Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why clothes aren't more expensive in bigger sizes

240 replies

mrsfoof · 03/06/2022 15:57

If you buy children's clothes, you'll have probably noticed that you have to pay a good few quid more for a T-shirt in age 12 than you would for the exact same T-shirt in age 5. Fair enough, the bigger size uses a lot more fabric.

Why then, is a size 24 ladies' T-shirt the same price as the same T-shirt in a size 6, despite it using a lot more - maybe even twice as much - fabric?

Would people be more motivated to stay a healthy weight if they had to pay more for bigger clothes? Why don't we charge more for bigger clothes? Are the prices based on the average amount of fabric used - so skinny people pay more and very large people pay less than they should do based on the resources used to make their clothes?

FWIW I'm marginally overweight and wouldn't have a problem paying more for my size 14 than a 6. I think it would motivate me to lose some weight if the size 10 was cheaper though!

OP posts:
newname12345 · 04/06/2022 13:58

HoppingPavlova · 04/06/2022 13:14

This is a weird concept. Look at the average man’s vs woman’s clothes. Generally men are considerably taller and more fabric is used but in general a woman’s top would cost three times what a man’s would cost. Just look at the price difference between our undies and the material used there!

Same with shoes, a strappy pair of womens shoes with a few bits of leather holding it together will always be significantly more expensive than a larger full leather man’s shoe.

Weird how OP is concentrating on a premise that fat people should pay more then slim people and not that by default all men’s clothing should be much more expensive than women’s. Hmmmmm

The thing is like for like women's clothing is not more expensive than men's clothing. For example men's basic underwear (from a supermarket, next, etc) costs a lot more than women's basic underwear from the same retailer, and a full leather women's shoe costs the same as a men's shoe.

Where women's clothes do cost more it is due to the design costs, quality of material and increased manufacturing costs because of the increased complexity and/or smaller numbers produced.

dottiedodah · 04/06/2022 13:40

Maybe larger ladies may not want to go shopping with their skinny friend ,and end up paying more for their large size ?Over half of women in UK size 16 or above! (Including me at s 16!)Usually in Sales /Charity shops ,lots of bargains to be had for s 8/10 less at other end! I imagine a range of dresses is priced somewhere in the middle!

Nothingiseverything · 04/06/2022 13:27

I think you should pay for what you get just like with everything else. We pay for what is in our trolleys at the supermarket and don't just pay for the average trolley. Should be the same with clothes and shoes.

HoppingPavlova · 04/06/2022 13:14

This is a weird concept. Look at the average man’s vs woman’s clothes. Generally men are considerably taller and more fabric is used but in general a woman’s top would cost three times what a man’s would cost. Just look at the price difference between our undies and the material used there!

Same with shoes, a strappy pair of womens shoes with a few bits of leather holding it together will always be significantly more expensive than a larger full leather man’s shoe.

Weird how OP is concentrating on a premise that fat people should pay more then slim people and not that by default all men’s clothing should be much more expensive than women’s. Hmmmmm

Quincythequince · 04/06/2022 13:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Salons near me do.

They charge more generally if you’re very hairy too. Or in other words, if you pretty hairless, they charge less abs give a reasonable discount.

They are using way less wax and taking way less time, why should it cost the same? I get why they do it.

Pandaeyes50 · 04/06/2022 12:58

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-4085886/The-size-4-slightly-smug-club-tips-women-stay-slim.html

Sorry for DM link but yeah only eating once a day and consuming 1000 calories a day is healthier than a size 12. Really?

LookItsMeAgain · 04/06/2022 11:42

Georgyporky · 03/06/2022 18:36

Part of the reason is VAT. Some children's clothing is exempt, there's a set of measurements that is a watershed.

As others have said, the cost of material is a minor part.

This.

This is why the retailers do their graded costs to the customer.

Only this.

As VAT is applied to adults clothes and shoes, it appears to be agreed that a flat cost per garment will be applied irrespective of the size.

But really, OP, way to go on the fat shaming, big busted shaming and basically everything shaming thread you posted.

I noticed you have turned off the option to vote? Why would that be I wonder???

OneTC · 04/06/2022 11:35

Was speaking to a manager in Black's or Millets and he told me that the reason they don't keep sizes other than the most popular (ie no really small or really large) is because they both cost more than the most popular sizes and they incur the wrath of management if they end up with excess stock in the highest cost items

erinaceus · 04/06/2022 11:35

42isthemeaning · 04/06/2022 11:14

So, what I'm taking from this is that the clothes companies shouldn't be charging more for the same kids' clothes in bigger sizes?
And as for kids' shoes? They don't have VAT added, so why are they so expensive? More expensive than the shoes I'd buy for myself!
Topic for a different thread, but still!

I read the other day, that kids shoes are only VAT exempt up to size 5.5 for girls or 6.5 for boys.

erinaceus · 04/06/2022 11:33

mrsfoof · 03/06/2022 17:36

So (and this is a genuine question, not to suggest that you're wrong), why do they charge different prices for kids' clothes depending on size? In the example I posted earlier, the top is £9 for age 4 and £14 for age 13+. I always assumed this was because bigger sizes = higher costs to make, but if this isn't the case, why do they do it?

I always assumed that this was more of a supply-and-demand thing, that parents are willing to pay more for older childrens' clothing and that is why it costs more. Until you get into the realms of luxury fabric, the quantity of fabric and time taken to assemble would have very little bearing on the price to consumers.

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 04/06/2022 11:29

Don't forget that we've lost sight of what's healthy

Wonderedhow long it would take to spout this line.

ForestFae · 04/06/2022 11:29

mrsfoof · 04/06/2022 10:33

Is this directed at me? I have no idea and the original question I asked didn't really relate to being healthy. I'm not suggesting that they 'tax' overweight people by charging more for their clothes to make them lose weight. I was asking why smaller clothes aren't cheaper than bigger ones as I assumed they'd cost less to make.

But if I had to guess at whether size 4 (old size 8 based on 1980s / 90s clothes measurements before vanity sizing was a thing) is healthier than a size 12 (size 16 in older measurements), I'd say yes if you're below average height, probably not if you're on the tall side and 'maybe' if you're average. Don't forget that we've lost sight of what's healthy. Just because size 16-18 is average size nowadays, it doesn't mean that it's the right size. For most people (not all), wearing clothes that size would mean that they're obese.

When I was a size 8-10, I had an eating disorder and had no energy, was struggling to get out of bed. My BMI was something like 20 - I looked skeletal, despite never being underweight. I had that head too large for my body look. I’m now a 12-14, no idea what my weight or BMI is - I can get out of bed no problem, I no longer have vitamin deficiencies. So I highly doubt that for most people, a 4 is healthier than a 12.

42isthemeaning · 04/06/2022 11:14

So, what I'm taking from this is that the clothes companies shouldn't be charging more for the same kids' clothes in bigger sizes?
And as for kids' shoes? They don't have VAT added, so why are they so expensive? More expensive than the shoes I'd buy for myself!
Topic for a different thread, but still!

Merryclaire · 04/06/2022 10:43

“we've lost sight of what's healthy”

Classic MN quote! So predictable. Next you’ll be going on about portion sizes and how 1,000 calories a day is more than enough.

You’ve admitted you’re fat yourself - so why don’t you stop judging others? Or are you just that full of self-hate?

mrsfoof · 04/06/2022 10:33

autienotnaughty · 04/06/2022 06:00

Do you think being a size 4 is healthier that a 12?

Is this directed at me? I have no idea and the original question I asked didn't really relate to being healthy. I'm not suggesting that they 'tax' overweight people by charging more for their clothes to make them lose weight. I was asking why smaller clothes aren't cheaper than bigger ones as I assumed they'd cost less to make.

But if I had to guess at whether size 4 (old size 8 based on 1980s / 90s clothes measurements before vanity sizing was a thing) is healthier than a size 12 (size 16 in older measurements), I'd say yes if you're below average height, probably not if you're on the tall side and 'maybe' if you're average. Don't forget that we've lost sight of what's healthy. Just because size 16-18 is average size nowadays, it doesn't mean that it's the right size. For most people (not all), wearing clothes that size would mean that they're obese.

OP posts:
FirewomanSam · 04/06/2022 07:29

I was speaking for myself (I'm overweight) when I said maybe it would be motivating. I genuinely think that I would be more motivated to lose weight if clothes were a few £ cheaper in smaller sizes, or if I could get cheaper seats on a plane or whatever. I appreciate not everyone would feel the same.

’Incentivising’ people to lose weight doesn’t work. Obese people already know that society looks down on them, and have to put up with all sorts of crap because of their size. They know that they’d have a much easier time and probably be treated far more kindly by many people if they were slimmer. They also already know that their health might be better (in some cases, not all) if they weren’t overweight. Those are two pretty big incentives to lose weight. But sure, the possibility of saving a couple of quid on a t-shirt is what’s finally going to motivate people to do it.

There are many many reasons why someone might be overweight and why they might not be actively losing weight at any given time, but a lack of ‘incentives’ is not one of them.

autienotnaughty · 04/06/2022 06:00

Do you think being a size 4 is healthier that a 12?

Pandaeyes50 · 04/06/2022 05:44

Same old shit on these types of threads. Let's make life as difficult as possible for these lazy obese people who are a drain on the NHS and make thrm feel more shit than they already probably do. . That will motivate them to lose weight. Well no it will probably have the reverse effect.
Fuck off. I am currently a size 20. I don't want to be a size 20 but I am suffering from depression and low mood due to external factors.When things were more stable and I wasn't so stressed. Anxious and depressed I lost weight. Still overweight just. Yet since lockdown my kids MH has taken a nosedive with inverse correlation with my weight.
I have been spectacularly let down by the NHS prescribing wrong meds leaving me with months of unnecessary pain. I have had diddly squat help with my low mood but my size 10 friend was automatically given drugs. So much prejudice in NHS with obesity. Excuse of a GP who funked up my meds seemed quite disappointed I wasn't diabetic and than suggested I fo a little exercise. Is 56KM continuous not enough for for you?
Same GP was convinced bloods were wrong or it must be down to meds when DH came out as pre diabetic. He is the one who needs to actually do a little exercise but as far as they know he is normal weight so must be ok. OK he is only that weight because he only eats one meal
Per day and no fruit or veg in sight.

RamblingEclectic · 03/06/2022 22:22

LilacPoppy · 03/06/2022 18:32

@User487216 Unfortunately with my height and bone structure I am never likely to be a size 10 in OPs motivational world being tall doesn’t stop you from being midsize and bones don’t define dress size.

Bone structure can affect clothes size. I have two children who are identical in height and we can see both of their hip bones, but they wear different size clothes because one has broader hips and shoulders.

They can just about share shirts, but only if they're baggy on the narrower one, and they can't share trousers or skirts -- ones that fit the broader one falls off the other. They're just very different shapes.

That's kinda the thing - two people can be the same height and a similar healthy weight and still be wearing different size clothes (before getting into how clothes size varies) entirely on body type. My husband and older son are about the same height, one has a long torso and short legs, the other is the other way around so they'd need entirely different clothes, whatever they weigh - their skeletons are very different.

Part of all of this is 'because companies decided it worked best for them'. With industrialization as it's developed, the components stopped being the biggest factor in this a long time ago. Tax on adult clothes, corporate wants and image are a bigger contributor to price. However, there are a lot of factors in clothes sizes and cost to manufacture beyond what someone's BMI is. I have shirts I bought when I was 25 kilos lighter (very underweight at the time) that still fit because of how I carry weight. Having clothes be cheaper when I was underweight wouldn't really have done much for me to healthy...

Iloveychildrenandmydoggie · 03/06/2022 22:19

PixieLaLa · 03/06/2022 20:02

You keep banging on and on about the kids clothing example but retailers can get away with charging a bit more when the ages go up because kids grow and this isn’t seen as discrimination. What your suggesting would be discrimination.

Do you also think they should charge more for maternity clothing? An incentive not to contribute to over population perhaps?
Or how about adults with larger feet?

Thong styled underwear and swimwear, should that be encouraged too?
Oh yes let’s start weighing people at airports and they can pay more for their plane tickets. Why stop there? Buses, trains. What a delightful thread.

Agree wholeheartedly with you pixie…let’s get on the scales at the airport!!

TangyTangerine · 03/06/2022 22:16

Saltyandvinegar · 03/06/2022 21:09

Completely agree. Things that cost per volume should be charged by volume. No idea why you get an extra 5 kg of body weight free but have to pay for baggage. Combined weight IMHO

Feel free to suggest to vendors then to charge a few pence more for larger items (as the fabric cost won't be that much) but also ask them to offer a discount based on demand, reduced complexity and wastage for larger sizes.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 03/06/2022 22:13

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 03/06/2022 16:27

Hardly if you are a size 14 as you say.

I'm sure the OP knows whether, or not, she is overweight. I'd definitely be overweight if I was a 14.

TangyTangerine · 03/06/2022 22:13

The cost of the fabric is negligible compared to the other costs. I assume they charge more for older kids just because they want to.

And no it's a horrible idea. I doubt anyone is overweight or obese because they have too much money. You come across as fat shaming and as if you want a medal for being a fairly standard size (even if overweight..)

Popsicle33 · 03/06/2022 22:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Doyoumind · 03/06/2022 22:05

If you think it's either necessary or such a good idea, OP, then yes, why aren't they more expensive? Could it be that retailers understand the market far better than you and know it doesn't make commercial sense to charge bigger people more?