a huge responsibility too.

I think if you can pay for things like driving lessons and stretch to helping them get on the property ladder that is hugely helpful. I wouldn’t go down the trust fund/monthly allowance personally. They can make poor decisions and also attract people who just use them.

GregBrawlsInDogJail · 04/06/2022 11:06

It would be a disaster. Most people, given that expanse of empty time, would spend it in two ways: a) self-pity, b) fucking their own lives up. Depression, addiction, catastrophic relationships.

"I'd be different, though! I'd spend all my time caring for injured animals." Sure you would.

Self-made rich people are acutely aware of this problem and often spend a lot of time ensuring that they don't do this for their children - that they give them advantages, but also make sure they work.

BrioNotBiro · 04/06/2022 11:04

I've got relatives whose father (who worked hard to develop a thriving business) has set them all up with private incomes. They have rather jet setting lives but have literally never worked at all.

They are so entitled and arrogant, they big themselves up and seem to believe that the life they lead is due to their own talents. It really isn't and if the trust fund failed they'd have no idea how to support themselves.

No, you don't want to graft till you collapse, but I honestly think getting everything without working for it does you no favours at all.

GrandRapids · 04/06/2022 11:04

I think that having a good work ethic is so important in life. You would be taking this away.

When I was in my early 20s I had a friend who's entire life was funded by his parents. It was an endless existence of partying, holidays and travelling. He was horribly entitled.

As far as I can see he is still living the same life now at 40. Although I don't have the same lavish lifestyle, I am really proud of what I've achieved with no handouts!

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 04/06/2022 11:02

I would pay them to do voluntary work or study, or indeed a top up for low paid but necessary work. Sport maybe. Not just for leisure. (Caring for their own children or other relative also included)

MrsTimRiggins · 04/06/2022 11:02

You run the very real risk of them not doing anything meaningful at all with their lives. A teenager, or a person in their early twenties I expect, presented with the opportunity of doing ‘nothing’ will squander their money and their time, in the vast majority of cases. Personally I’d want better for my kids. While I wouldn’t want my child to have to spend their life slaving their guts out in a crappy job to scrape through but equally I would want them to have a decent work ethic, an appreciation for what they have and a sense of pride in what they themselves have achieved.
I think I’d perhaps try to help them out in practical ways, with a car, a house, travel costs, that sort of thing but I don’t think I’d be inclined to just give them money as a youngster and hope they use it wisely.

SNWannabe · 04/06/2022 11:02

God no!! Just watch an episode of Made in Chelsea to see why having money that you don’t need to earn is a bad idea

PizzaPatel · 04/06/2022 11:02

No way - wouldn’t do this even if I could. I would love my kids to choose a job they love, prioritise happiness over money, perhaps aim to have a better work life balance than full time. But opt out altogether? No way. work is a way to make friends, relate to others, gain skills, use your brain, build your own self esteem. The only people I know who have never quite made it in the world of work and are overly reliant on parents are deeply dependent on others and low in self confidence. A couple of them are also selfish and entitled too.

titchy · 04/06/2022 11:00

A great deal of self confidence, resilience and other soft skills comes from having a job. Why would you want to deprive your children of those skills and the inner strength they'll need to get them through periods where life is tough?

Swipe left for the next trending thread