Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about child savings?

138 replies

pinkunicorns54 · 02/06/2022 18:02

Happy to be told I am being unreasonable just need some perspective!

We currently have a junior ISA set up for our toddler. Saving roughly £80pm - I suddenly have a sudden thought of if we are able to do this until they are 18, there will be a fair whack in there - I'm nervous about them having access to this when they are 18 and maybe not have the maturity to know how to manage this!

My DH thinks that we will be ok just instilling financial education into them when they are growing up and if they do decide to blow it on things I wouldn't want them to - then we just need to suck it up as it will be there's...

I'm of the view that we save in our names, so we have more control over it...

YABU - leave it in their name

YANBU - save it in yours!

Happy for anecdotes from people who have done similar / have grown up children!

OP posts:
Zpoa · 03/06/2022 10:47

My DC got £10k from his ISA last year. He's still got the money in an ISA and is saving it.

Fenella123 · 03/06/2022 10:44

Whatever you decide you want to actively educate them about finances - real world examples where people they know (e.g. you!) screwed up are excellent.
Grab them whenever you are renewing insurance, getting the gas/electric/water bills, getting the car MoT'd, any time you're spending money that's not personal to you. I.e. when you're on the LoveHoney site :)

Tayegete · 03/06/2022 10:35

We’ve been really upfront with ours that they will get £10k when they are 18. We’ve talked to them about putting some in a LISA and thinking ahead to a house deposit. We are also saving a bit more for them which we haven’t told them about so we can give it when they might need it.

babyjellyfish · 03/06/2022 10:23

When my son was born my in laws wrote a cheque for a few thousand euro and we didn't know what to do with it so we opened a savings account in his name and put it in there. We can no longer touch it and he will get it when he turns 18, plus anything else that gets paid into that account in the next 17 years.

We also wanted to save for him monthly but we didn't want him gaining access to a huge sum of money when he turns 18. So we now save into an investment vehicle in our own names, and the money remains ours to do what we like with even though it is intended for him eventually. It means we retain control over the money. It also means that if we were to fall on hard times we could get the money out and use it for essentials. The named beneficiary is our children rather than our son specifically, which means that if we have more children, there will be a joint pot for them rather than different children potentially having different amounts saved in their name if our financial circumstances change.

Courante · 03/06/2022 10:16

Our only DC is about a month off getting theirs (has received the letter from the bank and been able to see the balance on their banking app since 16, as CTF is with the same bank). We started saving £100/mth (which was the max at the time) for them into it when they were a baby but never increased it when you were allowed to put more in, and I'm glad we didn't. They'll be getting just over £30K to re-invest (it was a s&s CTF but not a great performer!) as a good start towards a house deposit.

Over the years we've made their financial education a priority and they've proved themselves to be sensible with money and interested investing so we're not worried about them blowing it. I think having this money in their name helped focus their attention on it but I'm not entirely convinced (without the benefit of hindsight that this would work out ok) that I would save this much again like this. Whilst we have saved in our own names etc we definitely weren't in a position to max out of own ISA allowances every year first.

They are getting a generous amount of money (way over normal budget) from us for their 18th for 'fun' and we are funding driving lessons/parental contribution to uni out of our won income/savings, so it is easier to do a straight transfer into a ISA for the whole lot.

RamblingEclectic · 03/06/2022 10:11

I'd say neither is entirely unreasonable and with the amount you're saving, it makes sense to me to have both savings for them to an amount you're comfortable with being in their control at 18 and another for later if there is something you want to make sure there are funds for.

I was given a few thousand at 18 by my grandfather and it made the transition to independence a lot easier, and so I'm trying to do similar for my kids. Sure, they might go crazy, but the damage is limited and with my oldest at 17 and having discussed it regularly, I'm not seeing signs he's preparing to blow it all.

PhotoDad · 03/06/2022 10:03

MrsClatterbuck · 03/06/2022 10:01

Just a note to advise if you die the monies in your name form part of your estate.
If joint with spouse they will go to the survivor of the account and if they die form part of their estate. You would have to mention the specific account in your will and who is to benefit from it.

Yes; also, in a divorce, the money might also not end up going where you would like!

MrsClatterbuck · 03/06/2022 10:01

Just a note to advise if you die the monies in your name form part of your estate.
If joint with spouse they will go to the survivor of the account and if they die form part of their estate. You would have to mention the specific account in your will and who is to benefit from it.

TeenPlusCat · 03/06/2022 09:52

Just suppose 1 in 100 teens go off the rails a bit around the age of 18.
Are you willing to risk your hard won savings against them not being in that 1%?

megletthesecond · 03/06/2022 09:49

Yanbu. Put as much in your name as you can.
It doesn't matter what you instill in them they can still go off the rails and waste it. And it won't really be a lesson learnt, they'll just feel awful about it and have lost opportunities. That money won't come back.

PhotoDad · 03/06/2022 09:44

Everyone here has such different experiences, so here's mine just for comparison. We set up JISAs for DD (now 18) and DS (now 14) and started talking to them about it very early. Both of them have agreed that a house deposit is the best use of the cash. We put the savings into their names partly because our finances fluctuate a bit and if it were in my name, I'd be too tempted to raid that pot from time to time.

DD got around £25k on her birthday. She took £1k as spending money, and moved the rest to a standard stocks-and-shares ISA. On my advice, she also opened a LISA and transferred £4k to it, and will do the same with the rest until it's all there. The plan might change, if she finds that she can't live on the standard student loan -- we'll be topping it up to max.

Of course it might all go horribly wrong with DS!

Proudboomer · 03/06/2022 09:41

I saved for mine and including them in the saving plan. Encouraged them to put away at least half of any monetary gifts they were given and then at 18 transferred the accounts over to them.The older is now 25 and still saving and has around £50k in his Issa. He has saved at least half of this himself. My younger has slightly less as he has learnt to drive and bought a car but he should have enough saved for a deposit to buy a property by the end of this year.

not every 18 year old will waste their savings as soon as they get access to it. But I believe you have to teach them about the importance of saving and include them in the actual process so they can watch their money grow. They need to learn that it takes time and some sacrifices to save a decent sum of money and once they have it to appreciate it and not squander it.

Dinotour · 03/06/2022 09:39

Savings for money others had given him and account in our name for money we are saving.

Dinotour · 03/06/2022 09:38

Any money DS got when too young to decide how to spend it I popped into a savings account in his name, we have a savings account in our name though earmarked for when he is older.

Youseethethingis1 · 03/06/2022 09:35

@Maggiethecat your DC would love me then, as my DS isn't even 3 yet 😂
I think there can be tax implications if they hit the lifetime limit (over £1 million just now) and they won't be able to save tax efficiently into a pension after that ceiling is hit.
I won't cry if my sons diamond shoes are too tight though, and anyway I don't actually think saving so much into a pension is a great idea as Chancellor after Chancellor seems to think they are fair game to mess around with.
I think for retirement savings splitting between pension (tax free on way in) and S&S ISAs (tax free on the way out and available when needed not just when the government says you can have it) is the way to go.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 03/06/2022 09:29

Split the money, one account in their name that can be used at 18 for whatever they like (hopefully something sensible like their first car) and an account in your name that can be used for the benefit of the child at your discretion, maybe education, or maybe gifted to them for a house deposit or wedding fund.

Work out how to split it based upon what you consider would be a safe and sensible amount for them to have at 18.

Cocodreams · 03/06/2022 09:19

We have a Junior Stocks & Shares ISA for DS(7) and save monthly into that.

In our names we also have S&S Cash ISA’s for his future house deposit and University fund (if he doesn’t go to the latter then we will use it for something else). We also have a SIPP for him.

Our DNiece is the same age and has nearly £100k in her Junior S&S ISA already which we think is absolutely crazy as the amount when she’s 18 will be massive (it is already obviously). It’s too much money for an 18yo to get their hands on - they could ignore all your financial advice, be feckless, have manipulative friends etc. Far better to distribute investments across yours and their name and when it’s on your name don’t tell them the money exists. DH is adamant that is DS turns out to be irresponsible then he won’t see a penny of the money we are saving in his name until he proves otherwise.

Womblesaremyfavouritefood · 03/06/2022 09:04

We're saving for our DC but it's in my name. They will get it when we, as parents, decide, not before. It's to be used as a house deposit.

Testina · 03/06/2022 09:03

TeenPlusCat · 03/06/2022 08:55

You can educate all you want but a minority of teens go off the rails and you don't know which ones that will be, especially when they are only 4 or 10.

I’d add to this that it isn’t even about going off the rails, which is easy (but foolish!) to assume won’t happen.

It can be buying a £5K car when all your friends have a £2K car that would have done. A holiday and being too generous with buying drinks and banana boat rides for your mates and coming back £1K lighter… a new phone you didn’t need.

There are so many ways an educated, well supported “good kid” can waste a financial opportunity.

TeenPlusCat · 03/06/2022 08:55

Zeus44 · 03/06/2022 08:52

Sounds like she/he wasn’t properly educated and had the right people around them.

You can educate all you want but a minority of teens go off the rails and you don't know which ones that will be, especially when they are only 4 or 10.

RoseGoldEagle · 03/06/2022 08:54

I remember the joy of my student loan going into my account, I always felt so rich, and yet every term I would run out of money with a week or so of term left, I remember walking instead of getting the bus, and eaten random combinations of food that I already had in the cupboards. I was 18, supposedly bright and definitely fairly boring and sensible, but it never occurred to me to budget, and make sure my money could last all term.

If I’d been given a big lump sum of money at that age, I’d have undoubtedly wasted it. It took working for a few years, renting my own place, wanting to travel, wanting a house etc to make me realise the value of money. DH was much more sensible with money at that age, but you just never know So we’re saving for our DC in our names for that reason.

Zeus44 · 03/06/2022 08:52

Sounds like she/he wasn’t properly educated and had the right people around them.

mrsfoof · 03/06/2022 08:50

My children are 10-12. I've saved some money in their JISA (about £10/month plus some birthday / Christmas money). This will give them in the region of £6-8K at 18 which is more than enough to buy a car, have a gap year etc.
I've got separate accounts in my name which I'll give to them when I think the time is right (probably house deposit).

Getoff · 03/06/2022 08:44

Discovereads · 02/06/2022 20:50

Children get access to junior ISAs at age 16, not 18.

They can start managing their account at 16, they can't withdraw money until they are 18.

Getoff · 03/06/2022 08:41

JustLyra · 02/06/2022 18:44

Money in children’s savings accounts counts toward benefits beyond a certain amount as well (as they are generally accessible by the parent).

Money in a Junior ISA will not affect the benefits a parent can claim, because the parents can't access it.

The one time I claimed, I had a large chunk of money in my own name that wasn't counted as savings at all, because it was held in shares that couldn't be sold immediately.

Swipe left for the next trending thread