Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would it be such a bad thing to set your children up financially so that they never have to work?

185 replies

wonderingWallaby · 04/06/2022 10:49

Let’s assume from the age of 21 you provide them with a monthly/annual allowance of x amount (a substantial figure), and they will receive this for the remainder of their life. Obviously I wouldn’t be happy if they spent all day sleeping, playing video games etc. But if the money allowed them to avoid the rat race that is work, maybe that’s not such a bad thing? I know there are a lot of positives to working, but my thought process is that life is short. And if you’re in a position where you don’t have to work or you can ensure your children don’t have to work, is that really such a bad thing?

OP posts:
coffeecupsandfairylights · 04/06/2022 18:21

Abra1d1 · 04/06/2022 17:17

The people I know who didn’t need to work weren’t always very happy and a lot of them had addiction problems. They were happier when they eventually found some kind of roles.

And I know a lot of people who are stuck in miserable jobs and who absolutely dread going to work each day. There are many more for whom work causes huge amount of stress and anxiety.

We're not all the same and not everyone is cut out for work.

Puglover287 · 04/06/2022 18:20

I know someone in my immediate family who has exactly this. I’m talking mid-20s, never worked a day in their life, no qualifications (failed all GCSE’s and never did any further education as was told they’d be fully provided for). They have their rent, car (brand new every 3 years), fuel, household bills and all other expenses (hobbies, food, holidays, cleaner) paid for. They are unfortunately very arrogant and have no desire to ever work or help others. They do not volunteer, or use their freedom to help their family or local community. If they want more money, they just ask and it’s given. However, their older sibling has never had a single penny given to them, as the parents could only (just about) afford to fund one child and did just that. Luckily, said older sibling has been able to create a very successful career but it doesn’t detract from the fact that the situation is very strange.

If anyone is considering it, make sure that your children are not relying on this happening without any fall back. Also, make sure you can afford it for all your children equally.

SleepQuest33 · 04/06/2022 18:07

Terrible idea!
human beings need some sort of purpose in life, if everything gets given to you, there is nothing to strive for or to work towards, I think that leads to depression.
Different story if a person has worked towards their goals and then want to relax.
a young person will do nothing with their life!

ncerer · 04/06/2022 18:03

I have changed name to contribute honestly and then I'll change back! We would be in a position to do something like this for our kids. We wouldn't give them an allowance through life though, as this would definitely be bad for their mental health and futures. But we will probably buy them all a house outright when the time comes. At sill also pay for uni so they don't have to be paying back loans etc.

Our kids are all very different. The eldest is going to Oxford and we don't need to worry about his work ethic because he can't do 'nothing' (he's like his dad) and he is extremely hard-working and focused. He's not interested in 'stuff' either. We won't be giving him an allowance, but my husband will maybe get him securely on the property ladder (London) and also an investment portfolio. I'm not exactly sure how much, but it could be a few million each. Most importantly, he has the self-confidence and resilience to make his own way.

One of our others is less likely to be a high earner as some mild SEN, less confidence and not particularly academic. We will help this one with a house, but this DC will need support to not be taken advantage of and how to invest / budget wisely. But this DC will definitely be working - just probably not in a job that would buy a similar kind of property in London.

Thr younger one is very bright and confident in her abilities, very socially switched-on and makes positive relationships easily (always has) and I don't doubt she'll have a great career. BUT I'm not sure she understands the value of money as much as the eldest does, instinctively, so we'll have to watch her there.

I worked in the public sector until age 31 when I had DC and I've not worked since. There are pros and cons to this - but also, life isn't set in stone and you adapt over time. If I'd kept working, yes, I would have had that identity and the fulfilment of a job (if it was something I enjoyed). But I don't know if I have been 'happier' as such and there is a lot I've done in my life that I couldn't have experienced if I was working. Unless you've lived two parallel lives - how can you tell? So no point worrying about it really.

I'm now at a point when I could volunteer or something and I'm looking into this, but, to be perfectly honest, the 'push' isn't there to earn money because it wouldn't make much difference. The 'cost / benefit analysis of someone working totally depends on context. In a different marriage, I almost certainly would have been working all these years. Maybe I'd be better for it, but also maybe not. I have no idea. On the one hand I feel the financial privilege my husband has provided has meant I've not pushed myself or used my degrees. In the other hand, I feel as if I've had a lot of freedom and generally have been incredibly lucky. I take nothing for granted though, as I grew up basically hand to mouth (not in U.K.). This has not been the case for our kids who have had private educations and every opportunity really. The eldest knows this and he says it is what drives him to make it count. The younger ones, I'm not so sure. Time will tell, I guess. But no, we are certainly not just going to give them money to squander.

Intrigueddotcom · 04/06/2022 17:56

Gettingthingsdone777 · 04/06/2022 17:38

Sounds great, did you choose finance as a career path or did you fall into it?
Sorry for grilling you 😂but I’m always interested to hear why people love their jobs and how they found that out. I love my job, but I’ve had plenty I didn’t like, and I also wouldn’t struggle with being wealthy and not working for pay either

Graduate training scheme 20 years ago.
no particular desire to get in to this industry
i went for it as meant move to London, got offered it and the rest is history

I love that my children (single parent) see work as a good thing because they see me challenged and positive about it

MattDamon · 04/06/2022 17:55

A friend's partner (now husband) received £10,000 a month, plus travel and car allowances from the age of 18 until his trust fund kicked in at age 35. He did fuck all with his life, dropping out of uni, smoking weed, playing video games, 24/7. For 17 years.

He's now the most boring 40-something on the planet, with no hobbies or interests or the ability to relate to most other adults.

His parents were insanely ambitious and hard-working, but by giving him everything, they really cheated him out of being able to appreciate anything.

Strokethefurrywall · 04/06/2022 17:53

I don't think enough can be said for the sense of achievement that comes from striving for something you want.
The reward is the knowledge that you have the drive to work for what you want, and this is fundamental to the inherent development for young people.

I would never deprive my kids of developing this part of their personalities.

That being said, I'd not be adverse to keeping a property for the kids as a relative security for the future, as well as a trust fund for education or personal development.

Ponderingwindow · 04/06/2022 17:46

I would never just give my adult child money. I have an educational trust set up to help pay for university. If I find myself with the means, I would
do the same with housing, set up education funds for grandchildren, pay into a pension fund, or even set up an earnings matching scheme. Basically there would always be strings and high expectations.

thecatsthecats · 04/06/2022 17:41

My sister and her husband work sporadically on short term contracts. High pay, but no permanent jobs. They have voids in work, and where they can, they plan these to coincide with their kids needing them.

My niece is like me. An academic high achiever who loves the outdoors and caring for animals. I was pushed into employment by academic achievements and social norms and I HATED it. It ruined my health and my body for years.

I'm so glad that my sister is supporting my niece in a lifestyle that suits her. Part of that is giving her money, support and teaching her financial skills that will enable her to do work that doesn't feel like work to her.

I want to do the same for my kids. Help them see money as a need, not a master, and live to enjoy life.

Gettingthingsdone777 · 04/06/2022 17:38

Intrigueddotcom · 04/06/2022 17:31

Nothing special
I work in finance, always have, but it is for a union and one i feel passionate about, plus I feel challenged and love putting my training to use. Plus enjoy my colleagues company and engaging with our members. Plus, I like working with money

Sounds great, did you choose finance as a career path or did you fall into it?
Sorry for grilling you 😂but I’m always interested to hear why people love their jobs and how they found that out. I love my job, but I’ve had plenty I didn’t like, and I also wouldn’t struggle with being wealthy and not working for pay either

Ballcactus · 04/06/2022 17:36

Can you adopt me please?

Intrigueddotcom · 04/06/2022 17:33

Topgub · 04/06/2022 17:25

@Intrigueddotcom

Usually wealthy sahms. No, not directly to me but on these kinds of threads on working v not working.

Its been said on this one a few times already.

That is very strange then because presumably these SAHMs have husbands that work a great deal in order to be the sole income. I wonder if the same the same to their husbands!

Helpyou · 04/06/2022 17:32

I think if I didn't have work I'd be depressed. I need a routine and like the feeling of earning my money and using it to enjoy life. That being said, I'd love a bit extra for bills / more holidays. But I think if I'd been handed this at 21, I wouldn't have experienced the things I have. Experiences which have shaped me.

Intrigueddotcom · 04/06/2022 17:31

Gettingthingsdone777 · 04/06/2022 17:18

What kind of work do you do?

Nothing special
I work in finance, always have, but it is for a union and one i feel passionate about, plus I feel challenged and love putting my training to use. Plus enjoy my colleagues company and engaging with our members. Plus, I like working with money

mycatisannoying · 04/06/2022 17:29

It would be dreadful for my children, as if left to their own devices, they're inherently rather lazy.
Work is good for them, and gives a sense of purpose and routine. They need the self-discipline.

Topgub · 04/06/2022 17:25

@Intrigueddotcom

Usually wealthy sahms. No, not directly to me but on these kinds of threads on working v not working.

Its been said on this one a few times already.

Gettingthingsdone777 · 04/06/2022 17:18

Intrigueddotcom · 04/06/2022 16:55

You have a shitty view of work op

i love my job, I get SO much from it

i don’t want to deny my children that possibility

I would suggest that you don’t indicate to your children that you view all paid work as “the rat race” and unfulfilling in its own right. Very demotivating

What kind of work do you do?

Abra1d1 · 04/06/2022 17:17

The people I know who didn’t need to work weren’t always very happy and a lot of them had addiction problems. They were happier when they eventually found some kind of roles.

Intrigueddotcom · 04/06/2022 17:12

They always (weirdly) slag people who do value work by saying ewww how boring. Imagine enjoying working. How miserable your life must be.

I always think they must be either incredibly sheltered or a bit dim if they can't figure out that most people manage to work and have hobbies and a social life. And spend time with kids and family.

@Topgub who says this? Very rich or unemployed? Either way, they say this to you?

Topgub · 04/06/2022 17:05

I think its really important to have financial independence.

Not to rely on family, husbands, state

I wouldnt want to bring my kids up to think they could rely entirely on sonekbe else.

Work also has value. I never really understand people who don't see the value in working. (And no volunteering one a month at your kids school doesn't count)

They always (weirdly) slag people who do value work by saying ewww how boring. Imagine enjoying working. How miserable your life must be.

I always think they must be either incredibly sheltered or a bit dim if they can't figure out that most people manage to work and have hobbies and a social life. And spend time with kids and family.

Intrigueddotcom · 04/06/2022 16:55

You have a shitty view of work op

i love my job, I get SO much from it

i don’t want to deny my children that possibility

I would suggest that you don’t indicate to your children that you view all paid work as “the rat race” and unfulfilling in its own right. Very demotivating

MargaretThursday · 04/06/2022 16:52

Depends on the kids.
Dd1 would see it as a financial backdrop so she didn't need to worry if things went wrong. So it would help her. She'd still get stuff done, but wouldn't have to worry about if things fell apart, so she'd be far more relaxed.
DD2 and ds, not sure. I think they'd both see it as a way to drift along trying out things and not quite get round to anything.

whumpthereitis · 04/06/2022 16:15

I think a lot of people are attached to the idea that the universe owes us fairness. You can’t be privileged AND happy AND well rounded because that isn’t fair, to balance out privilege you have to be fucked up and/or miserable.

Nothappyatwork · 04/06/2022 15:59

Mine have a house that they all have keys to that’s not in the most desirable part of the world but they would always have a roof over their heads so they all know that at any point if they need it they can go and live there.

i’m not sure I would ever handover the actual physical cash. I can see how that could be taken advantage of by outsiders

Lesserspottedmama · 04/06/2022 15:56

No. But I’d set them up in whatever they wanted to pursue. And when they came to have children I’d like them to have the option of being at home with them for years as nursery etc is not ideal in any way. I see wealthy families on social media etc who just go round the world in their sailing boat etc for a year with their little ones, or road trip around the US in a big RV. Who wouldn’t want their adult children to be able to live their passions and really focus on their own children, giving them fantastic experiences. But 21 no way, it’s a terrible idea. Let them
work hard first on their chosen career path, will give them a much better character in the long run.