Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“Well it has been a long engagement, hasn’t it…”

240 replies

Chubarubrub · 03/06/2022 16:28

I saw extended family today and I got this comment.

“Well it has been a long engagement hasn’t it…”

as well as:

”Are we going to get a Wedding then or are you just going to stay engaged?”

DP and I got engaged in Feb 2020, just before COVID kicked off, we didn’t want the mess around we saw others dealing with so thought we’d wait until things improved and then would start planning.

We started looking last Christmas for venues but then decided we wanted to have the holiday of a lifetime first (for us this is a road trip across America) so started planning this instead.

This prompted an immediate negative reaction from DM who oddly took me aside and asked if ‘I’m sure that DP really wants to get married’ 😡 one of my friends actually insinuated the same, when it was a joint decision!!

We are putting off planning the Wedding now until after the Summer, which seems to have rattled some cages.

Then today I got the above comments from two separate family members, which irritated me even more.

I just laughed it off and said ‘I’m not sure why people are more obsessed with us getting married than we are’ and left it at that, apparently that was rude, but I’m so annoyed:

  1. Was that rude?
  2. Is this really such a looong engagement? Especially with the pandemic etc. (I know lots of people got married but it was our choice to wait)
  3. Even if it is, who’s business is it except ours?
  4. Why do some people assume that the decision isn’t mine and that I’m not a woman who can equally make decisions with DP.
  5. ”are WE going to get a wedding?” ?? But it’s not about you. Why don’t you get married - for the fourth time. (Ok I thought this, I didn’t say it)
Actually I’m not sure what my AIBU is about, I’m just annoyed.

Why are people so obsessed with when other people get married or whether they get married at all. Also strangely, every question has been put to me, because obviously as the woman I’m the one just dying to get married and if we are not it means DP doesn’t want to… not that we both decided this as a team.

I thought this was 2022 not 1922?

OP posts:
Starseeking · 03/06/2022 20:12

I'm speaking as someone who was engaged for 5 years, and eventually left my EXDP after the 7 year relationship as the excuses to delay the wedding were getting more and more ridiculous. I could have accepted that if he'd explained the change of heart, and the relationship was otherwise perfect, however he'd turned horribly emotionally abusive so it was an easy decision for me to make.

To me an engagement is no more of a commitment than living together, or being a boyfriend and girlfriend living apart, if you're not actively planning the wedding, or have a date set. I really don't see the point. I wouldn't ask anyone about it though, I would just think it was a bit odd to myself.

Stroopwaffle5000 · 03/06/2022 20:10

I've been engaged for 11 years, but 2 children later and I just can't bring myself to spend money on a wedding, I'd rather spend it on a holiday to Disney World for all of us. We keep talking about just popping to the registry office, but never seem to get around to it. I wish we could fill out a form online and bam, suddenly be married! 🤣

BeatricePortinari · 03/06/2022 20:10

If you don't want people asking you about your wedding plans don't get engaged and announce it.

Once you announce you are getting married people will want to talk about it.

Announcing an engagement, expecting congtaultions and excitment, and then saying, yeah we just meant one vague day in sometime in the future, is seeking attention then wanting it dropped.

If you are going to get married one vague day in the future, no need to announce that as an engagemnt, just know that yourselves, and then tell everyone when you are actually going to get married.

Long engagements are pointless and demand something publically from others they don't then deliver on.

RedToothBrush · 03/06/2022 20:06

We were engaged for 10 years before we got around to it.

Then we just fucked off and didn't invite anyone cos we were so fucked off at the lot of them!

Coffeetree · 03/06/2022 20:02

Chubarubrub · 03/06/2022 17:29

Why are people saying we aren’t planning a wedding, we will, but after the holiday.

Not sure how, we will start planning after the holiday has turned into, we aren’t planning at all.

I get that you're feeling got at, but if you talk about "We will start planning," that means you aren't planning now

Sorry but to most people hearing about an engagement, the logical follow up is, "Congratulations, when's the wedding?" And if the answer is a long explanation then yeah, I'd think the couple were having second thoughts.

I hasten to add that I wouldn't say anything to you in public but if you were a close friend I'd have quiet word.

over2021 · 03/06/2022 19:59

I'm not a granny (35) but to me announcing an engagement is announcing that you're going to get married so I think it's reasonable for people to ask when that might be!

Wor · 03/06/2022 19:59

I’ve seen soooo many threads on here where the woman posts because she’s been engaged for many years, bought a house together and had kids but the DP basically refuses to get married and she feels shocked and tricked and the relationship begins to crumble.

Two years is a long engagement. I totally get the covid thing, but it is weird that you aren’t even planning the wedding even if itnis for 2024, and seem more interested in a holiday.

Yabu to be surprised that your family want to check if you’re being strung along / have got cold feet / if there is some problem eg financial that’s preventing the wedding.

EinsteinaGogo · 03/06/2022 19:57

maddy68 · 03/06/2022 16:41

It's not rude it's conversation

I think @maddy68 has it - aren't people just being pleasant and trying to take an interest?

If you were in my circle I might ask 'have you set a date yet' if i saw you.

ladygindiva · 03/06/2022 19:55

Yanbu. Got engaged Xmas 2019. Then covid caused unemployment which caused financial and other worries which we are still sorting out. We have literally put it on the back burner and wish people would mind their own fucking business!

Coffeetree · 03/06/2022 19:54

Chubarubrub · 03/06/2022 16:53

It’s curious that both your mum and your friend have picked up a vibe that your DP might not really want to get married.

I think they assume every woman is dying to get married asap, so if we aren’t doing that, it can’t be me, has to be DP.

Well it's the woman whose fertile years are limited, and who typcally suffers financially if babies happen before marriage, so yes it's the woman who typically gets disadvantaged by a long/indefinite engagement. A good friend and mum should take you aside and make sure nothing is awry.

But equally they should accept your answer.

Aunt Mavis however can go fuck herself.

Supersimkin2 · 03/06/2022 19:54

Don’t let it worry you.

It has.

Most people are just making conversation.

Sometimes they’re just tactless. I’ve lost count of the amount of weddings I’ve been to where the bride’s rolled up in full meringue mode surrounded by her groom, large children and practically GC to be greeted by ‘we didn’t think you’d bother’. A bit deflating but not unkindly meant.

WimbyAce · 03/06/2022 19:53

With us after we got engaged we went down the trying for children route which ended up taking a fricking long time and in the end money too. We now need any spare money for a house move. Add to that the thought of organising a wedding is my idea of hell but I don't think the families would appreciate us eloping on our own (with the kids) so I have no idea when it will happen! People stopped asking us a long time ago so no pressure!

Kanaloa · 03/06/2022 19:46

Some people are engaged years. Personally I think it’s a bit daft - I think the next step after engaged is planning, wedding, then marriage. However, we had a pretty small wedding. Some people want to save up for a big wedding but in that case I probably wouldn’t announce it until it was closer to the time I was going to actually get married. For me being engaged for ages and ages is just a bit pointless - just the whole thing of announcing ‘oh we’re engaged, we’re going to get married… in about 5 years.’

But if it works for you just tell people when they ask ‘we aren’t getting married soon, we’ll tell you when we know when the wedding is.’ I think it’s just people making conversation since you’re engaged. The same way some relatives will always annoyingly ask single people ‘so do you have a boyfriend/girlfriend yet?’

Blackopal · 03/06/2022 19:46

I was engaged for 10 years, my choice.
Although, it was interesting that people seem to make jokes that I hadn't managed to get him down the aisle.

People are full of comments, really isn't a good idea to give many of them any headspace.

ShirleyPhallus · 03/06/2022 19:45

BlackAmericanoNoSugar · 03/06/2022 18:09

Since being engaged is fairly meaningless (in as much as you can be engaged and never get married, or get married without ever getting engaged), you could always WhatsApp everyone with "Following a lot of comments about the excessive length of our engagement, we have agreed to cancel the engagement for now. We are still together, just moving at our own pace not extended family's desired pace." Then, when you're ready, book a wedding and send out invitations.

This may be the worst piece of advice I’ve seen on here… what a way to get the gossip going!!

bakewellbride · 03/06/2022 19:44

I really don't think a 2 year engagement is long at all. Ours was 3 years and we didn't plan anything until just over the 2 year mark. No-one said anything.

I know of a couple who were engaged for 8 years and have now been happily married for a good few.

sueelleker · 03/06/2022 19:44

CatSeany · 03/06/2022 18:56

We've been engaged since 2018 and nobody even bothers to ask about a wedding anymore. I think that they know that we would like to get married, but they know that we can't afford a big wedding, and they don't want us to have a modest one (they made that very clear early on) and they don't want to financially contribute. Sooooo it's completely ignored by everyone now.

Re. your family. Yes, they were rude. When you do plan your wedding then absolutely plan it for yourselves, not for anyone else. It isn't a particularly long engagement I don't think. With costs these days, a lot of people need at least a couple of years to save up for a wedding, especially if they're also saving for a home. Then a year or so to plan... it all makes sense. And questioning if he still wants to marry you is just awful!

So they want you to have a big wedding but don't want to pay for it? If they're not making a financial contribution, they have no say in the matter. It's like insisting you buy a Mercedes when you've only got the money for a Mini.

BrylcreamBeret · 03/06/2022 19:42

It's hilarious op and as proof that you can't please fucking anyone, I got engaged after six months but didn't get married for another 2 years and we had people telling us that was way too soon to be married whilst in the same breathe asking when we would have kids 🙄

NeverDropYourMooncup · 03/06/2022 19:42

Carrotten · 03/06/2022 16:31

Because you are engaged? You've essentially told them all you are getting married and then aren't getting married, they are probably excited

I would say that over 2 years of being engaged without even starting to plan suggests one of you doesn't actually want to get married.

It's about six years here.

Redundancies without payouts, bereavement, further job insecurity - paying the rent for the next 12 months is more of a priority than registry office fees and the like.

Paigeworkerx · 03/06/2022 19:41

I love the MN options, I wonder if these people would be the basis for an English version of stepford housewives.

My mum and dad where engaged for 8 years. Had me and my brother in the middle of being engaged and married.

Auntie and Uncle engaged 14 years.

Both ended up with low key beach weddings abroad with limited guests.

Announcing your wedding doesn’t open you up to assumption for every man/dog/family member would be invited. Weddings can be expensive, there is a backlog due to covid and I’ve found some don’t aren’t as special when they’re back to back with another.

People are rude! I’m single and a man at the gym told me if I don’t hurry up I’ll be forever alone due to being to old to bare children. I’m 24 for gods sake.

LadyApplejack · 03/06/2022 19:41

I think 2 years is quite a long time to not even begin the planning. If it was a funding or practical issue most people get it, but wanting a holiday doesn't just sound like much of a reason to put it off. Loads of people have long engagements for various reasons, it's nothing new. But I do see why you'd get a few comments.

Letterasaurus · 03/06/2022 19:31

No idea why people bother getting engaged or married but if that's your thing, it's nobody's business but yours and your partners. Everyone else should keep their nose out and certainly not comment.

romany4 · 03/06/2022 19:25

I was engaged for 6 years before we finally got married.else
Fuck all to do with anyone else

Perplexed0522 · 03/06/2022 19:25

Why don’t you just set a date? That will pacify them.

Look at venues, set a date and then go on holiday.

Both can be done simultaneously.

As many others have said, why wouldn’t you just book your trip to America as your honeymoon?

mam0918 · 03/06/2022 19:24

Are you really having this issue?

I was engaged 5 years before booking then it was postponed 2 years due to covid.

My best friend was engaged for 10 years then broke up and got engaged to someone else in less than a year.

Another friend was engaged 12 years then got married.

A family member was engaged 30 YEARS before getting married.

Another family member has been together 35 years engaged 6 and has no actual plans of getting married.

On the flip side my parents, my other best friend and my BIL/SIL got engaged and married in under 1 month.

Theres no right or wrong way but non of us where harrassed about getting married, honestly virtually no one mentions it.

People are pretty bored by weddings, have their own lives and any convosation is usually just them trying to make polite small talk they dont 'actually' care.

You'll see how little people care when trying to get your RSVPs back lol.