Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think it's cruel to force a toddler to sit on the loo

167 replies

Sheesh89 · 03/06/2022 21:36

I have posted before about my DS1 possibly having ASD and the difficulty I have with my DH not engaging/being difficult/awful.

My DS is 3 (only just) he going to pre school in Sep and its expected before he starts that he's toilet trained. We started yesterday, bye to the nappies, hello cool duggee pants.

He absolutely hates it. Literally hitting us every time we take him to the loo when he starts weeing. He has done it a few times in the loo but while sobbing. DH is sitting on the floor of the loo refusing to let DS off until he wees. So he is complying but it's so bloody traumatising.

Anyway I've said we are going too hard-core and it's awful. DH is now refusing to engage and saying "you bloody do it then" and basically saying I'm too soft and he won't be able to go to pre school because we are bringing up some "backwards, spoilt, kid"

I get that if we don't push DS he won't do anything ever. He refuses to do so much tidy toys, pick up clothes but also he was sobbing and totally out of control. Begging for his nappies. I think having the toilet brush thrown at me was a particular low point

Am I being soft? Does it need to be this drastic? Or is DH being awful? I feel so bloody confused. I just want to do the right thing by my DS but I feel like I'm not protecting him but then if neither of pushed DS he would just eat crisps and live in nappies until he was 8

I feel absolutely done in.

OP posts:
Skyeheather · 04/06/2022 08:45

Definitely speak to the key worker, it felt like a highly kept secret that they would take them still in nappies when DS started. It's probably easier for them if as many as possible are trained before they start but it's normal for boys to be harder to train and take longer.

Sheesh89 · 04/06/2022 08:44

@PinkSyCo I was just giving context, honestly I'm really really not trying to justify DH losing his temper. Its unacceptable. I've been reading "there's no such thing as naughty" book about under 5 kids and I really try to parent compassionately. I should have stepped in earlier with DH and DH was making me feel like I was being useless and ridiculous..hence me coming on MN to sense check myself. All I care about is my DC, if DH doesn't get himself in check asap, I will leave him. My loyalty is to my DC.

OP posts:
KitKattaktik · 04/06/2022 08:43

Your poor boy, being forced to sit on the toilet is cruel and is going to increase whatever worries he had about using the toilet in the first place.

You are meant to bring a child up, not break his spirit. I really feel for the little mite.

PinkSyCo · 04/06/2022 08:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Afterfire · 04/06/2022 08:39

I’m going to admit I haven’t read the whole thread properly - Ds aged 9 with severe asd isn’t letting me! - but just to say if your ds has asd then the school needs to make adjustments and you need to apply for an ehcp to get him the support he needs and that may include an intimate care plan to facilitate him wearing nappies for longer. My ds wore nappies until he was 5 and then he just got it and they were off in a week. If you carry on like this you’ll completely traumatise him and probably completely put him off using the toilet altogether.

Independent schools are well known for being absolutely dreadful when it comes to helping children with special needs. Look at other schools.

Sheesh89 · 04/06/2022 08:38

@Skyeheather that's v helpful. It says on the registration form "we expected children to be fully toilet trained. If this is an issue, please speak to your key worker before your start date"
So maybe I just speak to them and say its still a work in progress and if they respond with no empathy or support then it's not the place for us anyway

OP posts:
cansu · 04/06/2022 08:37

I toilet trained my dd who has asd. It was difficult and a bit upsetting. I was glad we did it though. We started a bit later, around 4 years I think. She had a little potty chair. I think the problem in your approach is the insisting he stays there until he wees. We gave my dd loads to drink and encouraged her to sit on the potty very frequently. She did not particularly like it. There were tears and lots of wet pants. I would persevere but in a less stressful way. I also would not be doing it just so he can go to the pre school. It should be something he is readyish for. There may not ever be a perfect time though and it is undoubtedly easier to do before he goes to school. The main reason I say this is that school won't do the training for you even special schools are very unwilling to do it. Why? Because it is time consuming, messy and difficult. Often, kids who are not trained, remain untrained either because their needs are so complex that they cannot do it or because it is too difficult for parents and carers to manage. Children with asd do get aggressive and upset when challenged to do things they find uncomfortable. Sometimes, you do have to decide what is worth this upset and what isn't, both for you and for them.

PinkSyCo · 04/06/2022 08:36

Sheesh89 · 04/06/2022 08:14

How am I villainizing my DS? That's a very hurtful thing to say. I'm not blaming him at all. I'm blaming myself and my DH. Saying he doesn't like pressure is just a statement of fact...so I need to get better at removing pressure in all situations...I get that i need to do better but I won't accept that I'm villainzing him. People have already said I sound too permissive.

You are coming out with statements such as ‘DH got angry because DS hit him so hard and threw the loo steps at him,’ that make me feel that you are justifying your husband’s cruel behaviour. Your DS is a tiny child who is lashing out because he is scared. Your husband is a grown man, who should be able to control his emotions (especially in his line of work and with a potentially autistic child) And seriously, how hard can a just turned 3 year old hit someone anyway?

ZuliKyanLarsFoz · 04/06/2022 08:33

I appreciate you have had a lot of ideas here and I haven't read them all so this may have already been covered but if not, here's mine! I've recently toilet trained my 3yo.

You need to make it fun. We bought him a small toilet potty that went in the bathroom and he sat on it when we did...often fully clothed and in his nappy but just to get him used to it When it was time to take pull ups away, we gave him a funny dance and told him what to say when he needed to go. He found it hilarious and I think it actually found it easy to tell us as it was funny. We would sometimes read a book on the toilet or sit and just chat. We gave lots of praise when he had been. Nobody shouted at him even when he insisted on sitting there for a frustratingly long amount of time!

If I were you, I would actually have a break for a couple of weeks, let him forget about it and introduce it in a calmer way with a potty. We bought a mini portable urinal for being out and about if no toilet around which has been very handy.

Skyeheather · 04/06/2022 08:33

When my son started nursery at age three I was told that he had to be toilet trained. I tried but he just wasn't interested and wasn't trained on nursery start day. I decided to send him in wearing a nappy and hope they wouldn't notice. Turned out there was other kids still in nappies too and it was fine, they just asked that I provide the nappies, bag wipes and nappy bags. When DS was three and a half the nursery suggested toilet training and they were great at getting DS trained at nursery.

I would do some digging around and see if it would be okay to send him in nappies to start with. My DS got interested when he saw the other kids at nursery using the toilet and eventually wanted to join in and have a go himself.

Sheesh89 · 04/06/2022 08:32

@PinkSyCo the suggestion of parenting classes didn't offend me. We all have stuff to learn. I just said it felt a bit rough. But I'll look into it. Thanks.

I'll pass your concerns onto my son. He'll be delighted to know you're thinking of him.

OP posts:
ForestFae · 04/06/2022 08:27

LissyBooks · 04/06/2022 08:25

@Sheesh89 you’re on a hiding to nothing trying to bend the world to your DS rather than the other way around. Let’s say you remove “all pressure” from him, what happens at nursery/school/the park? He will be totally ill-equipped to deal with any situation which doesn’t go his way

Absolutely terrible advice, especially re potty training. We should not be pressuring children. Children who are confident and nurtured do better in difficult situations, not children who’ve been thrown in at the deep end before they’re ready.

LissyBooks · 04/06/2022 08:25

@Sheesh89 you’re on a hiding to nothing trying to bend the world to your DS rather than the other way around. Let’s say you remove “all pressure” from him, what happens at nursery/school/the park? He will be totally ill-equipped to deal with any situation which doesn’t go his way

Sheesh89 · 04/06/2022 08:14

How am I villainizing my DS? That's a very hurtful thing to say. I'm not blaming him at all. I'm blaming myself and my DH. Saying he doesn't like pressure is just a statement of fact...so I need to get better at removing pressure in all situations...I get that i need to do better but I won't accept that I'm villainzing him. People have already said I sound too permissive.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 04/06/2022 08:14

You have time, but it’s good you are starting the process to get him assessed for ASD. I haven’t heard of the NHS not accepting private diagnoses from registered British psychologists.

On the pressure, our DC had similar. It was anything presented to them without a choice they could make to assert some control over the situation. So obviously some things have to happen, but you can still engineer choices in there like brush teeth before or after your bath? Do you want peas or carrots? Do you want Teddy or Bunny for story time and bed? Try and think of ways to present choices to mask the fact that you must go to bed now. Or you must eat your veg.

PinkSyCo · 04/06/2022 08:12

Btw OP, I don’t care if my suggestion that you and your husband attend parenting classes offended you. It’s your child that I’m concerned about, not your feelings.

Boymumsoymum · 04/06/2022 08:09

If the weather is nice can you go in the garden with bottoms off. Most kids love this and it's less stressful for everyone if a bit of wee goes on the lawn, nobody has to worry about carpets or sofas getting soiled etc! Pop the potty out there and if you spot wee coming out get excited and say 'oooh a wee, great, hop on the potty!' with a big smile and if so much as one drop gets in that potty that is a success!

PinkSyCo · 04/06/2022 08:07

I don’t know somethings not sitting right with me here. Maybe I’m reading it wrong, but with each post you seem to be practically villainizing your very young, possibly autistic child a bit more. Why? To excuse your husband’s draconian methods of ‘teaching’. Please stop doing that, and ‘listen’ to your DS. He needs an understanding parent, and one who will stick up for him against bullies.

Boymumsoymum · 04/06/2022 08:06

Sheesh89 · 04/06/2022 07:21

Also just to clarify DS definitely knows when he needs to go as he asks for his nappy so he can go. He doesn't want to go on the floor.

The analogy about it being like asking a grown up to wee standing in the middle of a train station is really helpful to me understanding the stress though. Back to cuddles and pulls ups today and I'll just get the potty back out.

You don't necessarily need to go back to pull ups today OP - that's just giving up, pull-ups are just nappies by another name. Just get the potty out, leave bottoms off and hang out with your son with the potty nearby, ideally in a room with non-carpeted flooring so it's easy to clean up accidents! I really think you need to find a middle ground - it does sound like you don't really impose natural consequences with your son, just send him to timeout, and perhaps your husband feels he has to be more strict to compensate for you being a bit permissive. Even aged 3 I'd expect a child to 'help tidy' with a clear simple instruction such as 'put the cars in the tub' or 'put the blocks in the box'.
But please don't just give up and stick him in pull-ups as that just teaches your son that if he refuses /screams / tantrums he doesn't have to do it anymore. Just scale it back a bit today and go for a slower approach, small potty, rewards, lots of drinks so that he feels the need to go plenty, pop teddy on the potty etc.

Abridget7 · 04/06/2022 08:06

Please buy the 'oh crap' potty training book that others on this thread have recommended You really need a better strategy.
Not only will it give you a method to follow but will also have you think about potty training from your sons perspective. Imagine having only ever known weeing & pooing in a nappy and that is suddenly taken away from you. Potty training is a learned skill that takes a bit of time.
If you continue the way you're going, you are creating a lot of anxiety around using the potty & toilet. It will take longer. Get the book.

Sheesh89 · 04/06/2022 08:03

I should say I don't know if he's ASD. Appointment to see GP this week but may go private but have read the NHS sometimes don't accept private diagnosis?

He just hates pressure. So for example he went to toddler football club every Satueday and loved playing, kicking, running up and down and playing with me but as soon as they asked them to do something more structured he ran into the disabled loo and refused to come out until the end. So we stopped going

Nursery say nothing to worry about. Health visitor who witnessed a meltdown said to see a GP. His meltdowns are extreme. Like he's not there anymore...no distracting him or getting near to him to be honest...had lots of gasps and pointing.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 04/06/2022 07:54

There does appear to be a lot of cuddling. It may be backfiring. Cuddling usually means something is going to be traumatic enough that it requires comforting for it and that can actually add stress to a situation. Sometimes it’s better to be neutral about things. So yes, bring the potty out, but perhaps rethink the cuddles. It should be use mistakes to encourage “too bad, maybe next time” and celebrate the successes. Cuddles shouldn’t be needed when potty training if you are taking a no pressure child led approach as it won’t be traumatic to them.

Like, I agree the time out and cuddling when he’s thrown his dinner at the wall is off. It should be consequences as in help tidy up the mess and no cuddles. Although with my ASD DC, we never forced them to the eat it this or go hungry and would always have to be short order cooks to feed them food they would actually eat. There’s so many sensory issues with an ASD child that their being a “fussy eater” is honestly something they cannot help.

Sheesh89 · 04/06/2022 07:51

We went for steps/toddler seat on the loo as opposed to the potty as he has no interest in the potty and we did persuade him to sit on it once but he looked super uncomfortable. And he actually loves being in the loo with me, flushes the chain, washing his hands so I thought wasn't too scary. Also he hates to poo in front of anyone, shouts "go away" so thought he'd like the privacy. I thought he would be resistant of course but you're right hadn't put in enough thought about how scary the loo must feel. I thought he'd resist change but not that he'd be scared

OP posts:
queenmeadhbh · 04/06/2022 07:46

Hope some of the advice here is helpful OP and good luck. It sounds to me like your expectations are unrealistic - one day of wearing pants and expecting him to confidently or compliantly go on a toilet? NT or ND that is very unlikely.

I havent understood your potty vs toilet strategy - you say you have a potty and in last post say “you’ll just get the potty back out” - why did the potty get put away? Did he go in the potty at all?

I also think that while you favour what you call “compassionate” parenting it feels to me like you’re not actually thinking about or empathising with what it must be like for him - so scary and weird to have to go into a big hole and not straight into a nappy!
Thats not meant to be cruel at all it just really strikes me that you’re doing lots of cuddling without really thinking about why he is upset.

Frankly your husband sounds like a bully and his approach as a teacher - even of older children - is unpleasant.

Goldfishjones · 04/06/2022 07:23

Sorry I meant your DS not DD.