Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you have a friend who suddenly became rich (eg marriage or inheritance)

64 replies

poorrelative · 03/06/2022 15:33

AIBU to ask if you, and especially your children, are still close?

I have an old friend (we are friends for 20+ years) who had married a very wealthy man. She seems to be very happy, and although her lifestyle has obviously changed massively, we stayed very close, and it has never been an issue from either side. I have a good professional wage myself, am reasonably comfortable, but will never be "rich". Both me and my friend are of quite humble origins.

Her children (and mine) are now of the age when they are able to start making long lasting friendships (and they do get along great). She let something slip after a couple of drinks that I cannot shake off. Her husband has nothing against our friendship (he's actually very supportive of it, and has been nothing but extremely pleasant to me), but is against the children spending a lot of time together and getting attached to each other. His justification is that they will live in very different worlds and it will be cruel to both sides when they will have to necessarily drift apart later. My friend actually thinks it is nonsense, and was telling me about this as just another complaint about him.

I was upset first, but then thought that there is a grain of truth there. It is very unlikely that their children will ever have to work for living, get a mortgage or see the inside of the public transport. Mine will, in all likelihood, have to go for student loans and live very frugally for years, if not decades, to be able to afford a deposit.

Is it possible for the children to stay close in these circumstances? I know there's absolutely no guarantee that childhood friendships persist in any case, but it looks like the wealth divide will be an additional obstacle.

OP posts:
Longdistance · 03/06/2022 18:06

So, does he have a crystal ball? If he’s rich it doesn’t necessarily mean his kids will do well. I’ve known plenty that have gone off the rails and some that have ended up working in pubs and cafes, nothing wrong with that, but who’s he to know how his kids lives will turn out. He’s talking shite!

CapMarvel · 03/06/2022 17:57

He's wrong and coming across as a massive prick to boot.

orangeisthenewpuce · 03/06/2022 17:50

It sounds like he's frightened that he'll be asked to stump up cash to pay for joint activities, holidays etc with your children and his. I hope you are your friend ignore him and carry on as you are. He's an idiot.

Lindy2 · 03/06/2022 17:41

I'd just leave the kids to it. If their friendship is strong then I'm sure it will carry on regardless of finances.

He's naive if he thinks his children will only mix with others who are wealthy. He's even more naive if he thinks handing them everything they need on a plate without them needing to achieve anything themselves, will help them become well rounded individuals.

dworky · 03/06/2022 17:28

He's wrong & I would lose respect for anyone with such views.

probablysaferoutdoors · 03/06/2022 17:27

I'd just see it as a flippant comment from someone from another kind of world.

How would anyone prevent them becoming close if they are spending time together?

I'd pay little attention to that because either they do become close and the wealthy ones won't just bin your kids off.

Or, they won't become close and will drift apart, which is normal anyway.

Or, they become close but the wealthy kids bin your kids off, which reflects badly on them, not your kids. Lesson learned etc.

I wouldn't worry personally. I don't know what it's like in that world of high society. I just assume they have very different viewpoints. I'm from a very working class background and I'm not ashamed of that so I'd just put it down to that; different worlds, different viewpoints.

What you going to do? Cut them off now?

I just can't see how this comment is of any real consequence?

PizzaPatel · 03/06/2022 17:09

I think that’s a crazy way to raise your kids no matter how much money you have… not using public transport?? Determining that there are certain people they won’t be friends with??

since when does mortgage status have any bearing on friendships? And student loans?! Most people are friends with all sorts… this sounds like a strange man!!

Kingharoldshairstyle · 03/06/2022 17:08

In my experience well adjusted children pick their own friends irrelevant of financial status of their parents.

my child is highly paid proffessional, the closest friend lives a nomadic life style, living in communes, travelling, occasional work, volunteering etc, they are always on the phone and the friend often comes to stay for a weekend, where they have an awesome time together.

if your child’s friendship circle is simply based on financial status of the parents, then you’ve done something very very wrong. And if he’s trying to narrow his child’s social circle and control it then he’s a thick wanker.

Eliakimi · 03/06/2022 17:02

Perhaps the dc are off to boarding school soon and he's trying to lessen the blow?

semideponent · 03/06/2022 16:56

"My friend actually thinks it is nonsense, and was telling me about this as just another complaint about him."

I think the issue here is that there's something missing where your friend's voice and values might otherwise be. You and her DH both seem fairly realistic about the outcomes if things carry on according to his (?) plans. But they don't have to be that way. Some wealthy people choose not to give their kids large trust funds precisely so they do find work, careers, vocations and the like, as well as learning their way round public transport. Why does she spend her energy complaining to you instead of speaking up to him?

edwinbear · 03/06/2022 16:54

Really odd way of thinking. Will they/do they, go to school? Even at private school, there will be a wide mix of children on full bursaries/scholarships whose parents couldn’t otherwise afford to send them, as well as very wealthy people. Will he stop them making friends with the kids on bursaries?

locak · 03/06/2022 16:49

I think it depends, if your friend is a millionaire that I can't see it being much different. Multi millions or billions then yes.

Uutuni · 03/06/2022 16:46

I think he sounds a bit snobbish. My best friend all through school age times was from an incredibly rich family, they had an actual castle 😐 and I was from a council estate. Yes it was awkward at times as I couldn't relate to certain things and vice versa but it was a beautiful friendship and we were incredibly close.
The kids can decide if they want to be friends feels ridiculous for him to try and ice them apart based on this.

Luredbyapomegranate · 03/06/2022 16:40

I don’t think this will be about you or
your kids, I think it’s about driving a little wedge between you and your friend so he can gradually separate you and have more control over her.

I say this because while he may or may not be right, I cannot imagine anyone would sit around thinking about whether it might or might not be cruel if their kids drifted apart from some other kids - friendships change and shed through life, that’s simply not something a parent would worry about.

So, don’t be fooled, keeping being a friend to your friend, she might need it. And let the kids sort themselves put.

Duploduplex · 03/06/2022 16:37

I think a lot of wealthy people say things like this, just to prove a point. You know, so the 'peasants' know their place.

And I say this as the 'one of those spoilt rich kids', whose parents came out with the same sort of bile, when I was younger..

Imissmoominmama · 03/06/2022 16:33

They won’t work? Has he said that?

Surely the role of parent is to prepare their children for independence?

WalkerWalking · 03/06/2022 16:33

Ps if this dad really is dictating to his wife/kids the "type of people" they can be friends with, and if this doesn't include the children of his wife's best friend? That sounds like a gilded cage to me, and it's not your kids I'd be feeling sorry for in that scenario.

Butterfly44 · 03/06/2022 16:27

Rubbish. Kids will be friends with who they like. Some friendships naturally drift from being in each other's pockets to further apart, but still the friendship is there.

WalkerWalking · 03/06/2022 16:26

I have a similar friend we're both from comfortable middle class backgrounds, but she's got a fantastic job, earning 6 figures for the last 10 years) and she's hinted before that she actively wants our kids to remain friends because wants them to have a few "normal kids in their lives, who don't have housemaids etc!

Luckily she's a lovely friend, and I'm taking this as a compliment.

theprincessofliechtenstein · 03/06/2022 16:21

Lots of friendships aren't for life. So what if they drift later? If it's a good friendship now, it's a good friendship now, and potentially an interesting insight into how the other half live to look back on in later life.

Strawberriesaregreat · 03/06/2022 16:16

What rubbish. They could lose it all tomorrow anyway. Its like saying you all stay in your corner and we'll stay in ours. Will their dcs never use trains again then? Just ignore it. He sounds like a new money snob, the worse type.

Porcupineintherough · 03/06/2022 16:15

My children's cousins family are considerably wealthier than we are. We just reminded them growing up that they had to take things like school more seriously than their cousins because they'd need to support themselves one day. It's fine .

Budgiegirlbob · 03/06/2022 16:10

His justification is that they will live in very different worlds and it will be cruel to both sides when they will have to necessarily drift apart later. My friend actually thinks it is nonsense, and was telling me about this as just another complaint about him

To be fair to her DH - it is sometimes true. Money, unfortunately, can cause issues.

My sister’s husband is a very rich, self-made business man. As a couple they are very understated, and don’t come across as at all flashy. But they’ve lost a few long-standing friends due to the disparity in their current earnings, I’m assuming through jealousy. And they move in very different circles now.

if course, it isn’t always this way, and it’s not a given that the children will drift apart. I don’t agree that you should stop the childrens friendship just in case, but it is true that it could happen .

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 03/06/2022 16:09

I can see his point very very slightly depending on their ages - I don't agree with him mind. If your friends kids are getting every whim catered for, and expensive gifts, and ponies and all sorts and never have to ask for anything and are never told no I can see how he'd be uncomfortable and thinking children can't understand that. But unfortunately that's just life and kids will learn that at some stage or another that someone in school always had the best and some don't have proper lunches.

poorrelative · 03/06/2022 16:07

I don't know him that well, he's usually just very pleasant and nothing more. It was just somehow strange to see my family through that lens.

OP posts: