Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the monarchy is regressive and should be abolished?

281 replies

Muezza · 01/06/2022 13:36

The principle of the monarchy, that they are superior people because of the family they were born into/married into is completely regressive and embarrassing for us as a country.

All the hoopla around the jubilee is cringe worthy

OP posts:
Why2why · 01/06/2022 19:17

@CurlyCew agree. First Past the Post is not the best way to give democracy its true weight. That’s why we are in a mess with the limited choice of party and PM and potential PM.

TheKeatingFive · 01/06/2022 19:14

You do know it used to be and they could legitimately claim all of it?

No they couldn't.

It was set up to fund the running of the state. Army, parliament, justice, all that stuff. George III couldn't be arsed with all that, so cut a deal and handed all that responsibility to parliament.

And no it was never in their private ownership, no.

You might want to do a bit more reading as I know this is a favourite topic of yours, so best to be informed 😉

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 19:13

wordler · 01/06/2022 19:10

Maybe that’s the solution - a sort of annual Royal Hunger Games - could make loads of money on the streaming rights for the NHS.

Winner gets to be Monarch for a year.

Do you remember the It's a Royal Knockout?

I can't even.

CurlyCew · 01/06/2022 19:12

Whatever side you are on, it is very healthy to see more debate/questioning about the RF now. Their wealth is astronomical just for being born, and much of it is and was generated by somewhat dubious means. The Duchy of Cornwall for example, the way the people of Scilly as tenants are treated is just not on. And to me it always seems that whatever wealth they have is never enough for them. Just by being born. Their wealth was not earned, it was inherited from someone who was also just "born" or married in. We are not allowed to ask any questions, their wills are sealed, but yours and mine are open to scrutiny by anyone as a public record. A lot can be done if there is little oversight correct?

It is all very fine to say that Charles and William have plans to drastically slim down the hangers on and streamline the RF, but I very much doubt that will be at the expense of their own private wealth - accumulated just because they were born.

Regarding a Republic and an elected president, it is very feasible. But - the voting system of FPTP would need to change. That is so undemocratic and I don't think a lot of people realise it. Same system in the US BTW. So a candidate can be elected on a certain number of votes, but the combined votes for all other candidates in the field exceeds his or her total vote. That is not representative at all. So either STV/Proportional Representation is something that is far more important than ditching the Monarchy. Think hard about the FPTP and you will see why the same party continually wins with the odd incursion by the other, but rarely if ever an Independent or one of the smaller parties.

My apologies for going on and on, but forget about personal insults to the RF and ask why they are what they are? It is because of tradition, privilege, and they cannot be held accountable ever.

wordler · 01/06/2022 19:10

MrsTerryPratchett · 01/06/2022 19:08

Could you do it? I probably don't have the confidence or the skill to go into battle.

I'm willing to bet I could take the Queen in a fight. Throw in Charles as well, make it interesting.

Maybe that’s the solution - a sort of annual Royal Hunger Games - could make loads of money on the streaming rights for the NHS.

Winner gets to be Monarch for a year.

Blossomtoes · 01/06/2022 19:10

TheKeatingFive · 01/06/2022 18:56

Crown Estates money is straight into the Treasury.

well apart from the cool 86 mill given to them. And you do realise it's not their money, right?

You do know it used to be and they could legitimately claim all of it?

MrsTerryPratchett · 01/06/2022 19:08

Could you do it? I probably don't have the confidence or the skill to go into battle.

I'm willing to bet I could take the Queen in a fight. Throw in Charles as well, make it interesting.

CapMarvel · 01/06/2022 19:07

"My point is that they're not royal randomly"

True, but usually for reasons that aren't really anything to be proud of.

wordler · 01/06/2022 19:05

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 18:56

It's an issue for sure. Get rid of the nobility and introduce a land tax. That might help.

And to do that you need a strong socialist government which the UK hasn’t had (ever?)

You can see why the Scandinavian countries don’t resent their Royals as much because their standard of living is more equally spread across their society - might change if they don’t manage to integrate their immigrant communities well though and start creating different layers of society.

FoiledByTheInsect · 01/06/2022 19:05

Blueberry The medieval monarchs fair enough, but that argument falls apart when you get to the various Georges.

Bluueberrryy · 01/06/2022 19:03

MasterBeth · 01/06/2022 16:51

The monarchy is an appalling anachronism: a family of hereditary rulers whose place in society is owed to the fact that hundreds of years ago, their warlord forebears stole the common land for themselves, told us they were superior to us and still we tug our forelocks to them? It's beyond crazy.

And how did that 'stealing' occur?

Could you do it? I probably don't have the confidence or the skill to go into battle.

Nothing was stolen, everything was fought for and won or lost. It's the same as lions fighting for territory for security and hunting rights.

Bluueberrryy · 01/06/2022 19:00

Who said the past doesn't matter? My point is that you don't continue living like your ancestors. Or perhaps you do. Do you eschew all modern medicine? Live without windows? Never wash your body? Not use technology? Shun everything made of plastic, etc. etc. Of course you don't.

You've missed my point.

My point is that they're not royal randomly. They're royal because someone in their family fought for the power and won. So as another PP put it, it was actually a meritocracy once upon a time.

Obviously we don't fight like that these days so they are now 'uncontested' and as such the crown is just passed down.

leotardrock · 01/06/2022 18:59

darisdet · 01/06/2022 18:41

A referendum would be needed I think.

I don't think we need another one of those! We haven't recovered from the last one! 🙄

FoiledByTheInsect · 01/06/2022 18:57

hummerbird · 01/06/2022 18:52

You do realise that they have no power of their own. The Government has taken it all away. The gongs they award are from the Govts list. The income they get all voted on by Govt and is reduced. Crown Estates money is straight into the Treasury. Dates and venues for visits by them or visiting Heads of State dictated by Diplomats.
It is convenient for Gov to have someone else to take the flak.

Put the bunting down for a sec and at least read this book before reposting total BS for the billionth time.
www.amazon.com/What-Do-You-Royal-Family/dp/1785904914?ref_=d6k_applink_bb_dls&dplnkId=f830b9ae-c94b-4c51-8387-2842b100d50c

Why2why · 01/06/2022 18:57

hummerbird · 01/06/2022 18:52

You do realise that they have no power of their own. The Government has taken it all away. The gongs they award are from the Govts list. The income they get all voted on by Govt and is reduced. Crown Estates money is straight into the Treasury. Dates and venues for visits by them or visiting Heads of State dictated by Diplomats.
It is convenient for Gov to have someone else to take the flak.

No power of their own? Really?

What does power and influence mean to you? Who has power and influence is not necessarily the pen pushers.

Who do you suppose have power in this country? Boris Johnson and his cabal? It’s easy to get Johnson to act as a puppet on a string. Even China can get your most moral PM, of high virtue to do catwheels if it so chooses.

The Queen signs laws into force and she has had enough power to ensure that whatever law she does not want to apply to her, it does not apply to her.

Power and influence? Indeed, who has it?

TheKeatingFive · 01/06/2022 18:56

Crown Estates money is straight into the Treasury.

well apart from the cool 86 mill given to them. And you do realise it's not their money, right?

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 18:56

wordler · 01/06/2022 18:54

Thinking about the smaller Euro monarchies - I think the issue is less royalty and more about how embedded the class system is in society.

You could get rid of the Royal layer of our class system but there would still be the ‘upper class’ layer who do actually hold the majority of wealth and power and influence in the UK. And they operate and would continue to operate without any oversight or obligation to the rest of society.

The Windsors without their titles would just be fairly average rich people free to do whatever they liked without scrutiny.

It's an issue for sure. Get rid of the nobility and introduce a land tax. That might help.

darisdet · 01/06/2022 18:54

Pedallleur · 01/06/2022 18:50

Article in the Guardian today worth a read. It's about the Duchies of Cornwall/Lancaster avoiding rewilding discussions. Those 2 Duchies are the property of the Queen and Prince Charles. He got £20 million from that. Doesnt pay corporation tax. Didnt know he is biggest private landowner in Britain. Not political? I think we now they have influence where it matters and Queens Consent protects the monarchs interests

That is interesting. I'll go and bookmark that to read properly later.

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 18:54

I think whatever happens in the future the queen's passing will absolutely be the right time to significantly pare down the monarchy. Even if we continue with a hereditary HoS (which I'm sure we will) that's no reason to entertain the rest of the family, nor pay a penny to support them.

So all these ridiculous hangers on like Andrew's vapid daughters etc. will fade away I hope. No grace and favour palaces, no tax payer funded security, no titles etc.

And whilst we're at it, all those ridiculous dukedoms etc. should be culled. We can certainly do with moving on from the nobility fgs.

wordler · 01/06/2022 18:54

Thinking about the smaller Euro monarchies - I think the issue is less royalty and more about how embedded the class system is in society.

You could get rid of the Royal layer of our class system but there would still be the ‘upper class’ layer who do actually hold the majority of wealth and power and influence in the UK. And they operate and would continue to operate without any oversight or obligation to the rest of society.

The Windsors without their titles would just be fairly average rich people free to do whatever they liked without scrutiny.

Deereemer · 01/06/2022 18:53

Can't belive its still going.

TheKeatingFive · 01/06/2022 18:52

I really like having a monarchy - it's like having our own private soap opera populated by people who feel like distant family. They're well worth it just for the entertainment value

See here's where i think it falls apart. We have Instagram/reality tv for that now. And its SO much cheaper.

IcedPurple · 01/06/2022 18:52

You’re not even a citizen but a mere subject.

Your 'knowledge' on this matter is 40 years out of date.

hummerbird · 01/06/2022 18:52

You do realise that they have no power of their own. The Government has taken it all away. The gongs they award are from the Govts list. The income they get all voted on by Govt and is reduced. Crown Estates money is straight into the Treasury. Dates and venues for visits by them or visiting Heads of State dictated by Diplomats.
It is convenient for Gov to have someone else to take the flak.

Why2why · 01/06/2022 18:51

The person who said EVERY country has killed millions outside their borders might need some history and geography lessons. That is so factually incorrect that one knows not where to start.