Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the monarchy is regressive and should be abolished?

281 replies

Muezza · 01/06/2022 13:36

The principle of the monarchy, that they are superior people because of the family they were born into/married into is completely regressive and embarrassing for us as a country.

All the hoopla around the jubilee is cringe worthy

OP posts:
FoiledByTheInsect · 01/06/2022 22:07

BJatemyhamster BJ signs off the ever-growing sov grant just like his weak-minded predecessors. Mutually beneficial and very opaque arrangement, not forgetting the creepy Privy Council weirdness.

As long as we're still run by the spineless on both sides of the HoC, the queen is quids in.

browneyes77 · 01/06/2022 21:53

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 19:32

CANCEL CULTURE KLAXON.

No one listens to the rich people any more! Their voice and influence is literally zero! They've been CANCELLED! WAAAAAAH!

You sound about 12. Grow up.

PerseverancePays · 01/06/2022 21:32

toastofthetown · 01/06/2022 13:42

The royal family is in a bit of difficult situation existentially, as the reasoning that they are innately more special by virtue of their birth doesn’t really fly any more. But then if they are just as average human beings as everyone else, why do they hold such a powerful and privileged position?

They are there because they are the descendants of the most powerful tyrants that ruled over and terrorised us in times past. They murdered and tortured, robbed and overcame all that stood in their way with little regard. All, and I mean all the wealth and land they own is stolen. The palaces and castles built on taxes wrested from every citizen however poor. The ancient estates bequeathed to their cronies still going today unchallenged. It is utterly ridiculous that they still have such obscene amounts of wealth and try to 'earn' it promoting charities and whatever else they do. I have nothing against any of them personally, I do think they are well past their sell by date and should be retired , pensioned off and their wealth returned to the nation.

BorisJohnsonatemyhampster · 01/06/2022 21:29

But those saying if we got rid of the royal family we’d get a President Boris/Blair etc. Do you not realise we kind of already do have a President PM.

The Queen never challenges, she signs every bit of paper waved in front of her by Boris. He’s been caught lying to her and she will still wave through everything so what’s the point of her?

She showed zero leadership during Brexit (which threatened and still threatens to tear the country apart) and we barely heard a peep from her during the pandemic. What’s the point of a leader who’s basically just a figurehead giving the stamp of approval for the government of the day?

Xenia · 01/06/2022 21:19

I support the monarchy but I have no problems with people taking different views within the law. It is one of the reasons our country is so good - that it is allowed.

CathyorClaire · 01/06/2022 21:18

You do know it used to be and they could legitimately claim all of it?

Only if they unwisely decide they want to take on the full expenses of running the country again.

I suspect Charles and definitely William have plans to do something about the different levels of expenses

Charles think 'slimming down' plays well with the plebs. The reality is it won't affect his own bloated lifestyle in the slightest. Likewise William in due course.

rather pity most of them for having very little choice about living a public life under scrutiny

And yet so few of them exercise that choice.

It would be better for those wanting a Republic if William and Charles don't make cuts though. If they manage to create a small working monarchy which cuts out the hangers on and grace and favour shenanigans, and concentrates on doing the positive charity work

Royal patronages have not been shown to influence charitable donations. Hardly surprising when 76% of charities with a royal patron don't see 'their' royal's boat darken their doors in a year.

I can't now find the post warbling about the queen paying taxes but I'd point out that she only reluctantly started paying tax 'voluntarily' some 30 years ago, has benefited from decade's worth of tax breaks and has as recently as within this past year managed to get her tax bill on grouse shooting in Scotland reduced to below the rates paid by local businesses.

That's before we take into account the secrecy surrounding royal wills and the fact monarch to monarch bequests remain free of IHT.

darisdet · 01/06/2022 20:42

Seconding to check out the ROI system!

TheKeatingFive · 01/06/2022 20:15

I personally am more interested in visiting places where they still carry out ceremonies that have been going on for a long time

You can still do all that crap. I went on a trip to St Petersburg years ago and they had all the horses traipsing round the imperial palaces. Much more fun than anything I've ever seen in the U.K. it's not like the royals make an appearance for the tourists.

lack of having to run expensive election for a president - who will undoubtedly also be a ‘privileged’ person.

check out the Irish system. Extremely cost effective and they've had brilliant figures, not from privilege but who have achieved a huge amount in their own right.

Namenic · 01/06/2022 20:08

I don’t think their situation is normal - but I think they are pretty average people, who happen to have been born into a particular family. The reason I think we should continue to have them is from a utilitarian perspective they provide more benefit than drawback:

  1. tourist income - they kind of are part of a living history. I personally am more interested in visiting places where they still carry out ceremonies that have been going on for a long time, rather than museums.
  2. lack of having to run expensive election for a president - who will undoubtedly also be a ‘privileged’ person.
browneyes77 · 01/06/2022 19:50

Gettingthingsdone777 · 01/06/2022 19:37

@browneyes77 Okay so I appreciate there are decent arguments for and against keeping a constitutional monarchy- but come on! framing a desire for a republic as “cancel culture” is a little bit of a bloody stretch. I mean cancel culture is about social and professionally ostracising people who don’t share the same social values as you, how does this fit? Republicans are trying to replace an undemocratic institution with a democratic one which better reflects the will of the people! they’re not trying to oust the queen because she misgendered Eddie Izzard or something

Cancel culture is ostracism. Pure and simple.

If you want the monarchy to be taken away/abolished, then you want them ostracised, because they would no longer have any professional or social meaning.

So yes, I do think it’s cancel culture.

CapMarvel · 01/06/2022 19:48

Namenic · 01/06/2022 19:30

I don’t mind the royals. I reckon they generate more money for the country than us presidents, and stay neutral.

They are normal people who are lucky to have been born into an important family. Many people in U.K. are luckier to be born in U.K. rather than some countries where life is more difficult. I’m an immigrant from one of the ex colonies.

There is literally nothing about the royals which is normal.

lameasahorse · 01/06/2022 19:40

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

lameasahorse · 01/06/2022 19:39

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

TheKeatingFive · 01/06/2022 19:38

They are normal people

well that's the dilemma isn't it?

If they are normal, why are we pouring such privilege and power into their laps?

If they aren't, what is it that makes them not? Blood? Divine providence? Does anyone believe in that sort of shit anymore?

Ithoughtsummerwascoming · 01/06/2022 19:38

Massively reduced down, keep some pomp, but get rid of all the hangars on.

lameasahorse · 01/06/2022 19:37

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Gettingthingsdone777 · 01/06/2022 19:37

@browneyes77 Okay so I appreciate there are decent arguments for and against keeping a constitutional monarchy- but come on! framing a desire for a republic as “cancel culture” is a little bit of a bloody stretch. I mean cancel culture is about social and professionally ostracising people who don’t share the same social values as you, how does this fit? Republicans are trying to replace an undemocratic institution with a democratic one which better reflects the will of the people! they’re not trying to oust the queen because she misgendered Eddie Izzard or something

lameasahorse · 01/06/2022 19:36

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

badhappening · 01/06/2022 19:36

Mommabear20 · Today 14:03
I love the monarchy and the history and so wish to keep it, but I'd majorly reduce the 'senior' royals to the monarch, heir apparent, and the next heir and the next etc. so just the Queen, Charles, William and his kids. The rest should all work for their money and pay for their properties, possessions, and weddings themselves with no input from the tax payers.

^^^THIS^^^^

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 19:33

They are normal people

Sure, they are. Just worrying about how to pay their fuel bill like everyone else.

Normal people. Lol.

TheKeatingFive · 01/06/2022 19:33

CANCEL CULTURE KLAXON.

😂

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 19:32

browneyes77 · 01/06/2022 19:24

I quite agree

I’m in no way a royalist, but I like the fact we have a monarchy. It does give us a point of difference. And despite some British people being negative, other countries seem to love our royal family and that encourages tourism.

I fear this is just yet more of the ‘cancel culture’ rearing its ugly head.

CANCEL CULTURE KLAXON.

No one listens to the rich people any more! Their voice and influence is literally zero! They've been CANCELLED! WAAAAAAH!

Namenic · 01/06/2022 19:30

I don’t mind the royals. I reckon they generate more money for the country than us presidents, and stay neutral.

They are normal people who are lucky to have been born into an important family. Many people in U.K. are luckier to be born in U.K. rather than some countries where life is more difficult. I’m an immigrant from one of the ex colonies.

EdithStourton · 01/06/2022 19:26

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Not just grouse, but all sorts of rare and red listed waders nest successfully on grouse moors - curlews, lapwings, golden plover and so on.

Yes, managed burns take place on grouse moors during the winter months, to provide the mosaic of habitats favoured by grouse (and other birds). Grouse moor managers argue that this not only provides a mosaic of habitats which favours grouse and other breeding birds, but also prevent wildfires.

And it seems they have a point, given the numerous wildfires on unmanaged moorland. These release far more carbon than the managed burns (which don't touch the peat layer):
Marsden Moor: 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022
Dovestones: 2020, 2021, 2022
At least four of those were in the breeding season.
And I could go on.

browneyes77 · 01/06/2022 19:24

standoctor · 01/06/2022 13:56

"The principle of the monarchy, that they are superior people because of the family they were born into/married into is completely regressive and embarrassing for us as a country.
All the hoopla around the jubilee is cringe worthy"

I personally do not know any one of any generation who thinks it is embarrassing to have a royal family.
No one says they are superior.
Queen does a great job as an ambassador for the Uk and it makes us different from most of the rest of the world
1000s tourists are attracted to the UK by its history much of which is tied up with royalty.
Go to Windsor Castle Buck Palace Kensington Palace and see how much tourists love it.
What is cringeworthy is people who are full of envy and hate and have no respect for the history of the country they live in and its institutions.
If you do not like it here and you are embarrassed you are free to leave.

I quite agree

I’m in no way a royalist, but I like the fact we have a monarchy. It does give us a point of difference. And despite some British people being negative, other countries seem to love our royal family and that encourages tourism.

I fear this is just yet more of the ‘cancel culture’ rearing its ugly head.