Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL - nephews birthday party

256 replies

lollipoplips · 03/06/2022 21:42

I don't know if I'm being overly sensitive or if this is a really shitty thing to do so interested to hear what people think.

I have 2 sons 18m and 3.
SIL has 2 sons 3 and 5.

It's my nephews 4th birthday next week and my mum gave me an invitation today for his party with just my youngest name on. I assumed it was a mistake and text SIL saying invite only says DS2 is that a mistake. She replied and said no, her son chose who he wanted to attend and he only said DS2, I replied and said I felt that was unfair to exclude 1 nephew from the party and she said she didn't think it would matter as he's never interested in playing with them.

For background my DS1 is suspected Autistic, he struggles socially and doesn't often interact with kids his age, but he loves going to see his cousins, he likes watching them play even if he doesn't get involved. There's no issues between them, no fighting/arguing he just keeps his distance, doing his own thing or watches everyone else. He's a happy boy, rarely has tantrums or meltdowns in public.

The party is at their house, in the garden, they have lots of space so numbers isn't an issue.

I don't know if it's just me being overly sensitive and heartbroken for my beautiful boy as I feel this is the start of how he will be treated growing up.

I'm thinking of just not bothering at all.

OP posts:
WhereYouLeftIt · 04/06/2022 11:24

lollipoplips · 03/06/2022 22:34

My mum wasn't happy but their relationship is strained anyway due to SILs behaviour so I wouldn't want her to get involved in it.

We aren't going, and I'll text tomorrow and tell her exactly why.

I wouldn't go either. Fuck SIL and fuck your brother.

LookItsMeAgain · 04/06/2022 11:18

Current situation aside (and I think the suggestion made by @SarahDippity is excellent as is what @timeisnotaline suggested), but in your post you wrote:
It's my brother and his wife. There's no point speaking to him as he will always back what she says whether it's right or not.
There are so many threads on MN where we ask for our DH's to back us up when we're in a family dispute and it seems like your DB is doing just that for his wife.

Getting back to this situation, I'd recommend replying to your mum, your brother and your SiL with some form of wording like what SarahDippity or timeisnotaline have suggested or both. It's clear, concise and gets your frustration and disappointment to be dealing with these issues in your own family across very clearly.

Fraaahnces · 04/06/2022 11:17

The party is for a kid who is about to turn 4. It is highly unlikely that they have been asked to write out the invitations. They would have little to no say in who was invited at all. The SIL is the one who has the final say in who is invited and if she genuinely wanted one cousin there, should know automatically that when it comes to family events, all siblings should be included.

BlueMongoose · 04/06/2022 11:13

SIL may think he doesn't want to be there or is bored if he's distant when he is there? I'd be tempted to explain to SIL that he may look distant but is actually enjoying himself.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 04/06/2022 11:11

This stuff drives me nuts. This situation is when a responsible parent sits down and explains to their child why excluding a family member is not ok. Children aren't born knowing this stuff - it us up to us to teach them. She's an idiot.

froggybiby · 04/06/2022 11:10

it is very sad and shocking. If that is the way they raise their kids!

Mummyoflittledragon · 04/06/2022 11:04

@Alb0
I understand where you’re coming from about being invited when not wanted. However, this is a small child being allowed to exclude his cousin because he doesn’t yet understand about empathy, not an attempt to break his spirits. The teen years will be very tough on parents of the pandered to children and adulthood very tough on those children. Op has not broken up the family and an 18 month old will not know he’s been excluded.

Unsure33 · 04/06/2022 11:02

Alb0 · 04/06/2022 09:54

I would never, ever, ever force my child to invite someone they didn't want, just because I was a virtue signaller. I would also, as someone who was actually diagnosed with HF Autism, never want to be forced on someone who wouldn't want me there. And you know if you're not wanted somewhere, trust me, you know. NT virtue signalling is incompatible with autistic children either being forced on someone, or forced to spend time with someone they don't want to, because the parents/relatives whatever what to try to make me/the child with autism appear normal and do normal things and fit in. It just does not work! I am extremely pro children's rights and childrens liberation and I would never force my child to invite someone they don't want, I would never break their spirit like that and force my view on them.

Really ? We don’t even know for definite that the child was even asked. It sounds like the SIL made up her own mind .

I taught my children to be inclusive and not discriminate and to consider the needs of others.

I have a nephew who actually is in care now , but we used to invite him to parties and make special arrangements that the parents were there with him if the need arose to intervene .

i am with the OP . I would decline the invitation. The SIL could have handled this so much better.

LondonMaybe · 04/06/2022 10:57

There is no not evil reason for that, being a house party with garden and family. So sorry and I wouldn’t want to go with just one sibling either.

Fraaahnces · 04/06/2022 10:56

I just popped back in to say that at least you know now and can protect you dc from that absolute gnome of a woman. You no longer have to pretend to tolerate her at all. Don’t waste your energy or emotions on her ever again.
BTW, I wouldn’t even RSVP to the party. This is one time I would deliberately bin my manners and let her (or more likely, your DB) come to you to find out why you didn’t show. Then either let her have it with both guns or simply say “You know exactly why…” and hang up.
Don’t get sucked into any future guilt trips about your kids having a relationship with their cousins. (From any family members - even your mum.) To do so, they’d have to have a relationship with their mother, and she’s shown herself to be someone extremely unsafe. (I would also ensure that everyone in your wider family knows about this ASAP and that her name is mud.)

worriedatthistime · 04/06/2022 10:53

@Alb0 but its not a child in the class its a family member who has done nothing wrong and is 3 ? So if your child wanted to invite 19 out of 20 in their class you would say ok ? You wouldn't explain that maybe thats a little unkind? In this situations there cousins and the sil could even explain in childlike terms that op child is different because of xyz and actually that we are all different and i can't believe he plays anymore with an 18 month old either
The sil is just being mean
We can teach our children that all situations need addressing differently , in life they will have to associate with people they don't like

Mammyloveswine · 04/06/2022 10:50

God this is awful! I have two sons and eldest is autistic and I can see how my youngest gets favoured by certain relatives-I avoid them now and see those that value BOTH of my children!

Eggshausted · 04/06/2022 10:48

How could an adult be so mean to a young child? I wouldn’t go and if anybody asks why, simply explain that she wanted to exclude one member of the family. No need to expand, they will be able to work out themselves what a cow she is. I wouldn’t bother sending a gift, the child will receive plenty. Spend the money on a treat for your two.

Oceanus · 04/06/2022 10:47

@Alb0 If your kids learn from birth every single will and want of theirs will be catered to, they're in for a truly bloody rude awakening when they're older an expect to get the same treatment from strangers, who'll obviously have no duty to bow to them. You better live to be 100 to pet them on the head when things get tough.

CoffeeWithMyOxygen · 04/06/2022 10:45

I’m glad you’re not going, I can’t even imagine only inviting one of my DC’s cousins to their birthday parties and not the other - to be honest it’s such a given that the cousins all attend each other’s that we don’t really bother with official invites any more!

BusyMum47 · 04/06/2022 10:43

@lollipoplips What a mean, shitty thing for your SIL to do! I would be SO upset & angry in your shoes & definitely wouldn't go at all!
Of course kids can invite who they like to a birthday party & siblings don't always have to do everything together etc BUT that doesn't apply to family!! I don't even understand why she bothered with actual invites for family - you just tell them when/where & ALL the children are included - especially at this young age & the fact that the party is only at their house anyway - its not like it's an event with paid for spaces!!
Your eldest son sounds absolutely awesome & deserves so much better from supposed family. I'd have to have it out with her & your brother definitely needs to grow a pair & put her straight. She sounds vile.

2bazookas · 04/06/2022 10:41

I'd take my two sons out for a nice day in the park and forget to mention to SIL DS2 isn't coming to the party.

Did she really expect you to roll up to a party with both kids then tell DS 1 "you can't go" and take him away again?

DFOD · 04/06/2022 10:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

@Alb0 - I am not sure that you know what virtue signalling means? The OP is not virtue signalling about anything - she is expressing the hurt and confusion of excluding a specific family member / vulnerable child from a family event. There is nothing nuanced about this - it’s straightforwardly socially unacceptable.

Notonthestairs · 04/06/2022 10:39

You don't break a child spirit by inviting all their cousins to a birthday party.

My youngest attends a SN school. Friendships certainly aren't forced but they are expected to behave decently towards each other.

Kindness and generosity does not equal virtue signalling.

Soapboxqueen · 04/06/2022 10:38

I wouldn't be going either. It's really mean to invite one sibling and not the other when it's family. We aren't talking about much older kids here either who might have different relationships with each other. They're all just little.

My ds ASD/PDA loves family gatherings. Sometimes he's in the mix, other times he's happy knowing everyone is there and he takes himself off to read somewhere. ALL of our family, on both sides, just let him get on with it. Even my in-laws in-laws just go with the flow. They'd never leave him out.

Tbh at the ages these children are, I wouldn't have allowed my child to only invite one cousin (who's a baby) and not the other. Potential ASD or not. Just logistically it's unfair on the parents.

And yes, it sets the tone going forward.

momtoboys · 04/06/2022 10:36

You are not wrong at all. No child should be left out by their own family. She is an awful human.

3peassuit · 04/06/2022 10:33

That’s no way to treat family.

SuperSange · 04/06/2022 10:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Folklore9074 · 04/06/2022 10:24

Do you think she realises how mean that is? You know your brother and sister in law but just spell it out when you respond - the 'invite who you want/like rule' only applies to classmates, not family.

I'd get in touch with your brother rather than SIL. Yes, he might just back her thoughtlessly but he's the one your closest to (I'd have thoughts) and he might hav a lightbulb moment if its laid out dispassionately to him.

Honestly though, it speaks very poorly of them that you need to spell this out in the first place. I'd keep it civil but distance yourself and your boys massively.

DFOD · 04/06/2022 10:23

LaBellina · 04/06/2022 10:14

Please don’t go - you’ll set a precedent for the future if you give in to this hideous and cruel behavior. Just a thought @lollipoplips, you mention your DM has a strained relationship with your SIL.
Could this be a deliberate attempt by your SIL to stir up shit between your brother and you and the rest of your family? You mention he always has her back to so possibly she’s counting on this to turn into a lot of drama which will involve him, you and your parents and will possibly cause a falling out. Whatever you do, don’t get too emotional in your response to her, keep it very clear but very polite because this could be some kind of nasty trap.

I agree with this. This is not about your DS or even her DS - your SIL sounds divisive and might be looking to cause a rift to isolate your DB. So just calmly withdraw from their lives / be “busy” etc don’t get drawn in to give her the agitation / rift she might be seeking.

I am sorry that such a character has joined your family. New set of management skills needed from now on in.

Swipe left for the next trending thread