Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about child savings?

138 replies

pinkunicorns54 · 02/06/2022 18:02

Happy to be told I am being unreasonable just need some perspective!

We currently have a junior ISA set up for our toddler. Saving roughly £80pm - I suddenly have a sudden thought of if we are able to do this until they are 18, there will be a fair whack in there - I'm nervous about them having access to this when they are 18 and maybe not have the maturity to know how to manage this!

My DH thinks that we will be ok just instilling financial education into them when they are growing up and if they do decide to blow it on things I wouldn't want them to - then we just need to suck it up as it will be there's...

I'm of the view that we save in our names, so we have more control over it...

YABU - leave it in their name

YANBU - save it in yours!

Happy for anecdotes from people who have done similar / have grown up children!

OP posts:
itwasntmetho · 02/06/2022 20:33

I save in my name, I would want to access the money if he has a nice opportunity that I couldn't afford, like school trips, or if he ever fell behind at school and needed tutoring or needed urgent health care that I felt couldn't wait.

Saying that I don't save as much as you, I'm hoping that when he's off hand and I'm not paying for him any more that I could then afford to help him financially through his life rather than be able to have a lump sum at the beginning of his adulthood.

Maggiethecat · 02/06/2022 20:21

Youseethethingis1 · 02/06/2022 19:20

DS has a Stocks and Shares JISA with a few K in, won't be adding much more to it in case he's an idiot at 18 but it will still be a decent amount for him to either be sensible with or not when the time comes.
Seriously considering starting a small pension for him, which he obviously won't be able to touch for a long time. Just as an ongoing lesson in compound interest and the benefits of saving small amounts over a long time. I figure even if he's an idiot at 18, when he's sensible again by 25, say, (hopefully!) he can start making his own small contributions.
Other than that, saving in my name and will help him if and when he deserves or needs it.
Hoping the government don't find a way to tax it off me, avoid an expensive divorce, bankruptcy, all manner of life disasters that may drain my savings I suppose. But at least something will be in his name so all bases covered.

@Youseethethingis1 - I’ve been talking to my girls about saving into a pension from now (they’re older teens) at which they scoff - far too young for that!

I’m thinking I’ll go ahead anyway for the reasons of compound interest and hoping eventually they’ll ‘get it’ and start contributing.

Is there the chance though of tax issues unwittingly arising if contribution limits are exceeded?

ItsReallyOnlyMe · 02/06/2022 20:13

I saved £50 a month in a unit trust for both my children. DD had £40000 in it, and when her salary was large enough to buy a house, she bought a house at 23.

DS is now 21 and still has his in savings, but he will use it as a house deposit when the time comes.

I think it's a lottery whether they are good with money or not - although having good 'role models' may play a part. We all know adults who spend money as soon they get it - I'm not like that and that may have rubbed off.

Mally100 · 02/06/2022 20:10

Yanbu. We are doing this as well. We can educate dc as much as we want but at 18 he's still a teenager with zero concept of financial maturity at that age. I know of too many situations where the kids just wasted through the money.

WeAllHaveWings · 02/06/2022 20:04

Ds(18) got a fair whack (to us) 6 months ago. He has put £4k into a LISA for a house deposit and plans to put the same in each year while he is at uni for the next 5 years to make the most of the government contributions. He knows and appreciates this money will be a one off from us so values it as something for his future after uni and not to fritter away.

He is working PT and that gets him around £120-£150/week which he is using for spending /saving for uni.

The important thing is to teach dc the value of money and what managing money can do for you from an early age and most will be OK getting a chunk at 18. Obviously there will always be stories where some blow the lot, and you'll never know if that will be your dc, but I think IME that is the minority so low risk (and I am quite risk adverse).

