Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP and his smelly friend

256 replies

ThatSmellIsntMeHonest · 01/06/2022 17:03

DP and I have a shared hobby, and we drive an hour each way every Saturday to take part in it. We started dating as lockdown eased and I’d stay with him on weekends when it was allowed and we would travel in together. I never knew about the friend. Once mask rules were relaxed, DP said his friend, Jim, would be coming back to join us for the hobby. Jim drives but doesn’t have a car and lives a fair way away and so he gets the train, DP collects him from the station. Then we drive another 45 minutes- then the same in reverse in the evening. This has always been their arrangement and it only stopped because of Covid (friend refused to wear a mask so couldn’t travel by train).

The first time we collected Jim from the station, Jim went to get in the back, but DP indicated to him to get in the front and Jim asked if he was sure, DP said yes (not mentioned this to me before!) and so he got in the front and I got in the back. I quickly realised that Jim smells. Badly. A mix of body odour, urine and… damp? I’m not sure but it’s really quite horrific. DP claimed he couldn’t smell it at first but would always open a window (even on freezing cold days) as soon as Jim got in the car! DP now admits that Jim is “starting to smell a bit”. The smell is getting worse. It’s so strong I can smell it in the car for days afterwards.

A few times recently when we’ve gone to go out on a Sunday (we now live together), I’ve noticed the smell is still pretty bad in the car. It never occurred to me how it must’ve been in the fabric of the chair, etc. it just smells. Once after a day out I thought I could smell a similar, but not as strong, smell on my own clothes as I put them in the wash, but I decided I must be imagining it. Fast forward to this Sunday and we went to hell a friend move and after a while she asked what the smell was. I wasn’t sure what she meant and she said there was a strange smell. Eventually after sniffing her kitchen cupboards etc she clearly realised it was coming from me and asked if everything was alright. We’re very close and I asked her what it smelt of! She said she wasn’t sure but she was certain I had an… odour. Then it dawned on me. I took her to the car which had been closed in the warmth for a couple of hours by now and when we opened then door she said “that, you smell of that!” I told her everything. I was mortified. We went home and I washed my clothes and then washed them again, and took a long hot shower. I could smell it on my jeans. I don’t think he actually messed the seat (it was dry!) but I think somehow the smell is… seeping into the fabric? I’ve just gone to check the car (we haven’t used it since) and it still smells faintly.

I’m really at a loss of what to do! It’s the front passenger seat so I travel in it several times a week (I don’t drive). I’m wondering how many other people have thought I smell vaguely of BO and urine 🤢 This has been going on for months. My DP doesn’t see a problem and quite honestly would probably think it was funny if he knew what had happened on Sunday (I was too annoyed to tell him and have him laugh and find it funny). All I can think of is I start travelling in the back whenever we go out together (which will look and feel very weird, it’s also not the most comfortable of cars and I have back problems). I’m sure DP will be annoyed at this and say I’m over exaggerating, nagging, being difficult etc (and it would be pretty weird when we are the only ones in the car) but I don’t want to smell of someone else’s pee!

We are due to go out in a couple of hours and I’m dreading sitting in the car. It isn’t just the seat that worries me now, it’s the headrest, the belt. Since my friend said I smelt I’m paranoid and I don’t want to sit in a cinema smelling for 2 hours! I’m fully aware people have much bigger problems than this but what can I do that won’t cause issues with DP but also won’t make me feel uncomfortable whenever we go out in his car?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ICantLogIn · 19/11/2022 18:30

Ferrets! Could that the source of Jim's problem?! Although I wonder if the OP still has to deal with it. I hope they didn't break up over it.
It just came to me today: that would explain how the smell is so strange and hard to define (it's not quite like anything else), how it's so transferable (it's in their skin/fur and transfers to your clothes/hands), and how someone with a home/job/normal lifestyle could stink so badly.

LadyEloise1 · 09/06/2022 18:47

As StatsandFlaps says
".....If you truly truly love someone you wouldn't be physically capable of treating them in the way he treats you........You deserve better."

You do.

SlatsandFlaps · 05/06/2022 13:07

@ThatSmellIsntMeHonest Are you ok? Please don't give in to his coercive persuasion. This man sounds just like a boyfriend I once had. OBSESSED with his crappy, money-pit of a light aircraft and looking back he 'tolerated' me at best. I had to make my way on the train to Norfolk where he was stationed with the RAF so I could come along in his car otherwise I had to make my own way to where his little plane was hangared. I was then relegated to a chair in the hangar and I was not to keep talking 'at' him or to him - if I didn't like it, I could leave. Of course I absolutely adored him and so I put up with it. For 4 years.....
I realise my ex is worse than how you've described your partner to be, but the principle is the same. If you truly, truly love somebody you wouldn't be physically capable of treating them the way he treats you. That would just not be possible.
Please OP. You deserve better.

SlatsandFlaps · 05/06/2022 12:49

Miscfeminista · 02/06/2022 02:05

@SlatsandFlaps yes yes I know you don’t have to shower every day but that is very individual matter IMO, some people sweat less some more and are active differently throughout day as you noticed(I wouldn’t necessarily shower if I wasn’t out all day etc). My brother for example is really oily and has problems with dandruff, it would be easier for him to shower every day not only to wash off extra sebum but because it ends up being more practical. Otherwise you have to wash face, feet and possibly groin separately(nothing horrible happens if you keep shower short, use mild instead of hot water as well as modest amount of soap on groin, feet and skin folds and some moisturiser after-I have KP/“chicken skin”and washing daily with gentle washcloth before moisturising helps a lot). The only way showering every day may contribute to ageing is if you don’t moisture/use too hot water/too much soap and generally pull and tug your skin excessively(which I can see people who do above doing), it accumulates over years.

Also there’s the routine aspect that people who haven’t had chance to have proper hygiene for whatever reason during upbringing, have problems with so for that reason too it’s easier to just do it every day to not go back to skipping showers. We came from not very rich household with an exhausted overburdened and depressed mother so we never got those habits from beginning like other people who take it for granted may have. I had to teach myself proper hygiene when I left home around age 20 and it's not as easy as some may think(both effort and”research on the right way to do things”wise), just saying.

Still that’s part of being adult so if another well meaning adult points out to you that things are off(even if it comes off offensive at that moment)then I would take note and do better. I find men refusing basic hygiene(when they have conditions to maintain it and it has been pointed out to them)quite offensive, I would push DP to talk to the guy or refuse to be in the car with him(especially given I have motion sickness, almost died next to one similar guy who was driving us for hours I can feel for OP)

Who has 'pointed out to me' that I need to do better???? What on earth are you talking about?!?! All I said was that showering every single day is not necessary except in certain circumstances and you've come back with an essay on how to wash and said "next time someone points out to you that you need to do better" wtf?!?!

RenegadeMatron · 04/06/2022 22:14

Fair enough @FictionalCharacter ! Smile

There have been so many posts on the thread about how the OP can remove the stink, when that so clearly is not the actual issue.

FictionalCharacter · 04/06/2022 22:09

RenegadeMatron · 02/06/2022 19:47

What the??

Can people just stop suggesting washing and cleaning!??

The ONLY way to neutralise this odour is to remove the ‘D’P and his stinking friend from her life. Confused

I agree - I wasn't for a second suggesting that the OP should be washing and cleaning. I was making a general point that Febreze doesn't remove a stink, but I obviously made it badly!

LookItsMeAgain · 04/06/2022 11:34

As it's a Saturday, I'm wondering if you're at your activity today @ThatSmellIsntMeHonest and if Jim got a lift with you or if you're there at all.

Hope you're managing to get through these last few days ok.

Forgottenmypasswordagain · 03/06/2022 19:38

OP you deserve more consideration than that. I hope things work out for everyone.

Newestname002 · 03/06/2022 17:53

@YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp

Andfor those slugging Febreeze nothing smells worse than that on top of an already gag-inducing smell 🤢🤮 Why the heck anyone thinks spraying synthetic and sickening ‘freshener’ around improves things beats me!

So true!! I was once in a cab going across London and the SMELL (unsure if it was actually Febreeze or something very similar they'd used either in valeting the car or to hide some other stench) was horrendous. I thought I was going to be sick. I had the windows open, which helped, but it took a while to settle my stomach afterwards... 🌹

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 03/06/2022 13:31

It’s sad OP that stinking Jim and the hobby override you and common decency. I think that if I were you I would seriously consider ending the relationship because clearly you’re pretty low in the order of priorities for your other half.

Andfor those slugging Febreeze nothing smells worse than that on top of an already gag-inducing smell 🤢🤮 Why the heck anyone thinks spraying synthetic and sickening ‘freshener’ around improves things beats me!

KettrickenSmiled · 03/06/2022 12:56

@StingrayStingray I had to google Mothers' Day Mr Clean.
Fucksake! If only Valerie Solanas were still with us ...

www.paramountbusinesscoach.com/blog/10-worst-print-advertising-mistakes/

KettrickenSmiled · 03/06/2022 12:50

ThatSmellIsntMeHonest · 02/06/2022 22:29

Thank you all for the responses, I have taken them on board and we’ve had a big argument tonight. I’ll update more when I’m less tearful x

Sorry it's so awful for you OP Flowers

Don't feel obliged to come back until/unless you want to. It's tough when, as PP said, the blinkers are falling off. While it must have been unpleasant, it's good you had an argument. You will be able to assess how he responds, if he's prepared to value you, & exactly how selfish he's committed to carry on being.

Take care of yourself today. Maybe go out & do something nice, just for you?

KettrickenSmiled · 03/06/2022 12:47

I’ve thought about all ways I can tell him without him being offended but he’s the kind of person who does offend easy so I’ll just have to put up with it.

So instead of saying "Bob, I'm sure you'd rather know than not, but that old cat's so ripe that people ask what the bad small is when they come in. You must have become accustomed to it, so I'm sorry it's a bit embarrassing for both of us, but that coat needs to go to the dry cleaners, thanks for understanding" you'd prefer to be offended by stink & have your visitors offended?

WiseRobin · 03/06/2022 09:25

YANBU to be upset about this, OP.

I do understand the awkwardness of raising this with Jim though as I have a similar situation but with a work colleague and his coat.

In work colleagues situation the coat must have been used as a bed by his many pets. Every time someone enters the office they ask what the smell is, has something died in there (we have had a pest controller in recently to sort out a rat problem so it was presumed that was the issue) and it was recently when the coat returned that I realised that the smell was definitely to do with the coat, a mixture of wet dog, cat and stale body odour.

I’ve thought about all ways I can tell him without him being offended but he’s the kind of person who does offend easy so I’ll just have to put up with it. I have many air fresheners dotted around and after a few hours I get used to it but it’s pretty grim.

I’m just hoping that the coat goes home and stays home as the weather improves!

StressedMumm1e · 03/06/2022 08:58

i find it very odd that your dp never mentioned Jim to you before, ever, even casually. Given the fact that Jim is an expert in this hobby, it is strange that you were never aware of him. Even stranger that your dp never once said that he drives him weekly (pre covid).
did you ever ask your dp why he never told you about jim?
did your dp give you a heads up about the car seat situation ie: “just to let you know that Jim always sits in the front seat, do you mind sitting in the back when he gets here please? Sorry, I know it’s weird for me to ask my girlfriend to sit in the back of my car”?
or did he spring it on you when Jim was there and tell jim to sit in the front and you in the back?

hasn't he asked why you have been missing your hobby so much recently?

what does he say when people at the hobby mentions Jim’s smell?

