Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you regret NOT having children

222 replies

josil · 03/06/2022 17:59

I'm looking for perspectives from those who made an active decision to not have children - not those that couldn't or didn't find the right person.

If anyone is out there that decided after thought it wasn't right for them even though they could have children (even potentially with fertility treatment assistance) I'd like to hear from you if you have any regrets.

Ideally from those who are 50+. Sorry to be specific but I'm really struggling here with potential parenthood.

I have tried to conceive three years now and while I haven't had any treatment yet I'm trying to weigh up whether I should just draw a line under it. Motherhood I don't think suits me for many reasons but also some aspects of it I know is really like.

But I just cannot feel the courage to say I'm not having them as I feel I will be riddled with complete regret in 10-20 years from now hence why I'm after perspectives.

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 03/06/2022 21:23

Tiredalwaystired · 03/06/2022 21:21

I’m intrigued to know - for everyone who never wanted children and has never regretted it…why did you choose Mumsnet as a platform of choice?

One of the biggest (UK) forums with a variety of topics. Same reason I use Reddit, minus the UK bit.

Tiredalwaystired · 03/06/2022 21:21

I’m intrigued to know - for everyone who never wanted children and has never regretted it…why did you choose Mumsnet as a platform of choice?

Catslovepies · 03/06/2022 21:19

I turn 50 in a couple of months and am childfree by choice. I've never regretted it. Sure, I sometimes think it would be nice having a couple of cute little kids around but no where near the extent of being willing to put in all the work and make all the sacrifices. As for not having anyone to look after me when I'm old - I figure I'll have a robot carer (only half joking, they've actually been making massive strides) and I've been able to focus on my career so I'll have a great pension and the ability to pay for carers. I also think that self-driving cars will help me keep my independence for longer. Plus I have lots of hobbies that will keep me busy.

mangoontoast · 03/06/2022 21:19

I'm 44. Didn't want children (thought I did in my mid 30s but pretty sure it was FOMO). I love my life. No regrets at all.

CounsellorTroi · 03/06/2022 21:17

Not quite the perspective you’re looking for, but I wanted children but couldn’t have them. Did IVF with no success. Now at 61 I don’t regret not having children, feel I dodged a bullet in many ways. Life is good.

whumpthereitis · 03/06/2022 21:16

‘They’ll think differently in the future’ is always a safe way to ensure that you’ll be right, no matter what someone may say about their own life. No, just hand wave to some unspecified future date, because you couldn’t possibly be wrong.I suppose you could apply the same to those happy with children currently, just give them twenty odd years and they’ll see the error of their ways.

OP, in any sort of big decision there will always be a possibly of regretting the road travelled, or yearning for the road not. Fear of regret can very end up easily holding someone in place, scared to make a move. Or it may inspire a panicked reaction and see someone make a very bad decision for themselves. I think you have to accept that you can never 100% guarantee against regret, and choose what is right for you at the time anyway. Short of a crystal ball, that is all you can do.

Personally, I’ve never regretted my decision to not have children. I don’t think it was even a decision really, I always instinctively knew I didn’t want them. Children would only ever be a burden to my life, and how I want to live it. I’ve never questioned that.

SpotOfTee · 03/06/2022 21:12

Gensola · 03/06/2022 20:44

I’m 37 and it looks like I won’t ever have children - we have tried 5 rounds of IVF and my DH has had his vasectomy reversed but no luck. He doesn’t want to do sperm donor so that’s it. I am very conflicted about it if I am honest - we have spent £30,000 on IVF, all because he had a vasectomy in a past relationship. I have no fertility issues. 😞

So sorry you're in that situation. I'd personally really struggle to stay if children were something I really wanted. I know that's probably really frowned upon, I have a friend in the exact same situation (partner had vasectomy prior to them meeting ect..) and I know it plays on her mind a lot whether she should stay or leave.

Costacoffeeplease · 03/06/2022 21:11

I'm looking for perspectives from those who made an active decision to not have children

Just in case any pp missed it

WildFlowerBees · 03/06/2022 21:07

No regrets, I'm mid 40's never wanted them and when I see friends and their kids and how hard parenting is I'm glad I didn't have them, plus I don't actually like children and parenting seems a thankless task. Not for me.

IrisVersicolor · 03/06/2022 21:07

No regrets at all. I’ve never had a flicker of broodiness and don’t really like children.

I could have chosen to be close to my nephews and nieces - my siblings really wanted it - but I cba. They’re nice enough kids but I have no desire to spend time with them.

Octopus47 · 03/06/2022 21:01

I can understand how older people might regret it in later life, I know someone who feels a bit like this. I have kids and whilst I love them at the moment I'm pretty confident that neither of them will look out for me in my old age. I have two boys aged 12 and 15 and tbh its very obvious that neither of them care about anyone but themselves. I dont regret having them, but my god its hard and at the moment I dont really get anything back.

GrumpyLovegood · 03/06/2022 20:59

#josil I know I’m not the responder you invited but I was in your position. Early thirties, we had been trying for a few years with no luck and made the decision to live child free. After a couple of years I got anxious like you are about our decision so we gave ivf a go. No joy after 4 cycles and tried again to find peace with being child free. We gave it a few years but the anxiety came back and after long discussions we looked into adoption.
Long story short we did adopt a little girl.
I think the anxiety would’ve kept coming back and while we may well have had a wonderful life without children, I thank 38 yr old me daily for not going down that road as I have such joy from dd.
I don’t think you can possibly know what will be the best decision for future you. But either way, you will wonder. And you will make the best of whatever decision you make.
Other peoples’ experiences are other peoples’ experiences. Yours will be yours.

Sleepytimebear · 03/06/2022 20:57

I'm late 30s so don't fit your criteria but I've never wanted children. I had some fertility testing in my early 30s because everyone kept saying I would change my mind. I'm fertile but still not keen. I thought I might change my mind when I became an aunt but no, still not keen. I find the arguments for having children quite odd (unless it's that you want them - obviously this is a great reason!). I get a lot of people saying I'll regret it, who will look after me in old age etc. I don't think I will regret it, I don't regret any decisions so far. I have enough money to pay for care. You certainly can't rely on your kids turning out a certain way and wanting to look after you when you're bedbound. All my friends have kids and I don't feel left out. I'm just not interested.

Justreadingtheforum3 · 03/06/2022 20:57

Very close to the age you ask and absolutely love my life. I decided children weren't for me and really happy.

BadNomad · 03/06/2022 20:56

Having children doesn't guarantee they'll be around for you in your old age. That is not a reason to have them, nor a reason to regret not having them.

DeanStockwelll · 03/06/2022 20:54

Oh I should of added I am in my late 40s now

mydogisthebest · 03/06/2022 20:53

I am 68 and DH is 64. We talked at length about whether to have children or not when we got married 42 years ago. We decided not to for various reasons.

Neither of us have ever regretted it, not even for a second. As the years have passed we have been more and more sure we made the right decision.

Quite a few of our family and friends are also child free by choice and none of them seem to have regrets either. On the other hand, quite a few of our friends and family with children say although they love their children, if they could go back in time they would not have any.

laloue · 03/06/2022 20:53

49, always said from teen years I wouldn’t have kids and it’s never happened, my DH would be an amazing dad, but I have zero maternal instinct. Got clucky briefly when friends started producing adorable babies 20 odd years ago, but I am now just a “naughty aunty” figure who’s happy to love and support when needed. No regrets at all.

DeanStockwelll · 03/06/2022 20:50

I knew from been very young ( around 10 ) that I didn't want kids.
My DM&D said I would change my mind but I never had ,they realise by the time I was about 16 that they were wrong before.

I am not at all maternal, if someone presents me with a child of any age under about 10 I have no idea how to act around it.

A animal on the other hand , even if it's a trpe of animal I have never come across before I seem to fairly instinctively know at least a bit about it and what to do

Bofthebang · 03/06/2022 20:50

AllAloneInThisHouse · 03/06/2022 18:19

No regrets here.
Quite the opposite, I keep appreciating more and more about the fact thats:


  1. I don’t have them

  2. I didn’t bring another person, who did not ask to be born, into this world.

I couldn’t put it any better myself!

I’m in the age range you asked for OP and no, I have never once regretted having children. In my view there are FAR too many people in the world as it is, and with climate change being roundly ignored, I don’t want to bring anyone into the world who will have to deal with all the many future problems that are in store for the next couple of generations.

My husband and I have a wonderful, busy, very fulfilled life and not having children has been one of the next decisions we ever made.

Aaaabbbcccc · 03/06/2022 20:46

Thought I didn’t want them, had one extremely late. So glad I did. I had/have a fantastic life of professional fulfilment, travel, adventure etc and the way I see is that if I hadn’t had a child I would have continued to have an entirely fulfilling life. Cuddling my DC is something I had never experienced anything like but the same could be said of flying a light aircraft through Southern Africa which gave me as much of a sense of being alive. So my point is that I would not see it as binary and one being good and the other being bad and try to empirically assess which one you should go for. The simple truth is that we adapt to our lives - obviously there are some extremes at either end but for the most part us humans find a way of being happy. There as so many paths to fulfilment in life, kids is just one of them.

so - if you feel you want to keep trying, do it (it took me 4 years without any fertility treatment) but if you don’t, don’t and see where life leads you.

grapewines · 03/06/2022 20:44

I also couldn't be a step-parent and have actively avoided that as well.

Gensola · 03/06/2022 20:44

I’m 37 and it looks like I won’t ever have children - we have tried 5 rounds of IVF and my DH has had his vasectomy reversed but no luck. He doesn’t want to do sperm donor so that’s it. I am very conflicted about it if I am honest - we have spent £30,000 on IVF, all because he had a vasectomy in a past relationship. I have no fertility issues. 😞

Heartoverheadheadoverheart · 03/06/2022 20:43

I hope you don't mind me answering. I'm not the person you were looking for an answer from. I have multiple children. I was always broody and desperately wanted to be a mum more than anything.

Whilst I wouldn't change them for the world and the love I have for them is like nothing else I guess I was so blind sided by wanting to be a mum so badly that I never realised what I was giving up. You don't realise what you have got until it is gone. I think aside from the physical stuff like sleep deprevation and freedom it is the fact that it puts you in a vulnerable position in every way possible.

When you look at it rationally you give up so much and all to bring another person into the world who will most likely go through huge amounts of suffering. Saying that me being someone who is so maternal would still go back and have them again, selfishly. But, I can now see what I could not before, how life if you are not maternal can be amazing too.

I don't think worries of loneliness is a good reason to have children. You will spend more of your life in a dire state from having them than feeling lonely from not. Their is no guarantee they will be around in your older age. You can make other close relationships if you try.

A couple of close relatives never had them just due to never being in the right situation. They struggled for a while but are at peace with it now, so it would seem. They do say they are lonely but so do a couple of my other family members who have children. Neither seems worse off. In fact at least the ones without children are more financially stable. The only thing is I guess I feel like they have missed out on a big life experience but then I have probably missed out on a lot of my own life by giving myself to my children.

IReallyLikeCrows · 03/06/2022 20:43

I was ambivalent about having children. Neither gung ho, I absolutely must have them, nor really against it. I have been pregnant more than once and miscarried relatively early. My reaction to this was sadness but I don't think I was as deeply sad as people who were planning children or who really, really wanted them.

I'm in my fifties and sometimes think it would have been nice to have them but I don't regret it not happening. Of course, some people will tell you that when you're elderly and there's "no one there to look after you" you will regret it which is hogwash, basically. Anyone who has children because they want to be looked after in their old age - and I'm pretty damn sure that the majority of parents don't do that - would be very odd indeed.

I'm a fabulous auntie and that's good enough for me.