Pallisers · 02/06/2022 20:02

At 18 you shouldn’t really have or want any control over them it’s their life their choice

My youngest is 20 and I certainly didn't go hands-off when any of them turned 18. My parenting was never about control (seems a weird thought to me) but about helping them to grow up into decent adults with as good a start as I could give them. I think saying "your life your choice" to an 18 year old and feeling your job is done now is lazy tbh

BenchOfCompany · 02/06/2022 20:01

There have been lots of threads about almost 18 year olds knowing they have Child Trust Funds with thousands in and parents posting on here asking if there is any way to stop them getting it as they are not sensible with money. The parents, grandparents etc pay into these accounts and the parent then has no control over how it is spent by the 18 year old.

I have friends who drilled financial responsibility into their children who are now late 20s, one can manage money the other two blow it. Dh is a saver like me, his sister is not, borrows money till pay day from her Dad. They had the same upbringing, very responsible parents and yet she burns through money and really has nothing to show for it.

Ds1 is 19, he got his CTF money but it was just the original cheque paid in and nothing else so he got over £1k, we saved in a separate account that we had control of. At 18 it did not revert to him due to the way it was set up with the bank. If you want to be able to control it, set it up under your name.

Ponderingwindow · 02/06/2022 19:59

We save money for our child in an educational trust. There is no option to go crazy with the funds.

Thatboymum · 02/06/2022 19:55

At 18 you shouldn’t really have or want any control over them it’s their life their choice but if it bothers you that much why not put a smaller amount in the isa and the rest in one in your name. I do think yabu tho

PicturesOfLily · 02/06/2022 19:50

My dds have a fairly small amount in a junior stocks and shares ISA each which they will get at 18. It will hopefully be enough for a basic second-hand car by then or towards travel if that’s what they want to do. DH and I will save separately in our names to try and give them a hand with a house deposit later on but I don’t want them to have access to a large sum at 18 because that will be all there is. My parents saved less than 1k for me as they didn’t have a lot of money when I was growing up but they were much better off by the time I was 18 so they paid my (£1k p.a.) uni fees and helped with living costs plus got me a second-hand car and gave me some money towards a wedding later so I definitely got a lot of help but also appreciated it too.

almostmummyof2 · 02/06/2022 19:47

From experience of getting money when I was younger like this... I spent it on weed mostly!! Save it in your name 😂😅

florianfortescue · 02/06/2022 19:44

I do £25 a month per child into a JISA and a larger amount into a S&S ISA in my name for uni fees/house deposit only. I could not have been trusted with a large amount myself at 18 so I want to ensure it is protected for my DC.

Kreature69 · 02/06/2022 19:41

Curiosity101 · 02/06/2022 19:21

We save half into an account in DCs name and half into an account under our name. If they decide to put 'their' money towards something sensible then we will match it... Effectively halving the cost to them. If they decide to fritter their money away or spend it on things we don't approve of then we'll either keep the second half until they're older and need it for something specific, or if they never get to that point then I guess we'll eventually spend it ourselves.

This is what I am doing!

DingDongBing · 02/06/2022 19:40

The bank does write to them yes which is why education needs to start earlier.

Ithoughtsummerwascoming · 02/06/2022 19:38

Hi op this has been discussed a few times on here with lots of food for thought!

My DC have small inheritance which has been split up into a cash ISA ,which is for a car/driving lessons and perhaps travel. This junior ISA has rubbish interest. The highest it's been was 3 %.
Then they have a stock's and shares ISA which has more in. perhaps uni fee's or house deposit.

This has a much higher interest, obviously as it's stocks it's been bobbing around but until now it's been around 25%.

To try and start to train them to manage these larger sums they have a few 100 each in normal accessible Bank account.
One DC is Very long term gain, the other is want it now.
The older one is already very sensible and has a debit card and saving with nation wide.
She sets limits for her self and can wait.

The younger one doesn't have this so I'm getting her a hyper jar account soon, and will drip feed smaller amounts in.
She's young so we have time to train her.
I'm teaching the older one about investing. I show her how much her account plummeted due to COVID and other issue's then how it bounces back.
I talk to her about individual stocks and. Fund's
.

