Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would it be such a bad thing to set your children up financially so that they never have to work?

185 replies

wonderingWallaby · 04/06/2022 10:49

Let’s assume from the age of 21 you provide them with a monthly/annual allowance of x amount (a substantial figure), and they will receive this for the remainder of their life. Obviously I wouldn’t be happy if they spent all day sleeping, playing video games etc. But if the money allowed them to avoid the rat race that is work, maybe that’s not such a bad thing? I know there are a lot of positives to working, but my thought process is that life is short. And if you’re in a position where you don’t have to work or you can ensure your children don’t have to work, is that really such a bad thing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
whatwasyournamesorry · 05/06/2022 07:24

What do you hope they'll do with their lives?

ToppTotty · 05/06/2022 00:34

Further to my note above—it doesn't mean you won't have to give them a nudge sometimes. My parents did this for me when I was 20 years old and drifting. They had been supporting me financially for around 2 years and then they said... either get a job or go back to school (those were the terms on which they would continue to support me). Of course going back to school didn't seem like such a bad idea then! Actually it turned my life around and helped me decide what I wanted to do.

ToppTotty · 05/06/2022 00:29

Of course it wouldn't be a bad thing to save your children from a life of drudgery, clock watching and wage slavery.

Meaningful occupation does not have to involve paid work. Especially if they are creative types as they will have the freedom to pursue their art.

starlingdarling does make a good point above. I don't think it would hurt to tell them this is in the offing, though. I had a colleague in a similar position (inherited millions when his parents died) and he was very successful , ironically, as he didn't have to worry about being fired or building a career and that gave him a kind of confidence the rest of us lacked.

PegasusReturns · 05/06/2022 00:07

You have a shitty view of work op

A lot of work is a a bit shitty though. Why bother unless you have to, or you get a lot from it. I’m very fortunate that I fall into the latter category. I “retired” in my 30s and went back to work after a few years. But I went into a very senior role where I have large amounts of non financial rewards, plenty of flexibility and I do something I really enjoy.

Gladragdoll · 04/06/2022 21:57

It depends on a lot of circumstances. Some of the young lottery millionaires have had big probs with being rich at a young age. Obvs that’s a lump sum so it’s different. I’d also be concerned with who and what the money attracts. Some kind of supervision might be needed.

XingMing · 04/06/2022 21:42

The fetishisation of work really matters because for most people, most of the time what you do to fund a meal on the table, is a large chunk of what you are. I do realise that I see this through a privileged lens, having been educated well and innately cleverer than many or most. I loved work. But most people don't, and it's a dull neccesssary evil.

CorvusPurpureus · 04/06/2022 21:32

Well, no. They are going to need purpose in life.

Plus, Come The Zombie Apocalypse, you'd be toast without a marketable & transportable skill. I do bang on to mine a lot about this.

Assuming I somehow won the lottery tomorrow, I can't envisage the best use of that money being to render 3 perfectly competent & intelligent young adults fundamentally unemployable over a period of entitled years of nonsense.

I would probably quietly dripfeed it down the generations, with helpful house deposits to grandchildren in trust until they turned 30 or so.

But no. I would never, ever pull the rug on my dc like that. They are all currently working to attain qualifications which lead to the next step in their futures.

To effectively say: 'NOT to worry, guys! I will just keep on covering everything you ever need.' sounds to me like a lousy & poisonous message to launch a young adult dc with.

orwellwasright · 04/06/2022 21:29

coffeecupsandfairylights · 04/06/2022 19:59

I think a life without work must be very boring and without purpose.

For me, the purpose of work is to pay my bills. I actually like my job, but I would give it up in a heartbeat it if I won the lottery!

Me too. I fantasise about being able to give up paid employment.

But I'm pleased I've had to work in my life.

Sirius3030 · 04/06/2022 21:08

I have a distant friend who never had to work (rich family, known in drama world). Can’t say his life has been particularly special or good. He had a personal family tragedy in later years and does a fair amount of charitable work now. I can’t say I envy anything about his life.

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 04/06/2022 20:46

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 04/06/2022 11:02

I would pay them to do voluntary work or study, or indeed a top up for low paid but necessary work. Sport maybe. Not just for leisure. (Caring for their own children or other relative also included)

This.

If my DC wanted to work at a domestic violence shelter, be a nurse with Médecins Sans Frontières, help with refugee resettlement, etc. and I had the means to top up their salary indefinitely, I would certainly consider it. But I would never condone not working. If nothing else, they’d run a real risk of not understanding how the world works, and lacking empathy.

I’m a very high earner, and one of the things I try to be most intentional about is making sure my DCs have responsibilities, do chores, and attend regular schools, even if they don’t “have” to.

lightisnotwhite · 04/06/2022 20:40

But working as a rich kid is not working as a poor kid. They know parents have money to bail them but equally have only known wealth. Even if Victoria Beckham told her kids to work why would they work as a waiter or shelf stacker like ours?
They have every connection going. They an pick what work they want . The reality is they become a model, voice actress, designer.. It’s really well paid and nothing like an actual job.

QueenOfHiraeth · 04/06/2022 20:38

It varies according to the "child" obviously but, on the whole, I think it creates more problems than it solves.

We don't have that kind of money but have helped a bit with weddings, buying homes, etc and hope to do more in time as it has always been appreciated and all of our DCs work and are doing well. If we had more I suspect DH would want to set up trusts to pay out on discretion rather than give it all.

Close friends of ours though always had an ambition to give each child a fully paid home and that has not been as positive. DC1 was given a 2 bed flat in London Zone 2, DC2 got a 3 bed detached house in another town and DC3 has a flat in a different zone 2 area. Two of them have not achieved much workwise despite being bright as the extra disposable income has reduced their ambition/need to work and, sadly, increased their social drug use which has caused other problems but the third has used it well, renting the property out and using the money to fund themselves to get into their chosen career

Minimalme · 04/06/2022 20:36

I think it would be morally very wrong indeed to use the money you have to 'protect' dc from the world of work.

It would be disempowering beyond belief.

Why ignore all the children growing up in poverty who desperately need money and who could be helped instead? Who knows what could be achieved.

Farawayfromhere · 04/06/2022 20:03

I think there’s a huge difference between giving your child so much that they never had to work, and giving them enough to give them freedom and choices and possibly the ability to work part time.

I don’t think never having to work is good for anyone, whatever the reason for it and whatever part of society you are part of.

I would love to be able to help my kids buy a flat or house. But I wouldn’t want to create a situation where they could live their whole life without working.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 04/06/2022 19:59

I think a life without work must be very boring and without purpose.

For me, the purpose of work is to pay my bills. I actually like my job, but I would give it up in a heartbeat it if I won the lottery!

lightisnotwhite · 04/06/2022 19:55

Yes but people are always banging on about “ know your worth”.
if all you know are great jobs that pay travel, expenses and over the odds for trivial things it’s impossible to do a shit job for shit money. Rich kids know money is out there,
I’m delighted if an INSET day means lunch is provided.. My husband gets £50 a day for food of which he pockets because there is free crew catering. That’s almost a TA daily wage.

orangeisthenewpuce · 04/06/2022 19:21

No. I'd never ever consider that. I like the fact that, like me, my children are hard workers and reliable employees. I think a life without work must be very boring and without purpose. I'd also hate to depend on my parents for money, I like to be independent. I found the short time that I had as a sahm very dull.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 04/06/2022 19:17

Nothappyatwork · 04/06/2022 18:28

Not everyone is cut out for every kind of job I would agree but I think most people can do something it’s often just a case of supporting them to find what that thing is. I did psychometric testing years ago and the long and the short of it was I cannot carry out repetitive tasks, literally my brain does not function that way and I cannot do it whereas I know all the people who have jobs in warehouses etc I can think of one of the top of my head but it’s to outting if I do but it’s just a simple repetitive task that’s done very well day in day out and they enjoy it got a great deal of satisfaction from it and quite a decent living too.

There’s a Lid for every pot.

