Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Falling out on family holiday

134 replies

Lemonickle · 03/06/2022 20:40

At Easter we went away for a weeks holiday with the grandparents and my brother, his wife and baby. We booked a 4 bedroom lodge to share so plenty of space for each family. Brother constantly complained we where making too much noise waking baby up at night, we basically sat in the lounge whispering but apparently we weren't quiet enough. He puts baby to bed at 7 every night without fail. We are understanding, we have a 7 year old but we even got told off for going out into the garden while baby was napping during the day. Since we have been home there's been an atmosphere and no one has been as friendly as usual.

We are supposed to be going away together again in the summer holidays for a week. It's expensive, costing us over £4000 which we and the grandparents agreed to go halves on (£2000 each) as brother claimed they can't afford to pay towards so we invited them and said it's ok we won't ask for a contribution so brother gets a free holiday. So Easter lodge holiday we cooked our own meals in the lodge as we couldn't afford to order out. Brother ordered takeout every night and went shopping and came back with designer clothes (but can't afford to contribute towards the summer holiday)

AIBU to think I'm being treated like a mug or am I as my dad's says that I am being oversensitive?

My mum made a couple of mean comments about my son, saying he's hard work and doesn't communicate well. She never speaks to him. As we had looked after my brothers son so they could go out for a meal, I mentioned to my mum that we would sneak out for a few hours one evening without our son and she refused to let us go, even though they where all in the lodge all evening and he is 7.

I mentioned to my dad that maybe we should cancel going away in summer if the situation isn't working for us. It's costing us a big chunk of our money and we are struggling to get it together. We don't want another week of being told off. My parents got in a bad mood with me and are now being difficult about picking up my son from school. My hours at work change soon and occasionally they where needed to walk around to the after school club at 6pm to collect my son as I don't get home till 6:15. This isn't even a regular arrangement maybe 3 or 4 times a month at the most. They are both retired and have said they will if I pay them £10 a time.

Part of me thinks I'm in the wrong. They don't have to babysit if they don't want to. But without those 15 minutes help every now and again I won't be able to do my job. I can't do anything about my hours, it's a rubbish job but it pays the bills.

OP posts:
SettingsO · 04/06/2022 00:16

Oh good god, you should absolutely cancel the holiday!

Caveydavey · 04/06/2022 00:10

Sod the holiday. Have a lovely time with your boy instead. Why would you pay for your rude brother? Let them all go and piss each other off. Save the cash and you have a child care fund. Find a local teen - way easier. They will be fun and grateful and entitled to pay. I would look at my mother very differently if she demanded - while being able to afford two grand holidays - payment for a few picks ups of my child.
invest in your son and your friends - build your own happy

SRS29 · 04/06/2022 00:03

OP just uncomplicate your life..... my daughters were under school age then school age and I worked full time my husband worked away all week....do not rely on anyone EVER and plan ahead......have the occasional back up if necessary....in this it was my mum who is a fabulous Grandma but not a 'nanny' and they have the most wonderful relationship

Bellyups · 04/06/2022 00:00

Cancel the holiday. Why on earth should you absorb half the costs so your brother can have a holiday???? Your parents can pay for golden boy and his family. CF’s!!!

ignore the posters saying you’re hard work. They obviously only read your last paragraph.

tkwal · 03/06/2022 23:44

Cancel that holiday, book another one and tell your brother you're not going because
A. You want to be able to relax with your child and
B. You aren't prepared to subsidise his takeaway meals and designer clothes or his holidays any more

Your parents are trickier. Is there really no one else who could collect your son from school ? I would try to rely on them as little as possible but I know that can be difficult. They would probably deny favouring your brother if you mention it to them . Maybe going on holiday with him without you there as a buffer might help open their eyes to him

Dinosaur975326788900864322456778899900754543 · 03/06/2022 23:38

cancel the holiday, say you can’t afford it and didn’t enjoy the last one

find alternative childcare but in the meantime pay the £10 for 5 minutes.

MushyPeasPrincess · 03/06/2022 23:34

RandomMess · 03/06/2022 21:11

Sounds like he's the golden child and your the family scapegoat.

Totally!

Have you done any reading around dysfunctional family dynamics OP? I reckon it could be very enlightening for you.