I worry immensely about them being taken advantage of , wasting it...but I hope they get all this out of their system by the time they access the larger amounts which; will be sold as ...money for. X y and z.
However I Also make sure they set aside money for fun and say there is no point without fun.
Hopefully this means they will not deny themselves! But not over splruge.
At the end of the day if they do waste it...it's a life lesson.
Many people get by without being given money so...

mumonthehill · 02/06/2022 19:35

Ds had his savings at 18, there were not nearly as large as some are on this thread. I know he put some in an ISA and bought a car but no idea what he has done with the rest. It was his money and once handed over I had no say.

pinkunicorns54 · 02/06/2022 19:34

Thank you all, really helpful ☺️.

A few people have said don't tell them, but the bank automatically write to them when they are 18.

OP posts:
custardbear · 02/06/2022 19:31

We save in our childrens names, they've always known about it and they also know it's for education or house deposit only. I actually think ours are locked til 21 from them if I recall

Hardbackwriter · 02/06/2022 19:29

My two are still very young but have £10k each in their own names because they inherited it - they inherited it directly so no choice but to put it in their own names. Everything else we're saving for them is in our names for exactly this reason. We won't be able to stop them wasting the £10k, but at least we'll hopefully have some savings that we can offer only at the point it's likely to be usefully and sensibly used, e.g. for university or to help towards a house deposit.

DingDongBing · 02/06/2022 19:29

Our daughter (8) has about £50k in savings we have put aside for her and our son (1) has £12k so far.

My parents did the same for me (house and savings) with the expectation that if I pissed it up against a wall there would be nothing else. To guard against that this financial education was instilled in me as soon as i became aware and it was made clear that none of the ‘but it’s mine, I am 18, give me access’ rubbish was expected.

I have done the same with our daughter (son too young) as well as a healthy dose of ‘don’t brag or people will take advantage’.

It may go wrong but then it could if they inherited everything at once. What do they say about people who win big sums of money? This way I have time to teach.

daffodilandtulip · 02/06/2022 19:24

Just because they CAN access it at 18, doesn't mean you have to give it to them then, does it? Couldn't you just not tell them it exists until they're like 21?

Curiosity101 · 02/06/2022 19:21

We save half into an account in DCs name and half into an account under our name. If they decide to put 'their' money towards something sensible then we will match it... Effectively halving the cost to them. If they decide to fritter their money away or spend it on things we don't approve of then we'll either keep the second half until they're older and need it for something specific, or if they never get to that point then I guess we'll eventually spend it ourselves.

TeenPlusCat · 02/06/2022 19:20

I really don't think it is right people not telling their kids about money that they hold as adults.
If nothing else, it could mean the 18yo claims benefits or grants they aren't actually entitled to.
Legally you could get into a lot of trouble, plus cause a family fall out when they find out you've been withholding their own money from them.

Much better to just not put it in their name in the first place.

Youseethethingis1 · 02/06/2022 19:20

DS has a Stocks and Shares JISA with a few K in, won't be adding much more to it in case he's an idiot at 18 but it will still be a decent amount for him to either be sensible with or not when the time comes.
Seriously considering starting a small pension for him, which he obviously won't be able to touch for a long time. Just as an ongoing lesson in compound interest and the benefits of saving small amounts over a long time. I figure even if he's an idiot at 18, when he's sensible again by 25, say, (hopefully!) he can start making his own small contributions.
Other than that, saving in my name and will help him if and when he deserves or needs it.
Hoping the government don't find a way to tax it off me, avoid an expensive divorce, bankruptcy, all manner of life disasters that may drain my savings I suppose. But at least something will be in his name so all bases covered.

Prometheus · 02/06/2022 19:17

Then don’t tell your kids about the ISA!! We have ISAs for our kids and haven’t told them. Apparently Halifax will write to them
when they’re 18 and inform them about the money. The chances of them actually collecting the mail from the doormat, looking at the addressee and then actually opening something with their name on is so slim!!!