Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to know more about this family history stuff...or should it all just stay in the past?

34 replies

Rojan · 02/06/2022 13:55

I never met any of my fathers family. I was told his mum died when he was a young child, and his dad also had died years earlier, and accepted that. My dad was brought up from infancy to age 11 by his maternal grandparents as his mum had severe MH issues. At 11 his dad remarried, and he moved to live with him his new wife and their children.

Many years later when my dad died, I found out that he had (during my lifetime) been living under a different name to his birth name. He'd taken my mum's surname and used his middle name as a first name. So if he was John Edward Smith and my mum was Jane Brown, he called himself Eddie Brown. My parents were never married (I didn't know this while they were alive) and my dad was married to someone else.

I did some research after my dad died, and found his real name, and details of his parents and his wife (I recently found out she only died 2 years ago). His dad died when I was a teenager, and his mum died when my dad was in his 30s, not a child. I couldn't find any details of divorce or subsequent marriage for his dad.

I just have so many unanswered questions about it all. Particularly my grandmother, was she in an institution for 30 years? Did my dad even know or did they just tell him she died?

There's no one I can ask about this, my dad had a close friend who died before him but no others. None of my mums family who are still living knew anything about my dad's life before he met my mum. I don't know to what extent I can research via Ancestry or similar - or whether I'd just be wasting my time?

I don't know why I want to know. Part of me thinks maybe some stuff I'm not meant to know, and if i do delve into it all, what will I do with that information? But I keep coming back to it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rojan · 02/06/2022 18:50

Sorry if I wasn't clear, the person who died 2 years ago was the lady that my dad was married to. My dads mum died many years before I was born.

What was a bit unexpected was that she lived in the same part of London as my mum was from. When I found out about the marriage (and lack of divorce) I'd assumed she had moved away or even abroad. I guess thats something I won't ever know about.

I've been thinking and part of it is probably because I know a lot about my mums side. There are some amazing women on that side, my 2 great grandmothers in particular. My dad did tell me a little about his childhood and maternal grandmother, but said almost nothing about his mum, and I would really like to understand more about what happened to her, it makes me sad to think she may have been in an institution for most of her life.

OP posts:
mrsjoyfulprizeforraffiawork · 02/06/2022 18:10

We had an unknown scandal in our family (my mother's grandfather became estranged from his wife, who was pretty horrible by all surviving relatives' accounts, and the family surname was changed officially) but my mother's generation were never told what had really happened and she was longing to know. After she had died (unfortunately) I was doing family history stuff, just in general about lots of branches of our family and I put a post on Knowhere guide for a town in Scotland my own grandfather came from. Someone replied about 2 years later and turned out to be the granddaughter of my mother's scandalous grandfather from his second family that we didn't know existed. They didn't know we existed either. She and I unravelled the scandal. My DM's grandfather had a v unhappy marriage with his unpleasant first wife . He then fell in love with his cousin and eventually went to live with her - this was around 1920 and they had two children. They weren't able to marry because nasty wife refused a divorce. He had changed his surname so that he and his new partner shared the same surname, presumably to conceal the fact that he was not married to the mother of his second family (very scandalous in those times). Nasty wife then changed her and her children's surnames to the same one out of spite. I think family history is fascinating. When we found all this out all the main player were very long dead so no-one was upset (apart from my new cousin who took a long time to accept that her grandparents had not been married - she said her grandmother was a very "proper" Victorian-type lady and she couldn't imagine such a thing - we found absolutely no record of a marriage).

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 02/06/2022 17:47

I don't think a DNA test will help. You're wanting to find out details of relationships not discover secret relatives.
If you know your gran died two years ago, did you get a copy of her death certificate? It will tell you where she died and who registered the death. That should at least answer your question about whether she was still living in a MH facility and also give you a contact name for trying to find out more concerning her contact with your DH as an adult, etc.

godmum56 · 02/06/2022 17:39

Momicrone · 02/06/2022 16:40

I think it's awful to leave things like this in the past, I would want to know

why is it awful

dudsville · 02/06/2022 16:57

My family history has a murderer white supremacist, non murdering but destructive white supremacists, a strong willed woman willing to burn the family house down to effect change, and misogyny that actively physically harmed women. These aren't things I'm proud of, at all, these facts make me uncomfortable, but these are the people who came before me and I value not being blind to it.

Ringmaster27 · 02/06/2022 16:46

I’d want to know too.
My paternal grandmother is the result of a WWII fling. She never knew who her real dad was. Her mother met and married my grandmother’s step-father when she was pregnant and that was that. It wasn’t mentioned again until years later when she was told as a teenager that the man who’d raised her was her younger brother’s dad but not her’s.
All my great grandmother had was a name. No contact information, no pictures, nothing. So again it went quiet and no more questions were asked.
About 10 years ago, when my great grandmother was long dead, my uncle came across some of her things in my Nan’s loft and that brought it all up again, so he decided to dig further. He used online Ancestry type databases and did a 23-and-Me dna test, and ended up tracking down the family of my grandmother’s biological father in America. Turns out he was an American soldier who was stationed in the area during the war. He was also dead, but his family had absolutely no idea of my Nan’s existence and were pretty sure that he didn’t know about her either!

Momicrone · 02/06/2022 16:40

I think it's awful to leave things like this in the past, I would want to know

TheSpottedZebra · 02/06/2022 16:39

If you're curious, you just have to be prepared that you could find out ANYTHING - good as well as bad. And be prepared for that.

My mum had some answered things,but guessed that there were some bad secrets. And there were! But she was prepared.

fallfallfall · 02/06/2022 16:36

I think it’s both interesting and educational from a sociological perspective.
I think it’s worth researching.

yesthatisdrizzle · 02/06/2022 16:33

Hi OP, there is a 'genealogy' board on MN with some knowledgeable people, so maybe ask some questions on there?

Greenpolkadot · 02/06/2022 16:27

I have been researching my family history for years, its fascinating.
I would encourage you to get your DNA tested. All sorts of links come to light then.
Researchers help each other and while you may never find the reasons why your father changed his name, you may discover photos of the grandparents you never knew

Good luck

2catsandacomputer · 02/06/2022 16:18

Like others, I would also recommend doing a DNA test through Ancestry and/or 23andme.

I did both and connected with a number of 2nd and 3rd cousins that I didn't know anything about.

One cousin in particular, his mother was adopted and they knew nothing about her birth mother's family.

The adopted child, along with her son, had emigrated to the USA just after World War 2 (she was a war bride) and he now lives in Colorado. Nobody knew anything about their family history from the UK.

After we worked out how closely we were related, combined with what little information they had about his mother I was able to identify who his mother was (it turned out that my grandfather and his grandmother were brother and sister - so his mother (the adopted child) and my mother were cousins) and gave him a whole load of information about his family that he had no idea about.

It absolutely blew him away. He had resigned himself to never really knowing anything about his mother's birth family (she died quite young) and was overwhelmed that just from his daughter doing a DNA test he was able to find out about his real family.

My mother is still alive (she's in her 80s) and I spoke to her about her adopted cousin and she was able to fill in a lot of the story as to why it happened.

I also shared this story with some friends of mine who live in the US and I was surprised that a number of them then opened up and said that they had similar stories of finding unknown cousins from when children had been adopted or otherwise looked after.

Rojan · 02/06/2022 15:55

This is all very very long ago, my dad if still alive would be almost 100 now. His marriage was just after the war ended. There were no children of the marriage and I did find my dad on electoral rolls from the 1950s living alone or certainly not with his wife. He didn't meet my mum until 1970 so I don't think it was an affair as such. But I don't know for certain of course.

I have looked through news archives and similar, there was something about my grandmother winning a prize as a child, and a couple of other bits and pieces but not much more. I did find my grandfather in the war archives, he was in the Royal Marines from 1912.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 02/06/2022 15:15

SchoolThing · 02/06/2022 14:33

Knowing who and where you come from is an important part of finding your sense of belonging in the world.

I would really encourage you to investigate. Good luck!!!

This. It would torment me unless I’d at least tried to investigate. There’s nobody left to be harmed by it. I wish you luck too.

WhereYouLeftIt · 02/06/2022 15:12

I would want to know.

Dominuse · 02/06/2022 15:09

Is it likely you Dad had an affair and lived with his OW (your mum) as his wife wouldn’t give him a divorce (was common in the 59/60/70)

Investicat · 02/06/2022 15:06

If you make a family tree using what you know on ancestry and link it to a DNA test on there you might be able to make contact with cousins etc who may be able to fill in the gaps.

I would be wary though. I have found out some stuff about certain family members I would probably in hindsight have preferred not to know.

Whatapickle21 · 02/06/2022 15:03

I would definitely recommend doing a DNA test and registering with Ancestry. My paternal grandmother died when my dad was a baby and he went into care, with no dad on the scene. I had no knowledge of anything from that side of the family. I have now found lots of extended family on Ancestry and learned a lot about events in the past. It has definitely brought me some comfort and closure, plus new family members (including a nephew that I did know existed and only discovered through DNA, which was amazing!) Not every discovery is necessarily positive but I found that getting answers was important to me.

godmum56 · 02/06/2022 14:54

I would leave it in the past. There are unanswered questions in both my family and in my late husbands. we figured if people didn't want this stuff known its not up to us to go against their wishes.....Different if you have medical reasons for knowing.

balalake · 02/06/2022 14:53

How will you feel if you don't try to find out? Records post 1921 that are accessible are limited though.

NotDavidTennant · 02/06/2022 14:50

Sites like Ancestry will help you piece together a family tree, but if you want life stories of individuals you really need to find some people who actually knew them.

Noelsjumper · 02/06/2022 14:48

It sounds like such a sad tale. Unfortunately ancestry etc only really work for family history 100+ years ago in terms of documents etc due to confidentiality I think. You can create a tree and potentially connect with distant relatives who could fill in the gaps/may upload more recent things. Might be best to try one of those DNA kits that link in with it?

Have you searched the archives of local newspapers to see if there's any mention of the family?

Back in the day it was fairly common to go by your middle name rather than your own name, and I'd imagine it might have been difficult for your grandfather to get divorced if your grandmother didn't have capacity. Ruby Wax's episode of Who Do You Think You Are might be quite interesting for you as I think she has a similar story in part of her family.

Movinghouseatlast · 02/06/2022 14:37

I have just done an ancestry DNA test and I think I have traced my real dad! I only had a name, but because of 3 matches with his great great great aunt I have traced through from her.

I was also contacted by a lady who is my 1st cousin once removed on my mothers side and we have been swapping family stories.

Rojan · 02/06/2022 14:36

I'd not thought about DNA but it's definitely something I'd consider.

OP posts:
Rojan · 02/06/2022 14:35

With my grandmother I think I'd like to know what happened to her, was she kept in an institution for 30 years or was she ever released? My dads last memory of her was aged 5 or so, she was clearly very unwell and he was taken to see her. She cried and begged him to take her home 😥as far as I know he never saw her again.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread