Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the monarchy is regressive and should be abolished?

281 replies

Muezza · 01/06/2022 13:36

The principle of the monarchy, that they are superior people because of the family they were born into/married into is completely regressive and embarrassing for us as a country.

All the hoopla around the jubilee is cringe worthy

OP posts:
PurpleButterflyWings · 01/06/2022 15:45

@Muezza

YABVVVVU to start yet ANOTHER Monarchy-bashing thread. There's one every other bastard day on here now. Tedious, predictable, and pathetic. Another one for me to hide. Doing that in five seconds! Bash and berate them all you like. I won't see it.

MrsTerryPratchett · 01/06/2022 15:42

Look at how much America spends on it's president.

There are so many reasons it's different I don't actually know where to start.

MrsTerryPratchett · 01/06/2022 15:41

Bluueberrryy · 01/06/2022 15:38

It's a bit more nuanced than that. Going back generations after generations their ancestors fought and won battles for the crown etc. obviously that hasn't been the case for some time but their ancestors paved the way

So it's because they are bigger murdering bastards than my ancestors. Not exactly a good genetic stock, then. And let's be honest, 'they' didn't win. It was the poor conscripted peasants that fought and died.

And many of those battles were fought against my ancestors so it doesn't exactly endear them to me.

Florenz · 01/06/2022 15:41

"That sounds really rather vague. What on earth do you mean. Could you elaborate? How? Why? Examples?"
If we had a president we'd have to pay them and all their staff and hangers on. Look at how much America spends on it's president. Plus all the former presidents (currently 5 still living) who still require security etc and are a significant expense.

MelonsMelonsMelons · 01/06/2022 15:39

MrsTerryPratchett · 01/06/2022 15:32

Lastly, despite what anyone thinks our Queen has dedicated 70 years of service to this country. She has worked beyond when any ordinary person would be expected to and has never put a foot wrong.

That is a lie. Defending her son is the last in a line of missteps.

Never put a foot wrong?

I like the Queen but her handling of Diana’s death was pretty awful until Tony Blair intervened.

Also, expecting the tax payer to pick up the bill for the Windsor Castle fire went down like a lead brick.

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 15:39

The money issue is a moot point. The royals generate tourist income but this wouldn't significantly reduce because we'd still have the palaces, Tower of London and whatnot.

We give money to the royal family but we'd still have to pay for a head of state. The queen also pays tax on her estates.

Finances aren't really the point - there are arguments for and against.

Bluueberrryy · 01/06/2022 15:38

CapMarvel · 01/06/2022 13:43

The idea that the head of state of a country is there purely because their mum shagged their dad is utterly absurd.

It's a bit more nuanced than that. Going back generations after generations their ancestors fought and won battles for the crown etc. obviously that hasn't been the case for some time but their ancestors paved the way

darisdet · 01/06/2022 15:35

I was beaten to it, answering the tourism myth argument!

StripeJacket · 01/06/2022 15:35

I agree the Queen worked longer than most, she has pet her foot wrong loads, they have very good PR you are an example repeating the propoganda.

If hypocrite carbon footprint William gets too big for his boots we will let him know, we can tell our elected politicians to tell him to wind his neck in and remember what Happened to the Democrats hopeful - Mr fist Gentleman - Harry.

JanisMoplin · 01/06/2022 15:34

Man. The queen certainly put a foot wrong when she paid for her pedophile son's settlement, even if from private funds.
It's such a colonialist, outdated institition. Hilary Mantel had it so right. Must dig up her essay about Kate.

darisdet · 01/06/2022 15:33

"It would however make a substantial difference to the funds available in the public purse."
I really don't think it would. Having a President would just add even more to the political gravy train. Politicians cost us many times more than the Royals.

That sounds really rather vague. What on earth do you mean. Could you elaborate? How? Why? Examples?

MrsTerryPratchett · 01/06/2022 15:32

Lastly, despite what anyone thinks our Queen has dedicated 70 years of service to this country. She has worked beyond when any ordinary person would be expected to and has never put a foot wrong.

That is a lie. Defending her son is the last in a line of missteps.

MelonsMelonsMelons · 01/06/2022 15:31

SleeplessInEngland · 01/06/2022 15:29

"The monarchy bring a phenomenal amount of money into the UK through tourism!"

This is a myth - our history and culture brings in tourism. The number of people who actually come here because we have an existing monarchy is totally negligible.

Plus, even if they did bring in loads of tourist money, we’re supposed to be a modern democratic nation, not a bloody Kings and Queens theme park.

MelonsMelonsMelons · 01/06/2022 15:30

I think in an ideal world we’d be a republic but I can’t get massively worked up about the monarchy. There are far bigger fish to fry.

SleeplessInEngland · 01/06/2022 15:29

"The monarchy bring a phenomenal amount of money into the UK through tourism!"

This is a myth - our history and culture brings in tourism. The number of people who actually come here because we have an existing monarchy is totally negligible.

WifeMotherWorkRepeat · 01/06/2022 15:27

The monarchy bring a phenomenal amount of money into the UK through tourism! For example my US colleagues love the Royal Family and are so excited to hear about the Jubilee Celebrations. I also think that on a global platform many people look at the UK’s rich history, castles, pomp and ceremony with envy.
I do think the royals see themselves as superior beings but no more than anyone else with pots of money!!
Lastly, despite what anyone thinks our Queen has dedicated 70 years of service to this country. She has worked beyond when any ordinary person would be expected to and has never put a foot wrong.
I think abolishing the monarchy would be foolish.

Florenz · 01/06/2022 15:24

"The Queen-> head of state because her mum and dad had a shag. Accountable to...?
A president-> head of state because the people voted them in. Accountable to those same people."
But our current PM is elected whereas the Queen was born into her job. Who is better at their job?

The Queen is accountable to the people. If she wasn't we'd have abolished the monarchy by now.

"It would however make a substantial difference to the funds available in the public purse."
I really don't think it would. Having a President would just add even more to the political gravy train. Politicians cost us many times more than the Royals.

sst1234 · 01/06/2022 15:22

It’s a non-issue. They have less power than your local incompetent council leaders.

Beatrixpotterspencil · 01/06/2022 15:22

it's tradition isnt it? And the proles love having someone to look up to.

CathyorClaire · 01/06/2022 15:21

abolishing the monarchy won’t make you any richer

It would however make a substantial difference to the funds available in the public purse.

MrsTerryPratchett · 01/06/2022 15:20

Boris is the Prime Minister, put there following a democratic process. What makes you think democracy would work any differently in electing a head of state to how it works in electing a PM?

Democracy is flawed. That doesn't make undemocratic processes better.

CapMarvel · 01/06/2022 15:17

There really is, and it's not a particularly hard one to grasp either.

The Queen-> head of state because her mum and dad had a shag. Accountable to...?

A president-> head of state because the people voted them in. Accountable to those same people.

I can get the crayons out if you like.

Florenz · 01/06/2022 15:16

Because there is no point.

CapMarvel · 01/06/2022 15:15

Florenz · 01/06/2022 15:14

"The point is that our head of state should be someone put there following a democratic process, not that we all think Boris should be the sodding president because obviously only idiots would want that."

Boris is the Prime Minister, put there following a democratic process. What makes you think democracy would work any differently in electing a head of state to how it works in electing a PM?

How can you still be missing the point here?

Florenz · 01/06/2022 15:14

"The point is that our head of state should be someone put there following a democratic process, not that we all think Boris should be the sodding president because obviously only idiots would want that."

Boris is the Prime Minister, put there following a democratic process. What makes you think democracy would work any differently in electing a head of state to how it works in electing a PM?