Step away from them. You're not oversensiitve. You're being treated badly. And your brother is taking the absolute piss not paying his share.

NumberTheory · 03/06/2022 23:31

I agree with trying to find a teenager or other local to do the 15 minutes a few times a month. I'm sure there are plenty who would jump at the chance to make a tenner for such little work. You might even be able to talk one of the staff at the after school club into doing it for you.

Work on distancing yourself from both your parents and your brother. Don't think of them as people to turn to for anything. Increase your social network with other parents, friends, local childminders, etc. Try some technique like medium chill.

Canceling the summer holiday sounds like a sensible move. But if you think your parents would really leave you high and dry over the pick up or you would lose your money and feel like you have to go don't be cowed into not enjoying the space by either your brother or your parents. Just do your thing. If it wakes the baby say "That's a shame, but we're not making our holiday miserable to make yours perfect." If your brother's buying takeout tell him he should be buying it for all of you if he isn't contributing to the rental (he probably won't, but you making it clear you aren't buying his claims of poverty isn't a bad idea). Don't offer to babysit for them. Don't lend any of them money or take on anything on the promise of something from them later. Center the holiday around you and your DC and don't sway to your parents or brother's demands. If they say they've decided something that you don't want, just say "That doesn't work for us." Go out with out them. Don't tell them your plans, keep everything vague. If they try and surprise you with something (like babysitting) after you've said you're doing something that makes it seem like you could, just say something like "Oh, we really don't want to do that on holiday. I'm sure you understand." Don't back down, but don't raise the stakes by being confrontational. Just say you don't want to or change the subject. Make the best of it for yourselves and when you get back, do more of that distancing.

Thinkingblonde · 03/06/2022 23:30

Cancel the holiday, why put yourself and your son through being sidelined and criticised by your mother and brother? If your brother can’t afford to pay then he doesn’t get to go.
Your son probably picks up on the way his grandmother feels about him. Don’t let them do this to him.
Use the £2.000.00 saved by cancelling the holiday on a holiday for the three of you.
Your parents see you as a cash cow. It’ll continue it you let it.

Gladragdoll · 03/06/2022 23:30

Yanbu, cancel the holiday. Let them chase your brother for the difference…🙃Be prepared for negative vibes as they were all reliant on your contribution for the holiday.
Have a word with your workplace and see if they can be a little more flexible about your hours. If they can’t then try to find someone else.

Murdoch1949 · 03/06/2022 23:25

Blimey, parents & brother are taking you for a mug. Pull out of the holiday, it's hardly a holiday anyway! Your brother obviously prefers to spend his money in other ways and relies on sponging off you & parents. Find someone else to collect your child from after-school club, and pay them. There may be someone who picks up their own child or sibling who would be willing. Ask the assistants at the club. Your parents are being thoughtless and uncaring about helping you in this tiny way. There are many grandparents who relish the chance to spend time with grandchildren, some who do whole days of care, out of love. I don't know why your parents are being like this, is there another agenda? I'd prefer to not be beholden to them as they obviously see it as a job not a grandparent opportunity.

Basilbrushgotfat · 03/06/2022 23:22

Yanbu to cancel the next holiday, the last one sounded awful and your family are treating you really shabbily.

Yabu to feel that the hell with childcare is not a regular arrangement. It is - 3 to 4 times a month is once a week, that's regular. If your parents don't want to do it, that sucks but you'll need to find someone else.

BilboBagBin · 03/06/2022 23:22

Mellowyellow222 · 03/06/2022 22:23

paying for your brothers holiday is nuts. He clearly can afford it - he’s just tight. And he isn’t good company - either are your parents.

can you get out of it - is it non-refundable?

if it is refundable, simply pop a group message up saying :

all - the summer holiday is expensive and it is a huge stretch for us. The Easter family holiday didn’t really work for us - the kids are at different stages and it all got a bit tense! So to preserve family harmony, and my bank account, we have decided we have to cancel the trip. Sorry for the short notice.

What is the brother like with his nephew? If I had been entering someone else’s child for seven years and they put in a group WhatsApp that they couldn’t bear to be around my baby for one week it would take me a while to get past that!

freshstarters · 03/06/2022 23:17

Holiday - CANCEL. Have a lovely holiday by yourselves. (Might it be a bit late to cancel and still getting most of your £ back?) Remind your family that it didn’t work out last time. Suggest you all meet on neutral territory for air-clearing meal. Watch out for CF behaviour from DB and stay well clear.

Childcare- find a local babysitter.

Gettingthingsdone777 · 03/06/2022 23:15

Im sure they are a lot nicer than they seem in your post, but it does sound like they’re not really considering your feelings at all here. I think you already know what you need to do. I’m not sure why your brother is the favoured child- you sound way better, and way more together! Maybe they feel sorry for him?

BilboBagBin · 03/06/2022 23:14

*agro

BilboBagBin · 03/06/2022 23:13

Lemonickle · 03/06/2022 20:48

Thanks for your message. I know I don't expect or demand it. That's why when they asked for £10 for 15 minutes I agreed to pay them for their time. (I pay after school club £15 for 3-6) and the grandparents get £10 for 15 minutes.

Yeah, stop doing this it’s ridiculous.

You can’t expect free childcare off of them but they can’t except you to pay over the odds either. If they/you want to continue this arrangement then they look after your son for a full hour. If they complain, explain what the minimum wage is per-hour and that they are making good money out of it.

You are in the wrong about the baby though. Presumably you knew he was bringing the baby before you agreed to the hol? I think you have forgotten what it is like and that you probably would have been expecting similar.

That doesn’t mean you have to go away with them again. Just say you can’t afford it due to cost of living (you also shouldn’t offer to pay things for your brother if you are going to then be resentful about it) and go away together again in a couple of years when there kid is older if you can bear it.

Don’t bother going into why you didn’t enjoy the holiday as a reason or it will just cause extra Afro and drama.

Maybe your bro is a pain in the ass and a cheap skate but it also sounds like you are a bit envious to no longer be the provider of the only grandchild and to have to share in the attention. Sounds weird but I’ve noticed this is definitely a thing.

DeusInAbsentia · 03/06/2022 23:11

Jesus OP life is too fucking short for this shit. Cancel it. And as for £10 for their own grandkids, my gob is smacked. I drove half way across the country to collect my DD’s bloody dog for her a few weeks ago because she needed my help. I didn’t charge a tenner because she’s my child and I love her and a, happy to help her. The dog is a dick though 😉
I don’t have grandkids yet, just a grand dog but I can’t imagine not being there to help be it child, hound or sodding hamster.

you need to step back and look at this relationship, it’s not you. It’s them.

Mally100 · 03/06/2022 23:11

Needanotherholidayasap · 03/06/2022 20:50

Ask a neighbour or a recommended teenager..
Don't accept being treated so shabbily by your family.

Exactly! More fool you for going away again with them. Your parents sound horrible, stop being reliant on them because it's giving them the power to treat you like shit.

JudgeJ · 03/06/2022 23:07

cinq · 03/06/2022 21:00

your parents are charging you to pick their grandson up a few times a month and keep him for 15 minutes??? Wtf.? That’s not normal.

BUT this is mumsnet where it’s a cardinal sin to get help from your parents 🥴

your parents are dicks though. HTH.

Just getting a calculator out to see how much I'm owed at £10 for 15 minutes, £40/hour. then I'm off to order a new Porsche

Viviennemary · 03/06/2022 23:01

I dont think the amount of childcare you need from your parents is by any means excessive. The holiday didn't work last time. If it isn't too late pull out if it is then make it the last holiday with them.

paisley256 · 03/06/2022 22:56

You're family, including your 'Golden Child' brother are completely unreasonable op. Like @billy1966 says Step Away from them all and look after your little family. Wishing you all the best. 💐

Longdistance · 03/06/2022 22:48

Cancel that holiday.
Why did you agree to another and sub your tight arse brother?
As for you parents charging for childcare for 15 minutes once a week, they can fuck off too!

Mariposista · 03/06/2022 22:46

I wouldn't want to go on holiday where I have to whisper in my own accommodation, not be allowed to come and go as I want. What is it - a school trip?

Spohn · 03/06/2022 22:39

Your relatives are assholes. Obviously cancel the ‘holiday’.

Why would you make your son spend time with a woman who doesn’t like him and doesn’t speak to him? So cruel of you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread