Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband wants to go away for a night when our baby is 4 weeks old…

361 replies

SnowBall86 · 01/06/2022 13:56

My husband wants to go away to celebrate his nephews 21st birthday for 1 night and take our son who is 5 with him whilst I will stay at home with our 4 week old baby (recovering from c-section). The drive is around 5 hours. I have a couple of problems with it. Firstly, I think tagging our 5 year old along for a 5h drive each way is a bit too far for one night. Then, I know there might be some alcohol involved since it’s a 21st birthday celebration, so I’m not too keen on what our son is going to experience… also, I think that with 4 week old baby I might need all help I can get including looking after me considering that I don’t know how I’m going to feel recovering from c-section. My DH argument is that his nephew is 21 only once and that he’s helping by taking our son with him…. Am I being unreasonable by not feeling too happy about the whole situation?

OP posts:
Hillaria · 02/06/2022 15:57

LuckySantangelo35 · 01/06/2022 23:07

@Hillaria

you must see that that is unusual though?

That you wouldn’t trust your children’s father with them overnight?

And also your thought process that you and your child should be together for car journeys so that if worse comes to worse you die together is very unusual…are you ok?

you must see that that is unusual though?

That you wouldn’t trust your children’s father with them overnight?

And also your thought process that you and your child should be together for car journeys so that if worse comes to worse you die together is very unusual…are you ok?

@LuckySantangelo35 Yes, you're probably right that it's unusual. Several of my friends would have thought the same, but I also have plenty who wouldn't! I am definitely a catastrophiser, and doubly so post-natally.

Thanks for asking after me. The children whom I mentioned are now all adults, so I have more or less got over it Grin. Though I'm still funny about them going in cars with other people (also because a very dear family member was killed in a car crash aged 17 so I'm edgy about it anyway).

KettrickenSmiled · 02/06/2022 15:11

You are a good person @SnowBall86

It's often better to compromise than to sit all offended on a high horse - NOT that I'm suggested at all that you were! - & the way you chose to point out First thing he thought of is how to make it to the family celebration with minimal impact on me, admittedly suggests that you & he are reasonable folk who will reach a comfortable agreement - on this & the several thousand other small annoyances that accompany the bliss of parenthood Wink

SnowBall86 · 02/06/2022 14:32

Thanks again for all your replies. Plenty of food for thought!

Upon reflection, I think what annoyed me was the fact that staying and helping was never his first thought. First thing he thought of is how to make it to the family celebration with minimal impact on me, admittedly. We don’t have any family around so bringing our 5 yo up I didn’t have any help. I never stopped DH having a night out or a week/weekend away in these 5 years. I always managed and always encouraged him too because I always thought since he works FT his mental health should be our first priority. So it’s not like I don’t believe that I can manage on my own for one night - of course I will. Even if the baby has colic. Back when our son was born, I didn’t even have any friends around either. Which is different this time around.

It’s just that maybe this time around I selfishly wanted him to give up the “fun” bit of life in order to stay and help. So actually I think I’m the one with the issues here 🙂

OP posts:
saleorbouy · 02/06/2022 10:46

He's obviously thought about the burden of you and wants to take his son to help you in this respect.
Surely if you plan ahead and get as much ready as possible while he's there it won't be too difficult. Get clothes ready, food pre-prepared etc.
Let him go, it's only for one night. Have some confidence in your own abilities too!

esoryelneh · 02/06/2022 10:17

Herejustforthisone · 01/06/2022 18:46

A bunch of pissed-up 21 year olds and a pissed-up husband pretending he’s 21? Sounds totally shit for your five year old.

But of a reach there to assume her partner wants to think of himself as 21 for a night.

What's wrong with people older than 21, going to celebrate a 21st birthday?

So if one of your close relatives turns 21 and invites you, do you automatically pretend you're 21 too?

Some strange replies on this thread

esoryelneh · 02/06/2022 10:16

Hillaria · 01/06/2022 18:43

The only possible answer to the idea of taking the 5 yr old on that journey, even if it weren't to a 21st, is "over my dead body". I would not have let any of my DC out of my sight for that long at that age, even with their father. And particularly not on a long car journey. Not bloody likely. My DH suggested similar not long after I had a c-section with DC2. I said it was absolutely fine for him to go (DC1 was a toddler), but there was no way he was taking DC1. We managed fine rather better than when he was there, actually

What?

How strange..

Blarting · 02/06/2022 04:07

*i'd be ok with it

Blarting · 02/06/2022 04:06

I think your DH is trying hard to minimise the pressure on you by taking the child and only staying one night. I'm sure he'd rather go for a couple of nights alone.

He wants to attend a family party.

If no ok with it.

