Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nursing should be re-named?

544 replies

SunshinePie · 02/06/2022 17:42

Was pondering over this recently, is calling “nursing” is a bit old fashioned? You now need a degree to be a nurse, and they often are pretty much doing junior doctor jobs. Calling it something else that recognises it’s academic demands, and also more inclusive to males wanting to work in the field…something like Healthcare Medic / Healthcare Practitioner/ Assistant Medic…. Or similar, you get the idea….

-YABU, it should be kept “nurse”, it’s traditional and has roots in “nursing an infant” ie breastfeeding (that reflects the caring nature)

-YANBU it’s old fashioned, insulting to people with degrees and esp males.

OP posts:
lameasahorse · 03/06/2022 00:24

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Topgub · 03/06/2022 00:15

@lameasahorse

I dont have a chip on my shoulder

I dont understand why you think a nurse who is responsible for caring for your relative wouldn't be capable of answering those questions

They seem pretty basic and easy to answer to me

Dealing with relatives and their expectations absolutely is a skill. One which (much like smears and injections) nurses are far more capable of due to repeated exposure.

I've had to stay with patients and relatives countless times and go over what the doctor has said because they didn't understand. Because the doctor used jargon and skirted round or rushed

Youre experience doesn't match mine but that doesn't make mine invalid

lameasahorse · 03/06/2022 00:10

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

lameasahorse · 03/06/2022 00:08

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

ANP2020 · 03/06/2022 00:06

I hope the doctor does know things like that about your relatives to continued holistic treatment of them! Pretty useless if they don’t know if they’ve needed pain relief top ups, or if bladder and bowels are working as they should be.

Topgub · 03/06/2022 00:05

@PomRuns

Yeah mine too

Thank goodness.

Couldn't cope with working with doctors who want hero worship

ANP2020 · 03/06/2022 00:03

Your incorrect there, nurses can do further 2.5 years msc to become advanced clinical practitioners (as can paramedics and other hcps). The course focuses on diagnosing, treatment plans and full prescribing. They can then work in GP surgery’s seeing the same pts as doctors, or on the wards.

unfortunately the roles changed to sustain the needs of the NHS you can get 2 ACPs for the price of one GP just the general public haven’t been kept updated!

Topgub · 03/06/2022 00:02

@Luredbyapomegranate

Maybe you should look up the NMC code of conduct?

I dont remember the charge nurse in the Vale of leven enquiry being able to pass the buck to the consultants

ozymandiusking · 03/06/2022 00:02

When I was a Nurse, ( a long time ago! ) we were taught that it was better to be a first class Nurse rather that a second rate Doctor.

lameasahorse · 03/06/2022 00:02

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Topgub · 02/06/2022 23:59

@lameasahorse

You asked a question. I answered. Honestly.

I'm not overstating my experience.

Nurse prescibers exist. ANP prescribe, run their own clinics and perform minor surgeries

Its fairly insulting to suggest that even 'ward nurses' wouldn't know what tests were required or what prognosis a diagnosis would give.

I routinely pick up px errors and omissions. Thats my job.

I'm quite disappointed but not surprised by the reluctance to accept the huge skill and knowledge nursing involves.

Is it sexism? Classism? Maybe both.

PomRuns · 02/06/2022 23:56

@Junepassing wow such a nasty post.

Luredbyapomegranate · 02/06/2022 23:55

Topgub · 02/06/2022 23:36

@Luredbyapomegranate

Really?

Nurses are accountable for theor practice.

If a doctor prescribes a drug wrongly and a nurse gives it, they will be held accountable for their lack of knowledge of the properties of that drug.

The doctor told me to is not a defence.

The consultant is accountable for their own practice, not mine.

The buck stops with me.

No the buck doesn’t stop with you.

Of course you are supposed to question prescriptions that are clearly incorrect, any skilled team member is required to do that, in any work situation, from building sites to cruise ships.

But treatment plans are decided and signed off by the consultant team. They consult nurses and other medical professionals. But the buck stops with them. It’s crazy you are questioning this BTW, it’s established protocol.

PomRuns · 02/06/2022 23:54

@lameasahorse some nurses do prescribe and absolutely are aware of
contra indications for prescribing.
too many assumptions on this thread, there are so many different roles and specialities and different levels of autonomy. There’s not normally nonsense like this thread in trusts - simply not time or desire to squabble, people generally work together in my experience.

Junepassing · 02/06/2022 23:52

Nurses aren't known for being the cream of the crop intellectually, and consequently it seems to attract a fair few characters who are insecure about their own role. I've lost count of the times I've been belittled and barked at by nurses, however I've never had that from any of the AHPs or Doctors I've worked with, who have always been unfailingly respectful and appreciative. It speaks volumes. The nurse upthread arguing the toss about how certain nurses are more senior/knowledgeable than Doctors . . 🙄They don't need a different title, many of them need an attitude adjustment.

lameasahorse · 02/06/2022 23:52

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

lameasahorse · 02/06/2022 23:50

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

lameasahorse · 02/06/2022 23:48

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Bagadverts · 02/06/2022 23:41

As a patient this thread is pretty depressing. I know this is an anonymous online forum but the bickering about who has most knowledge or specialism is sad.

As a patient I’ve had wonderful and shocking treatment from all kinds of health professionals. Both nurses and doctors have provided specialist care. Nurses in high dependency were amazing.

OTOH Family members who are doctors have been given more information from my doctors than when I ask the same questions, like it’s a club even though it’s my body

As an about 16 year old, first time on adult ward. I sat in a chair hearing nurses at the station chatting for about 30 minutes about how doctor’s child had special privileges and cubicles. I was so upset and as soon the doctor came I asked to be moved. I was in a cubicle because I’d be there a few days, nothing to do with my parents.

The latter part of the thread also feels like it denigrates basic care. Maybe that is what health care assistants rather than nurses do now such as bathing, turning, feeding, bringing tea. It’s the stuff that makes me feel human when I have a drip and pain or feel lonely.

Topgub · 02/06/2022 23:37

@lameasahorse

Yes.

Whether I would or not would depend on lots of factors.

Topgub · 02/06/2022 23:36

@Luredbyapomegranate

Really?

Nurses are accountable for theor practice.

If a doctor prescribes a drug wrongly and a nurse gives it, they will be held accountable for their lack of knowledge of the properties of that drug.

The doctor told me to is not a defence.

The consultant is accountable for their own practice, not mine.

The buck stops with me.

SunflowerGardens · 02/06/2022 23:31

PostMenPatWithACat · 02/06/2022 22:33

Are healthcsre assistants trained to nurse? Can they tell if a patient is dehydrated and deal with it? Can they sit and smell if a patient is deteriorating? Can they actually arrange a pillow for comfort? Can they sit and judge if a patient is in pain?

Of course they can? They aren't brainless idiots. HCAs often work in a pair with a nurse on the wards like when carrying our personal care for and moving and handling bed bound patients. The inexperienced HCAs will be learning from working with the nurses all the time. And they have ongoing training that allows them to carry out more complex tasks throughout their career.

lameasahorse · 02/06/2022 23:31

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Luredbyapomegranate · 02/06/2022 23:30

Topgub · 02/06/2022 18:53

@Notallangels

My ego is fine thanks. I'm very secure in my opinion of my professional ability.

More qualified? Depends on your definition.Certainly not more experienced.

I have no choice but to escalate as that is protocol. But most of the time they come and tell me to do what I've already done.

I dont think FY1s are beneath me. But they're not above me either. Neither are consultants.

Thankfully the consultants I work with would be horrified to think anyone thought they should be.

But that protocol is there for a reason.

Of course most of the time you’ll be doing what the consultant asks for anyway, because you are following protocol.

And of course when treatments need to be altered or aren’t working any good consultant team will take your opinion, and that of other experienced specialists into account.

But being a consultant is similar to being in any leadership role - you are not being paid for the 80 or 90% of the time that things are occurring more or less as expected, you are being paid for when they don’t. And when they don’t, it is the responsibility of the consultant team to decide what do to. It’s good leadership to make the whole team feel part of that decision, but whatever you think, they know it’s their decision. This is it to suggest nursing isn’t very important - it is , but is it is not primarily centred around diagnostic decision making, and when it comes to treatment plans, the buck stops with the consultant team, not the nursing team.

Topgub · 02/06/2022 23:28

@lameasahorse

I'd be pretty unimpressed if the nurse in charge of my relatives care couldn't answer a question about their care

Worried too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread