Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the monarchy is regressive and should be abolished?

281 replies

Muezza · 01/06/2022 13:36

The principle of the monarchy, that they are superior people because of the family they were born into/married into is completely regressive and embarrassing for us as a country.

All the hoopla around the jubilee is cringe worthy

OP posts:
StoneofDestiny · 01/06/2022 18:03

Imagine Boris in Buckingham Palace.(Ok not really but he would be elevated to Presidential status wouldn't he and probably have some kind of White House establishment)

Why? The whole Head of State thing would be designed from the start. We don't have to copy any model in existence, though Ireland might be a good model to look at.

However, if it was Bawbag Johnson, we could vote him out. We would we be responsible for providing his extended bunch of relatives houses, privileges and security. Now would we be expected to provide his offspring 'jobs' and lives of luxury for life.

Bring on the Republic!

Blossomtoes · 01/06/2022 18:02

I don’t think anyone sees imperialism as a mark of greatness any more @orwellwasright. My dad would have been 106 now, he was a patriotic monarchist who hated what the empire did.

I see people are already camping out on the Mall, by the way!

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 17:56

That's the thing about history - you can interpret it in different ways.

The flag-shaggers see Blighty's imperial shenanigans as the mark of greatness whereas more enlightened people are increasingly seeing our past endeavours as a source of shame.

lameasahorse · 01/06/2022 17:56

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 01/06/2022 17:51

Off with their heads. I hate the lot of them

wordler · 01/06/2022 17:46

There wouldn't be much benefit financially to the general public by replacing the constitutional monarchy with an elected head of state. Most of the money spent goes to the upkeep of the various historical properties. You'd still have all of that and paying for staff for an elected head of state, etc.

There would also need to be a massively expensive and very long transition of all the various workings of law, parliament, money, armed forces etc - to change how everything is done. It would make organising Brexit look like a Sunday picnic.

That's why no government is willing to undertake it without the serious backing of the public - it would be the work of decades - so until the public majority is seriously on the side of a Republic, nothing will change.

In the last poll in 2021 by yougov.co.uk - 61 percent wanted to keep the Monarchy. In 18-24 year olds only 31 percent wanted to keep the monarchy but 28 percent said they didn't know. There was still only 41 percent for an elected head of state.

It will be interesting to see how many of that age group keep those views in 20 years time, or whether they will follow the pattern of becoming more traditionalist as they grow older.

Even so - it's going to be at least another 20 years before a government will even consider a referendum and a serious attempt at a republic.

Discovereads · 01/06/2022 17:44

FoiledByTheInsect · 01/06/2022 17:37

You were talking about everyone having bloody revolutions to get rid of the monarchy and establish a republic.

They had a peaceful referendum in 1946, so after Mussolini, and the king and his male heirs were exiled. Not guillotined.

Mussolini killed over 400,000 innocent Italian people…and this is in addition to how he also worked with Hitler to genocide the Italian Jews. Saying the monarchy was abolished by a ‘peaceful referendum’ in 1946 is being deliberately obtuse and ignoring the years of revolution caused by Mussolini and his Italian Social Republic in the two decades prior. A referendum that arguably was only peaceful because it was done post WWII and under the eye of the Allies and the UN.

Blossomtoes · 01/06/2022 17:37

That he then became power crazed is a separate issue to the country's desire to overthrow a hereditary monarchy

It’s hardly a separate issue when it led to the restoration of the monarchy. Better the devil you know and all that.

FoiledByTheInsect · 01/06/2022 17:37

Discovereads · 01/06/2022 17:29

Never heard of Mussolini? And his Italian Social Republic?

You were talking about everyone having bloody revolutions to get rid of the monarchy and establish a republic.

They had a peaceful referendum in 1946, so after Mussolini, and the king and his male heirs were exiled. Not guillotined.

Hawkins001 · 01/06/2022 17:34

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 17:19

I think I'd rather take pot luck with society than have Andrew represent me.

That's why I wrote most members.

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 17:34

Discovereads · 01/06/2022 17:18

No we did not. Charles I had his head chopped off by Cromwell to establish a hereditary theocracy. Not a republic. Yes we had a civil war, actually we have had several civil wars. But we have not had a war in which we have killed millions in order to establish a democracy. Unlike everyone else with a Republic has done.

Seems you are the stupid one as you don’t even fucking know basic history.

Lol. Ok then. We've literally invaded every country in the world bar 22 but you keep peddling some myth we're a benign nation.

There's absolutely no evidence that Cromwell intended for his son to succeed him. He gained support because he wanted to abolish the monarchy and people were tired of the belief that kings had a divine right to rule. It was very much about overthrowing a hereditary monarchy and 'I'm going to put my son in charge after I die' was not in the manifesto.

That he then became power crazed is a separate issue to the country's desire to overthrow a hereditary monarchy.

Gettingthingsdone777 · 01/06/2022 17:34

@Discovereads that’s an interesting take on British history but it’s one not widely shared beyond (maybe also within?) the UK. There is a reason the union flag is often referred to as the “butcher’s apron” outside of Britain.

I won’t get into a body count (it’s arguably in the tens of millions during empire) but there were many atrocities enacted under the watchful eye of a constitutional British monarchy, mostly overseas but also some on “home” soil. Just Google “atrocities committed by Britain” I think you will agree, at the very least, that pacifism is not a defining feature of British history. Also, plenty of countries without a monarchy can be considered more peaceful than the UK today, according to the global peace index score, the UK doesn’t even crack the top 10, yet Iceland and Ireland do and they have no monarchy. So constitutional monarchy is not the causal factor for peace you imagine, though probably it doesn’t prohibit it necessarily either.

Blossomtoes · 01/06/2022 17:30

has anyone claimed the bring in through tourism much more than they cost? It's like a verbal tic and usually gets mentioned sooner or later

Equally predictably followed by “What about Versailles?” We’ve been here too long @Puzzledandpissedoff!

Discovereads · 01/06/2022 17:29

FoiledByTheInsect · 01/06/2022 17:25

Discovereads Really sure about that? Italy?

Never heard of Mussolini? And his Italian Social Republic?

darisdet · 01/06/2022 17:29

Not caught up with the whole thread yet, but has anyone claimed the bring in through tourism much more than they cost? It's like a verbal tic and usually gets mentioned sooner or later

They have indeed! I was looking forward to replying to that one but someone beat me to it.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/06/2022 17:26

Not caught up with the whole thread yet, but has anyone claimed the bring in through tourism much more than they cost? It's like a verbal tic and usually gets mentioned sooner or later Grin

I don't think you're BU, OP - not because of money or individuals but the sheer principle of the thing. Fact is the majority don't yet feel the same way, but I have hope it'll come in time, though probably not in my lifetime unless Charles makes an even worse hash of the job than I'd expect

FoiledByTheInsect · 01/06/2022 17:25

Discovereads Really sure about that? Italy?

Discovereads · 01/06/2022 17:22

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 17:19

I think I'd rather take pot luck with society than have Andrew represent me.

That’s just it though, the royal family doesn’t represent anyone in terms of governance. They have no political power at all. Their roles today are that of ambassadors and as living heritage.

LimpBiskit · 01/06/2022 17:22

standoctor · 01/06/2022 13:56

"The principle of the monarchy, that they are superior people because of the family they were born into/married into is completely regressive and embarrassing for us as a country.
All the hoopla around the jubilee is cringe worthy"

I personally do not know any one of any generation who thinks it is embarrassing to have a royal family.
No one says they are superior.
Queen does a great job as an ambassador for the Uk and it makes us different from most of the rest of the world
1000s tourists are attracted to the UK by its history much of which is tied up with royalty.
Go to Windsor Castle Buck Palace Kensington Palace and see how much tourists love it.
What is cringeworthy is people who are full of envy and hate and have no respect for the history of the country they live in and its institutions.
If you do not like it here and you are embarrassed you are free to leave.

People don't have to leave their own country because they challenge the status quo. That's how things grow and transform.

FoiledByTheInsect · 01/06/2022 17:21

darisdet · 01/06/2022 17:13

What's happened to the thread 🤣

It's GCSE history in places!

Didn't do any of this at school. They were too busy indoctrinating us about how we won the war and glossing over centuries of abominations.

Blossomtoes · 01/06/2022 17:21

Can we stop calling each other stupid and swearing at one another? It’s a pretty interesting thread.

lameasahorse · 01/06/2022 17:21

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 17:19

Hawkins001 · 01/06/2022 17:15

When you compare the behaviour of a good portion of society, it could be argued that most members of the current monarchy are more useful on the world's stage for the uk.

I think I'd rather take pot luck with society than have Andrew represent me.

Discovereads · 01/06/2022 17:18

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 17:03

Oh my fucking goodness. Where do I start?

We literally chopped our king's head off to become a republic. We had a fucking civil war.

Are you trolling or are you really this stupid??

No we did not. Charles I had his head chopped off by Cromwell to establish a hereditary theocracy. Not a republic. Yes we had a civil war, actually we have had several civil wars. But we have not had a war in which we have killed millions in order to establish a democracy. Unlike everyone else with a Republic has done.

Seems you are the stupid one as you don’t even fucking know basic history.

Hawkins001 · 01/06/2022 17:15

Muezza · 01/06/2022 13:36

The principle of the monarchy, that they are superior people because of the family they were born into/married into is completely regressive and embarrassing for us as a country.

All the hoopla around the jubilee is cringe worthy

When you compare the behaviour of a good portion of society, it could be argued that most members of the current monarchy are more useful on the world's stage for the uk.