But many jobs pay so little that people can't afford to work in them AND support themselves or their family without help. So if your skill set lies in a poorly paid career, then there would be a benefit to your parent being able to help you out.

Topgub · 04/06/2022 19:12

@Intrigueddotcom

Quite the contradiction eh?

lightisnotwhite · 04/06/2022 19:02

Nothappyatwork · 04/06/2022 18:28

Not everyone is cut out for every kind of job I would agree but I think most people can do something it’s often just a case of supporting them to find what that thing is. I did psychometric testing years ago and the long and the short of it was I cannot carry out repetitive tasks, literally my brain does not function that way and I cannot do it whereas I know all the people who have jobs in warehouses etc I can think of one of the top of my head but it’s to outting if I do but it’s just a simple repetitive task that’s done very well day in day out and they enjoy it got a great deal of satisfaction from it and quite a decent living too.

There’s a Lid for every pot.

There’s different types of repetitive tasks, I walked out of my bar job because ai literally couldn’t stand the pointlessness of pouring pints to drunk people and then washing hundreds of glasses, hosing down and repeating every night. Cleaning was the same Whereas I had a very dull job in a processing plant where you could banter with people all shift and work fast and it was fine.

What do rich kids do though? Their parents have the best well paid interesting work with some of the most well paid interesting people. 90% of jobs are shit that people do because they need money. You can’t blame them for not working for the council.

lightisnotwhite · 04/06/2022 18:45

Trouble is if you are loaded and don’t give your kids a share you are being a bit of a twat really. They know you have it but are withholding it. It’s a different dynamic to actually growing up with nothing that make them work hard.

My DH is well off and will inherit a good chunk ( not trust fund amounts). But I can see the difference having a “back up” can make to raising kids and to work. DH has a great job he loves and was prepared to work a shit job in lock down ( which everyone said what a marvellous work ethic he had).. But the truth is he really wasn’t up for the shit job for longer than necessary. Money gives him choices and that family money counts.

MissChristie · 04/06/2022 18:33

I think it is a bad thing. A good work ethic is important and helps to create a well rounded person. Work isn’t just to earn money, it’s about contributing, learning to get along with others and putting a structure around one’s life.

I know someone very wealthy whose children, mid-20s have never worked and they’re not well rounded individuals. There’s nothing interesting about them, they’re lazy, work shy and unpopular. I’m all for supporting one’s children as much as possible but even if I was mega wealthy I would teach and expect a healthy attitude towards work.

Nothappyatwork · 04/06/2022 18:28

coffeecupsandfairylights · 04/06/2022 18:21

And I know a lot of people who are stuck in miserable jobs and who absolutely dread going to work each day. There are many more for whom work causes huge amount of stress and anxiety.

We're not all the same and not everyone is cut out for work.

Not everyone is cut out for every kind of job I would agree but I think most people can do something it’s often just a case of supporting them to find what that thing is. I did psychometric testing years ago and the long and the short of it was I cannot carry out repetitive tasks, literally my brain does not function that way and I cannot do it whereas I know all the people who have jobs in warehouses etc I can think of one of the top of my head but it’s to outting if I do but it’s just a simple repetitive task that’s done very well day in day out and they enjoy it got a great deal of satisfaction from it and quite a decent living too.

There’s a Lid for every pot.

GrassWillBeGreener · 04/06/2022 18:27

I guess if you were in a position to be able to do this / know you would be able to do this while your children were young, I'd want to bring them up with a strong service ethic - to be giving back something to the community in some way, using whatever skills they had or could develop. And then hope that that would help produce rounded fulfilled adults.

I know what I'd do with a million or two - set up a subsidised music school, with rooms that teachers could use to give lessons, and a larger concert space. I've even eyed up a property locally that might be adaptable ... I'd need to employ an administrator I think. Only a dream ....

RibNSaucyArseCrack · 04/06/2022 18:27

Our two have a property each for when they’re grown. They’re both near a university too so the condition will be they do a degree and they can live rent free. We will also have savings for them which they can have when they’re properly matured adults. For putting towards buying a house, travelling, having kids etc.