Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why clothes aren't more expensive in bigger sizes

240 replies

mrsfoof · 03/06/2022 15:57

If you buy children's clothes, you'll have probably noticed that you have to pay a good few quid more for a T-shirt in age 12 than you would for the exact same T-shirt in age 5. Fair enough, the bigger size uses a lot more fabric.

Why then, is a size 24 ladies' T-shirt the same price as the same T-shirt in a size 6, despite it using a lot more - maybe even twice as much - fabric?

Would people be more motivated to stay a healthy weight if they had to pay more for bigger clothes? Why don't we charge more for bigger clothes? Are the prices based on the average amount of fabric used - so skinny people pay more and very large people pay less than they should do based on the resources used to make their clothes?

FWIW I'm marginally overweight and wouldn't have a problem paying more for my size 14 than a 6. I think it would motivate me to lose some weight if the size 10 was cheaper though!

OP posts:
yesthatisdrizzle · 03/06/2022 19:03

mrsfoof · 03/06/2022 17:36

So (and this is a genuine question, not to suggest that you're wrong), why do they charge different prices for kids' clothes depending on size? In the example I posted earlier, the top is £9 for age 4 and £14 for age 13+. I always assumed this was because bigger sizes = higher costs to make, but if this isn't the case, why do they do it?

Because they have been doing it for years and getting away with it.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 03/06/2022 19:00

ForestFae · 03/06/2022 16:22

This just seems like fat shaming, and spiteful at that. If it makes you feel better OP, busty women have to pay more for bras than smaller chested women

Doesn't it just? A disingenuous OP scouting for likeminded chums to froth with... what a rarity that is!

mrsfoof · 03/06/2022 18:57

Fairislefandango · 03/06/2022 18:46

I don't think it's fat-shaming merely to ask the question, so I don't see why it was necessary to pile onto the OP to such an extent. The answer to the question is clearly that there are practical and economic reasons, as has been explained by several posters.

Thank you 😊

OP posts:
User487216 · 03/06/2022 18:56

OP seems to think size 10 is midsize because that is what she aspires to

JuneJubilee · 03/06/2022 18:54

Quincythequince · 03/06/2022 18:46

And anyway, most things don’t concern most people so regardless, it’s still a ridiculous phrase in the context of a discussion forum.

And THIS is why many of us didn't want 'quoting'

🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄

@mrsfoof twat is another slang word the same as foof.

FlumpyLump · 03/06/2022 18:54

Trainfromredhill · 03/06/2022 18:43

There are many reasons people are fat, absolutely none are your business

whilst my taxes are paying for all the treatment they get/will get on the NHS it totally is my business. There is literally nothing positive about being overweight and we need to stop normalising it.

You know why I'm fat?
I eat too much. I sit on my arse shoving my face until I feel sick and then cry afterwards.
I do this because I can't actually cope with the world.
I have numerous mental health problems which go unchecked by the NHS because mental healthcare is non existent.
I have been let down in my life by people who were supposed to protect and help me. GP's, Mental Health, Police, Criminal Justice system, hell even my own family at times.
I just get chucked another pill.
"Take these pills that do nothing and go away."
I'm left with a fragmented brain that needs repairing but there isn't anything available.
So I eat. Makes no sense to other people, but it's the only constant in my life sometimes.
Don't worry though, I don't really leave the house so my fat self isn't going to cross your path anytime soon and repulse you.

Maxineputyourredshoeson1 · 03/06/2022 18:49

Would people be more motivated to stay a healthy weight if they had to pay more for bigger clothes?

Not everyone is overweight because they aren’t motivated. I became very overweight in my early 30’s after I became disabled, I’m now in my 40’s. The medications I took and the vast difference in my mobility meant that the weight just piled on despite eating less than before and being a size 8-10 from my late teens.

I lost 6 stone after a medication change, I then put another 2 stone back on after an adjustment to my meds. I’ve been working my arse off and have lost 17lbs. I have been working alongside my physio so that I can exercise without causing myself further pain etc but I know if my meds have to change I can put the weight back on through no fault of my own.

I have clothes from size 8 to 24. I live on benefits any clothes I buy are cheap, usually second hand because I simply can’t afford expensive clothes. So I guess in that respect plus size being more expensive in shops wouldn’t impact me so much.

Beeday · 03/06/2022 18:49

Quincythequince · 03/06/2022 18:42

I understand supply and demand. You have just confirms that single, and or smaller people are disproportionately charged more simply due to there being fewer of them.

I’m not even saying that bigger clothes should cost more, but I don’t think it’s an unreasonable question.

Smaller people are being charged exactly the same, that's the point. I don't know how you got that they're being charged more for there being fewer. They're charged the same because to a retailer everyone, large or small, is one person that needs clothes so will be charged the same price to encourage as many sales as possible.(But yes, single people using a single duvet alone are usually paying more than a person in a couple sharing a double duvet).

Trainfromredhill · 03/06/2022 18:47

@ForestFae i don’t feel any ownership over their bodies at all. But I totally reserve the right to judge them.

Quincythequince · 03/06/2022 18:47

Fairislefandango · 03/06/2022 18:46

I don't think it's fat-shaming merely to ask the question, so I don't see why it was necessary to pile onto the OP to such an extent. The answer to the question is clearly that there are practical and economic reasons, as has been explained by several posters.

The Most sensible response on here so far.

Quincythequince · 03/06/2022 18:46

Quincythequince · 03/06/2022 18:45

We can agree to disagree on that.
It was a very popular figure of speech when I was younger, and intended to mean ‘enough’ with no opportunity for response, or else.

I hear it infrequently to be honest as it’s an inelegant phrase. But there you go - we’re all different.

And anyway, most things don’t concern most people so regardless, it’s still a ridiculous phrase in the context of a discussion forum.

Fairislefandango · 03/06/2022 18:46

I don't think it's fat-shaming merely to ask the question, so I don't see why it was necessary to pile onto the OP to such an extent. The answer to the question is clearly that there are practical and economic reasons, as has been explained by several posters.

Quincythequince · 03/06/2022 18:45

ForestFae · 03/06/2022 18:39

Telling someone to butt out isn’t aggressive - “fuck off” might be, but butt out is just saying stop involving yourself in something that doesn’t concern you.

We can agree to disagree on that.
It was a very popular figure of speech when I was younger, and intended to mean ‘enough’ with no opportunity for response, or else.

I hear it infrequently to be honest as it’s an inelegant phrase. But there you go - we’re all different.

ForestFae · 03/06/2022 18:45

Trainfromredhill · 03/06/2022 18:43

There are many reasons people are fat, absolutely none are your business

whilst my taxes are paying for all the treatment they get/will get on the NHS it totally is my business. There is literally nothing positive about being overweight and we need to stop normalising it.

They’re not “your taxes”, taxes are the price of living in a civilised society. It’s amazing how people feel ownership over other peoples bodies because you contribute to the society that we live in, and likely use far more than you put in anyway. Ridiculous comment.

Trainfromredhill · 03/06/2022 18:43

There are many reasons people are fat, absolutely none are your business

whilst my taxes are paying for all the treatment they get/will get on the NHS it totally is my business. There is literally nothing positive about being overweight and we need to stop normalising it.

Quincythequince · 03/06/2022 18:42

Beeday · 03/06/2022 18:39

You're failing to see the simple supply and demand issue. A set number of people will always need duvet covers or tents, so if they're selling single/1-man ones (2 per 2 people) they're going to be able to sell more than if 2 people are sharing a double/2-man (1 per 2 people), so they need to make the smaller one cheaper to match selling more of them (else everyone will buy the bigger one and be miffed about it). It's not to cover material used, that would be pennies difference, it's for the difference in profit!

Whereas with clothes, two size 8 women are never going to buy size 22 clothing and go round wearing it together! So there's no advantage in charging more for bigger sizes unless your business model is to attract thinner women with cheaper clothing as some retailers do. Most though need large women's money as much as smaller women's so will have the same price regardless of size.

I understand supply and demand. You have just confirms that single, and or smaller people are disproportionately charged more simply due to there being fewer of them.

I’m not even saying that bigger clothes should cost more, but I don’t think it’s an unreasonable question.

User487216 · 03/06/2022 18:40

LilacPoppy · 03/06/2022 18:32

@User487216 Unfortunately with my height and bone structure I am never likely to be a size 10 in OPs motivational world being tall doesn’t stop you from being midsize and bones don’t define dress size.

I'm size 14, my BMI is 21.5 so I am not overweight, even when it was under 20 I was still a size12-14, I'm 5'11

Beeday · 03/06/2022 18:39

Quincythequince · 03/06/2022 18:13

Why is this fat shaming?
I don’t see how it is at all.

Lets take something larger that isn’t about a persons size explicitly.

Duvet covers.
Festival tents (1 man v 2 man for example).
Sleeping bags.

The bigger ones all cost more. Substantially more.

So why not for clothes?

It’s a fair question

You're failing to see the simple supply and demand issue. A set number of people will always need duvet covers or tents, so if they're selling single/1-man ones (2 per 2 people) they're going to be able to sell more than if 2 people are sharing a double/2-man (1 per 2 people), so they need to make the smaller one cheaper to match selling more of them (else everyone will buy the bigger one and be miffed about it). It's not to cover material used, that would be pennies difference, it's for the difference in profit!

Whereas with clothes, two size 8 women are never going to buy size 22 clothing and go round wearing it together! So there's no advantage in charging more for bigger sizes unless your business model is to attract thinner women with cheaper clothing as some retailers do. Most though need large women's money as much as smaller women's so will have the same price regardless of size.

ForestFae · 03/06/2022 18:39

Quincythequince · 03/06/2022 18:36

‘Butt out’ in Canadian discourse is intended to mean ‘this stops now’

Well it clearly doesn’t, and it’s an incredibly aggressive, ill-reasoned, visceral response.

The nationally i neither here nor there - I just recognise it from foreign discourse.

It’s maybe similar to that brilliant phrase ‘do one’ which I don’t think many people use.

Telling someone to butt out isn’t aggressive - “fuck off” might be, but butt out is just saying stop involving yourself in something that doesn’t concern you.

Quincythequince · 03/06/2022 18:38

Nobody says ‘butt out’ calmly. Not IME

Quincythequince · 03/06/2022 18:36

ForestFae · 03/06/2022 18:32

What’s visceral about saying “it’s not your business”? Also un-British? What’s anyone’s nationality got to do with this discussion? What a strange response.

‘Butt out’ in Canadian discourse is intended to mean ‘this stops now’

Well it clearly doesn’t, and it’s an incredibly aggressive, ill-reasoned, visceral response.

The nationally i neither here nor there - I just recognise it from foreign discourse.

It’s maybe similar to that brilliant phrase ‘do one’ which I don’t think many people use.

Georgyporky · 03/06/2022 18:36

Part of the reason is VAT. Some children's clothing is exempt, there's a set of measurements that is a watershed.

As others have said, the cost of material is a minor part.

Lipsandlashes · 03/06/2022 18:33

Oh good! A “fat bastards deserve it” thread for a bank holiday. Slow clap OP

ForestFae · 03/06/2022 18:32

Quincythequince · 03/06/2022 18:29

Yes well people can speak for themselves can’t they.

I work with very seriously obese people, who could rightly feel persecute by this, but they wouldn’t respond as viscerally as you have

Nobody’s health is anybody’s business of course not, but if aspects of this become prevalent In various day to day dealings (clothing size and costs, airplane seat sizes etc) people can and will reasonably ask.

You do sound defensive but you don’t speak for all, and certainly not half the patients I have ever seen. A neutral fact giving exchange is so much bette than your very un-British ‘butt out’

What’s visceral about saying “it’s not your business”? Also un-British? What’s anyone’s nationality got to do with this discussion? What a strange response.

LilacPoppy · 03/06/2022 18:32

@User487216 Unfortunately with my height and bone structure I am never likely to be a size 10 in OPs motivational world being tall doesn’t stop you from being midsize and bones don’t define dress size.