Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about child savings?

138 replies

pinkunicorns54 · 02/06/2022 18:02

Happy to be told I am being unreasonable just need some perspective!

We currently have a junior ISA set up for our toddler. Saving roughly £80pm - I suddenly have a sudden thought of if we are able to do this until they are 18, there will be a fair whack in there - I'm nervous about them having access to this when they are 18 and maybe not have the maturity to know how to manage this!

My DH thinks that we will be ok just instilling financial education into them when they are growing up and if they do decide to blow it on things I wouldn't want them to - then we just need to suck it up as it will be there's...

I'm of the view that we save in our names, so we have more control over it...

YABU - leave it in their name

YANBU - save it in yours!

Happy for anecdotes from people who have done similar / have grown up children!

OP posts:
Enko · 03/06/2022 08:34

Outs had a savings account like that we put money in and mil put money in. We always call it grandmas money. (MIL put in the most) the kids know ita for education and have all kept it strictly that way. Even dd3 who was not sure she wanted to go to uni have left the money (she is almost 19 now so could have spent it) and said she would want and see. She is now applying for universities so will be going and spending it there e like jer siblings.

I think us being firm it was for education made it so the kids simply accepted that

IanOsenfrote · 03/06/2022 08:28

JustLyra · 02/06/2022 19:03

Any savings in the child’s names, beyond the basic limit, still count for means tested benefit claims. Being in the kids name doesn’t protect them.

@JustLyra

Do you have a link to back up your claim?

Money cannot be withdrawn from a junior isa until the child reaches 18 so I cannot see that any money there can be assessed as being accessible.

I would argue that if a child has a tax liability, then it should also have a saving ability seperate to its parents, otherwise, whats the point of childrens bank accounts, premium bonds etc.

pearly1792 · 03/06/2022 01:04

OP it sounds as if your saving this money to help your child get a start in the setup of his life such as a good deposit on his own home. It doesn't sound as if your saving this for him to use as a good piss up at 18. I think you need to point this out to your husband as our brains don't fully mature until we are around 25. Thus if you mean to help him in the long term aspects of life you need to wait until his brain has fully matured. I am doing the same for my daughter and will transfer it over when she is 25 I also have shares of hers in my name as well which will be transferred over at that age. She knows this and she knows why.

NotDonna · 03/06/2022 00:32

If you do decide to open a JISA your child WILL absolutely be aware of it as the bank will write/email/telephone etc when she’s 16/17 (no access until 18 though) Any intercepting or withholding you try to do is illegal.
Most current 18yr olds know about the child trust funds as their mates have them in varying amounts due to the government scheme when they were born. This will be different by the time yours is 18 though OP.
My eldest has very sensibly re-invested her JISA into a LISA snd an adult ISA with my advice. But it is THEIR money and you do hear some horror stories where it’s spent on drugs etc. Despite my DD using hers wisely (so far) if I had thought it through I wouldn’t have paid into the CTF/JISA but saved where I had control. Just to be on the safe side.

Lordofmyflies · 02/06/2022 23:51

We have CTF for both of our DC and save £150 per month into each account. By the age of 18 there was a substantial amount in their accounts but thankfully my eldest used his to put down a deposit for a house which he now rents out his friends in the second year of uni which more than covers the mortgage. He is doing a 4 year degree but may well keep the house if it continue to bring in a good return. We've always taught them about money and the cost of things and I believe that's paid off. It is a risk though.

timeforchange2022 · 02/06/2022 23:47

I have a couple of different savings accounts for my children, one being the Nationwide Future Saver. When the child is 18 years 6 months the money is transferred into an instant access savings account in the parent/guardian's name until that parent/guardian transfers the account into the child's sole name. They also have a JISA which they can obviously access earlier. I figured they'd be able to have some at 18 to do as they want (one of them is a saver the other is a spender) but the majority will be kept in my name until a time when they need it (e.g. house deposit or car, etc).

locak · 02/06/2022 23:30

I didn't say he had a £20,000 deposit? He had more than that. With regard to the BTL mortgage my DH had to go on the mortgage with my DS but we do not pay anything towards it.

I misread re the deposit but that makes more sense that DH was on the mortgage.

Myleakycauldron · 02/06/2022 23:29

I think if you are saving for your children and sacrificing stuff in order to put money away for your DC each month it would be so annoying to see them fritter it away. I think it takes a few years of working / living expenses to appreciate the value of money and how long it takes to pay stuff off so not sure even sensible 18 year olds would appreciate it!

Icequeen01 · 02/06/2022 23:09

locak · 02/06/2022 19:14

When my DS was 18 he was given the money and he bought himself a gaming computer he had always wanted and put the rest down as a large deposit on a flat which he rented out.

How did he get a BTL mortgage with 20k deposit & as a student?

I didn't say he had a £20,000 deposit? He had more than that. With regard to the BTL mortgage my DH had to go on the mortgage with my DS but we do not pay anything towards it. The rent for the flat is £650 a month and the mortgage is just over £200 per month so he clears around £400 per month after the letting agent fees.

Testina · 02/06/2022 22:13

autienotnaughty · 02/06/2022 22:11

My 18 and 22 year olds inherited money. 22 yrold bought a car . 18 yr old bought TikTok merch - 10k worth!!!

😳 The very fuck?!

autienotnaughty · 02/06/2022 22:11

My 18 and 22 year olds inherited money. 22 yrold bought a car . 18 yr old bought TikTok merch - 10k worth!!!

Hardbackwriter · 02/06/2022 21:25

Prometheus · 02/06/2022 21:21

Yes the bank will write to them - but what are the chances of them actually picking up and reading the post? By the time they’re 18 they’ll be ignoring snail mail and only noticing things if they’re emailed to them (or whatever the replacement to email is by then). As an old person who knows what a letter is, you just have pick the post up from the doormat first……

Yeah, at the point that you're not just omitting to tell them about the account but actively keeping it from them by stealing their post you've crossed a bit of a line...

Prometheus · 02/06/2022 21:21

pinkunicorns54 · 02/06/2022 19:34

Thank you all, really helpful ☺️.

A few people have said don't tell them, but the bank automatically write to them when they are 18.

Yes the bank will write to them - but what are the chances of them actually picking up and reading the post? By the time they’re 18 they’ll be ignoring snail mail and only noticing things if they’re emailed to them (or whatever the replacement to email is by then). As an old person who knows what a letter is, you just have pick the post up from the doormat first……

Annfr · 02/06/2022 21:16

Sheilaroundthefountain · 02/06/2022 21:02

My children have a trust set up by my parents.

it’s a lot of money - currently £1.7 million between all grandchildren.

My children are the oldest grandchildren aged 23 and 21 and don’t know anything about this money. I’m not sure when they’ll be given it, but my dad asked me when I thought was a good age and I said 35. My dad was quite shocked, but I had my reasons.

Firstly I want them to develop a proper work ethic. My eldest has almost saved up a flat deposit. She’s really proud that she’s done this , and I’m proud of her. I think this should be money for her second or third home.

I’d hope that they’re both settled or settling down by this age. They’re both single right now.

Hopefully they’ll both have a better idea of the value of money. The amount of clothes they buy and then give to the charity shop with the labels on horrifies me! They say Vinted is too much effort

I’m not patronising them, but they’re just young girls. They’ve had a normal upbringing. My parents are wealthy, but they’re self made, and when I was growing up, their money was being ploughed back into the business, so I wasn’t brought up in a wealthy house, although it was a fantastic house!

I know to a lot of people on here £400k isn’t a fortune, but it would be to my daughters. They stand to inherit a lot more in the future but I hope that’s a long long way off.

People will probably disagree with me, but it’s not my money it’s my parents, and if they’ve listened to me, that’s good, and if they haven’t that’s fine too, as it’s between them and their grandchildren.

Couldn't agree with this more!!

I've been extremely "lucky" and had the majority of the money for my 1st flat from the life insurance payout my Mum saved for me when my Dad died when I was really young. She could have spent it but was always really careful and saved it for me. I didn't know about it until I was 25-ish? And in the stage to be ready to looking to buy.

Because of the delay in me knowing it didn't change my work ethic (I'm self employed and never stop) or my route in life as I'd been through university.

Annfr · 02/06/2022 21:10

We're doing both.

But also... they only know about it if you tell them 🤷‍♂️ The bulk of our daughter's savings for house deposit etc will be in our name so it can be used for that reason etc.

TitInATrance · 02/06/2022 21:05

I saved for DC in their names but with me as trustee. They are now grown up and spent most of it (as allowed by me) but the building society continue to write to me and I still have control of the accounts.

Hollipolly · 02/06/2022 21:04

GallstoneGlory · 02/06/2022 18:46

Save it in their name but don't tell them?

My thoughts too!

lenaperkins · 02/06/2022 21:03

Save it in you name.

My friend did an ISA for her daughter thinking she'd use it for uni or a deposit. Daughter spent it on tattoos, weed and got an unsuitable boyfriend.

Sheilaroundthefountain · 02/06/2022 21:02

My children have a trust set up by my parents.

it’s a lot of money - currently £1.7 million between all grandchildren.

My children are the oldest grandchildren aged 23 and 21 and don’t know anything about this money. I’m not sure when they’ll be given it, but my dad asked me when I thought was a good age and I said 35. My dad was quite shocked, but I had my reasons.

Firstly I want them to develop a proper work ethic. My eldest has almost saved up a flat deposit. She’s really proud that she’s done this , and I’m proud of her. I think this should be money for her second or third home.

I’d hope that they’re both settled or settling down by this age. They’re both single right now.

Hopefully they’ll both have a better idea of the value of money. The amount of clothes they buy and then give to the charity shop with the labels on horrifies me! They say Vinted is too much effort

I’m not patronising them, but they’re just young girls. They’ve had a normal upbringing. My parents are wealthy, but they’re self made, and when I was growing up, their money was being ploughed back into the business, so I wasn’t brought up in a wealthy house, although it was a fantastic house!

I know to a lot of people on here £400k isn’t a fortune, but it would be to my daughters. They stand to inherit a lot more in the future but I hope that’s a long long way off.

People will probably disagree with me, but it’s not my money it’s my parents, and if they’ve listened to me, that’s good, and if they haven’t that’s fine too, as it’s between them and their grandchildren.

MyNameIsAngelicaSchuyler · 02/06/2022 20:57

Absolutely NO chance I’d save in my children’s names. It’s highly risky. You can install all the values you like but one abusive relationship and all your careful savings are gone. Don’t do it.

IDontDrinkTea · 02/06/2022 20:56

I was given a savings account at 18 - I spent it on a car (cost about £3k so not the big amounts like others in this thread). But it was drilled into me from the beginning that it was for a car. I have done the same for my children, and it will be very clear I have saved enough for a house deposit and that’s what I expect it to be spent on. The account is in their names as I wouldn’t want the money to be taken into account should I ever end up divorced. I’m not anticipating it but you never know what the future brings

Discovereads · 02/06/2022 20:50

Children get access to junior ISAs at age 16, not 18.

ScootsMcHoy · 02/06/2022 20:47

My dd is 18 now and one of the dc that got the child trust fund. Without exception, every one of my friends who added to the CTF in a significant way regrets it.

And the eighteen year olds are perfectly nice and civilised people. They just haven't a clue about getting a big pile of money. None of them are thinking ' oh that will help me with a house deposit'.

It hasn't helped that it's so difficult to get driving tests and lessons.

dillydally24 · 02/06/2022 20:40

daffodilandtulip · 02/06/2022 19:24

Just because they CAN access it at 18, doesn't mean you have to give it to them then, does it? Couldn't you just not tell them it exists until they're like 21?

The ISA provider will start writing to them, not you, so unless you hide their post, then they'll find out about it.

Sortilege · 02/06/2022 20:37

There was one small account for each of elder two that I genuinely forgot to tell them about until recently (early 20s). So you always have the option of not mentioning the account until they are a bit older. Not sure of that work withh to junior ISAs, though.