Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why am I useless at mum relationships?

65 replies

LittleFeet178 · 03/06/2022 17:30

So I've got a senior level professional job in which I manage a large team. A key part of my role is building relationships with colleagues across the business. My team is considered high performing and I get good manager feedback. I have never found it difficult to build relationships with my reports or wider colleagues and am well liked. If asked my colleagues would probably say I'm outgoing and even quite chatty. I enjoy work and had made several long lasting friendships through it.

Outside of work I'm hopeless. I dread nursery and school drop off because I don't know what to say to the other parents and I'm hopeless at instigating playdates for DC. I hate bumping into other parents in the playground and having to make conversation. But my absolute hell is kids parties where I stand on my own "supervising" DC feeling like a spare part and wishing the 2 hours away.

How is it possible I'm a completely different person at work and home?!
I want to fix it because I don't want it to affect my kids but I don't know how...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HandyGirl76 · 04/06/2022 15:46

This is so me OP! For a long time I wondered if there was something wrong with me. I think you have to learn the mum talk thing but also you need to find your crew. I've found them now and they're mostly professionals like me but it's taken 10 years. Go out and meet more parents, the ones you'll click with may not be on the school or nursery run so make sure to go to other things such as school mums nights out etc. There will be people in exactly the same boat, you just need to find them.

Chickenkatsu · 04/06/2022 15:36

You tried talking to the Dads?

Sometimeswinning · 04/06/2022 14:20

Pumperthepumper · 04/06/2022 11:50

I have literally never met a woman who only wants to talk about their kids. Never.

Also, if you're 2 people dropping your kids at the same school, then it's a bit of a common ground thing to talk about. I never understand these people who say they don't care about school gate friendships but then come across as really bitter and judgmental about it all!

EllaPaella · 04/06/2022 13:46

Sometimes the problem is that a lot of other Mum's already know each other from before their kids went to school, maybe they have older siblings who were in the same class etc and so you might feel left out but it will be unintentional on their behalf.
Also different year groups vary so much - I have three boys, two of them we have had great year groups of parents all being very sociable, lots of meet-ups etc and bbq's, parties for parents and kids. My eldest is 20 and I still go out with and away with a group of Mum friends from his school year several times a year. Youngest one we all socialise a lot as well, partly because we got to know everyone a lot better through football and sports clubs that they all go to.
My middle one however I would only pass the time of day with one or two parents, never socialise with any of them. Just a different vibe in that year.
Just try and strike up casual conversation and see where it goes. Some people come across as being stand-offish but are actually just quite shy and socially awkward- they would probably really appreciate you heading over for a chat!

Ferngreen · 04/06/2022 13:09

There was thread recently about your worst kids birthday party - I wanted to post All of them!
Kids are overexcited, won't do what you tell them, charge around (I just don't see that as fun) , stuffing junk food, apart from th bratty kid getting dozens of presents is there an up??
Next is weddings - everyone sitting or standing around making stiltedconversation. With people they don't rally know - I hate them

But I do like doing things with others, writing group, painting,walking - I think it's because you have a clear object of discussion but are under no obligation to join in -as you are doing something else.

Pumperthepumper · 04/06/2022 11:50

RainCoffeeBook · 04/06/2022 11:44

The truth is, talking about kids is boring. When you're at work adults talk about all sorts of things. You'd be an idiot to start twaddling on about kids.

So when you're out of work, find the other mums who don't want to talk kids either. Any talking about their kids are bores. Best avoided. Find the ones who don't talk about kids and who talk about interesting things.

Being stuck in conversation with a kid talked is hell. I had one start crying on me about her husband when I had my coat on and was leaving a childcare building. I hadn't even started talking to her. She just started bleating personal stuff at me. Honestly I just avoid people who 'want mum friends' or think having kids is their whole life. Make normal friends.

I have literally never met a woman who only wants to talk about their kids. Never.

RainCoffeeBook · 04/06/2022 11:50

iwanttobeasquare · 03/06/2022 18:11

Here's what I say -

How is x getting on at school?
How are you finding it?
Does x do any after school clubs?
Does h/she like it?
Where are you living now/ did you have to travel far?
I love x's dress / trousers / t- shirt whatever

Fine, but also none of your business. Finding what? Maybe. Maybe. In my house, which I won't tell you because I don't want you knocking on. Did I travel...? I never answer this. Actually at this point I walk off.

Why not start a conversation with them about THEM? Digging for info on their kids and house is creepy. Just talk to them like a normal person. About normal things. Do you think this is how adults talk?

RainCoffeeBook · 04/06/2022 11:47

Mariposista · 04/06/2022 10:13

One of my friends is in the same position as you OP. Like you, she is very clever in a high level job (she is an engineer) and just has nothing in common with the women at nursery. She just doesn't fit in with their boring conversations, their 'we've known each other since we were toddlers' clique-ness, and has been reduced to tears by their judgemental comments of 'ahhh poor thing' aimed at her daughter when she told the teacher her husband would be doing drop off for 3 days because she was going on a business trip to Milan. Don't worry about them OP. Enjoy your job and bonds you make with colleagues, your own friends that you choose, and your family.

Yes, I've had this. I was a stay at home mum for years and posh judgemental working women would call me a drudge, and then when I started working again (with travelling too! Yay) they'd already given up work and acted like I was a career obsessed child abandoner. In short, you can't win and they basically will sneer no matter what you do.

RainCoffeeBook · 04/06/2022 11:44

The truth is, talking about kids is boring. When you're at work adults talk about all sorts of things. You'd be an idiot to start twaddling on about kids.

So when you're out of work, find the other mums who don't want to talk kids either. Any talking about their kids are bores. Best avoided. Find the ones who don't talk about kids and who talk about interesting things.

Being stuck in conversation with a kid talked is hell. I had one start crying on me about her husband when I had my coat on and was leaving a childcare building. I hadn't even started talking to her. She just started bleating personal stuff at me. Honestly I just avoid people who 'want mum friends' or think having kids is their whole life. Make normal friends.

Mally100 · 04/06/2022 11:40

iwanttobeasquare · 03/06/2022 18:11

Here's what I say -

How is x getting on at school?
How are you finding it?
Does x do any after school clubs?
Does h/she like it?
Where are you living now/ did you have to travel far?
I love x's dress / trousers / t- shirt whatever

Good suggestions. I say these too knowing I don't actually give a shit or care. I hate these small talk conversations too but I just do it because of my dc.b

Mariposista · 04/06/2022 11:37

RenegadeMatron · 04/06/2022 11:18

Your friend sounds amazing @Mariposista . What a shame she doesn’t fit in.

Where do you fit in?

She really is! And her kid is great, a really happy child and loves saying ‘mummy works with boats’. And becoming a mum has just made her even more interesting to talk to and rounded, not self-centred with nothing to talk about except HER child, nappies, sleep patterns, soft play etc YAAAAAAAWN change the radio channel please!

Where do I fit in? No doubt about it, with my own chosen friends, and on my swimming team (I am a professional swimmer). Some of us are married, others in relationships, divorced, single, widowed, gay, straight, from other countries… it’s such a varied group that there is always something and someone to talk to and we support each other. And yes, we all come from different professional backgrounds - not all are in management positions (that also would be boring), some are shop assistants, taxi drivers, whatever, but they are just INTERESTING people who are also interested in others and their lives, not just what’s going on in their own. And yea some of us are parents and some not - it’s fun when the kids join us at competitions sometimes. So please don’t worry OP, how good or bad you are at making friends as a mum is not defined but this very small, boring group.

RenegadeMatron · 04/06/2022 11:18

Your friend sounds amazing @Mariposista . What a shame she doesn’t fit in.

Where do you fit in?

FiveNineFive · 04/06/2022 11:09

Mariposista · 04/06/2022 10:13

One of my friends is in the same position as you OP. Like you, she is very clever in a high level job (she is an engineer) and just has nothing in common with the women at nursery. She just doesn't fit in with their boring conversations, their 'we've known each other since we were toddlers' clique-ness, and has been reduced to tears by their judgemental comments of 'ahhh poor thing' aimed at her daughter when she told the teacher her husband would be doing drop off for 3 days because she was going on a business trip to Milan. Don't worry about them OP. Enjoy your job and bonds you make with colleagues, your own friends that you choose, and your family.

As we know, all women without high powered jobs are stupid and boring and never have anything interesting to say.

Glitterspy · 04/06/2022 10:18

Errr so OP let me get this straight…you think all the “PTA mums” are “excruciating” and have “no interest in making friends” but you somehow expect these same “excruciating” people to talk about “mum stuff” with you despite not having any interest clue what to say to them, and can only think that all these “excruciating” people want to talk about is their own children?

You are incredibly judgemental, rude and disrespectful and I expect this is why no one speaks to you outside of your so-amazing “professional job”. Maybe someone you pay to be nice to you from your large team will care. Frankly you sound absolutely horrible and I wouldn’t bother with you either.

Mariposista · 04/06/2022 10:13

One of my friends is in the same position as you OP. Like you, she is very clever in a high level job (she is an engineer) and just has nothing in common with the women at nursery. She just doesn't fit in with their boring conversations, their 'we've known each other since we were toddlers' clique-ness, and has been reduced to tears by their judgemental comments of 'ahhh poor thing' aimed at her daughter when she told the teacher her husband would be doing drop off for 3 days because she was going on a business trip to Milan. Don't worry about them OP. Enjoy your job and bonds you make with colleagues, your own friends that you choose, and your family.

GroggyLegs · 04/06/2022 09:56

Im not great at forging friendships but I really wanted a couple of mum friends to avoid the situations you describe.

I pretty much faked it till I made it. I channel a couple of friends who ARE very confident & brilliant at making friends & followed whatever I think they would have done - asking a couple of ppl if they fancied a coffee after drop off etc.

Worked like a charm.
Also, homed in on smiley mums.

Worth remembering a lot of the parents may have gone to school together too, so they have existing bonds to build on - its nothing you're doing wrong. I always forget many people don't move away from where they were raised!

Do your kids have friends at school? Are their parents a route in?

PlantingTrees · 04/06/2022 09:54

What do you do in other situations where you don’t know people? How do you normally chat to strangers?

I don’t really get the whole thing about school mums either. They’re just people like you. I’ve never experienced any bitchiness at the school gates. Everyone has been so nice. Maybe I’ve been lucky tho.

Kids parties are a bit dull. You could ask people what else they have planned for the weekend, you might discover something interesting about them.

Sometimeswinning · 04/06/2022 09:45

Thisisit2022 · 03/06/2022 19:00

My DD is now an adult and I avoided the Nazi PTA "Mums at the school gate" thing at all costs. Didn't effect either of us. My dd loves my real life friends and their kids.

You sound incredibly bitter about the whole thing in your post! Maybe you need to focus on how "happy" you say you!

I speak to anyone and everyone not just my fellow pta parents! If someone is as awkward at conversation as you say you are I would probably avoid you as its really hard work sitting at a child's party with someone who can't make conversation!

LittleFeet178 · 04/06/2022 09:40

Pumperthepumper · 04/06/2022 09:27

Exactly this. People who think they’re so above the school mums and their boring ‘excruciating’ chat, then wonder why nobody talks to them.

Oh crap, some of the posts on this thread are making me feel even more reticent. Everyone does think I'm a snooty cow and I'm destined to stand in the corner alone at parties forever 😭

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 04/06/2022 09:27

RenegadeMatron · 03/06/2022 20:36

Maybe think of them as people rather than ‘Mums’ and it might help the conversation to come more naturally.

I never understand people who seem to ‘other’ Mums, eschewing any sort of collegial, friendly relationship with them, being seemingly above the school gate … and then come and hang out on Mumsnet…..

Exactly this. People who think they’re so above the school mums and their boring ‘excruciating’ chat, then wonder why nobody talks to them.

sashagabadon · 04/06/2022 09:20

Don’t assume mums want to talk about their kids. Yes at first as that is the common bond but then move on, holidays, national events coming up, work ( they may have a much more interesting job than you do), films you have seen, people you might know in common ( no gossip) , did they grow up in area, what a nice party it is, etc etc etc

LittleFeet178 · 04/06/2022 09:14

rattlemehearties · 04/06/2022 06:57

Having read all your posts, the answer to your question in your title is probably because you look down on all the school gate mums and don't make an effort! You know a lot of them will also be professionally successful with careers? In fact you don't know because you don't talk to them.

Seems a bit harsh! I don't look down on anyone and have friends from all walks of life

OP posts:
CharSiu · 04/06/2022 09:04

I had a friend and her DH round for a BBQ yesterday, we met at the school gate and have known each other for 15 years and click really well together. It’s unusual to have conversations immediately that are deep with anyone because it’s a bit if a risk. We started with just a few passing low level interactions.

Wokplaces have codes of conduct, rules. handbooks so unless someone has social anxiety or other communication issues then of course it’s easy to have conversations.

Mums are people with their own interests and once you get to know someone and past that initial low level interaction you may find you have a lot in common or share an interest.

Bex000 · 04/06/2022 07:48

No advice, but ditto!
I think that in some ways it is just no common interests, I would not expect to be friends with everyone I meet but would seek out those with whom I relate.
In the case of school mums their lives may be very different but just smile be polite ask open questions and eventually you may find one that clicks.
Perhaps think of it like internet dating and weeding out the candidates.

MagicTurtle · 04/06/2022 07:12

It's not necessarily that you're bad at small talk. Some of the mums are probably close friends who see each other a lot and whose kids play together outside school etc. It's hard for you to come into a group like that if you're around less. Is there anyone else who seems like you, a bit on the outskirts? Try focusing on them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread