Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think it's cruel to force a toddler to sit on the loo

167 replies

Sheesh89 · 03/06/2022 21:36

I have posted before about my DS1 possibly having ASD and the difficulty I have with my DH not engaging/being difficult/awful.

My DS is 3 (only just) he going to pre school in Sep and its expected before he starts that he's toilet trained. We started yesterday, bye to the nappies, hello cool duggee pants.

He absolutely hates it. Literally hitting us every time we take him to the loo when he starts weeing. He has done it a few times in the loo but while sobbing. DH is sitting on the floor of the loo refusing to let DS off until he wees. So he is complying but it's so bloody traumatising.

Anyway I've said we are going too hard-core and it's awful. DH is now refusing to engage and saying "you bloody do it then" and basically saying I'm too soft and he won't be able to go to pre school because we are bringing up some "backwards, spoilt, kid"

I get that if we don't push DS he won't do anything ever. He refuses to do so much tidy toys, pick up clothes but also he was sobbing and totally out of control. Begging for his nappies. I think having the toilet brush thrown at me was a particular low point

Am I being soft? Does it need to be this drastic? Or is DH being awful? I feel so bloody confused. I just want to do the right thing by my DS but I feel like I'm not protecting him but then if neither of pushed DS he would just eat crisps and live in nappies until he was 8

I feel absolutely done in.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FearlessFreddie · 05/06/2022 19:48

@Sheesh89 In your shoes I would leave it completely for at least a week and try to reset a bit. What worked for us was having a potty in every room and showing DD where it was, then pants off and letting her do what she wanted- we really praised her if she sat on the potty whether or not she did anything. Accidents (lots of those!!) we just cleaned up without a comment. It took a couple of weeks but then she was away. She also didn't respond well to pressure so just letting her do it in her own time was the best approach for us. It helped that it was summer and also we have lino floors- might not be for you if you have carpets/very house proud!! Another idea is you can put a folded out nappy in the potty so DC is weeing into the nappy, if you get me, as a sort of halfway.

I think your bigger problem is your DP. Did you post about him the other day? What you described sounds really distressing and really isn't going to teach your little lad anything. It sounds to me like your instincts are totally right and DP are totally wrong!! It's not possible to learn anything when so upset. I don't know what to suggest because presumably he has his good points but I'd find it very hard to respect a partner who acted like that.

amicissimma · 04/06/2022 11:28

"And I stepped in and told him to give him a break"

So the loo is where mummy and daddy fight in front of DS. Hardly going to be a place he wants to be.

I used re-usables, including pull-ups, for mine when we were potty training. When the child has wee-d they remain wet and go cold encouraging the DC to try to avoid that. Disposables don't seem to feel different wet or dry so hard for the wearer to distinguish.

PomegranateSeed · 04/06/2022 11:09

Here it is

AIBU to think it's cruel to force a toddler to sit on the loo
PomegranateSeed · 04/06/2022 11:08

OP I’m sorry you are having such a hard time. Can I recommend you find other sources of support for looking after a child with Autism. People really dot know what it’s like and whilst they may be well meaning in their advice a lot of it is just ablist and offensive. There are a lot of great FB groups for example. I really like the Autistic Girls Network (although I know you have a boy.

Also, I thought I would post this extract from a book, because many of us will have been in the position of having our parenting criticised.

CanofCant · 04/06/2022 10:28

You mentioned previously that you think your husband is neurodiverse too and that's why he has been resisting having your DC diagnosed and feels he has to just 'fit in' with the world. I think it's important to know that information as it could mean your husband isn't just a bully but is carrying his own unresolved emotional baggage. Or he could be a complete arsehole, I don't know him.

I do agree with pps that you are both parenting to extremes and that you need to find a medium setting. He sees you as too soft and so goes overboard with strictness which in turn makes you (understandably) want to make everything easier for DS and take the path of least resistance which probably frustrates your husband and leaves you both at a stale mate and probably creates a horrible atmosphere at home for you all. I don't think either of you is wrong in your intent and I'm sure your husband loves your son just as much as you (unless there is a big reveal), I think the whole situation has evolved into a mess.

Good luck with today.

PeekAtYou · 04/06/2022 09:21

Ime most children train between2.5 yo and 3.5 yo so there's plenty of kids your son's age who aren't trained yet.

If you're only training because of September nursery then stop.

Having read your replies, my son did the pooing and needing "privacy" thing too. Afterwards, does he ask you to change him? My son doing this made me try potty training.

At first he was bottomless and we went in the garden to save washing and simplifying things. (Remembering to take your trousers and pants down before weeing is an extra step) There were times when he'd end up just watching the wee come out but he worked out quite quickly what to do. I used a potty because they are portable, less high up so feel more stable (toilets where feet dangle aren't going to be pleasant- especially if you're ND)

I know some people have sitting on the potty before bath time as part of their routine regardless of whether or not anything is produced.

Mummyof287 · 04/06/2022 09:19

*don't compare

Mummyof287 · 04/06/2022 09:19

*don't compare

Mummyof287 · 04/06/2022 09:18

Jeez your DH is being a complete arsehole...what a way to talk about his child!

DS is clearly not ready, and if he has ASD maybe he won't be for abit longer than others.Don't compare.

And PLEASE choose another nursery....one that actually has an understanding of child's needs, not a 'they all need to be doing this by this age' sort of approach.If they are being like that now what other unreasonable expectations will they put on the poor little boy once he is there.
You need somewhere that treats children as individuals, and understands additional needs!

Scrap the toilet training for now and the nursery too...your little boy (and you!) need a break x

Mummyof287 · 04/06/2022 09:18

Jeez your DH is being a complete arsehole...what a way to talk about his child!

DS is clearly not ready, and if he has ASD maybe he won't be for abit longer than others.Don't compare.

And PLEASE choose another nursery....one that actually has an understanding of child's needs, not a 'they all need to be doing this by this age' sort of approach.If they are being like that now what other unreasonable expectations will they put on the poor little boy once he is there.
You need somewhere that treats children as individuals, and understands additional needs!

Scrap the toilet training for now and the nursery too...your little boy (and you!) need a break x

BlazingRufus · 04/06/2022 09:18

Just a quick recommendation here for free app 'Poo Goes to Pooland' (download it on your phone). A lady with a strong Scouse accent reads a cheerful story about Poo. Sounds unhinged but it was mentioned on Mumsnet and was invaluable in helping my 3y old son to make sense of toilet training and see it's not scary after all. We had to read it several times of course!

towelsa · 04/06/2022 09:16

I only succeeded on my third attempt to potty train DS2 when he was 3.5. Nursery continued to do his nappies until then with 0 pressure to potty train before. For what it's worth I know several boys for were potty trained past 3 - it's definitely not that uncommon.
It turned out my son is autistic and demand avoidant (which stems from anxiety). Rewards, praise, bribes and threats really don't work for him. Forcing him to do something and trying to 'win' and show him who's boss (which is what your husband is doing) doesn't work and is very traumatic. Once my son decides to do something he usually picks in up quickly. When he was ready for the toilet/potty it all happened v quickly with virtually no accidents and no stress. I only wish I hadn't tried earlier tbh!
I have 3 neurodivergent children and you do need to parent differently and the kinder more sympathetic approach is better. They have enough added stress in their lives without parents adding to it further.
Your husbands response sounds fairly extreme and he sounds triggered- I would suggest he works out what about this upsets him so much and he deals with that rather than take it out on his son. Your instincts sound right you just need to stand up for your son more confidently.

Kanaloa · 04/06/2022 09:14

To be fair I think much of it could be solved with some decent communication. It sounds like the two parents are very at odds over parenting altogether (not just in potty training) with mum cuddling him because he screams and cries after throwing an unwanted dinner and regularly hits her, then dad overreacting in response. I think maybe sitting down and really talking/agreeing on plan going forward could really help. It would also clear any resentment or pressure.

lavenderfine · 04/06/2022 09:12

DS is 3yrs 8m and has been trained for about 2 months. He's still not reliable (we've just moved house and he struggles massively with change), but I only trained him when he was ready, he started going to the toilet like me and his dad and his cousins, thought it was super cool and there was no tantrums and upset involved, if there was I'd have just stopped tbh, it only makes it more of a thing I think. We do also think DS is autistic and he does have a language delay that prevented him from being able to communicate his needs for a long while but he doesn't HAVE to be trained for pre-school, they can't refuse to take him if he's not trained.

PinkSyCo · 04/06/2022 09:11

Sheesh89 · 04/06/2022 08:46

@PinkSyCo Sorry. Just frazzled on 5 hours sleep with 1 year old and 3 year old and a shitty DH and a ton of work to do. Sorry.

It’s ok. I’m sorry too if I come over harsh, but I have an autistic (just turned 2) grandson, and the thought of someone treating him the way your husband did your child makes me feel very sad, and I’m sorry to say but all the cuddles in the world won’t make up for the pressure he is putting on your child at such a very young age. Sad

Timeforsinging81 · 04/06/2022 09:08

Can I recommend Yvonne Newbold approach to dealing with ASD/behaviour difficulties (website and Facebook). I think you'd find it really helpful and a supportive community of parents, many of is have also been accused of being too permissive or soft!

