Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry one of my DC is much more 'likeable' than the other

143 replies

jublieetastic · 03/06/2022 20:04

We've been at a street party and it's really brought this home to me.
My DC2 (8) has great communication skills, confidence and just has a knack with people. She seems to click with most children her age and all the adults today at the party were telling my how lovely she is.
My oldest child (11) has anxiety and is being assessed for ASD due to not very good communication skills. She is clingy and shy, and due to her anxiety struggles with regulating how she feels and acts even in public. But it's not so noticeable others would know why she behaves how she does.

It's great to see DC2 thrive and do well, but really tough to see the contrast between them and also how others perceive them. DC1 is getting more aware of this difference too and it is really effecting her self esteem and hence making her worse if anything. Anyone in a similar situation - any advice on how to handle it.

OP posts:
ForestFae · 04/06/2022 11:54

Oblomov22 · 04/06/2022 11:49

The world is uncompromising. Actually it works ok. For most, for many. I felt very differently to one of my friends with ASD children. She expected the world to change. I don't. My duty to ds1 was to help and assist, to help smooth out the bits he found hardest. Theory of mind, lack of empathy, lack of ability to think through consequences. I've worked on those bits, to help him in the last few years. I now know I've tried the best I could.

That doesn’t make the world right - I don’t think it’s right to force square pegs into round holes, instead teach your kids it’s okay to make a life for yourself that looks different to other peoples. You don’t have to engage in bullshit societal norms if you don’t want to.

Me, DH and our 3dc are non NT. Our life looks very different to a mainstream one, and that’s how we like it and it’s okay. It’s fine to be neurodivergent, unapologetically

Oblomov22 · 04/06/2022 11:49

Where did I say above?
I clearly stated alongside.

Oblomov22 · 04/06/2022 11:49

The world is uncompromising. Actually it works ok. For most, for many. I felt very differently to one of my friends with ASD children. She expected the world to change. I don't. My duty to ds1 was to help and assist, to help smooth out the bits he found hardest. Theory of mind, lack of empathy, lack of ability to think through consequences. I've worked on those bits, to help him in the last few years. I now know I've tried the best I could.

PonyPatter44 · 04/06/2022 11:47

Its not a problem. My sister is much more pleasant and likeable than I am - we've both got happy thriving lives as adults (and I have a job where being a grumpy old cow is not necessarily a drawback).

ForestFae · 04/06/2022 11:44

i just don’t think we should be promoting “fitting in” as something to be prioritised especially above being comfortable with your authentic self

Oblomov22 · 04/06/2022 11:43

No one. Not a single person said there was anything wrong with being introverted.

whumpthereitis · 04/06/2022 11:43

ForestFae · 04/06/2022 11:34

No but there’s a definite issue with society saying there’s something wrong with introverted kids. We should encourage people to embrace who they are. Not thing to be someone else.

Society may be wrong, but the fact remains that it’s not changing any time soon. OP would be doing her daughter a massive disservice if she chose against helping her to develop a social skillset in the name of ideological purism. Technically, I didn’t ‘have’ to learn English when I moved to the UK, it was massively fucking beneficial to me that I did though.

Human beings are a social species and having the skills to navigate social situations make life a hell of a lot easier for the vast majority of people. They’re important skills to have, whether you use them or not.

While there’s nothing wrong with being ‘true to yourself’ there’s nothing wrong with adapting either if it makes you happier and improves your life.

Oblomov22 · 04/06/2022 11:42

See that's where I disagree. She's clearly very unhappy.
So she might need both. At least suggest and promote both. The accepting of oneself, AND the change, to try and learn the bits that allow easier acceptance, fitting in. It might be hard as first, but it often becomes easier. Or at least to acknowledge it, think about it. The self awareness of the bits we find hard.

ForestFae · 04/06/2022 11:34

whumpthereitis · 04/06/2022 11:32

Or, you know, she may actually want to develop social skills.

She’s not you.

No but there’s a definite issue with society saying there’s something wrong with introverted kids. We should encourage people to embrace who they are. Not thing to be someone else.

whumpthereitis · 04/06/2022 11:32

ForestFae · 04/06/2022 10:47

She might not realise there’s an alternative and that it’s fine to be as she is. Kids tend to give introverted kids shit.

Or, you know, she may actually want to develop social skills.

She’s not you.

Introvertedbuthappy · 04/06/2022 11:08

It sounds like social anxiety, not that your eldest doesn't want the things that come naturally to your youngest. My youngest is like that - really struggles at parties, but mainly because he wants to join in, but gets anxious then doesn't, realises folk are looking at him then tries to join in but can't, which then raises his anxiety...etc etc.

Main thing is emphasising the fun of social situations and talking through events like that before going, eg what might happen, what she could say or talk about, rehearse a few bits. That seems to help my youngest (who seems to be neuro diverse in a couple of areas). It's tough though, I really get it. It's hard as a parent not to feel 'shame' (not really the right word) when people notice and pass comment on your child's social anxiety. My feeling is, now, that it is them with the issue, not my youngest, and if they can't feel empathy with a wee one who is in clear need of a bit of help socially then they themselves can't be as well socialised as they think!

ForestFae · 04/06/2022 10:47

liveforsummer · 04/06/2022 10:45

Sounds like OP's dd does want these things though ...

She might not realise there’s an alternative and that it’s fine to be as she is. Kids tend to give introverted kids shit.

liveforsummer · 04/06/2022 10:45

ForestFae · 03/06/2022 21:52

Right but you don’t need extensive social skills, unless you want the things that they bring. Not everyone does.

Sounds like OP's dd does want these things though ...

liveforsummer · 04/06/2022 10:44

My girls are like this however it's the other way around so dd2 who is 9 has had the advantage of an older sibling to learn from which I think has helped her. The main thing though is her hobby. She rides and is starting to get quite good at it which has done wonders for her self stern and she'll talk confidently about the subject where she'd normally be awkward in the same situation without that to talk about. At the yard there are loads of like minded dc and they often spend half of or all day there and just recently I've noticed a huge improvement in her confidence, social awkwardness and general ability to socialise. Is there a hobby or interest you could expand on to create a social circle of like minded people?

ForestFae · 04/06/2022 10:38

ChocolateHippo · 04/06/2022 10:22

But the OP's DD1 isn't happy and fulfilled. She wants friends and a social life and to have a better understanding of those unwritten, social codes of conduct which her sister has already grasped. She may change her mind as she gets older and becomes more comfortable in herself, but surely for now the best thing is to try to help her get to grips with them and also to meet people who she gels with and enjoys spending time with.

Surely the best thing is to teach her to be comfortable with herself now, not “this is how you can change yourself to fit in”? She might be unhappy because she doesn’t know it’s okay to be who she is.

ChocolateHippo · 04/06/2022 10:22

ForestFae · 04/06/2022 09:11

Is there anything wrong with not being able to fly though? It’s perfectly possible to live a happy, fulfilling life never flying. That’s my point, that you don’t have to do these things and you can live a good life even if it looks different to other peoples.

But the OP's DD1 isn't happy and fulfilled. She wants friends and a social life and to have a better understanding of those unwritten, social codes of conduct which her sister has already grasped. She may change her mind as she gets older and becomes more comfortable in herself, but surely for now the best thing is to try to help her get to grips with them and also to meet people who she gels with and enjoys spending time with.

Ferngreen · 04/06/2022 09:22

I didn't develop any skills or hobbies as a child. I think I needed some support and time from others I didnt get.

Now old I've a flair for things I didn't know. Also never got good at any sport -came late to learning to cycle and swim - just a scaredy.
I would concentrate on helping older girl learn a sport and crafts (dc2too if she wants) as they are such an entry into socialising later.

ForestFae · 04/06/2022 09:11

Is there anything wrong with not being able to fly though? It’s perfectly possible to live a happy, fulfilling life never flying. That’s my point, that you don’t have to do these things and you can live a good life even if it looks different to other peoples.

MsTSwift · 04/06/2022 08:52

Not if they are 11 and just abit shy. People sometimes change massively. They might always be like that equally they may just want to learn then be entirely different as an adult.

That’s why parenting is so hard working out which approach is right for your child. If you don’t help a NT child that needs you to that’s not great parenting but on the other hand helping a child who will never learn and doesn’t want / cannot learn fails them too. You can’t put your own experiences onto everyone.

Oblomov22 · 04/06/2022 08:51

Plus I wasn't referring to ASD masking, which can be damaging, because there often is an element of 'pretending'.

I meant more recognising and adjusting and learning to do it things a bit more, comfortably. A bit like TerryPratchett referred to overcoming flying. We can work on things. They can become easier.

ForestFae · 04/06/2022 08:43

MsTSwift · 04/06/2022 08:40

It would be lovely if it didn’t matter but it will help a child in life if they have conversation skills and can make low key pleasant small talk with others, ask them questions, make eye contact, not be totally awkward.. Not forcing them to be the jazz hands party central extrovert.

Many children are shy at this age not necessarily neuro divergent. You are advocating sitting back and watching a shy 11 year old flail and not step in to help them at all? Not sure most loving parents would take that approach tbh.

How? It will only help them if it’s something they want to do and enjoy, otherwise they’ll just feel drained and wonder why they’re “broken” and not like everyone else. Teaching people to mask doesn’t change the way they feel it just teaches them to repress it which causes more problems.

ForestFae · 04/06/2022 08:41

Reallyreallyborednow · 04/06/2022 08:38

I don’t think it’s a good thing to force kids to conform to societal norms, especially when they’re damaging

we need to make children aware it’s ok to prefer reading a book to going to parties or shopping with friend.

it’s ok if you aren’t the child that always gets invited to those parties or aren’t in with the popular girls.

my mum actually discouraged me from swimming as a kid because she said when I got to teenage years I would want to be going out with friends rather than training, and I would get “big shoulders” and smell of chlorine. I was bloody good at it, then got to those teenage years and realised parties friends and boyfriends weren’t actually that great.

Exactly! I’m lucky, my mum is very much like me and is introverted too so she never made me feel strange or weird for preferring to read or draw than hang out with other kids. But I know loads of other introverted and or neurodivergent people aren’t as lucky and are constantly made to feel othered because of it. It’s very frustrating.

MsTSwift · 04/06/2022 08:40

It would be lovely if it didn’t matter but it will help a child in life if they have conversation skills and can make low key pleasant small talk with others, ask them questions, make eye contact, not be totally awkward.. Not forcing them to be the jazz hands party central extrovert.

Many children are shy at this age not necessarily neuro divergent. You are advocating sitting back and watching a shy 11 year old flail and not step in to help them at all? Not sure most loving parents would take that approach tbh.

Reallyreallyborednow · 04/06/2022 08:38

I don’t think it’s a good thing to force kids to conform to societal norms, especially when they’re damaging

we need to make children aware it’s ok to prefer reading a book to going to parties or shopping with friend.

it’s ok if you aren’t the child that always gets invited to those parties or aren’t in with the popular girls.

my mum actually discouraged me from swimming as a kid because she said when I got to teenage years I would want to be going out with friends rather than training, and I would get “big shoulders” and smell of chlorine. I was bloody good at it, then got to those teenage years and realised parties friends and boyfriends weren’t actually that great.

ForestFae · 04/06/2022 08:31

MsTSwift · 04/06/2022 08:26

Fair enough but if you were not able to hold a conversation at work or present at conferences that would hold you back surely? Doing that is social skills.

The child is either someone like forestfae or a child who is broadly NT but shy and keen to conform but needs some parental help with social skills to do so. There’s no blanket “right approach” it depends on the child.

In my family it was the latter and my mothers tough love and insistence on social skills was absolutely right for my painfully shy sister who is now incredibly sophisticated socially it’s part of her job. This is why parenting is so hard!

It depends what you want to do for a job, surely? I’m predominantly a stay at home mother but I’m also an artist. I do exhibitions and sell my work, and it so happens people almost expect artists to be a bit unconventional so no one gives a monkeys if I come over as awkward.

Youre right that there’s no one size fits all approach, but there is evidence that teaching neurodivergent kids to “mask” (conform to social norms) leads to trauma, PTSD and burnout later on

www.choosingtherapy.com/autistic-burnout/
www.spectrumnews.org/news/autistic-burnout-explained/

Personally I wouldn’t want to risk contributing to that as it’s really unpleasant