Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thinking this is ridiculous on all levels

59 replies

holihell · 01/06/2022 16:24

www.london.gov.uk/what-we-do/environment/climate-change/climate-adaptation/cool-spaces

Money & time spent on advising people where to keep cool in London..??! The mayor is seriously promoting this on Twitter right now.. there is no heatwave now or forecast.. why?!

  1. are we really at that level of spoon feeding now that people can't be trusted to find a bit of shade or a shop with air con if they feel a bit hot?!
  2. do other, truly hotter, cities have these? Would have been useful for Dubai or Florida (if I was thick!!!) but London??
  3. what about all the warm places for the homeless.. much rather we point those out
  4. who is this actually for?? Just an exercise to tick a bizarre future box or am I missing something here?
  5. and why has it made me insanely furious?!
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Augend23 · 08/07/2022 08:15

I don't live in London so avoid it at all costs during heat waves. But I was in Avignon a few years back and would have really welcomed this there. I didn't know where water fountains were, or which places you could dive into that had air con.

In London not everywhere is air conditioned by any stretch so a map seems useful. If places can be added it's also something which will get more useful over several years so it needs starting before it's essential.

holihell · 08/07/2022 07:58

@Joyfultoes good morning & gosh that must feel good, to dig out an old post just to get your 'I told you so' in....except I didn't take issue with mr khan issuing a heatwave warning. I took issue with him funding a map of 'cool spaces' which I deemed to be unnecessary for a variety of reasons- some have been argued with validity by PP & I accept that - I also found it bizzare to release said map WEEKS in advance of any seriously hot weather. Maybe he'll retweet it today?! I am in no way a climate change denier. I am in no way a denier that heat kills. I am all for sensible resources that guard against both. I simply didn't think mr khan's map was the most effective solution.

OP posts:
Joyfultoes · 07/07/2022 22:41

oh look @holihell 5 weeks after you stated it’s ridiculous for the London Mayor to prepare for a heatwave there is a SECOND UK heatwave: Temperatures to hit low 30s as heat-health alert issued www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-62084934

Saracenia · 18/06/2022 20:20

This is really important for elderly, vulnerable or people with young children, especially those who live in flats, crowded housing. If I knew the local library was air conditioned, for example, I might head there for a couple of hours. It's only going to get worse with global warming.

CottonSock · 18/06/2022 20:07

BBC News - In pictures: Europe swelters in blistering June heat
www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-61850903

MrsTerryPratchett · 15/06/2022 20:27

Ah that must feel good!

It really did. I am absolutely that petty. It's a fault but at least I'm aware of it Grin

Thanks for being a good sport!

Holihell · 15/06/2022 20:25

OneTC · 14/06/2022 23:13

What an utterly bizarre thing to be getting pissed off about

Haloit takes all sorts eh!

OP posts:
Holihell · 15/06/2022 20:23

Oldfilmsareshit · 14/06/2022 22:17

Oh look. There’s a heatwave warning. Less than 2 weeks after you said planning for such a thing was ridiculous

www.theguardian.com/society/2022/jun/14/met-office-issues-heat-alert-warning-for-england

Nope, never said planning for a heatwave was silly. Said an online map of 'cool places' released over a wet weekend was silly.

OP posts:
Holihell · 15/06/2022 20:16

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/06/2022 20:18

I just wanted to come back to this thread and say I told you so update. Just to say this is how quickly it goes from cardigans to heatwaves!

Ah that must feel good! I still maintain the map is a wasted resource but just my opinion. The fact he's out on Twitter giving hot weather advice today with no mention of this crucial resource is interesting.. I think it's the blatant box ticking that got my goat so much but we are where we are. Hope everybody is managing to find their own 'cool places' at this challenging time anyway Wink

OP posts:
OneTC · 14/06/2022 23:13

What an utterly bizarre thing to be getting pissed off about

TheWayoftheLeaf · 14/06/2022 22:49

Well there's a heatwave now and as someone in London it gets BAKING here because of all the tarmac, concrete and buildings basically insulating the whole place.

When out and about if you start to feel sun sick it can be handy to know where to find air con

Oldfilmsareshit · 14/06/2022 22:17

Oh look. There’s a heatwave warning. Less than 2 weeks after you said planning for such a thing was ridiculous

www.theguardian.com/society/2022/jun/14/met-office-issues-heat-alert-warning-for-england

eatingapie · 14/06/2022 20:27

“It sums up everything that is off kilter in this country. Wasteful, virtue signalling, nannying & alarmist.“

I’m really not sure THIS is what I’d use as an example of the above and a prime example of a waste of taxpayers money 😂

Aswad · 14/06/2022 20:20

You sound very worked up OP

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/06/2022 20:18

I just wanted to come back to this thread and say I told you so update. Just to say this is how quickly it goes from cardigans to heatwaves!

AtomicBlondeRose · 06/06/2022 15:47

But do you think this online map would have helped you?

it would absolutely have helped me - I didn’t know where the library/town hall/community centre was and it’s very dangerous to assume that “everybody knows” where things are. There are many many reasons why they wouldn’t know. There’s actually not all that many air conditioned public buildings in Northern Europe so not at all obvious where to go (in a recent hot spell here I was surprised to find Specsavers had aircon here but our local B&M was a fetid cave) and if you’re already hot and weakened from that you don’t want to go traipsing around in exactly that same heat in the hope of finding somewhere that you’re welcome to use.

if you’ve never experienced a real heatwave in a big city you can’t imagine it. I was starting to feel quite panicky and trapped by the oppressive nature of the heat and the inability to escape it.

holihell · 06/06/2022 15:44

MrsTerryPratchett · 06/06/2022 14:50

I've never heard of a heat dome in London... but accept I may be wrong.

There wasn't in mainland Europe until there was. There wasn't in Canada until there was. It's future planning for emergencies.

My point is when there is very hot weather, the most vulnerable are often not out in it

Being out in it isn't the issue. People die in their homes in heat events. This map is supposed to show them where they can go OUT to to get cool.

and in the case of the very elderly, are often not online either.

True. But people that work with them will be.

I'd add the percentage of very old, vulnerable people residing in central London where this map covers is very low too and due to built up nature of the city will usually have someone looking out for them.

It goes down to Croydon, where I can assure you a lot of older, poorer, vulnerable people live.

I have nothing against safeguarding all human life from extreme weather, where and when it is necessary and appropriate to do so. I just think the NHS stand a far better chance of saving lives in extreme weather than an online map of cool places.

During heat events the NHS will not cope at all. And if someone is already ill, they may well die. Making sure they don't get sick in the first place, by cooling, is the goal.

And, as a comms person myself it strikes me that a wet weekend in June is a bizarre time to alert us all to what is essentially a map of common sense.

As I said before, the most dangerous time for heat events (and the most fatal) is early in the summer when people aren't expecting it and aren't acclimatised. And it's not common sense because you keep repeating things which are 'common sense' but untrue.

We'll have to agree to disagree on this one!

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 06/06/2022 14:50

I've never heard of a heat dome in London... but accept I may be wrong.

There wasn't in mainland Europe until there was. There wasn't in Canada until there was. It's future planning for emergencies.

My point is when there is very hot weather, the most vulnerable are often not out in it

Being out in it isn't the issue. People die in their homes in heat events. This map is supposed to show them where they can go OUT to to get cool.

and in the case of the very elderly, are often not online either.

True. But people that work with them will be.

I'd add the percentage of very old, vulnerable people residing in central London where this map covers is very low too and due to built up nature of the city will usually have someone looking out for them.

It goes down to Croydon, where I can assure you a lot of older, poorer, vulnerable people live.

I have nothing against safeguarding all human life from extreme weather, where and when it is necessary and appropriate to do so. I just think the NHS stand a far better chance of saving lives in extreme weather than an online map of cool places.

During heat events the NHS will not cope at all. And if someone is already ill, they may well die. Making sure they don't get sick in the first place, by cooling, is the goal.

And, as a comms person myself it strikes me that a wet weekend in June is a bizarre time to alert us all to what is essentially a map of common sense.

As I said before, the most dangerous time for heat events (and the most fatal) is early in the summer when people aren't expecting it and aren't acclimatised. And it's not common sense because you keep repeating things which are 'common sense' but untrue.

holihell · 06/06/2022 14:32

AtomicBlondeRose · 06/06/2022 14:28

I was in Paris a few years ago during a heatwave and this protocol was in place there. You might think it seems very obvious but we were two able-bodied people in a top-floor studio AirBNB without aircon and I was actually getting seriously worried about my own health as I just could NOT cool down, no matter how many fans, cool damp cloths, closed shutters during the day I employed. They had water sprays set up outside which were amazing to cool you quickly and absolutely needed. Maybe it hasn't happened in London yet but when we start to get temperatures in the mid-30s and upwards for days on end everyone will be saying "why weren't there any plans for this...?"

Fair enough. But do you think this online map would have helped you? Or did you think to yourself, let's get into some shade/find some aircon... I'm all for making plans. Useful ones.

OP posts:
holihell · 06/06/2022 14:29

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 04/06/2022 16:24

Nope, this is a good example of climate change adaptation in action and it will make a difference in real life as the impacts of climate change continue to intensify.

Interestingly I tend to find those who throw around accusations of incompetence tend to either have an poor grasp of the subject they are dismissing or are just trying to be contrary for the sake of some attention. Can't work out which it is for you but I'm sure your response will enlighten us.

First to admit I don't know an awful lot about climate change, but I accept it is real and action is needed. I'm really not being contrary, I just fail to see the value of this resource. I live in London and work with elderly people (the ones everyone appears to think this is aimed at) - there must be better ways of safeguarding them from hot weather than this.

OP posts:
AtomicBlondeRose · 06/06/2022 14:28

I was in Paris a few years ago during a heatwave and this protocol was in place there. You might think it seems very obvious but we were two able-bodied people in a top-floor studio AirBNB without aircon and I was actually getting seriously worried about my own health as I just could NOT cool down, no matter how many fans, cool damp cloths, closed shutters during the day I employed. They had water sprays set up outside which were amazing to cool you quickly and absolutely needed. Maybe it hasn't happened in London yet but when we start to get temperatures in the mid-30s and upwards for days on end everyone will be saying "why weren't there any plans for this...?"

holihell · 06/06/2022 14:23

MrsTerryPratchett · 04/06/2022 17:01

But this is an online map showing where to cool off in central London.. hot weather is always forecasted in advance

Heat domes happen very quickly and without a lot of warning. Not like heat waves at all.

& of course kind people will look out for their elderly neighbours when that's the case.

Isolated, vulnerable older people died in their hundreds in the Pacific NW heat dome. Alone in their places, not being checked on.

This resource is of no clear value to anyone beyond the boxes it ticks as part of a 'wider govmt project'.

Our plan is to use these to put up posters in buildings just before something happens so that we can tell the people who live there where is close to them. When we call people to check on them we can say, "there's a park just around the corner, spend a couple of hours there'. Same with our homeless clients. We can tell them where the water fountains are. And if they are outside, they are much safer. Most people die alone in their homes in heat events. Often overnight when no one is watching/checking. If they spent time in a cooler area in the daytime, that may be enough to stave that off.

It sums up everything that is off kilter in this country. Wasteful, virtue signalling, nannying & alarmist.

Your 'reckons' aren't better than actual professionals' actual opinion.

And by the way, even checking isn't great unless you know where to go. By the time someone is in distress they are much more likely to die AND the emergency services would be hours and hours out. In the American/Canadian event paramedics were being diverted from one cardiac arrest to another (leaving the first person to die) because there were so many. You think the NHS would cope with a heat event? No, self-help before distress is the only way to assist.

Are you based in London?
I've never heard of a heat dome in London... but accept I may be wrong. My point is when there is very hot weather, the most vulnerable are often not out in it, and in the case of the very elderly, are often not online either. I'd add the percentage of very old, vulnerable people residing in central London where this map covers is very low too and due to built up nature of the city will usually have someone looking out for them. I have nothing against safeguarding all human life from extreme weather, where and when it is necessary and appropriate to do so. I just think the NHS stand a far better chance of saving lives in extreme weather than an online map of cool places. And, as a comms person myself it strikes me that a wet weekend in June is a bizarre time to alert us all to what is essentially a map of common sense.
Oh, and my 'reckons' are just as valuable as any 'professionals' opinions actually - they will have a financial interest/incentive in creating these resources..my taxes are paying for them so I'm questioning them...

OP posts:
TooBored1 · 04/06/2022 17:13

I think this is a fabulous idea. We know that urban areas are getting hotter, and not just from climate change. The removal of trees in cities causes huge increases in temperatures, plus the number of vehicles/people etc can cause a real danger of overheating for many people.

As a fit and healthy red head, I know I'm prone to dizzy spells when I get hot (and a moderately warm day in London will be enough), so I actively plan days to make sure I can get enough time out of the sun. I'd certainly make use of a map like this - it would have been a godsend when I was pregnant and living in London.

Plus, it's a good way of supporting businesses and encouraging people to visit them and who doesn't want to know where they can fill up a water bottle?

MrsTerryPratchett · 04/06/2022 17:01

But this is an online map showing where to cool off in central London.. hot weather is always forecasted in advance

Heat domes happen very quickly and without a lot of warning. Not like heat waves at all.

& of course kind people will look out for their elderly neighbours when that's the case.

Isolated, vulnerable older people died in their hundreds in the Pacific NW heat dome. Alone in their places, not being checked on.

This resource is of no clear value to anyone beyond the boxes it ticks as part of a 'wider govmt project'.

Our plan is to use these to put up posters in buildings just before something happens so that we can tell the people who live there where is close to them. When we call people to check on them we can say, "there's a park just around the corner, spend a couple of hours there'. Same with our homeless clients. We can tell them where the water fountains are. And if they are outside, they are much safer. Most people die alone in their homes in heat events. Often overnight when no one is watching/checking. If they spent time in a cooler area in the daytime, that may be enough to stave that off.

It sums up everything that is off kilter in this country. Wasteful, virtue signalling, nannying & alarmist.

Your 'reckons' aren't better than actual professionals' actual opinion.

And by the way, even checking isn't great unless you know where to go. By the time someone is in distress they are much more likely to die AND the emergency services would be hours and hours out. In the American/Canadian event paramedics were being diverted from one cardiac arrest to another (leaving the first person to die) because there were so many. You think the NHS would cope with a heat event? No, self-help before distress is the only way to assist.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 04/06/2022 16:24

sst1234 · 02/06/2022 15:36

When incompetent people run out of ideas to do stuff that makes a real difference, they resort to stuff like this to make it look like they are productive. This is a good example

Nope, this is a good example of climate change adaptation in action and it will make a difference in real life as the impacts of climate change continue to intensify.

Interestingly I tend to find those who throw around accusations of incompetence tend to either have an poor grasp of the subject they are dismissing or are just trying to be contrary for the sake of some attention. Can't work out which it is for you but I'm sure your response will enlighten us.