Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why clothes aren't more expensive in bigger sizes

240 replies

mrsfoof · 03/06/2022 15:57

If you buy children's clothes, you'll have probably noticed that you have to pay a good few quid more for a T-shirt in age 12 than you would for the exact same T-shirt in age 5. Fair enough, the bigger size uses a lot more fabric.

Why then, is a size 24 ladies' T-shirt the same price as the same T-shirt in a size 6, despite it using a lot more - maybe even twice as much - fabric?

Would people be more motivated to stay a healthy weight if they had to pay more for bigger clothes? Why don't we charge more for bigger clothes? Are the prices based on the average amount of fabric used - so skinny people pay more and very large people pay less than they should do based on the resources used to make their clothes?

FWIW I'm marginally overweight and wouldn't have a problem paying more for my size 14 than a 6. I think it would motivate me to lose some weight if the size 10 was cheaper though!

OP posts:
MountainClimber22 · 04/06/2022 23:03

I was a size 8 after having my son (had depression and didn't eat) I'm now a size 16 and would pay more for a bigger size. I've thought this myself actually.

XenoBitch · 04/06/2022 22:22

Sometimes they are. If you buy made to measure clothing from a small business, they will likely charge you more than if you were a smaller size.

jcyclops · 04/06/2022 22:20

On a typical t-shirt the sales price (excluding VAT/sales tax) is broken down thus:

Materials - 7%
Design & Manufacture - 14%
Duty - 2%
Warehouse - 11%
Freight - 8%
Mark-Up - 58%

...so the difference for a t-shirt using 50% more material would be negligible in comparison to the sales price.

mrsfoof · 04/06/2022 19:20

GregoryRowling · 04/06/2022 16:25

Love all the comments from people with no actual knowledge of clothing manufacturing! Most large retailers buy their clothing direct from factories (based on the design and spec of the retailer). Many of these lines will have a point or 2 within the price range that has a step up in cost and there fore a reduction in margin on larger sizes for the retailer. Sometimes the factory will make this clear and have stepped changes on other occasions they will spread the cost against the price of all sizes. The cost difference still exists. None of the retailers I know pass this cost on to the higher size they just insure they hit their margin across the range, so this means an inflated margin on the smaller sizes to balance out the bigger lower margin sizes.
A different way to have this conversation is to think about that… Why is it ok for smaller people to contribute more than their larger counterparts to the retailers margins?

Thank you. Interesting insight there.

OP posts:
PavlovaTescobar · 04/06/2022 18:39

@NeverDropYourMooncup unkind, mean or spiteful are not physical characteristics, so I’m not sure what you are talking about. The opposite of fat is thin, that’s a good word to use to describe non fat women and men. Skinny on Mumsnet seems to be used as a derogatory term by certain posters.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/06/2022 18:10

PavlovaTescobar · 04/06/2022 17:49

I completely agree with you OP, why are smaller sized women being penalised for being small and paying the same for clothes as larger women. As for all the talk of fat shaming, how about all the rudeness directed at thin people and the implication that if you are thin you are skinny, unhealthy and anorexic. Why is the word fat seen as an insult, it’s just a word describing someone’s appearance.

Fat is the word for adipose tissue. So it's used to describe them as their obvious component. An equivalent for other people would be 'muscly' (from muscles being obvious), 'bony' (from bones being obvious) or 'skinny' (from skin being most obvious).

If you don't like being described as your most obvious characteristic apart from unkind, mean or spiteful, don't use the most obvious characteristic for somebody else.

PavlovaTescobar · 04/06/2022 17:49

I completely agree with you OP, why are smaller sized women being penalised for being small and paying the same for clothes as larger women. As for all the talk of fat shaming, how about all the rudeness directed at thin people and the implication that if you are thin you are skinny, unhealthy and anorexic. Why is the word fat seen as an insult, it’s just a word describing someone’s appearance.

Merryclaire · 04/06/2022 17:39

Tania64 · 04/06/2022 14:38

So if larger bras cost more why wouldn't other larger clothing cost more? I agree with you OP. I have often thought that if I was any good at dress making I would buy the largest size the shop had and make it into 2 outfits. I would then sell the one I didn't need, could be a great sideline money spinner :)

That would be pretty much impossible unless it was small children’s clothes! You’d be surprised how much fabric you need for one item of clothing as you are cutting out specific pattern pieces, not just wrapping a length of fabric around you.

Stylishkidintheriot · 04/06/2022 17:13

Ah sweetheart.. if you think charging a bit more for my clothes is going to make me lose weight... you’re very very wrong

GregoryRowling · 04/06/2022 16:25

Love all the comments from people with no actual knowledge of clothing manufacturing! Most large retailers buy their clothing direct from factories (based on the design and spec of the retailer). Many of these lines will have a point or 2 within the price range that has a step up in cost and there fore a reduction in margin on larger sizes for the retailer. Sometimes the factory will make this clear and have stepped changes on other occasions they will spread the cost against the price of all sizes. The cost difference still exists. None of the retailers I know pass this cost on to the higher size they just insure they hit their margin across the range, so this means an inflated margin on the smaller sizes to balance out the bigger lower margin sizes.
A different way to have this conversation is to think about that… Why is it ok for smaller people to contribute more than their larger counterparts to the retailers margins?

FrangipaniBlue · 04/06/2022 15:51

More than the womens in the same sizes I mean.

FrangipaniBlue · 04/06/2022 15:48

TeachesOfPeaches · 03/06/2022 16:07

We all pay the same for shoes whether you're a 3 or a 9. Why would clothes be different?

Not strictly true.

If you look at trainers in any of the branded shops such as Nike, Reebok, Adidas - the mens are nearly always more.

UndertheCedartree · 04/06/2022 15:36

I've been overweight due to an under active thyroid and psychiatric medication. So no paying more would not have motivated me to stop taking meds or my thyroid to stop being under active.

GnomeDePlume · 04/06/2022 15:36

Pricing of children's clothing is unlikely to be anything to do with cost especially in supermarkets.

Small children's clothes are frequently low margin leaders to get parents doing their shopping in particular supermarket. For small children's clothes a low price will result in a higher volume of sales. Basically, stack it high and sell it cheap. Parents will chuck a pack of t shirts in the trolley along with their weekly shop.

Older children tend to get more of a say in their clothes. The volume of sales, especially in supermarkets, will tend to be lower. The price is less significant in the decision making.

Older children's clothes follow more of the adult pricing model.

nickthefox · 04/06/2022 15:34

fallfallfall · 03/06/2022 16:05

And why are mens clothing cheaper? They tend to be taller. Their pants and trousers need all that extra zipper work and extra fabric?

you forgot better, thicker fabric. My girls tops are so thin but my dhs tshirts and thick and last him a lot longer despite him working physically more than me. plus he has less so his gets more wear and they last longer than mine

Pixiedust1234 · 04/06/2022 15:24

Not rtft but I have to pay more for mine. I shop at asda, tesco etc. Its only a couple of pounds more but there is definitely a price increase at size 20-22 Confused

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 04/06/2022 15:13

mrsfoof · 03/06/2022 19:24

Interesting... French women are typically slim. Maybe because they don't want to pay more for bigger sizes!
(French women stats: 15% obese, 25% overweight in 2019, compared with 31% obese, 30% overweight in UK for the same year).

Those stats don't necessarily translate to clothes sizes.

You could be very short, considered overweight for your height but still be a size 8.

You could be very tall, normal weight but be a size 14 due to your height.

You could be a cross fit nut and your muscle mass would play a factor.

Body shape is an issue - my donkey thighs mean my upper body garments are generally a size lower than trousers. My waist isn't an issue, just years of playing sport filled my thighs out.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 04/06/2022 15:04

mrsfoof · 03/06/2022 15:57

If you buy children's clothes, you'll have probably noticed that you have to pay a good few quid more for a T-shirt in age 12 than you would for the exact same T-shirt in age 5. Fair enough, the bigger size uses a lot more fabric.

Why then, is a size 24 ladies' T-shirt the same price as the same T-shirt in a size 6, despite it using a lot more - maybe even twice as much - fabric?

Would people be more motivated to stay a healthy weight if they had to pay more for bigger clothes? Why don't we charge more for bigger clothes? Are the prices based on the average amount of fabric used - so skinny people pay more and very large people pay less than they should do based on the resources used to make their clothes?

FWIW I'm marginally overweight and wouldn't have a problem paying more for my size 14 than a 6. I think it would motivate me to lose some weight if the size 10 was cheaper though!

That's not the sole reason you pay more for 12+ clothes, you need to consider VAT.

Also I saw this question raised with regards to designer brands and branded sportswear and in a lot of cases, as already pointed out, the actual cost of the fabric is only a small % of cost. In a lot of cases, you're paying for the brand name.

Savedbythebell1 · 04/06/2022 15:03

I agree. I don't think it makes sense for a size 12 to be more expensive than a size 10 because there isn't much difference. But for a size 20+ there is a huge difference in the amount of material. It's not fat shaming, it's matter of fact that it uses more material so it costs more to make and that should be passed on to the consumer. I think a lot of people need to face up to reality that we have a) an obesity crisis and b) an environmental problem with fast fashion. I think charging more for bigger sizes could help with those two issues even if just a little.

mrsfoof · 04/06/2022 14:57

@Tania64 Genius ideaSmile

OP posts:
Tania64 · 04/06/2022 14:38

ForestFae · 03/06/2022 16:22

This just seems like fat shaming, and spiteful at that. If it makes you feel better OP, busty women have to pay more for bras than smaller chested women

So if larger bras cost more why wouldn't other larger clothing cost more? I agree with you OP. I have often thought that if I was any good at dress making I would buy the largest size the shop had and make it into 2 outfits. I would then sell the one I didn't need, could be a great sideline money spinner :)

Quincythequince · 04/06/2022 14:31

It’s a poor attempt to shut down a discussion that people feel uncomfortable with by calling it ‘xxxxxx-shaming’

I don’t think anyone here has said anything pejorative about overweight or obese people have they?

mrsfoof · 04/06/2022 14:30

@HoppingPavlova. I disagree with many of your points about mens' clothing being less expensive than ladies'.
A pack of 3 mens' simple boxers is as much as £15-18 in M&S. I can buy a pack of 5 briefs for under £12. Yes, if you want fancy / lacy garments they are more, but the basic ranges are not. I assume that the boxers cost more because the use more material and cost more to make.

OP posts:
mrsfoof · 04/06/2022 14:26

@LookItsMeAgain I haven't 'turned off' the option to vote - I posted on the app which as far as I can see doesn't give the option to vote.

And I'm not 'fat shaming' or 'big-busted shaming' anyone. If you'd read my posts, you'd notice that I am both overweight and big-busted myself.

OP posts:
mrsfoof · 04/06/2022 14:23

Merryclaire · 04/06/2022 10:43

“we've lost sight of what's healthy”

Classic MN quote! So predictable. Next you’ll be going on about portion sizes and how 1,000 calories a day is more than enough.

You’ve admitted you’re fat yourself - so why don’t you stop judging others? Or are you just that full of self-hate?

I'm not judging anyone. Just stating a fact that as a nation (myself included), we are generally overweight and this has become the norm.

OP posts: