Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There's no such thing as a well behaved three year old

93 replies

TerribleThreees · 03/06/2022 17:08

OK so perhaps there is, but I'd love to be told that they're all little horrors and it's a phase they all go through. It might make me feel a bit better about my day!

My DD has been hellish today. There was tantrum after whinge after tantrum, she was being rude to strangers in supermarkets who kindly asked her what the matter was. She was screeching like a banshee around said supermarket when i wouldn't buy her every request, completely defiant and non compliant all day. To top it off she was extremely rude about a gentleman on the bus who she had to sit next to (it was the only seat left) and the poor bloke had to listen to her exclaiming that she doesn't like that man and doesn't want to sit next to him.

I don't know what has gotten into her, she used to be so mild mannered and polite and it's actually quite embarrassing.

Needless to say such behaviour doesn't go unchecked.

Anybody else care to share their stories of their obnoxious pre schoolers or am I unreasonable and just have a little horror 🤔

OP posts:
Alcibiade · 03/06/2022 20:20

OP I think it is actually expected for a three-year old to be 'defiant'. They are, at this stage, just beginning to develop their own personality (as opposed to being just an extension of you), so what looks like 'defiance' is actually them trying to establish that they are their own separate individual. Of course, being only three or four, they cannot be expected to do this in a mature, reasonable fashion.

Just keep telling yourself that the one time in your life that it is okay to behave like a toddler is when you actually are one.

So, sorry but you are being unreasonable. Your delightful little daughter is not a little horror but in all probability just a perfectly normal little three year old who is just beginning to establish her own sense of self and doing it in the only way she knows how. And will probably grow up into a lovely little girl in a few years.

CountTheStars · 03/06/2022 20:20

My DS2 is a happy boy most of the time but OMG he’s got a pair of lungs on him & when he fights with his brother or gets cross he shouts and SCREAMS - and literally goes red in the face. He sometimes hits people either with his hands or throws a toy. His aim is horribly accurate as well. 😡

If I tell him off he says “you are NOT the best mummy,” which makes me laugh a bit. He’s big & strong too so we sometimes have what can only be described as toddler wrestling matches whilst I try and change him or get him ready for bed. He finds it hilarious.

So yeah, good times & bad

Mammyloveswine · 03/06/2022 20:14

My 6 year old has been a demon the past two days...honest to god he's driven me demented!!

Joanajoanna · 03/06/2022 20:13

My older 2 were fine at ages 3. My youngest has had the most horrid terrible twos and I put this down to the divorce. He's 3 now and I hoped he'd be less of a handful but he's still an almighty handful. I keep telling myself it can't stay like this forever.

Mulhollandmagoo · 03/06/2022 20:06

Right here with ya OP!!! of there is such thing as a well behaved three year old I don't have one 😭😭

TerribleThreees · 03/06/2022 20:04

itsgettingweird · 03/06/2022 19:42

I thought it was normal as this thread shows.

My ds was the most placid conforming quiet child ever. I waited through the 2's and then 3's and onto the 4's to witness this.

Everyone kept telling me it would come and I'd be shocked by his personality transplant. I was always waiting for it thinking it was normal.

It never came.

He was diagnosed as autistic at 8.

Which makes me think that his behaviour was more abnormal than the defiant independent argumentative 3 year olds most people had - and this was out clue Grin

He sounds wonderful 🙂

I too have an autistic DS, he's 4.5. Meltdowns aside (usually from sensory overload) he's a really laid back little chap.

We're as sure as we can be that DD isn't on the spectrum, although I know girls do present differently.

He's definitely the easier one!

OP posts:
TerribleThreees · 03/06/2022 20:02

JennyForeigner · 03/06/2022 19:46

Haha his other trick is to say, 'mummy, x crying. X need a PWARSTER' fake crying 'Got to go to hospical. Doctor got to ZIP x up!' fake limp staggers off down the road.

It's amazing how many toddler injuries are linked to not having jelly at mealtimes.

No way, DD is always fabricating injuries which absolutely must require a plaster or bandage immediately too 😂

There must be an unwritten script they live by that we're not aware of!

OP posts:
StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind1 · 03/06/2022 19:51

Dd was a wonderfully well behaved toddler, would hold my hand, be polite and do everything she was told.
Then she grew up......

JennyForeigner · 03/06/2022 19:46

TerribleThreees · 03/06/2022 18:16

That made me laugh because that is my DD!

Haha his other trick is to say, 'mummy, x crying. X need a PWARSTER' fake crying 'Got to go to hospical. Doctor got to ZIP x up!' fake limp staggers off down the road.

It's amazing how many toddler injuries are linked to not having jelly at mealtimes.

itsgettingweird · 03/06/2022 19:42

I thought it was normal as this thread shows.

My ds was the most placid conforming quiet child ever. I waited through the 2's and then 3's and onto the 4's to witness this.

Everyone kept telling me it would come and I'd be shocked by his personality transplant. I was always waiting for it thinking it was normal.

It never came.

He was diagnosed as autistic at 8.

Which makes me think that his behaviour was more abnormal than the defiant independent argumentative 3 year olds most people had - and this was out clue Grin

KnottyKnitting · 03/06/2022 19:40

DD1 was an angel at 3. DD2 was an absolute nightmare- Stroppy little moo who used to bite!

They then swapped and DD1 was a difficult teen whereas DD2 was very easy and laid back.

funinthesun19 · 03/06/2022 19:34

And mahoosive meltdowns to boot.

funinthesun19 · 03/06/2022 19:31

My DD is 3 and can be nightmarish too. Won’t get dressed, won’t let me do her hair, won’t eat her food, won’t hold my hand.
Today she asked for her pink shoes when she doesn’t even have any pink shoes. No paddy or anything, just absolute refusal to put any shoes on apart from the pink ones that she doesn’t have.

Don’t get me wrong. She’s absolutely wonderful too. But sheesh. 😂

TerribleThreees · 03/06/2022 19:26

NealSeal · 03/06/2022 19:22

Ooh, OP, I (apparently) was known for “see it, want it, get it!” 🙌
We are kindred spirits 😄

You have made my day 😁

OP posts:
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 03/06/2022 19:25

I’ve told this story before - but one of the worst days of my life was having to manhandle a three year old whilst pushing my newborn round a supermarket and trying to wrangle another more compliant three year old. I needed nappies so couldn’t just walk out - I ended up having to bundle him under my arm like a carpet and walk home, I was crying the whole way round the shop and going home. Just one person giving me a sympathetic look would have made me feel so much better.

Said three year old is now 13 so has a completely different set of issues (!) but it does get SO much better! Three was way worse than 2 for us.

NealSeal · 03/06/2022 19:22

Ooh, OP, I (apparently) was known for “see it, want it, get it!” 🙌
We are kindred spirits 😄

TerribleThreees · 03/06/2022 19:18

Boredom could definitely be an issue.

I try to do plenty with her like colouring, reading stories, going to the park, days out. We went to feed the ducks today before shopping to ease the burden of the dreaded food shop.

She's always 'on the go' though and looking for something new / better / more exciting. She doesn't much like playing on her own.

My DM told me that when I was around that age they used to nickname me "Have it. Want It. Touch it" and thats very fitting for DD too, she wants evvvvvvverything she sees 😬

OP posts:
NealSeal · 03/06/2022 18:58

Mine didn’t have the ‘terrible twos’ he had the ‘foul fours’
Lovely baby and toddler, easy going, good company loved sleep, naps etc…. Then… there was this horrid phase between out-growing playgroup but not quite old enough for school!!😱
He was so ghastly, I rang the school asking if they could take him earlier than the January he was 5!! The lovely lady said I wasn’t the first Mum to ring and ask/plead for help when the DCs get to that age. When my Ds finally started school, he went back to being my lovely boy again as school was stimulating and challenging for him, and got rid of the boredom.
Maybe it’s boredom for your Dc, too?

pantsandpringles · 03/06/2022 18:58

To be fair though, even though I previously mentioned the reading, toilet training etc she's actually very indapendant in other ways. She's an amazing eater and loves sushi /green beans /fruit and eats like a bloody machine since the day she discovered that food was a thing.
Like others though, i also get the "I'm not your best friend 'enny moar"whenever I've had to tell her not to do something like climb on worktops or pull everything out her wardrobe.

It's about 50/50 I guess, because for the past 3 or 4 hours she has been an absolute angel, full of cuddles and "i love you mummy".

TheRoadToRuin · 03/06/2022 18:53

DS was a monster at 3. One memorable occasion in a supermarket I refused to let him have some of the baguette that was in the trolley.
His voice was projected across the entire store.
"I want it NOW. I'm counting to three mummy. ONE, TWO, THREE"

He was delightful from 5 up and is now a lovely young man.

Iguessyourestuckwithme · 03/06/2022 18:44

There are some that already trickier than others, and that's to do with personality and also knowing what works best for that child in terms of engaging/discipline/rewards.

I am a preschool teacher and there are some children who are a delight at nursery but I know are tricky at home for parents, there are some that are not used to being told no and struggle when others try to be consistent with their behaviours and some that are just lovely however may have been a tricky baby.

There are well behaved 3 year olds in pockets of the day when they know the expectations and can keep it together there are others who just find it ever so hard to sit still or listen or follow instructions.

As long as your consistent and show there are repercussions to their behaviour that's all you can do.

TerribleThreees · 03/06/2022 18:35

Blueyandbingosmum · 03/06/2022 18:18

I think 3 is such a hard time for children, so many big feelings, yet they don't have enough language to communicate their distress.

That is what I tell myself when I am internally calling her an asshole. Today has been such a hard day here too - we drove to the countryside to give her a walk in nature but ended up just going home without even getting out of the car as she had such an epic meltdown in the car park when we arrived. While she was napping in the car I cried to my husband as I am finding motherhood so hard and unrelenting at present.

It really is isn't it? Such a thankless and unrelenting task. We're almost expected to forget we're human too whilst we commit to (what feels like a lifetime of) servitude to little people who can be quite unpleasant to us some of the time.

Know that you're not alone though and continue to lean on your DH, as PP said "this too shall pass" ❤

OP posts:
sayanythingelse · 03/06/2022 18:35

My DD started the terrible twos at 1.5 and has been hard work since. She's 4 now and super smart but stubborn, argumentative, overly emotional and has an answer for everything.

I was reading some Facebook comments where a parent was arguing with a non-parent. Parent said "ha no one's toddlers are well behaved!". Non-parent argued that all children are well behaved if they are raised properly and parent obviously just couldn't be bothered to raise her children correctly. I did have to laugh. I've parented my DD until I'm blue in the face but some DC are just plain hard work!

Fairislefandango · 03/06/2022 18:24

Mine were pretty easy. I'm under no illusions that was anything but luck though! Threenagers are the norm, I think.

TizerorFizz · 03/06/2022 18:22

DM has a “fiercely independent” child next door. It’s been very hard for her parents to do everything she wants from 0-4. But they did. The child ruled the house. Now at school! It’s all been very difficult. Getting your own way all the time at school is not going to happen. I found ‘be quiet’ and ‘no’ useful words. Not all three year olds are having tantrums and being demanding. You really have to say ‘no’ snd mean it. Plus make it clear what the consequences are. There must be some or life gets even harder.

Swipe left for the next trending thread