Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about child savings?

138 replies

pinkunicorns54 · 02/06/2022 18:02

Happy to be told I am being unreasonable just need some perspective!

We currently have a junior ISA set up for our toddler. Saving roughly £80pm - I suddenly have a sudden thought of if we are able to do this until they are 18, there will be a fair whack in there - I'm nervous about them having access to this when they are 18 and maybe not have the maturity to know how to manage this!

My DH thinks that we will be ok just instilling financial education into them when they are growing up and if they do decide to blow it on things I wouldn't want them to - then we just need to suck it up as it will be there's...

I'm of the view that we save in our names, so we have more control over it...

YABU - leave it in their name

YANBU - save it in yours!

Happy for anecdotes from people who have done similar / have grown up children!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
savoycabbage · 06/05/2023 15:19

My dd is 19 and of the Child Trust Fund era. Every one of the 18 year olds that I know whose parents put extra money into theirs have blown it on holidays and other things that were unnecessary. It might not have helped that most of them spent their eighteenth birthdays in lockdown and were desperate for some fun.

CookieBaker88 · 06/05/2023 13:51

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Mummyshark2019 · 04/06/2022 09:17

I have been saving for my child since birth. He has two accounts. One with the main savings pot in my name and a second account in his name (where all xmas and birthday money is deposited). This is a child ISA. He also has a SIPP which he will be able to access at retirement.

I feel having the bulk of savings in his name is too risky. My intention is to use this for university fees, first car etc...

sashh · 04/06/2022 06:16

Isn't this why people put money into a trust? So it belongs to the child but they cannot access it until certain circumstances eg marriage, 25th birthday, house buying etc etc.

ChampagneLassie · 04/06/2022 03:33

Unless you're maxing out your own ISAs I wouldn't be saving into JISAs. Just save in your own ISA, gives you more flexibility and control.

Suddha · 04/06/2022 02:34

You can get a child savings account which reverts to you at 18 so you control the funds. When I was 18 my boyfriend fleeced me for most of my student loan. Borrowing, asking for expensive gifts, blackmailing, and eventually hitting me and taking money out of my purse. I was too naive. You can teach your kids financial sense but you can’t stop others being greedy and manipulative, and it’s too easy nowadays to transfer money out of an account.

Sweepingeyelashes · 04/06/2022 02:30

My children are quite frugal. The 20 year old is a bit woebegone that the growth fund he invested in has taken a hit with the sharemarket slump. The eldest is in medical school with a part-time casual job. It all depends on how sensible your children are likely to be.

Chaoslatte · 04/06/2022 02:02

Absolutely financial education. I came into around £40k when I was 19. I had a great time at uni living off real food rather than beans on toast and travelling (cheaply) in the summers, and then bought a house when I was 24. By no means will all young people just waste it all. Actually the reason I didn’t was because I knew it was my only chance to get on the housing ladder and I suspect things won’t have improved much there but the time your DC has grown up.

Sswhinesthebest · 03/06/2022 17:16

Account in my name and is now being syphoned into a Lisa as they are 18.

Trafficjamlog · 03/06/2022 16:44

I have a child older than 18 and he doesn’t have his money. It’s in his name but in an account linked to mine and my email address. I’ve not offered him access to it but I do give him some if he asks for it. Have no intention in handing it over to him at least until he finishes uni. Whilst I appreciate he can have it I don’t feel even slightly guilty holding on to it for him. My parents did the same for me

SquigglePigs · 03/06/2022 16:42

We have one ISA in DD's name with a few thousand in (an inheritance and the ISA was a condition). The money we're saving for her is in an account in my name. Although I hope she will be sensible at 18 I'm not willing to risk it so we will keep it in our names and then she will have choices on how to use it. If she blows the money in the ISA in her name then it would be disappointing but not the end of the world. If she did it with the amount we're saving I would be quite upset and she would likely regret it when she is older.

Ithoughtsummerwascoming · 03/06/2022 16:36

Teen and simple I do agree.

I can't blame anyone for wanting to blow some cash with a windfall but there is a difference between blowing it because they dont have money training and blowing it with money training.

DH and I are now trained like monkeys and any money 💰 get split 100 way.

A 10k windfall would go into various pots and savings!

MissChanandlerBong80 · 03/06/2022 16:15

Really interesting thread. I don’t think either is right or wrong, there are pros and cons either way. My parents have set up junior ISAs for my children (who are toddlers) and they’re paying a certain amount into them each month. It’s my parents’ money, not mine, so it’s entirely up to my parents what they do with it, but I am concerned about my children coming into fairly large sums of money aged 18.

SimpleShootingWeekend · 03/06/2022 15:56

Loads of adults would blow a windfall too. Most adults spend spare income on having a nice time and nice things that could be saved for the future. Even people who are good savers don’t save every penny they can. Adults who have been in charge of their own saving and spending for decades can make daft and impulsive choices if they get a sudden windfall. Teens shouldn’t be held up to a higher standard. The difference is the parent has done the saving and thinks they have no right to spend in on what is important to them in the moment. If you want the right to decide what the money you have earned and set aside is to be spent on then save in your name.
How many 18 year olds aren’t used to having any money? Most of them will have been working for 2 years.

TeenPlusCat · 03/06/2022 15:37

Ithoughtsummerwascoming · 03/06/2022 14:14

Re the 1% absolutely but...a child who has learned money management from very age, has already infused the habit of spending and saving, understand the rudiments of investment and compound interest etc...why would that child blow it all?

This is why I got both dc bank cards and some money to manage right now.
So habits are already established!

Because:


  • they're 18 and they are rebelling

  • they have an unsuitable boyfriend/girlfriend who they are influenced by / are trying to impress

  • their brains are still developing so they decide to have a blow out holiday instead

  • they've got into drink/drugs and their previously sensible self has gone up in smoke

Teens can know all the theory and still not put it into practice. Most no doubt will be fine, but there are enough threads on here to show a significant minority are not. And you don't know when they are 4 or 14 which way any individual will go.

Ithoughtsummerwascoming · 03/06/2022 14:14

Re the 1% absolutely but...a child who has learned money management from very age, has already infused the habit of spending and saving, understand the rudiments of investment and compound interest etc...why would that child blow it all?

This is why I got both dc bank cards and some money to manage right now.
So habits are already established!

StrawberryPot · 03/06/2022 14:10

Definitely don't let them have access to a large amount of money at 18 - I speak from experience!

Darkstar4855 · 03/06/2022 14:06

I have a JSA for mine but it’s registered to a different address so with any luck he won’t find out about it until he’s financially responsible enough to access it!

BreakinbadBreakineven · 03/06/2022 13:20

I save in a savings account in my name then I'll probably give her some at a time as and when she needs it for big thjngs like a car or uni.

Ithoughtsummerwascoming · 03/06/2022 13:14

@RoseGoldEagle

I was the Same.
And it's still hanging around my neck.

My df tried loosely to educate me re Money but I hate to say ,not well or properly.

Proper financial education is non existent.

I've seen the most pitiful financial education in action and the people giving it ,can't save themselves!

Investment education is important and should be taught properly.

People say " my neice inherited 10 grand and spent it at 18 on madconands and tattoos"...

Did that 18 year old ever have prior savings? Did she ever...save or understand investment?
Had she ever had to manage her money?

PurpleFlower1983 · 03/06/2022 12:54

We have decided to cap their junior ISAs at 10k each then save the rest ourselves for them so if they do blow it it’s not the end of the world!

WaterBottle123 · 03/06/2022 12:51

Absolutely save in your name, anything else is madness.

SimpleShootingWeekend · 03/06/2022 10:52

I have an 18yo and a 17yo so I know an awful lot of dc who have got access to their CTF in the last couple of years. I know 2 who have transferred it to LISAs, and roughly 10 who have basically spent it weed. The majority have spent it on “living” so better phones than they would otherwise have, more clothes, Ibiza for 10 nights rather than 7, a trip to NY that they wouldn’t have otherwise been able to have, gaming computers and cocktails. It hasn’t helped that gap year travel has been off the cards for many, and driving lessons have been tricky. I do know a girl who bought a car (parents paid for the lessons) and she bought a brand new car. Without the money she may have stuck to a £2k car instead. It’s absolute crap that you can prevent “waste”, whatever that means to you, through financial education alone. It’s developmentally appropriate for these kids to be branching out and be pretty impulsive. There is a rough correlation between how impulsive these kids were when they were younger and how “sensible” they are being now but it isn’t really related to how well parented they are, or how affluent their family is. Nobody can guarantee “well, my 4yo would never spend money on weed” or “it’s for driving lessons/education so I’ll tell them that and they won’t buy a gaming computer.” I have 4 dc, 1 saver, 1 spender and 2 in the middle but they’ve all been raised in the same house with the same values. I wouldn’t want any of them to be burdened with the responsibility of my diligent savings at 18. A couple of grand is great to ease transition to adulthood, or even to blow on a great time but I would rather save in my own name and transfer to Lisas at 18.

mumofone2019 · 03/06/2022 10:52

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn at the poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Singlebutmarried · 03/06/2022 10:49

pinkunicorns54 · 02/06/2022 18:02

Happy to be told I am being unreasonable just need some perspective!

We currently have a junior ISA set up for our toddler. Saving roughly £80pm - I suddenly have a sudden thought of if we are able to do this until they are 18, there will be a fair whack in there - I'm nervous about them having access to this when they are 18 and maybe not have the maturity to know how to manage this!

My DH thinks that we will be ok just instilling financial education into them when they are growing up and if they do decide to blow it on things I wouldn't want them to - then we just need to suck it up as it will be there's...

I'm of the view that we save in our names, so we have more control over it...

YABU - leave it in their name

YANBU - save it in yours!

Happy for anecdotes from people who have done similar / have grown up children!

If you want them to have something and not access it up they’re all sensible start a child pension.

Swipe left for the next trending thread