Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about child savings?

138 replies

pinkunicorns54 · 02/06/2022 18:02

Happy to be told I am being unreasonable just need some perspective!

We currently have a junior ISA set up for our toddler. Saving roughly £80pm - I suddenly have a sudden thought of if we are able to do this until they are 18, there will be a fair whack in there - I'm nervous about them having access to this when they are 18 and maybe not have the maturity to know how to manage this!

My DH thinks that we will be ok just instilling financial education into them when they are growing up and if they do decide to blow it on things I wouldn't want them to - then we just need to suck it up as it will be there's...

I'm of the view that we save in our names, so we have more control over it...

YABU - leave it in their name

YANBU - save it in yours!

Happy for anecdotes from people who have done similar / have grown up children!

OP posts:
locak · 02/06/2022 19:14

When my DS was 18 he was given the money and he bought himself a gaming computer he had always wanted and put the rest down as a large deposit on a flat which he rented out.

How did he get a BTL mortgage with 20k deposit & as a student?

dillydally24 · 02/06/2022 19:14

I would also add that it only makes sense to add to a junior ISA if you're not using up all of your own ISA allowances. If you put the money in a JISA then you can't take it out if you need it and there's the risk they spend it unwisely at 18. The only reason to add to a JISA is to save tax efficiently and you can do that through your own ISA, unless you routinely use up your annual allowances of £20k each.

dillydally24 · 02/06/2022 19:11

YANBU. I have put a lot into my DCs' ISAs and am shit scared they are going to blow it at 18. I am trying to educate my eldest about spending and saving already and he is a pre-schooler. I am hoping good financial sense will be drummed into them by the time they're 18. I am also not saving separately for Uni fees, so the plan is for them to use that money to fund themselves through Uni. I guess that is one way of making sure they spend it wisely.

Pallisers · 02/06/2022 19:09

YANBU We saved everything in our names.

Savings were for the family in the end. You never know how things work out and I would like to be able to access money for emergencies/children's needs/whatever.

Also, we didn't want our children to have access to a significant amount of money at age 18. Financial education is great but you have no idea what issues or attitudes your child will have by 18. That said, a grandmother and stepgrandfather gave each of them a significant amount of money for a car when they turned 18. None of the 3 bought a car (didn't need it/no parking at university etc) but put it into a stock account. I don't think they think of it as spending money just a windfall for saving and investing. The step-granddad would have totally bought a flash car when he was 18 though and was probably a bit disappointed with his conservative grandson :).

My sister saved her children's allowance for her children in their own accounts. Nephew spent it all once he got his hands on it - on nothing at all.

transformandriseup · 02/06/2022 19:04

I'm not planning on telling my DD about her savings until she is at least 21, possibly 25.

JustLyra · 02/06/2022 19:03

Hallyup89 · 02/06/2022 18:53

This. If you ever find yourself needing to claim universal credit or anything like that, you won't be able to until the children's savings are used up.

I put my children's savings in junior ISAs for this exact reason.

Any savings in the child’s names, beyond the basic limit, still count for means tested benefit claims. Being in the kids name doesn’t protect them.

Georgyporky · 02/06/2022 18:54

Keep it in the DC's name, but don't tell them about it until they are ready to use it sensibly
Much easier to do with an on-line account.

Hallyup89 · 02/06/2022 18:53

IanOsenfrote · 02/06/2022 18:08

Be aware that if you go bankrupt in 10 years time and the childs savings are in your name, then they are gone.

Put the savings in your childs name, make sure it's a stocks and shares ISA, invest in a simple global tracker and let compounding work it's magic.

Educate them financially and pray that they actually listen.

This. If you ever find yourself needing to claim universal credit or anything like that, you won't be able to until the children's savings are used up.

I put my children's savings in junior ISAs for this exact reason.

TeenPlusCat · 02/06/2022 18:52

GallstoneGlory · 02/06/2022 18:46

Save it in their name but don't tell them?

If it's in their name they legally have to have it at 18.
You could run into all sorts of trouble by just not telling them.

TeenPlusCat · 02/06/2022 18:51

You can hand it over when they are 18 if you want, or hand it over in yearly chunks, or wait until they are more stable at 21 or 25.

Theyellowflamingo · 02/06/2022 18:51

Mine have accounts in their own name for money they’ve been given by relatives etc. Its enough to have a bit of fun at 18 but not enough to be upset if it’s “wasted”.

We don’t save any money specifically earmarked for them, in their names or ours. We have decent savings from which I will consider making gifts to them when they’re old enough and have something sensible to spend it on. But I’m not deciding now when that will be or how much.

SafelySoftly · 02/06/2022 18:50

Honestly, this thread is perplexing. How many people save with bankruptcy in mind!!! If you’re in a state to become bankrupt then you need the kids’ savings in your bank account to you know, feed and clothe them!! I have plenty of rainy day savings and will give money to then when they need at an appropriate time, 18 is madness.

TeenPlusCat · 02/06/2022 18:50

I'm definitely in the save it in your name camp.

Your sweet biddable 4 year old, or even 14 year old can change in late teens due to temperament, or unsuitable friends, or drink/drugs. The tax benefits on it being in their name are far outweighed by the chance of it getting wasted.

merryhouse · 02/06/2022 18:50

We saved using National Savings Children's Bonus Bonds (don't exist any more) which mature after 5 years and until they're 16 just get reinvested if you don't do anything. Did £25 every 6 months (that was pocket money in them days) till the age of about 7, and PiL bought some every birthday.

Consequently they got sums of money coming through quite regularly from 16 to 21, one or two in the 4 figures.

So far as I can tell neither has splurged it. S2 spent last summer going out for meals with his girlfriend quite a bit, but that was all. S1 did buy a mini-ring last term, mind (more the proceeds from his choral scholarship than our savings, I think). They're both able to budget and to think beyond the moment, and I think that's served them better than assuming they'll be irresponsible.

LakeTiticaca · 02/06/2022 18:48

Could you put a portion of it into a pension fund for them?

GallstoneGlory · 02/06/2022 18:46

Save it in their name but don't tell them?

JustLyra · 02/06/2022 18:44

ChessieFL · 02/06/2022 18:21

As a pp said, any savings in your name will be lost if you become bankrupt and would also be taken into account if you need to claim means-tested benefits. This may not affect you in which case saving in your own name is probably safer so you can make the decision when they get the money.

Money in children’s savings accounts counts toward benefits beyond a certain amount as well (as they are generally accessible by the parent).

Furrydogmum · 02/06/2022 18:33

I didn't have the money to save for mine when they were small so recently I put the max into ds1's (23) lifetime ISA for 3 years so he and his fiancée, who was saving the same, could buy a house. I'm being more leisurely about ds2's as I know he won't buy as young. I have slightly less confidence in ds2 to not piss it up a wall at some point.. if he does there won't be any more to look forward to - equal ops all the way!

riotlady · 02/06/2022 18:33

YANBU- DD has a savings account for christening/birthday/Christmas money which she can have access to when she’s older, she can spend that as she likes since it was “present” money although I hope she’s sensible with it.

We plan to help her out with uni/house/wedding (whichever of those she chooses to do!) and that will come out of our general long term savings. I don’t think it’s that helpful to suddenly get thousands of pounds age 18, Id I’d rather help her at the points she really needs it

Testina · 02/06/2022 18:31

Your husband is naïve if he thinks he can stop it happening through good financial education - though he certainly might!
More sensible is his recognition that you might just have to accept it being pissed away.
Nearly £20K without allowing for growth (or inflation) - I wouldn’t risk that.

IanOsenfrote · 02/06/2022 18:28

Another option may be to split the investment between a S&S ISA and a junior SIPP. At least that way, half the money should be secure and can keep on compounding until the toddlers retirement age.

WooNoodle · 02/06/2022 18:27

At least until they get older and you can see what they are like with money

WooNoodle · 02/06/2022 18:27

It depends if you're maxing out your own ISAs or not and what your general tax position is. But I'd do a bit in the JISA but most in your name.

Icequeen01 · 02/06/2022 18:25

It's not always the case that an 18 year old will fritter the money away!

My DS inherited some money from my DF when he was 14. It was put in trust until he was 18 and from the time he received the money we talked to my DS about how his grandad wanted him to use it for a house deposit. When my DS was 18 he was given the money and he bought himself a gaming computer he had always wanted and put the rest down as a large deposit on a flat which he rented out. The money he got from the rent went towards his Uni expenses and now he has been through Uni it either supplements his monthly income or he saves the money.

He is 22 now and deals with any problems regarding the flat himself, so it's been a real life lesson for him but he has proved to be very sensible.

Cherryblossoms85 · 02/06/2022 18:25

I'll be giving them about 20k each from their ISAs and it's definitely a worry. I can't save in my own ISA for them though as it's not got enough head room. Oh well, I'll probabaly lose my job in the recession and it'll be a non- problem!