Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would it be such a bad thing to set your children up financially so that they never have to work?

185 replies

wonderingWallaby · 04/06/2022 10:49

Let’s assume from the age of 21 you provide them with a monthly/annual allowance of x amount (a substantial figure), and they will receive this for the remainder of their life. Obviously I wouldn’t be happy if they spent all day sleeping, playing video games etc. But if the money allowed them to avoid the rat race that is work, maybe that’s not such a bad thing? I know there are a lot of positives to working, but my thought process is that life is short. And if you’re in a position where you don’t have to work or you can ensure your children don’t have to work, is that really such a bad thing?

OP posts:
bringonsummer2022 · 04/06/2022 15:55

I think my parents got it right. They set us up to get through uni with minimal fees so we got into professional careers on high incomes. They helped with house deposits but not straight away, waited until we were at a good time to buy a house and settle down. They taught us to budget and understand pensions and debt and so on.
They could have given us loads of money if they'd wanted to but they like cruising too much.

Newmumatlast · 04/06/2022 15:53

Palavah · 04/06/2022 10:51

Human beings are programmed to expend the minimum effort necessary for survival. Our brains have not evolved as quickly as our society has.

21 year olds barely have fully developed brains.

What kind of behaviour will they be likely to engage in if they don't have to work? What have they shown their motivators and behaviours to be so far?
How will they navigate good choices?

Not sure about this. Otherwise none of the difficult jobs would be done by anyone unless they absolutely had no choice but to do them to survive. I had way easier options available to me for work and coming from a background where we didn't have tons of cash flying around my expectations were very modest. Why did I choose to go to uni and slog my guts out, working 3 jobs to save to go and then working during, and then go after a profession where I was unlikely to succeed and then continue slogging my guts out working stupid hours non compatible with family life to climb the ladder once I did get in? I think some people just like working, competition and ambition.

LuckySantangelo35 · 04/06/2022 15:48

@Louise0701

i agree with @Snoken

i think life is about balance

and you really appreciate not being at work when you do work

im in a similar position in that all my mates work too, so in reality not working would probably lead me to being pretty lonely and bored.

Your weekly itinerary of running a few groups and making a few phone calls can’t add up to even 2 full time work days so you must still have a lot of time to fill. I think I would find that quite hard

Snoken · 04/06/2022 15:22

Louise0701 · 04/06/2022 11:50

@Snoken don’t you find it really sad that you can’t possibly think of anything at all to fill your time with other than work? I think that’s awful and a really miserable way to live that there’s literally nothing else you can think of to do with your life.

Well, it’s not really what I meant. I am by no means a workaholic now either. I work 4 days a week as it is, but if all days were just wide open I would struggle to fill them with things to so since my kids are old enough to do their thing, my friends are working, my family members are working etc. I would get incredibly bored if I didn’t have the structure of working, and I wouldn’t be able to enjoy my free time if every day was just that.

KateMcCallister · 04/06/2022 14:47

This sounds like something off 90 Day Fiancé where the groom to be's mum asked her soon to be dil what she would be doing for work )and to contribute towards the household) and was told "I don't work and I don't plan to. Work doesn't suit me"

Spat my brew clean across the room.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 04/06/2022 14:26

PinaColadaSunset · 04/06/2022 13:45

I know a family who did this. Three children all had expenses paid so didn’t have to work. All three have had a turbulent time. One is alcohol dependent, the other two have drug addictions. They have all attempted to work and failed. All three have had failed relationships and poor relationships with their own children.

Work gives you purpose, opportunities for learning, routine, meaning, friendships and connections. It gives you an ability to contribute to society and gives you something meaningful to say. The family I know have none of that. Everyone of their age is working or learning. They are bumming around all day by themselves.

Why do you think work is a rat-race? It really doesn’t have to be.

Plenty of people who work have alcohol addictions. Look at the amount of people on here who drink to cope with the stresses of day to day life.

whumpthereitis · 04/06/2022 14:19

TedMullins · 04/06/2022 13:27

Why do your kids deserve to do that any more than anyone else though? What makes them special and above working for a living? In an ideal world we’d all just fuck about doing what we liked but most people manage to do it around work, or make their passion into a job/business that pays.

It’s not about whether they deserve to or not though, it’s about whether they have the resources available to them to choose to do that. Some people have those resources, and while it may not be ‘fair’, it is life.

I consider myself lucky enough to be in a position where I’m financially comfortable enough that I could choose not to work now. As it happens, I do work part time doing my own passion projects because I enjoy it (so I do understand that work doesn’t have to be a rat race). I don’t however think that someone choosing not to do what I means that they’re unhappy, without purpose (whatever that actually is), wasting their lives etc. Its arrogant for anyone to think there’s only one right way to do life.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 04/06/2022 14:18

Louise0701 · 04/06/2022 13:50

@LuckySantangelo35 I take it you purposefully ignored my response to you when you asked what I do with my day and are choosing to try any jump on other untrue comments instead.

@Thebestwaytoscareatory that’s not the case in our situation.

It's the case in every situation. Somewhere along the value chain there will be exploitation, that's how capitalism creates the value. While there's some good work going on with regards to creating fair and equitable value chains and investments it's a long way off from being the status quo.

I have no idea what your husband does but I can guarantee there will be exploitation either in his business or it's supply chain and it will 100% be present in any investments.

RaininSummer · 04/06/2022 14:14

I don't think it's a great idea. They may become lazy peter pan types with no ooomph or interest or vacuous trust fund types. Lovely that you have the money to support them but I wouldn't let them know that until they have started making their way in life. It can also have an effect on their potential partner and finding that partner

Namenic · 04/06/2022 14:10

@Louise0701 - I think it’s lovely all the work you do, and I think there is lots of unpaid work that is worthwhile.

however there are some people who, if they could, would not engage in useful things, but things that are useless or harmful. I feel that having an experience (not necessarily all their lives, but at least 10years or so) of working hard and economising would help my kids gain skills for survival if they were to need it in the future.

orwellwasright · 04/06/2022 14:08

JustLyra · 04/06/2022 13:31

It’s interesting how many posts seem to think people can only contribute to society if they are in paid employment.

Lots of unpaid volunteers contribute massively in many areas, and society would be considerably poorer if they all had paid jobs just because it was the done thing.

How many of these volunteers have never been in paid employment?

Lots of people have jobs then retire early and continue working as volunteers. That's very different to growing up knowing you'll never have to earn a penny if you don't fancy it.

Gettingthingsdone777 · 04/06/2022 14:05

LuckySantangelo35 · 04/06/2022 13:41

Exactly!

What about them @Louise0701 those people who work to actualise your husbands investment and business?? When do they get to volunteer and “be there for” for their children?

Em, I feel like some of these responses are more of an argument against capitalism- which- fair enough! I’d probably agree with radical redistribution first and foremost. If everyone started from the same level of wealth that would be fairest of all. I don’t think it’s particularly fair to shame people for being a bit well off and making the most of it.

If we’re being realistic, a lot of people on here probably live to a relatively high standard when looked at globally, there are probably many sacrifices some of us could make very easily which would be massively beneficial to someone else where in the world.

Example, there’s a charity were they give the poorest people in the world the equivalent of 15 dollars a month every month over 5-10 years, 85% of donations to the charity goes direct to the people and there are no conditions or strings attached. Totally transformative for the people who get it, they thrive, they massively improve their housing, education, their businesses. Health is better, mental health is better and where there are whole towns receiving it, they attract new businesses and grow and improve. That’s probably equivalent of monthly cost of streaming services , pretty cheap way of transforming someone’s life, most people could stretch to that if they wanted to but don’t for various reasons. So I think it’s worth being mindful that a lot (not all) of us lead pretty unfairly privileged lives compare to the rest of the world just because of where we were born and could easily change that if we wanted to. Which of us can say we live a life that doesn’t exploit others, at all? Given that most governments invest taxes in really corrupt and exploitative industries like oil and tech, so many goods we use everyday come from places were people have few rights and little wealth. what about the people who got 50p to make an item of your clothing, work 16 hour days and never get to “be there for” their children either? Is it more okay because they’re far away?

coffeecupsandfairylights · 04/06/2022 13:58

LuckySantangelo35 · 04/06/2022 13:42

@coffeecupsandfairylights

bit of a difference between funding a few driving and setting up your children so they never have to work a day in their life

But giving your child driving lessons and a car still gives them a huge advantage over children who have to fund those things themselves.

You say you don't agree with private school - presumably because it gives an unfair advantage, so why draw the line there and not elsewhere? I mean, if private school was banned, rich parents would just pay for private tutoring and the same divide would still exist...

Louise0701 · 04/06/2022 13:57

@Gettingthingsdone777 thank you. I feel very lucky and I’m very happy with my life.

Louise0701 · 04/06/2022 13:51

@Gettingthingsdone777 thank you. I feel very lucky and I’m very happy with my life.

Louise0701 · 04/06/2022 13:50

@LuckySantangelo35 I take it you purposefully ignored my response to you when you asked what I do with my day and are choosing to try any jump on other untrue comments instead.

@Thebestwaytoscareatory that’s not the case in our situation.

PinaColadaSunset · 04/06/2022 13:48

Oh and just to add…they have awful relationships with their parents (who gave them the money in the first place). Two won’t speak to their parents at all. The other one lives in another country and sees them once a year.

A poor outcome on every level.

PinaColadaSunset · 04/06/2022 13:45

I know a family who did this. Three children all had expenses paid so didn’t have to work. All three have had a turbulent time. One is alcohol dependent, the other two have drug addictions. They have all attempted to work and failed. All three have had failed relationships and poor relationships with their own children.

Work gives you purpose, opportunities for learning, routine, meaning, friendships and connections. It gives you an ability to contribute to society and gives you something meaningful to say. The family I know have none of that. Everyone of their age is working or learning. They are bumming around all day by themselves.

Why do you think work is a rat-race? It really doesn’t have to be.

hellcatspanglelalala · 04/06/2022 13:45

What purpose in life would they have then? Sounds like a terrible idea to me.

I'd buy them a house, and help them out if they wanted to train for a specific career/start their own business, but I can't see the benefit in giving them that much that they don't have to bother doing anything for themselves.

LuckySantangelo35 · 04/06/2022 13:42

@coffeecupsandfairylights

bit of a difference between funding a few driving and setting up your children so they never have to work a day in their life

coffeecupsandfairylights · 04/06/2022 13:41

TedMullins · 04/06/2022 13:31

Yeah I’d also quite like to abolish private schools and have a 100% inheritance tax so my bar is pretty high.

Okay, and what about all the millions of other ways children are advantaged because of their parents?

Are you going to ban foreign holidays? Children having their own rooms? Houses with swimming pools and tennis courts? Buying your child a car or driving lessons when they turn seventeen? Passing on your own knowledge skills/to your children in case it gives them an unfair advantage in the workplace? Private tutors? Music lessons or sports because not everyone can afford it?

Where do you stop?

LuckySantangelo35 · 04/06/2022 13:41

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 04/06/2022 13:33

You do realise that your husband's very successful business and investments are only successful because they exploit people who have to work right?

Exactly!

What about them @Louise0701 those people who work to actualise your husbands investment and business?? When do they get to volunteer and “be there for” for their children?

BlackAmericanoNoSugar · 04/06/2022 13:39

I've seen it in action and it didn't go well. It led to a lifetime of not really doing much at all, constant low-level drug use, surrounded by spongers instead of real friends and a relatively early death. Of course there's no guarantee that this person would have been any happier being poorer, but I think most people grow through dealing with consequences of their choices and learn to make better choices. The independently wealthy don't have that sort of forced learning because they can buy their way out of consequences.

Orla83 · 04/06/2022 13:38

If it could be managed properly, I agree. Conditions attached such as completing further education, volunteering, starting a business. I haven't thought it through, but it sounds interesting.

LuckySantangelo35 · 04/06/2022 13:37

TedMullins · 04/06/2022 13:27

Why do your kids deserve to do that any more than anyone else though? What makes them special and above working for a living? In an ideal world we’d all just fuck about doing what we liked but most people manage to do it around work, or make their passion into a job/business that pays.

exactly! I don’t want my kids having that kind of superiority complex - I don’t think it would make them nice people