Personally I think you are dealing with things in the right way and perhaps pausing potty training for a few weeks would help both you and your ds. I also had big problems with my husband forcing my 3 yr old to sit on the toilet; the judge at our family court trial agreed that this was abusive, and is partly why we are divorced.

orwellwasright · 04/06/2022 09:08

Find a better preschool. One that actually cares about children not its la-di-da reputation.

Sprogonthetyne · 04/06/2022 09:04

Toilet trainings my child with ASD was nothing like training my NT child. Firstly he just wasn't ready until much older (nearly 4 vs 2.5), and when he did finally train it had to be very much on his terms. It might be worth reading about PDA, it's a type of autism where the person finds the stress of been told to do something (having a demand placed on them) is triggering. DS's profile includes some aspects of this, which came out very strongly during toilet training.

With DS what worked was giving he lots of incentives, choices and logical reasons, then been really hands off. We initially got him on bord by showing him that the nappies in the shop cost the same as a dinosaur magazine he wanted, telling him we only had money for one and letting him choose. Then at home we gave him as many choices as possible (eg. Potty/toilet/tree in the garden (very popular), standing up/sitting, naked/just pants/trousers).

Once we'd agreed what he'd do, we offered a treat when he managed, then left him to it. That was really hard to do, sometimes I would see him dancing or straining and knew there was likely to be an accident, but had to stop myself from saying anything. Like with your DS, trying to take him would result is complete refusal, even it he'd been planning on taking himself before I mentioned it.

Not sure any of that would actually help with you DS, but wanted to make the point that with SEN children, what 'should' work often doesn't, it doesn't mean your doing it wrong, it just means your walking a much harder path.

Herejustforthisone · 04/06/2022 09:04

What do you do when your son frequently hits you?

Also, your husband sounds like a shit teacher.

Threeboysandadog · 04/06/2022 09:02

I don’t think you sound too permissive. I think sometimes, especially when they are the “big brother”, it can be easy to forget that just turned 3 is really very little. He’s already had a lot going on in his three years, lockdown (presumably not the same chances to socialise) and a new baby brother. You are doing the right thing speaking to the GP. How does your dh feel about the possibility of SN’s. I know mine finds it very difficult to accept.

The private nursery may suit him very well but you need to visit it, find out how they feel and what experience they have of children with additional needs. A nursery that refuses to take them until toilet trained wouldn’t be the right one for me. My boys all went to different nurseries as they each had different needs.

My ds1 and ds2 were both toilet trained by two and a half. Ds2 was dry day and night from then. I thought I must be pretty good at it! Then came ds3. Several failed attempts by me, supported by my very experienced childminder, and off he went to nursery in pull-ups. He was almost three and a half before he “got it” and 7 before he was dry at night. He does have ASD but is, academically, very bright. They are all different.

In your shoes, I would back off, go back to pull-ups and try again in 4-6 weeks with a potty or little kiddy toilet. You could try reading stories about potty training with him. We had “I love my potty” but I know there’s a few different ones.

…….And remember, no one knows your son better than you do. He will get there in his own time. I hope you can get your dh on board. Good luck.

Afterfire · 04/06/2022 09:01

I find it shocking he’s got such awful views about children with sen and asd when he’s a secondary school teacher! Wtf!

Mischance · 04/06/2022 09:00

Forcing a toddler to sit on the loo is not just cruel, it is counter-productive and your OH needs to get a grip.

It is annoying when a child does not do what we want, when you know that physically they are able. But your OH needs to understand that it is not as simple as that and, as with many stages in parenting, the only thing to do is to try and look at it from the child's point pf view. From his very first moments of consciousness, he has had a nappy on - it is like an arm or a leg to him - he has never known anything different. Suddenly it is whipped away and a whole new life is forced on him.

First of all, you must stop his toilet training completely right now and leave it for several months. It is now associated in his mind with trauma and he will fight every inch of the way. Continuing with it now will be damaging and unproductive. Your OH needs to know this.

When you decide to reintroduce it, do it in a low-key way. Get out the potty and just leave it around. After a few days, sit a doll/human toy on it and say "Oh look, X is doing a wee!" .... small things like this re-introduce the concept in an unthreatening way. Talk about it - "I need a poo; can you come with me and hand me the toilet paper?" You really are going to have to go softly softly now. It has become a battle and hard work will be needed to dispel that negative aura.

How you get your OH onside with that I do not know and I really feel for you.

Looking at it from the child's point of view again - how would we like to be suddenly forced to clamber onto a vast receptacle that is waist height and sit there waiting to be sucked under by the swirling water which goes who knows where? You need some discussion about how a toilet works; or stick to the potty for now.

