Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL - nephews birthday party

256 replies

lollipoplips · 03/06/2022 21:42

I don't know if I'm being overly sensitive or if this is a really shitty thing to do so interested to hear what people think.

I have 2 sons 18m and 3.
SIL has 2 sons 3 and 5.

It's my nephews 4th birthday next week and my mum gave me an invitation today for his party with just my youngest name on. I assumed it was a mistake and text SIL saying invite only says DS2 is that a mistake. She replied and said no, her son chose who he wanted to attend and he only said DS2, I replied and said I felt that was unfair to exclude 1 nephew from the party and she said she didn't think it would matter as he's never interested in playing with them.

For background my DS1 is suspected Autistic, he struggles socially and doesn't often interact with kids his age, but he loves going to see his cousins, he likes watching them play even if he doesn't get involved. There's no issues between them, no fighting/arguing he just keeps his distance, doing his own thing or watches everyone else. He's a happy boy, rarely has tantrums or meltdowns in public.

The party is at their house, in the garden, they have lots of space so numbers isn't an issue.

I don't know if it's just me being overly sensitive and heartbroken for my beautiful boy as I feel this is the start of how he will be treated growing up.

I'm thinking of just not bothering at all.

OP posts:
ChocolateHippo · 04/06/2022 17:18

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 04/06/2022 17:09

I must come from a totally different type of family based on some of these comments. I don't have the best relationship with my in-laws but even so we wouldn't dream of not inviting every cousin to a party, especially for this age. And I wouldn't rely heavily on a 4YO to give me a guestlist. I can't even rely on my 4YO to tell me what she wants for breakfast 🤣

For my DC's last party, he said he wanted a bouncy castle and then named one - one - child he wanted to invite. To avoid hiring said castle and a hall for two children only, I invited friends and family and asked the nursery staff who he played with at nursery. There turned out to be a group of 8 or 9 of them who played together frequently 😁! So ime definitely you can't trust a 4 year old.

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 04/06/2022 17:09

I must come from a totally different type of family based on some of these comments. I don't have the best relationship with my in-laws but even so we wouldn't dream of not inviting every cousin to a party, especially for this age. And I wouldn't rely heavily on a 4YO to give me a guestlist. I can't even rely on my 4YO to tell me what she wants for breakfast 🤣

Morph22010 · 04/06/2022 17:06

FateHasRedesignedMost · 04/06/2022 16:55

If it’s more for friends and not a family gathering why invite just the younger sibIing and exclude the autistic one of same age if the birthday child

Who knows, maybe the birthday child adores his baby cousin and especially asked for him to be on the guest list? 4 year olds often enjoy playing with babies and toddlers.

It seems odd to assume the SIL is cruel and spiteful rather than thoughtless.

Does she even realise her nephew is being investigated for autism or does she just think he doesn’t like parties/games/playing with her children? Without a diagnosis it can be difficult to explain behaviour; not everyone tells relatives they suspect their child has autism or autistic traits. If he had a formal diagnosis and SIL was aware she might be more sensitive?

Tbh even if the child wasn’t autistic I still thing it’s out of order to invite the baby and not the one the same age as the birthday child where they are both cousins. She may well just be thoughtless but then when the op asked you would have thought she would have realised at that point. When my child was 3 if I asked him who he wanted to invite he’d name a few names, if I’d asked him another day he’d have named different names, thats why they need guidance at that age.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 04/06/2022 16:55

If it’s more for friends and not a family gathering why invite just the younger sibIing and exclude the autistic one of same age if the birthday child

Who knows, maybe the birthday child adores his baby cousin and especially asked for him to be on the guest list? 4 year olds often enjoy playing with babies and toddlers.

It seems odd to assume the SIL is cruel and spiteful rather than thoughtless.

Does she even realise her nephew is being investigated for autism or does she just think he doesn’t like parties/games/playing with her children? Without a diagnosis it can be difficult to explain behaviour; not everyone tells relatives they suspect their child has autism or autistic traits. If he had a formal diagnosis and SIL was aware she might be more sensitive?

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 04/06/2022 16:18

Tbh as well OP I can guarantee that this decision DIDN'T actually come from the birthday boy. They don't have the malice to exclude like this. It almosr certainly came from his parent(s) I'm sorry to say

ChocolateHippo · 04/06/2022 15:21

This is awful. SIL is out of order.

I'd be tempted to message back, "Thank you, but we'll have to decline. We'd prefer to spend the weekend doing a family activity with both our beautiful DSs, rather than attending a "family" party to which only one is invited".

SmartCarDriver · 04/06/2022 14:07

FateHasRedesignedMost · 04/06/2022 13:10

Unkind because you’re family, but maybe it’s more of a party for friends than a family gathering?

If your child doesn’t join in with games and playing and just watches, perhaps it makes other children feel uncomfortable and scrutinised?

or SIL thought he wouldn’t enjoy the party? Or the birthday child feels disliked by your son (or dislikes him) if he won’t engage with anyone?

It’s unwise to ask such a young child to choose who to invite, but at the same time a bit unreasonable to insist on inviting someone ‘because they’re a cousin’ if the birthday child dislikes them, is uncomfortable around them or they make the party awkward by not joining in at all.

Different if all cousins and relatives are invited.

I’d work on social skills like joining in party games even if he just joins in one or two, greeting people politely, saying thank you, engaging a little bit if he can. Otherwise I think parties will be an issue at school; if he just watches and declines to take part or play, people will assume he doesn’t want to be there?

It may be a big garden but I’m guessing SIL capped numbers so it doesn’t get hard to manage, expensive to feed everyone etc. Maybe she told her son to choose 10 friends and your youngest was one of those regardless of being related?

What an awful post! Have you read the OP? The 18th month old DS2, is invited? So I presume they're more "liked" by a four year old?

I'm glad that you and the SIL are well in the minority!

Morph22010 · 04/06/2022 13:54

FateHasRedesignedMost · 04/06/2022 13:10

Unkind because you’re family, but maybe it’s more of a party for friends than a family gathering?

If your child doesn’t join in with games and playing and just watches, perhaps it makes other children feel uncomfortable and scrutinised?

or SIL thought he wouldn’t enjoy the party? Or the birthday child feels disliked by your son (or dislikes him) if he won’t engage with anyone?

It’s unwise to ask such a young child to choose who to invite, but at the same time a bit unreasonable to insist on inviting someone ‘because they’re a cousin’ if the birthday child dislikes them, is uncomfortable around them or they make the party awkward by not joining in at all.

Different if all cousins and relatives are invited.

I’d work on social skills like joining in party games even if he just joins in one or two, greeting people politely, saying thank you, engaging a little bit if he can. Otherwise I think parties will be an issue at school; if he just watches and declines to take part or play, people will assume he doesn’t want to be there?

It may be a big garden but I’m guessing SIL capped numbers so it doesn’t get hard to manage, expensive to feed everyone etc. Maybe she told her son to choose 10 friends and your youngest was one of those regardless of being related?

Why invite the baby then? If it’s more for friends and not a family gathering why invite just the younger sibIing and exclude the autistic one of same age if the birthday child. Ican’t see the baby being able to join in properly with the games either

FlissyPaps · 04/06/2022 13:23

If your child doesn’t join in with games and playing and just watches, perhaps it makes other children feel uncomfortable and scrutinised?

This is the most bullshit thing I’ve read on this thread.

I’d work on social skills like joining in party games even if he just joins in one or two, greeting people politely, saying thank you, engaging a little bit if he can.

Did you even read OP’s first post?

FateHasRedesignedMost · 04/06/2022 13:10

Unkind because you’re family, but maybe it’s more of a party for friends than a family gathering?

If your child doesn’t join in with games and playing and just watches, perhaps it makes other children feel uncomfortable and scrutinised?

or SIL thought he wouldn’t enjoy the party? Or the birthday child feels disliked by your son (or dislikes him) if he won’t engage with anyone?

It’s unwise to ask such a young child to choose who to invite, but at the same time a bit unreasonable to insist on inviting someone ‘because they’re a cousin’ if the birthday child dislikes them, is uncomfortable around them or they make the party awkward by not joining in at all.

Different if all cousins and relatives are invited.

I’d work on social skills like joining in party games even if he just joins in one or two, greeting people politely, saying thank you, engaging a little bit if he can. Otherwise I think parties will be an issue at school; if he just watches and declines to take part or play, people will assume he doesn’t want to be there?

It may be a big garden but I’m guessing SIL capped numbers so it doesn’t get hard to manage, expensive to feed everyone etc. Maybe she told her son to choose 10 friends and your youngest was one of those regardless of being related?

mam0918 · 04/06/2022 13:08

Alb0 · 04/06/2022 09:30

I'm autistic. I have a 45 year life experience of not being included in things.

Yet I still say it is unfair to force yourself on others, and to force children to spend time with people they don't want to. I think it takes away children's free will, their agency. It's deeply unfair to not give children a choice, or to totally disregard their wishes. You won't earn children's respect by being a dictator and breaking their sense of agency and choice. Besides, if your DS1 is anything like I was growing up, he'd find going their awkward and would prefer to be at home doing his own thing anyway, so why force it on both children? Let children make their own choices and find their own way. And don't cut off your nose to spite your face with SIL. Choose your battles, the wishes of the birthday child is not one of them.

Your likes and wants are not everyone elses - you dont like parties but you are not OPs DS and cannot speak on his behalf.

Many people DO feel upset at being excluded, and teaching a child its ok to exclude people just because they are different is abhorant especially in a situation of excluding 1 family member from and event all the other family members are attending.

Its abhorant for mannerless and cruel adults to do it too and would be bad parenting to allow your child to be excluded in social situations where the are blatently being discriminated against.

Its not just something children are 'forced' into it something all decent people learn about society.

pictish · 04/06/2022 12:03

saraclara · 04/06/2022 12:01

Everyone is talking about SIL. But she's not the only parent. If anything it's OP's blood relative who is more in the wrong for letting this happen. And not talking to him 'because he'll just back her up' is defeatist and not holding him to account.

Agree. This is why I advised telling the brother to fuck off.

saraclara · 04/06/2022 12:01

Everyone is talking about SIL. But she's not the only parent. If anything it's OP's blood relative who is more in the wrong for letting this happen. And not talking to him 'because he'll just back her up' is defeatist and not holding him to account.

jackstini · 04/06/2022 12:01

lollipoplips · 03/06/2022 22:34

My mum wasn't happy but their relationship is strained anyway due to SILs behaviour so I wouldn't want her to get involved in it.

We aren't going, and I'll text tomorrow and tell her exactly why.

Good for you. Let us know how it goes

Schoolchoicesucks · 04/06/2022 11:57

Timeline's response is good. Send a card and gift and that response. Take your DC out for a fun treat.

Sadly, your eldest may find himself excluded from more things than if he were NT. Family parties are the one place you would expect him not to be.

Your SIL is bad mannered and inconsiderate. Allowing a 4 year old to choose which friends from school to invite is fine - but the parents should be managing it, ensuring they are not excluding one kid from a friendship group, or inviting the whole class bar one or two. If they don't want your older child at that party, they have 2 parties - one for school friends and one for family.

ivykaty44 · 04/06/2022 11:53

this is such a sad way for your SIL to behave

Can you explain to her that although it doesn't appear that your ds wants to play he loves attending his cousins house and it would be great if all the family i.e. both boys were to attend as leaving one person out is hurting you. Say have a think about it and let me know

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 04/06/2022 11:41

Out of order. It's a bloody garden party as well so nothing your DS can't duck out of if needed. This sounds like sheer spitefulness and I wouldn't indulge in it. Don't cause drama. Just as pp have said explain that you can't allow one of your similar aged cousins to come and not the other. You encourage inclusivity and not discrimination in this household. You are happy to engage in playdates which include both children but cannot allow your DS to be excluded. The end

Anotherdayanotherdisappointment · 04/06/2022 11:38

lollipoplips · 03/06/2022 22:34

My mum wasn't happy but their relationship is strained anyway due to SILs behaviour so I wouldn't want her to get involved in it.

We aren't going, and I'll text tomorrow and tell her exactly why.

I'd announce why publicly on social media or at least a family group chat.

She sounds like the type that would make you out to be the bad guy for not going.

catandcoffee · 04/06/2022 11:38

If ,as you say your son causes no issues, then your sil and brother are a nasty vindictive pair.

MrsRinaDecker · 04/06/2022 11:37

If she had invited the older dc who is a similar age to her dc, and not the 18m old, then that would be sort of understandable (toddlers can be tricky! And the activity might not have been suitable for the wee one) but this just seems mean. I just wouldn’t go.

Rinatinabina · 04/06/2022 11:34

sorry just read the rest, honestly, I’d be more furious at my brother for this. They are awful. Yup don’t bother with them.

Rinatinabina · 04/06/2022 11:32

Sorry is this your brothers wife?

DFOD · 04/06/2022 11:31

WhereYouLeftIt · 04/06/2022 11:24

I wouldn't go either. Fuck SIL and fuck your brother.

Interesting that she (they?) already have your DM adapting and tap dancing to their tune not wanting to rock the boat. This is very controlling. They are dysfunctional. Get off their boat!

Morph22010 · 04/06/2022 11:30

Alb0 · 04/06/2022 09:30

I'm autistic. I have a 45 year life experience of not being included in things.

Yet I still say it is unfair to force yourself on others, and to force children to spend time with people they don't want to. I think it takes away children's free will, their agency. It's deeply unfair to not give children a choice, or to totally disregard their wishes. You won't earn children's respect by being a dictator and breaking their sense of agency and choice. Besides, if your DS1 is anything like I was growing up, he'd find going their awkward and would prefer to be at home doing his own thing anyway, so why force it on both children? Let children make their own choices and find their own way. And don't cut off your nose to spite your face with SIL. Choose your battles, the wishes of the birthday child is not one of them.

The older school hasn’t got a choice or free will though he’s not invited so if he wants to go and that would be his choice he still can’t go. Not all autistic kids want to stay at home all the time

Figgygal · 04/06/2022 11:29

Totally shit behaviour from her
What a way to treat family

Swipe left for the next trending thread