Sunnytwobridges · 02/06/2022 00:36

I think it’s fine. It’s only one night and it sounds more like a family bday for the most part. My dd spent 11hrs one way when going to her dads house and she was fine. A couple of stops on the way but was ok. She was only 4 at the time. And took that trip a few times up til age 6.

how long does it take to heal from a c section? Most people I know are up and about within a week or two.

Apollonia1 · 02/06/2022 00:17

I don't think the c-section will be an issue. I had one with twins - minimal pain, walking normally next day, and pretty much back to normal by day 3. I left hospital on day 5, and was home alone, running up and down stairs with the twins, etc. By week 4, the c-section was a distant memory.

Im your situation, I'd rather the 5-year old stayed at home too (to avoid a 10-hour car journey and a potentially boozy party).

Namechanger355 · 01/06/2022 23:54

saraclara · 01/06/2022 22:49

No other operation to that level would be classed as non-major by anyone. What nonsense.

But it isn't major surgery. It's quick and relatively simple. Major surgery is complex, involves risk to adjoining organs and veins/arteries and takes hours. A CS is a case of an incision, lifting the baby and placenta out, and closing up again.
Ask any surgeon if its classed as major surgery.

You do realise that 7 different lawyers of abdominal wall and the uterus are cut and then open to get the baby out

you do realise that c sections were deadly before modern medicine - in the old days it was a case of the mum or the baby

it is major surgery by any stretch of the imagination - no it is not a heart transplant but there can be blood loss, infection so of course it’s major.

please stop saying ridiculous things

Herejustforthisone · 01/06/2022 23:48

I don’t agree with the concept that it’s not major surgery. it involves cutting through eleven layers and a whole host of internal stitches. Just because they can do it quickly, doesn’t make it a minor event.

I was a totally straightforward elective and I still nearly needed blood as I had an unusually placed major blood vessel and started to bleed profusely. I didn’t realise it happened at the time apart from the fact that I felt very sick suddenly as my blood pressure dropped.

Anyway I bounced back as much as possible, driving in a fortnight, gymming inside six weeks, etc, and it was still hard work. The pulling pain was rank when you try to get out of bed.

Herejustforthisone · 01/06/2022 23:48

I don’t agree with the concept that it’s not major surgery. it involves cutting through eleven layers and a whole host of internal stitches. Just because they can do it quickly, doesn’t make it a minor event.

I was a totally straightforward elective and I still nearly needed blood as I had an unusually placed major blood vessel and started to bleed profusely. I didn’t realise it happened at the time apart from the fact that I felt very sick suddenly as my blood pressure dropped.

Anyway I bounced back as much as possible, driving in a fortnight, gymming inside six weeks, etc, and it was still hard work. The pulling pain was rank when you try to get out of bed.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 01/06/2022 23:41

That's the thing with child birth, well at least on here . You see plenty of posters all the time wanting a csection instead of a vb and posters saying we'll demand one , it's fine etc

It is major surgery and like vb things can go wrong .

My first Cs was an emcs at 32 weeks due to cord prolapse . Hip to hip scar and internal stitches too as he was transverse and high up luckily for him so not a small easily healing scar

I'd have still been fine to look after him on my own for 24hours 4 weeks in, actually I'd have enjoyed it as my older 2 were 8 and 16 at the time so it would have been quite nice to just have the baby to think about, even if I did have to wake him up every 2-3 hours for feeding due to prematurity

Until closer to the time of the party I think it's hard to say . It's likely physically op would be fine but emotionally I guess everyone's different

KettrickenSmiled · 01/06/2022 23:39

saraclara · 01/06/2022 22:49

No other operation to that level would be classed as non-major by anyone. What nonsense.

But it isn't major surgery. It's quick and relatively simple. Major surgery is complex, involves risk to adjoining organs and veins/arteries and takes hours. A CS is a case of an incision, lifting the baby and placenta out, and closing up again.
Ask any surgeon if its classed as major surgery.

I'm hazarding a wild guess that YOU are not a surgeon & have never asked one, @saraclara.

A caesarean is a major operation that carries a number of risks, so it's usually only done if it's the safest option for you and your baby.
www.nhs.uk/conditions/caesarean-section/

JustLyra · 01/06/2022 23:29

saraclara · 01/06/2022 22:49

No other operation to that level would be classed as non-major by anyone. What nonsense.

But it isn't major surgery. It's quick and relatively simple. Major surgery is complex, involves risk to adjoining organs and veins/arteries and takes hours. A CS is a case of an incision, lifting the baby and placenta out, and closing up again.
Ask any surgeon if its classed as major surgery.

You should inform the NHS that you know better than them…

A caesarean is a major operation that carries a number of risks, so it's usually only done if it's the safest option for you and your baby.

it is major surgery. The fact women are expected to be content with two paracetamol and hobbling to the breakfast room a few hours later is a scandal.

Pretending it’s not major surgery to have a pop at the OP says so much about some people ok this thread.

LuckySantangelo35 · 01/06/2022 23:07

Hillaria · 01/06/2022 22:33

You can use all the capital letters and exclamation marks in the world, and I still wouldn't have gone with that when my DC were small. And no, I wouldn't entirely have trusted my children's father to take care of them properly overnight (a whole other story), which probably colours my thinking. But the car journey would have been a no in itself, however responsible the father, because there are so many bloody idiots on the roads, and you're more likely to have an accident close to home, but you're more likely to have a fatal one in a motorway collision. If my children were going to be in a fatal motorway accident, I'd have been in the car with them so as not to survive without them. So shoot me.

@Hillaria

you must see that that is unusual though?

That you wouldn’t trust your children’s father with them overnight?

And also your thought process that you and your child should be together for car journeys so that if worse comes to worse you die together is very unusual…are you ok?

aSofaNearYou · 01/06/2022 23:04

But it isn't major surgery. It's quick and relatively simple. Major surgery is complex, involves risk to adjoining organs and veins/arteries and takes hours. A CS is a case of an incision, lifting the baby and placenta out, and closing up again.
Ask any surgeon if its classed as major surgery.

I've yet to find a single reputable source that does not describe it as major surgery.

BasicDad · 01/06/2022 23:02

Post recovery of CS with a 4 week old! I think you're 100% entitled to feel how you feel with no compromises.

21st birthday party...massive whoop!?

I wouldn't negotiate. Just be very upfront with what YOU NEED right now.

daisymade · 01/06/2022 22:56

Well obviously if you’re struggling post surgery that’s a different question and any decent partner would stay.

but assuming it all goes well, a night away is an absolute non issue and to set it up as anything but is just bizarre. You’re a grown up, you can parent solo for one evening, many of us do it regularly with multiple children.

saraclara · 01/06/2022 22:49

No other operation to that level would be classed as non-major by anyone. What nonsense.

But it isn't major surgery. It's quick and relatively simple. Major surgery is complex, involves risk to adjoining organs and veins/arteries and takes hours. A CS is a case of an incision, lifting the baby and placenta out, and closing up again.
Ask any surgeon if its classed as major surgery.

Hillaria · 01/06/2022 22:33

LuckySantangelo35 · 01/06/2022 20:09

@Hillaria

The child is FIVE YEARS OLD!!

Five! What would you trust your husband, his father, to take care of him overnight?!

And what’s the issue with travelling a few hours to a family party and your child staying at home
well cared for??

Sorry, don’t get it 🤷‍♀️

You can use all the capital letters and exclamation marks in the world, and I still wouldn't have gone with that when my DC were small. And no, I wouldn't entirely have trusted my children's father to take care of them properly overnight (a whole other story), which probably colours my thinking. But the car journey would have been a no in itself, however responsible the father, because there are so many bloody idiots on the roads, and you're more likely to have an accident close to home, but you're more likely to have a fatal one in a motorway collision. If my children were going to be in a fatal motorway accident, I'd have been in the car with them so as not to survive without them. So shoot me.

JustLyra · 01/06/2022 22:26

Solonge · 01/06/2022 21:00

Having a baby is what women do. A caesarian is not really major surgery and your scar is about five inches across and disappears in time. Four weeks post op some women are back in work. One night is not unreasonable.... unless there are complications. A lot of mums have to do all the nights on their own anyway as their partner is working.

The fact that women are treated in such a dismissive way does not make it minor surgery.

it’s major abdominal surgery.

No other operation to that level would be classed as non-major by anyone. What nonsense.

KettrickenSmiled · 01/06/2022 21:44

Solonge · 01/06/2022 21:00

Having a baby is what women do. A caesarian is not really major surgery and your scar is about five inches across and disappears in time. Four weeks post op some women are back in work. One night is not unreasonable.... unless there are complications. A lot of mums have to do all the nights on their own anyway as their partner is working.

"not really major surgery" 😂😂😂
You are of course at perfect liberty to make dismissive & ludicrous remarks, but the NHS disagree.
www.nhs.uk/conditions/caesarean-section/

& why so dictatorial?

OP would PREFER to have her DH at home with her, sharing the parenting.
What other mums do or do not do makes no odds to that preference.

Is wanting the care & support of your co-parent really such an outlandish notion to you that you have to scold OP for having feelings & expressing a valid choice?

stuntbubbles · 01/06/2022 21:34

In what universe is a Caesarian not major surgery? Certainly in all the disclaimers you sign the NHS makes very clear it is a major operation.