Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think it's cruel to force a toddler to sit on the loo

167 replies

Sheesh89 · 03/06/2022 21:36

I have posted before about my DS1 possibly having ASD and the difficulty I have with my DH not engaging/being difficult/awful.

My DS is 3 (only just) he going to pre school in Sep and its expected before he starts that he's toilet trained. We started yesterday, bye to the nappies, hello cool duggee pants.

He absolutely hates it. Literally hitting us every time we take him to the loo when he starts weeing. He has done it a few times in the loo but while sobbing. DH is sitting on the floor of the loo refusing to let DS off until he wees. So he is complying but it's so bloody traumatising.

Anyway I've said we are going too hard-core and it's awful. DH is now refusing to engage and saying "you bloody do it then" and basically saying I'm too soft and he won't be able to go to pre school because we are bringing up some "backwards, spoilt, kid"

I get that if we don't push DS he won't do anything ever. He refuses to do so much tidy toys, pick up clothes but also he was sobbing and totally out of control. Begging for his nappies. I think having the toilet brush thrown at me was a particular low point

Am I being soft? Does it need to be this drastic? Or is DH being awful? I feel so bloody confused. I just want to do the right thing by my DS but I feel like I'm not protecting him but then if neither of pushed DS he would just eat crisps and live in nappies until he was 8

I feel absolutely done in.

OP posts:
Sheesh89 · 03/06/2022 23:18

@flurryofcurry this is so so helpful. Thank you. I will put Iggle Piggle on the loo tomorrow and I've the idea of throwing water down there too. Thank you

OP posts:
Ownedbymycats · 03/06/2022 23:16

Enforced sits on the toilet are never going to work Get a potty, let him pee in his pants a few time. You both just need to relax and realise it's a gradual process.
It's really only one of many parenting hurdles and you've obviously managed to come through quite a few of them already so you will get there.

Helenknowsbest · 03/06/2022 23:15

I think you've come for advice and clearly very drained after today.

I would take a week and introduce a potty instead of a toilet. Kids thrive off praise and positivity and I think its best for you all to leave it a week. Also please don't pressure yourself to have him potty trained by September, just use the summer to increase his awareness. Let him see you go to the toilet and let him flush. You can say 'bye bye wee wee' my toddler loved doing that, he then just wanted to do it himself. Tell him you've bought him some big boy pants 'like daddys'.

Hope this helps

flurryofcurry · 03/06/2022 23:14

*crisps

flurryofcurry · 03/06/2022 23:12

I teach in a preschool for kids with ASD and we potty train when we feel the child is ready. That could be just gone 3 or just gone 4. I know your child doesn't have a diagnosis yet but i can give you the strategies we use.

A few weeks before we start potty training we talk almost incessantly about the toilet and what happens in there. We read books about it and sing songs. We have a little toy toilet and we sit dolls and teddies on it and praise the them (the toys) for using the loo.

Next we make the bathroom a super fun place to be. Books, songs, stickers. Anything that's high value to your child - put it in the bathroom.

We use cups to pour water down there to see what happens. We put tissue down and flush. The toilet can be really scary.

And finally we reward MASSIVELY for a wee in the loo. Jellies, crisis', iPad... whatever is the most reinforcing item. It can be anything.

However... there are always tears, and tantrums and hitting and throwing. It's easier for us because they're not our children but we persevere.

Sorry for the essay. Ultimately- is your child ready and can you persevere once you've started.

Best of luck

Onwards22 · 03/06/2022 23:10

Using the toilet shouldn’t be traumatising!

And it’s hard to go for a wee if you don’t need to go or you’re being forced to.

I would get him excited about his new big boy pants and then let him choose whether to use a potty or toilet each time.
He will feel grown up making those choices and you’ll be toilet training him at the same time.

Praise him for sitting on the toilet for 30 seconds - even if he doesn’t go.
If he can’t manage 30 seconds start shorter and then increase the time.

When he’s comfortable sitting on it then you can start asking him does he feel like he could do a wee - if not that’s ok, don’t push it just try next time.

Slow and steady wins the race.

confusedlots · 03/06/2022 23:10

With DD, I started to try potty training a couple of months before she turned 3. I definitely persisted too long with the first attempt because I thought persistence was key. Eventually gave up, 2 more attempts over the next 6 months and then eventually she just took to it very quickly.

Couldn't face the trauma again when it came to DS so didn't bother trying so early. He showed a few signs of readiness a few weeks after he turned 3, I gave it a go and he potty trained like a breeze on the first attempt.

I have a friend who used to tell me quite regularly how her child was potty trained, both day and night, when she was 2. She's now 5 and having major toileting and soiling issues in school.

They're all so different that's is so difficult to give any advice to help your own situation, but I would say that if it's not working, give it a break for a month and try again.

ChocolateHippo · 03/06/2022 23:09

Your DH risks giving your DS negative and stressful associations with using the toilet. Your DS should not be 'punished' or shouted at for not getting this or finding it upsetting.

This may not be the right approach for your DS and other approaches have already been suggested, but what we did with our DC (admittedly NT) was take a very relaxed approach. 2 potties downstairs, toilet with seat and steps upstairs. He could choose every morning if he wanted pants (with his favourite character on them) or a pull-up. At first, DC only had pants in the house and a pull-up for nursery/trips out. And there were lots of accidents until he got used to the feeling of needing to go, but we never commented, just changed him into dry/clean clothes and told him he was a good boy for coming and telling us. And slowly he learnt about his body's signals and gained confidence, and then it was no more pull-ups at nursery and finally no more pull-ups on trips out either. And we've had very few accidents since, but when there has been one, we've tried to deal with it without comment or frustration (and with a quick hug when it's sorted) as this is not something we ever wanted DC to feel shame or stress around.

DontPickTheFlowers · 03/06/2022 23:08

I think your DH is in danger of making this into even more of an issue than it is.

Potty training doesn’t happen over night and requires a lot of patience. Accidents are normal. Your DS shouldn’t be forced to do anything but rewarded when he eventually does the right thing - and he will!

danni0509 · 03/06/2022 23:08

@Sheesh89

This is particularly for children with additional needs. www.eric.org.uk/Handlers/Download.ashx?IDMF=68390a94-b585-414d-bab6-abe0558f8669

The whole website is useful actually.

Hugasauras · 03/06/2022 23:03

It sounds like you have diametrically opposed parenting styles and that's probably making your son even more confused and unsettled too.

danni0509 · 03/06/2022 23:01

I have an asd child, persistence is key to achieving anything, but not to the point of traumatising him, leave it for now and try again at a later date. Or persist for a bit longer this time around but not to the point he’s in tears being made to have a wee before he’s allowed off. I understand to a degree what your husband is doing, hoping to push through and get it done and dusted, another thing ticked off the list so to speak, but it could have a negative effect and work against you and then he won’t want to wee at all. So don’t force it but keep at it.

Mine was 5yrs 3 months when we took nappies in the day away for the last time, after several false starts from age 4. He’s almost reliably dry now at 8.5 years, so took 3 years a while to get to this point. He still wears them for bed.

Nursery cannot insist on a toilet trained child with suspected additional needs either. So don’t worry regarding that.

For the tidying toys away, and general getting your ds to do things he doesn’t want to do, you can buy now and next type boards to help with this. ‘First tidy toys, then x’. Etc.

I buy mine off eBay. / Amazon. I like these ones. I’ll add pic.

AIBU to think it's cruel to force a toddler to sit on the loo
Womencanlift · 03/06/2022 23:01

Sheesh89 · 03/06/2022 22:47

Started yesterday in the sense that we started using pants yesterday morning but been prepping for it e.g. Reading him books. DH got angry because DS hit him so hard and threw the loo steps at him. DH is apologising for getting angry this evening but still seems to think we need to force him somewhat.

I get told how soft I am the whole time by my family...cuddling DS to comfort him after he's thrown his dinner at the wall, remaining calm when DS kicks me...and now I feel like I'm a dragon reading thus thread. I have clearly underestimated how scary this would be for DS though. Expected lots of accidents but not flat out refusal.

You sound far too soft and your DH far too harsh so the answer is somewhere in the middle

Why are you comforting him when he has misbehaved? I appreciate there may be some ASD but he has to learn there are consequences to bad behaviour and you are giving mixed messages

This and then your DH OTT reactions - poor child probably doesn’t know what to do

Sheesh89 · 03/06/2022 22:58

I didn't expect success this early. I just didn't expect such a violent, extreme reaction. I should have done because he has v extreme reactions and often hits me. I feel like a dick.

He did actually wee on the loo a few times so he can do it. He always poos in the same spot in the house and insists we all go away. He hates his nappies and was so eager to wear pants. It had all seemed positive and then bam...slap round the face. I should have stopped then and I let my Dh push it and I feel so awful for that

OP posts:
Minniem2020 · 03/06/2022 22:57

It doesn't sound as if he's ready op. We tried DS around 3 and he just wouldn't even contemplate going near the toilet. We then tried again in February half term so that we could spend the week pretty much at home with no nappy on and he got there, this was a week before his 4th birthday. He still has the odd accident and we haven't got it cracked through the night yet.
We suspect DS is autistic but are still waiting for his assessment at the end of the month.
They're all different and he will do it when he's ready.
Your husband sounds like a nasty,horrible bully and all he will do is make your DS associate going to the toilet with those feelings of being upset and traumatised.

Kanaloa · 03/06/2022 22:55

Why are you cuddling him after he throws his dinner though? I mean he’s three, not a baby. It sounds like your husband is overly aggressive and negative and you’re too permissive. Do you think you have an appropriate balance?

Theyellowflamingo · 03/06/2022 22:51

I missed you started this just yesterday. Bloody hell. My enthusiastic, on board, neurotypical and absolutely ready other child took at least a week before they “got it”. The first 48h every single time they went on the floor after getting on and off the loo half a dozen times, they literally didn’t know how to let go into a toilet. Your expectations and those of your husband are way way off.

MyCatIsInCharge · 03/06/2022 22:49

I’ve just written a really long post and and it vanished but short version - my DC1 was hugely resistant to toilet training despite showing signs of readiness from 2.5. We had to toilet train him around 3 yrs 3 months as he was withholding bowel movements and we needed to eliminate a physical cause for this (the issue in question vanished as soon as he was trained). It goes against my instincts to be child-led, but DC1 is the kind of child who is reluctant to move to the next stage and generally needs a gentle push. Toilet training was no exception!

He consistently refused a potty and we had no downstairs loo. So I bought a mini toilet, with a removable lidded basin type thing, and that worked really well - I think it was comfier for him and also easier to carry upstairs for disposal of contents.

I don’t remember exactly how we went about it but chocolate buttons may have been involved - reward charts never really worked with DC1- and he was day dry within a week or two, and naturally night dry without any intervention shortly after he was four.

What I would say is, do not let this become a Thing or it may become quite entrenched. And if he has ASD, he may be slower to get the hang of it - DC1 still has some toileting issues at six. Your DH needs to calm down and get with the programme so you’re both on the same page. You could do worse than drop it if it’s not going well after a week, and revisit later in the summer. Is he showing signs of readiness?

Teacupsandtoast · 03/06/2022 22:48

Your 'DH' sounds like a nasty bully.

My NT, incredibly bright and articulate flat out refused to potty train till she was nearly 3.5. Training was done and dusted in 3 days. When they are ready it should be straightforward

PinkSyCo · 03/06/2022 22:47

Your husband is an insensitive bully. I would not be sending a child of mine to a pre school that he worked in.

Sheesh89 · 03/06/2022 22:47

Started yesterday in the sense that we started using pants yesterday morning but been prepping for it e.g. Reading him books. DH got angry because DS hit him so hard and threw the loo steps at him. DH is apologising for getting angry this evening but still seems to think we need to force him somewhat.

I get told how soft I am the whole time by my family...cuddling DS to comfort him after he's thrown his dinner at the wall, remaining calm when DS kicks me...and now I feel like I'm a dragon reading thus thread. I have clearly underestimated how scary this would be for DS though. Expected lots of accidents but not flat out refusal.

OP posts:
SleepingFrog · 03/06/2022 22:46

Personally I'd persist with it but in a nicer approach. Go shopping with DC to:

  • Select their own potty (or get stickers to decorate an existing potty)
  • Select their own rewards, e.g sweets/stickers
  • Select the hand soap or wipes

Take all bottoms off your DS and initiate lots of garden play (to save your carpets!). Put teddies/toys on the potty and make it a part of the play games. Start small-scale e.g. big rewards for just sitting on potty, progress up to sitting on potty for 30 seconds, progress up to trying to do a wee (extra rewards if any comes out) and continue this approach until the potty becomes a positive thing and the rewards are given for the actual potty use. If they have an accident, sit them on the potty and give a small reward to remind them it's ok to use the potty but ensure they know the big rewards come from using it for the wee or poo.

Our DS knew potty meant sweets so within days he wanted to sit on it for a sweet. Prior to this he didn't like it and was scared of it. It's a big transition for any child let alone one with potential ASD.

All I'd say in relation to the ASD is take it slowly and give a lot of prewarning, e.g. "tomorrow DS we are going to get a sticker if we sit on the potty for 30 seconds. We will be trying that tomorrow. Can you repeat to me how we get the reward tomorrow?" Don't try to rush each stage if one is going well as ASD children typically thrive from routine and need warning about changes ahead of time. Your DS might like to have a regular potty time each day so setting alarms could be another method to support with the transition.

Fingers crossed for you. It's the best thing once you've cracked it and no more nappies!

LifeIsBusy · 03/06/2022 22:44

Maybe take a totally different approach. You mention a potential ASD element and as far as I can tell reward charts aren't actually that helpful with the ND.

We broke it down gently for our DS. He followed us to the loo and I commented on the fact I was weeing. Then when he was in the bath he'd always pee so I talked about it then and built.it up from there. We never asked him all the time if he needed the loo, and followed his lead.

Have you tried picture charts for routines? First one brush teeth, second toilet ect... It can take some of the pressure off the transitions.

Lastly when I used to sit him on the loo we would count 1, 2 3 pee over and over and tried to get him to focus on that rather than expecting him to wee. Seemed to keep his mind off the scary.

Theyellowflamingo · 03/06/2022 22:44

Have you thought how easy you’d find it to do a wee on command while sobbing, angry, scared, struggling to communicate, trying to balance on a narrow ledge above a noisy whirlpool while being watched by an unkind adult? Not to mention that he’s only learning bladder control and probably has all sorts of sensory stuff going on.

Honestly, back off. I toilet trained my child with ASD who at one point I was convinced would go to school in nappies - force or upset would have made it worse. You just cannot make them use the toilet, you have to figure out how to get them on board or just leave it for now. We rewarded every tiny step - use the nappy in the bathroom? Get a reward. Use the nappy sitting on a potty? Reward. Sit on the toilet fully clothed? Reward. Tell me you need the toilet even if you don’t do anything? Reward. Wee in the potty/toilet? Huge reward. He chose potties, seats, steps, pants, books, he picked the day we started - he needed to be in control and go at his pace. We blew bubbles, took toys, read endless books, played games… he needed to be relaxed. Getting off the toilet and immediately going on the floor is par for the course, even my typical child did that a few times. Set backs are normal, it’s not necessarily a linear process.

It took a year before he was completely out of nappies during the day, he didn’t even start until past 3 and yes it was frustrating and demoralising but he was a tiny and scared child. You can’t force it, you just can’t. Your DH sounds very unpleasant and unkind.

And if preschool can’t handle the thought of a 3 year old in nappies they are the wrong setting for a child with suspected autism.

Bitwornout · 03/06/2022 22:41

You say you "started yesterday" and already expect him to use the toilet? That's crazy. Also you are sending DS to private kindrgarten because your DP works there. Is your DP a teacher and is this a school rather than a preschool where you can pick and choose hours? Is that why he's expected to be toilet trained? Alarming that DP is getting angry 24hrs after starting potty training. Get a couple of pottys and take DSs bottoms off and go from there.