I am not helping you one bit with your pre-school dilemma - but you will get nowhere and cause psychological trauma to continue to pursue it now. Stand back, take a pause and start again later. Talk gently about it after a pause, and do not rush in with a total no-pants regime. Find some good books where children are seen sitting on the toilet - read them along with his other books - sow the seeds gently before actually taking any action.

Kanaloa · 04/06/2022 08:58

WiddlinDiddlin · 04/06/2022 04:48

Honestly I sit on my hands almost all the time at these threads but I just can't tonight.

Disclaimer: not a parent. Animal behaviourist.

A 2/3 whatever year old who has only ever toileted in their living memory, against the absorbent fabric of a nappy, is conditioned to toilet in a nappy.

They have not experienced ANYTHING else. In fact sometimes, the feel of that fabric against their bums/bits actually tells them 'it's safe to let go now'.

And then you take that off, sit them on a precarious, too high up seat with a fucking big hole in it into cold cold water that disappears off who only knows where...

Yeah, I'd tense up and not let go too.

Imagine for a second that I ask you to ignore all your conditioning to going on a nice comfy toilet seat in a private little room.

Lets say I've asked you to piss your pants in the middle of the pub, or drop your trousers and do a poo in the middle of Kings Cross station, at rush hour.

Seriously, how many could actually do it and do it quickly, and happily, without a moments anxiety?

I would bet almost none of you. Because you've had decades of conditioning to ONLY toilet in VERY specific contexts.

Just look at the number of threads posted about not being able to pee outdoors, or not being able to do a poo at work or in a public toilet etc etc. That conditioning is SO strong, it's incredible.

Now think again about the small child who is being asked to do something completely new, and absolutely does not have the communication skills to explain the above to you, about why it feels SO wrong, and SO alien and SO scary.

OP - you aren't soft, you are thoughtful and kind. Do not let others bully you into ignoring your instincts.

Break the job down into stages - get a potty, make it familiar and generally nice, if you really need to, start some games of things go in the potty, doesn't at this stage matter what the things are, just the notion that 'something goes in there and then gets tipped out'. Water will do. Water and bits of tissue even?

So now there is no mystery about that - make it fun, make it rewarding and take off the pressure.

Then build the 'sitting on the potty' idea, build it into a game, 'can you stand on this, sit on that, lie down on that, stand on one leg, sit on the floor, sit on the potty, sit on a chair..'

Whilst this is going on, talk to him about the whole going to the toilet thing, about knowing when you need to go, what that feels like, how do you know, etc. Reward him for telling you he is peeing or pooing in his nappy, reward even better if he can tell you BEFORE he has to go (but still don't pressure him to go anywhere else).

I'd also give him some general discussion on where the toilet stuff goes - show him any pipework, tell him (in as simple terms as necessary obviously, he doesn't need a degree in plumbing) where the water from the loo goes, where the water down the sink goes. Make it normal and not scary.

Get him thinking about his body and how that feels - up until now, he has not HAD to be aware of it, it just ... comes out, so thats new.

Then when he is telling you about it, when the potty is familiar, and safe, you can start to offer him the CHOICE... to go on the potty with a bare bum for a bit, or stay in his nappy and sit on it...

Keep going like that, the more you can give him choices (they're not really FREE choice, they're choices between 'this and that' not 'do as you like', its more an illusion of choice!) and stack the odds in favour of him going for option you want, the better.

All this force and shouting and making it a huge deal is just going to build a horribly negative association not just with the toilet, but with his parents teaching him ANYTHING at all. Regardless of whether he has SEN, the force and the aggro will only make matters worse.

Ok, burn me with fire, I'm out.

Burn you with fire? You’ve literally just said the exact same thing everyone else has said. Nobody is saying anything different.

ChocolateHippo · 04/06/2022 08:54

ForestFae · 04/06/2022 08:27

Absolutely terrible advice, especially re potty training. We should not be pressuring children. Children who are confident and nurtured do better in difficult situations, not children who’ve been thrown in at the deep end before they’re ready.

Agree @ForestFae . The children who are comfortable and confident in new situations are those who have been nurtured and supported when little and whose 'safe adults' have been there for them when they're finding everything a bit too much. In the OP's case, her DC may always going to need a little bit of extra support (I've heard people refer to it as 'scaffolding') to cope with situations that other children may not be phased by, but he may absolutely thrive if given the right support early enough. It's not about bending the world to him, but about being realistic about what he can cope with and equipping him with additional tools to help him cope in the world as it is.

Sheesh89 · 04/06/2022 08:46

@PinkSyCo Sorry. Just frazzled on 5 hours sleep with 1 year old and 3 year old and a shitty DH and a ton of work to do. Sorry.

OP posts: