Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would it be such a bad thing to set your children up financially so that they never have to work?

185 replies

wonderingWallaby · 04/06/2022 10:49

Let’s assume from the age of 21 you provide them with a monthly/annual allowance of x amount (a substantial figure), and they will receive this for the remainder of their life. Obviously I wouldn’t be happy if they spent all day sleeping, playing video games etc. But if the money allowed them to avoid the rat race that is work, maybe that’s not such a bad thing? I know there are a lot of positives to working, but my thought process is that life is short. And if you’re in a position where you don’t have to work or you can ensure your children don’t have to work, is that really such a bad thing?

OP posts:
newtb · 04/06/2022 12:59

Made me think of Prince Andrew and thé Marquis of Blandford - heir to Blenheim. Not really a startling success, either of them.
Never knew HMQ was a mnetter.

1nsertusername · 04/06/2022 12:58

I married into a family where the father did this for two of his children( not my husband but that is another story)

It's been a disaster with one attempting suicide and the other with complicated mental health issues too.

Both are long term unemployed and without partners. They live together is a nice house though!

Both are unhappy and are unable to leave the house. They have tried various jobs but ultimately they have no drive.

I've also witnessed others in the same situation,drugs and mental heath issues are a common theme.

Not sure where it starts,a childhood of wealth and privilege or adulthood of wealth and privilege.

I've noticed that these people never seem to have grown up,without true responsibility they haven't been able to progress in life. They have never had to worry about a bill not being paid,or the consequences of losing a job. They dont seem to want to improve themselves either.

I'm not saying all people who have this chance are suicidal,but seeing a number of families who have done this,at least one child has had huge issues with drugs and mental health. The other child or children have done well,or okay, but at least one is suffering. Maybe they would be like that what ever life chances they had. You just cant tell.

Where I've seen it work has been where the child has been brought a small property,and told you are now on your own. There may be money from trust funds later on,or for grandchildren,but ultimately the child has a helping hand but not too much. It's a hard balance.

Money can be a curse as much as a blessing.

I wasnt born into money at all,so witnessing these people is a really eye opener to the realities of wealth( some of these people have billions)

Real wealth comes from love and support from your family network. Money does help of course. But I wouldnt swap my life for theres,even with all their money. Especially when you see that many of these peoples parents used the money as a way to justify being shitty and absent parents

PinkSyCo · 04/06/2022 12:58

I think it’s a terrible thing. If you’ve never worked how can you appreciate the freedom of not having to? How will you appreciate the value of money? If you’re not a motivated person what are you going to do to occupy fill your days. How are you going to cope with not being a useful member of society? I could see it causing low self esteem, depression and probably problems with addiction too.

MintyCedricRidesAgain · 04/06/2022 12:57

Certainly not going to happen in my circumstances but even if money was no object I wouldn't do it.

I'd love to be able to clear DDs student debts and give her a decent deposit for her first home.

I'd happily help out in other ad hoc ways going forward but I wouldn't bank roll her for life and she wouldn't want to.

For reasons too complicated to go into I'm currently reliant on a certain amount of financial help from my surviving parent atm and although I'm fortunate that they're able to provide that assistance it's a horrible situation to be in.

LuckySantangelo35 · 04/06/2022 12:54

Louise0701 · 04/06/2022 11:14

I don’t work (31) and probably never will as I am in an incredibly fortunate financial position. It would bring nothing to my life at all.
I do lots of meaningful things and have the time to experience things I wouldn’t be able to if I was working.
I would do it.

@Louise0701

what exactly do you do with yourself all day?

LuckySantangelo35 · 04/06/2022 12:53

PegasusReturns · 04/06/2022 12:43

The fetishisation of work on this thread is fascinating.

People don’t need to have paid employment to bring value and importance to their lives, there are a million things they can do to productively fill their time; support their communities; help other people or otherwise build their lives.

My priority as a parent is to ensure that the lives of my DC are as smooth as possible and financially supporting them is surely just on aspect of that.

@PegasusReturns

its good for young people to strive!

To make some sacrifices in their twenties for future financial security, to live in a shitty house share and move around the country or further afield for job opportunities, to push beyond their comfort zone, etc.

Its what they should be doing when young! Not a cosy cushy easy life doing a few hours volunteering a week

AngelinaFibres · 04/06/2022 12:52

Georgeskitchen · 04/06/2022 10:59

No it's a crazy idea. Take a look back at some of these wealthy toff typse who've lavished everything on their children who have then gone on to descend into drug abuse alcohol, prison sentences, death.
Young people need a direction and a purpose in life. A reason to get up in the morning, friends, colleagues, life experience.
Why would anyone not want this for their children?
Help them onto the property ladder by all means but don't ruin their lives by mollycoddling them into an early grave!!

All of this. Plus the Royal family . That hasn't gone well has it.

iwanttobeasquare · 04/06/2022 12:51

I've also got a friend who lives off family money. She's quite frugal and moral but has started a woo business teaching women about their fertility. She has absolutely 0 qualifications for this and I disapprove so completely I can't even begin to express it. So dangerous to mess about with peoples medical situations and give them false hope etc. not sure that's related to independent wealth tho.

LuckySantangelo35 · 04/06/2022 12:49

PegasusReturns · 04/06/2022 12:43

The fetishisation of work on this thread is fascinating.

People don’t need to have paid employment to bring value and importance to their lives, there are a million things they can do to productively fill their time; support their communities; help other people or otherwise build their lives.

My priority as a parent is to ensure that the lives of my DC are as smooth as possible and financially supporting them is surely just on aspect of that.

@PegasusReturns

Nope! Completely disagree. If they can work, they should.

Sswhinesthebest · 04/06/2022 12:47

Early 30’s is perfect. I gave up work to be a sahm then, and didn’t work for a long time and only do a few hours now. But I really appreciated it, having experienced the grind of low paid work as a student and then a career!

LuckySantangelo35 · 04/06/2022 12:46

Nope!

I’d struggle to respect my kids if they were just happy to live off my hand outs and not contribute to society.

iwanttobeasquare · 04/06/2022 12:44

My step mum has done this with her daughter. Really interestingly her daughter works like a Trojan trying to make it in the arts (and failing). So having an income hasn't stopped her wanting to strive and work and succeed on her own merit. But it has stopped her from recognising her actual skill set / abilities and re routing her efforts accordingly. It's sort of set her up to fail in a way. But who's to say she would be happier in more conventional circumstances.

PegasusReturns · 04/06/2022 12:43

The fetishisation of work on this thread is fascinating.

People don’t need to have paid employment to bring value and importance to their lives, there are a million things they can do to productively fill their time; support their communities; help other people or otherwise build their lives.

My priority as a parent is to ensure that the lives of my DC are as smooth as possible and financially supporting them is surely just on aspect of that.

Attractinglife · 04/06/2022 12:41

This is exactly the sort of pointless hypothetical exercise that I waste time I do not have to waste on!

So, I did have a friend who lived off family money, and when that was about to run out, hitched up with a guy who kept her. She did not have a luxury lifestyle but lived a materially nice life. Think middle class, like a nurse's or teacher's salary would afford.

But she had absolutely zero resilience. Several times she tried to do vocational courses, or volunteering or whatever, but something would always happen to piss her off and she would just leave. Because she could. She never had to stick anything out. She had no idea, socially, how to handle people saying things that annoyed her, or to get on with people who did not please her, because she never had to. And that lack of resilience did cause her real problems.

It made me realise that work does require you to build resilience to persevere when things aren't being done as you like, when things aren't going well and to find ways to get on with people don't really like.

So I think I would want my kids to have to work for a while. To build that. And they might find a vocation or satisfaction they love. But, if I had the choice, I would keep back a lump sum they could use to live on to retire early, like from the age of 40 or something, and do something else with their life.

whumpthereitis · 04/06/2022 12:39

Situation, and child, specific imo. I don’t think it’s an inherently bad, or good, thing to do. Similarly if don’t think partaking in the rat race is inherently valuable if you don’t ‘need’ to do it. Furthermore, what meaning life does or doesn’t have is a very individual judgement.

dottiedodah · 04/06/2022 12:34

I think generally its not the best idea really.Too much free time to get into trouble! A job provides stability and a knowledge of the value of money! Just handing over cash is no good at all.Also presuming they have their own DC eventually, they may get upset if they were unable to do the same for them surely?

Clymene · 04/06/2022 12:31

They'll end up dead by 30 in all likelihood

Gettingthingsdone777 · 04/06/2022 12:31

Louise0701 · 04/06/2022 11:14

I don’t work (31) and probably never will as I am in an incredibly fortunate financial position. It would bring nothing to my life at all.
I do lots of meaningful things and have the time to experience things I wouldn’t be able to if I was working.
I would do it.

Listen to Louise OP, life can be so much more than just working for a wage! I know I would love it, I also know my parents would have done it for us in a heartbeat if they had the money

Knackeredmommy · 04/06/2022 12:31

Nah, If I could I'd buy them properties so they could live in or rent I would, but I'd hope they'd still study or follow their passions. If I'd been given an income at 21, Id have missed out on a lot of life experiences. I like my career and it gives me a sense of purpose

lljkk · 04/06/2022 12:30

My dad had a neighbour (first met in his mid 30s) who was set up for life. Wealthy family that felt he wasn't right to help run family business but could have a generous permanent annual allowance out of it. My parents' view is that the situation was very bad for him. He was about as capable as most people but never got to test himself, improve, learn, get resilience from failures. The neighbour was not a happy man for feeling purposeless.

Isn't this why Bill & Melinda Gates told their kids they won't inherit huge amounts, only bought them sensible cars, didn't embrace luxury lifestyle, saying "You need to learn how to earn your own way" ?

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 04/06/2022 12:29

I think unless the child has the sort of demanding hobby that requires lots of time but earns very little and you could fund them to pursue it full time then it is likely a bad idea.

I mean Princess Anne, Zara Phillips, Athina Onassis, Jessica Springsteen, Laura Tomlinson etc have all benefited from family money meaning that they don't have the pressure to make a living and can instead focus on their sport and have a life away from grafting.

I'm sure there are similar examples in other sports that don't pay well and in the arts.

I know of people who are opera singers, artists, dancers, musicians etc and can only do that comfortably because their parents have provided a level of support. They are still hardworking motivated individuals.

I don't think paying an unconditional allowance is a great idea though.

Ensuring your child will not face hardship and has good opportunities is a good idea though. Just a mortgage free property to live in is a huge advantage.

I think Peter Jones has a scheme for his kids where he will match their salaries or invest in their business but not give an allowance. He will also pay a higher rate if the child decides to do something worthwhile but poorly paid (eg nursing or teaching).

Gettingthingsdone777 · 04/06/2022 12:24

I think if you are able to set them up in a house and pay off all the debts is pretty much comes to the same thing but maybe that is the best option if you’re not sure about giving them a steady income.

The other issue is if they know there’s money coming eventually it might have a very similar or worse negative effect, I know a few people who you can tell are sort of waiting for the money to come in when parents pass away and that seems to be the most paralysing- no money to do anything interesting at the moment and also very certain they’ll be comfortable in the end (like probably by the time they are 70! But I don’t think they’ve thought that part through).

Larping as a low-middle income family is as likely to breed contempt for parents as it is to instill a good work ethic, ironically it’s sort of infantilising, they’ll know that their parents have the power to help them but are just standing by watching them struggle to teach them a life lesson. A bit demeaning really. If it’s really more noble to have less money and struggle then just give it all away now to poor people who really need it- there are literally people working two jobs and still skipping meals so their children can eat- I’m sure they won’t worry if free money will ruin them or their children.
Or spend it on the people you love- what is the point of having money if you don’t spread it around and make people’s lives easier and more enjoyable? I personally hate seeing really rich people being over careful with money and sort of pretending the reason they’re rich is because they don’t splash out on frivolities or luxuries, i don’t see it as virtuous at all, everyone tends to know they were born rich and the pseudo-skrimping is just their mad way of showing off.

JudyGemstone · 04/06/2022 12:21

In my undergraduate degree I studied the history of intoxication/addiction - we learned that the reason so many artists/musicians have substance issues is that they don’t have a lot of structure/routine. Addiction creates that structure/routine in its own way.

so no, I wouldn’t do this. I want my kids to develop the skills and resourcefulness to be self sufficient, and not to be out of touch with 90% of the population.

I think super privileged kids can often only comfortably spend time with each other, which means they lack the experience of rubbing along with those who are different from you.

as much as you think you might be broadening their world, it would also be narrowing it.

gunnersgold · 04/06/2022 12:17

My mums friend did this for her son and he has never worked . I would make sure they do something with thr money as part of the deal . Set up a charity and run that or start a business so you see a return on the money . Just to give them a goal in life!
I don't have to work but I do because it's great socially and for my brain to keep busy and functioning!

C152 · 04/06/2022 12:14

Yes, it's a terrible thing. How would you teach them the value of anything - money, hard work, a job well done, behaving appropriately in any given situation, social skills etc., if they never have to actually experience any of that first hand?