I think it’s time to be honest with your dp and tell him exactly how you feel. Explain what happened with your clothes, why do you feel he will laugh and minimise your feelings?

surely it’s okay for him to say to jim “look mate, on Friday night or before I collect you on Saturday morning, I need you to have a shower and change your clothes please mate, thanks”. It doesn’t have to be a big deal, simple as that one line, can be done by text so no embarrassment for anyone.

Unfortunately, it doesn’t bode well for your relationship if he can’t address this issue in a mature way, especially if it’s causing you such distress.

HeyItsPickleRick · 03/06/2022 08:31

Everything else aside Jim sounds like a horrible person laughing at a homeless person with no/limited access to running water and I wonder what your DP is like if he continues associating with him....

AnuSTart · 03/06/2022 08:26

I'm so sorry about the arguments @ThatSmellIsntMeHonest . It isn't fair and he should be prioritising you, not his disgusting smelly friend.

XelaM · 03/06/2022 08:22

Can you not have a word with Jim?

DontLookBackInAnger1 · 03/06/2022 06:55

ThatSmellIsntMeHonest · 01/06/2022 23:19

You’ve just reminded me- last weekend we drove past some homeless people just after we collected him. He started making comments about “how the other half live” and then saying he walked past a homeless person recently in his town and they smelt bad and he was laughing! How the fuck can he smell them if he can’t smell himself?!

If he's willing to comment on other people's smell then I think it's ok for you to address his. I know it's sensitive, he sounds lonely and out of touch with reality a little. I doubt he ever washes properly. I guess he's lost everyone close to him and now, not needing to work, has totally lost sight of personal hygiene.

"Friend, I'm so sorry to have to text this, but I've noticed that your clothes have started to smell quite whiffy recently, I wanted to tell you as I'd want to know if it was me. I know bills are ridiculously expensive at the moment, so if you ever need to come round for a shower/bath and stick some clothes in the washing machine you're very welcome to.

I hope you're not offended, I just thought I know I'd rather know, so thought you'd feel the same :-)"

Honestly, whilst no one wants to upset him, no one's doing him any favours. He's become immune to his smell and this will be holding him back from making friends, a partner, getting employment etc. He needs to address it, whether it's uncomfortable or not.

RenegadeMatron · 02/06/2022 22:50

ThatSmellIsntMeHonest · 02/06/2022 22:29

Thank you all for the responses, I have taken them on board and we’ve had a big argument tonight. I’ll update more when I’m less tearful x

Really sorry Flowers

I do hope the blinkers are lifting.

There’s much better out there - and you deserve it.

Aquamarine1029 · 02/06/2022 22:34

ThatSmellIsntMeHonest · 02/06/2022 22:29

Thank you all for the responses, I have taken them on board and we’ve had a big argument tonight. I’ll update more when I’m less tearful x

Stop wasting your time, op. He puts a disgusting, filthy man above you. This relationship is doomed. Get rid and move on.

StingrayStingray · 02/06/2022 22:32

@ThatSmellIsntMeHonest I'm sorry, I hope you are alright Flowers When you feel up to it I'd start a new thread in the Relationships board, you'll get better support than in the chaos of AIBU.

ThatSmellIsntMeHonest · 02/06/2022 22:29

Thank you all for the responses, I have taken them on board and we’ve had a big argument tonight. I’ll update more when I’m less tearful x

OP posts:
Stravaig · 02/06/2022 22:11

OP, I hope you're able to heed the warning responses. You have a DP problem. Do not move in with him, do not marry him, and absolutely do not have children with him. This is not a man who will do his fair share, step up to difficulty, or put his partner and children first.

Ontobetterthings · 02/06/2022 20:33

Can't you say "god whats that smell?" its revolting... Or "something stinks... Time to say something! Absolutely disgusting