Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the monarchy is regressive and should be abolished?

281 replies

Muezza · 01/06/2022 13:36

The principle of the monarchy, that they are superior people because of the family they were born into/married into is completely regressive and embarrassing for us as a country.

All the hoopla around the jubilee is cringe worthy

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
jcyclops · 02/06/2022 00:05

I would rather the second chamber of the British Government was made democratic ie. an elected House of Lords, before we consider abolishing the monarchy.

Another thing that seems to have been ignored so far is that the Queen is head of state of the UK (pop 67m) and 14 other countries (pop 80m) and also British Overseas Territories and Crown Dependencies. Would they accept an elected head of state if more than half the population don't get a vote? Do they get a vote on whether the monarchy is abolished? At the moment they get the same say as Brits do, ie. none.

If the monarchy was to be replaced by a president, then like others have said, I would prefer the role to be almost totally apolitical and the office holder must not be a current (or even recent) member of a political party - more like the Lord Mayor of London than the Mayor of London - and their role should be very much ceremonial like the monarch's current duties. The Irish Presidency is a very suitable template for this - about the only political power they have is that any bill they are given to sign into law which they don't approve of can be sent for consideration by the Supreme Court before they sign.

If this happens then one problem is that the world knows who the Queen is, but who can name the current presidents of countries like Ireland, India or Germany.

Hawkins001 · 01/06/2022 23:33

Gettingthingsdone777 · 01/06/2022 23:29

okay, makes sense, that’s what I imagined it was, so in what way is it different from having an elected but totalitarian ruler? Are there any good examples?
Or is it that they are still just heads of state but instead of being born into it they are elected? In which case is this different from the Republic of Ireland presidency model in anyway?

At this point in time, I don't have enough research to offer a qualified analysis.

Gettingthingsdone777 · 01/06/2022 23:29

Hawkins001 · 01/06/2022 23:24

elective monarchy is a monarchy ruled by an elected monarch, in contrast to a hereditary monarchy in which the office is automatically passed down as a family inheritance. The manner of election, the nature of candidate qualifications, and the electors vary from case to case.

okay, makes sense, that’s what I imagined it was, so in what way is it different from having an elected but totalitarian ruler? Are there any good examples?
Or is it that they are still just heads of state but instead of being born into it they are elected? In which case is this different from the Republic of Ireland presidency model in anyway?

Wor · 01/06/2022 23:28

SleeplessInEngland · 01/06/2022 13:38

The monarchy is utterly riculous but I've softened on its existence recently because if it was absolished we'd have to create a written constitution and I simply don't trust those in power right now to write and vote through good one.

This!

The monarchy is so old fashioned it’s embarrassing, but our current ‘government’ is even worse.

Hawkins001 · 01/06/2022 23:24

Gettingthingsdone777 · 01/06/2022 23:14

Elected monarchy- is that not just a dictatorship? Worth a try I suppose- what’s the worse that can happen?

elective monarchy is a monarchy ruled by an elected monarch, in contrast to a hereditary monarchy in which the office is automatically passed down as a family inheritance. The manner of election, the nature of candidate qualifications, and the electors vary from case to case.

Gettingthingsdone777 · 01/06/2022 23:24

Blossomtoes · 01/06/2022 23:07

I completely disagree. We’ve completely fucked the country with our voting decisions for the last 12 years. I have no faith in the electorate.

I know its just an AIBU thread but it makes me so sad when I read this. I honestly think the first past the post system has led to people to really despising their own because the inbuilt polarising effect makes it’s seem like everyone’s total idiot. I’ve lived in a few countries with some version of proportional representation and while they’re not perfect and you get a bit of the usual political backbiting, there is nowhere near the polarisation and vitriol I’ve seen in the UK and the USA. It’s not the electorate that are the problem, it’s just the system, imho the UK is a good country generally it deserves better than this.

CurlyCew · 01/06/2022 23:19

Blossomtoes · 01/06/2022 23:15

FPTP certainly doesn’t help @CurlyCew. I’m not excusing the electorate for the last debacle though and you can’t blame the system for Brexit.

Brexit vote was a straight Yes/No so FPTP as you know didn't impact it.

Most of the pro Brexit voting public were led by donkeys though, I will agree, and will now shut up about Brexit so as not to derail.

Blossomtoes · 01/06/2022 23:15

FPTP certainly doesn’t help @CurlyCew. I’m not excusing the electorate for the last debacle though and you can’t blame the system for Brexit.

Gettingthingsdone777 · 01/06/2022 23:14

Hawkins001 · 01/06/2022 23:12

Elective monarchy, seems an intriguing one ?

Elected monarchy- is that not just a dictatorship? Worth a try I suppose- what’s the worse that can happen?

darisdet · 01/06/2022 23:14

Suddha · 01/06/2022 22:58

Voting is the best option we’ve got for selecting a head of state. It’s not perfect but it’s better than a hereditary monarchy where we have no choice at all.

Agree. FTPT is far from perfect but it's more democratic than hereditary head of state where they're also unaccountable. Obviously electoral reform for general elections is not going to be a priority for the Conservative Party as the current system benefits them. A lab-lib coalition might be interested in electoral reform! We can only hope.

I also agree with you, Blossom, in part, in that I have little confidence in a good portion of the electorate.

Rambling away there^

CurlyCew · 01/06/2022 23:12

Blossomtoes · 01/06/2022 23:07

I completely disagree. We’ve completely fucked the country with our voting decisions for the last 12 years. I have no faith in the electorate.

I think the problem lies more with the system than the voters. Why vote for an independent or lesser known/funded party if they cannot win a seat in a single seat constituency under FPTP? It is so undemocratic really and leads to voting for the "least worst" or "what's the point?", the candidate from any source other than Labour or Tory has little to no chance, so it's Yin and Yang forevermore.

Hawkins001 · 01/06/2022 23:12

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Elective monarchy, seems an intriguing one ?

Blossomtoes · 01/06/2022 23:07

Suddha · 01/06/2022 22:58

Voting is the best option we’ve got for selecting a head of state. It’s not perfect but it’s better than a hereditary monarchy where we have no choice at all.

I completely disagree. We’ve completely fucked the country with our voting decisions for the last 12 years. I have no faith in the electorate.

Justdontbejudgy · 01/06/2022 23:00

Ducksinthebath · 01/06/2022 13:37

Would we get a bank holiday on abolition day plus one each year on republic day?

Yes! I'm down with this. Vive la révolution!

lameasahorse · 01/06/2022 22:58

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Suddha · 01/06/2022 22:58

Voting is the best option we’ve got for selecting a head of state. It’s not perfect but it’s better than a hereditary monarchy where we have no choice at all.

CurlyCew · 01/06/2022 22:57

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Democracy does not really exist under the FPTP system. FPTP is not democratic. Same system applies in the US, go figure.

Hawkins001 · 01/06/2022 22:55

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Correction, I'm asking if voting would be the best option with regards to how the people are choosen, as then it opened the topic for debate.

Hawkins001 · 01/06/2022 22:52

Suddha · 01/06/2022 22:31

People need to have a choice even if they choose the “wrong” option. You’re talking about removing freedom of choice so the people at the top can patronise us and take the power out of our hands. “We know best, we’ll just take charge now”. Personally I’d prefer to have my choice.

But even with a choice, if the deck is already stacked then is the choice, all but an illusion ?

Hawkins001 · 01/06/2022 22:51

Why2why · 01/06/2022 18:13

It is nonsense. Really, really embarrassing. The idea that Britain needs the monarchy for tourism is insulting. People come to visit symbols of history. Just as they do in France and else.

Britain does not need this outdated unbelievable fantasy to be relevant or great on the world stage.

Do you have any statistics or research to confirm your perspectives ?

lameasahorse · 01/06/2022 22:47

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Suddha · 01/06/2022 22:31

People need to have a choice even if they choose the “wrong” option. You’re talking about removing freedom of choice so the people at the top can patronise us and take the power out of our hands. “We know best, we’ll just take charge now”. Personally I’d prefer to have my choice.

Hawkins001 · 01/06/2022 22:23

Suddha · 01/06/2022 22:15

My problem with the monarchy is that they’ve done nothing to earn their positions, the people haven’t voted them into power and there’s no mechanism for their removal if they turn out to be unsuitable. I think we should be able to choose our head of state and I don’t think it should be a lifelong gig. So I would vote to become a republic.

But when half of voting is basically public relations, is voting the best option ?

Suddha · 01/06/2022 22:15

My problem with the monarchy is that they’ve done nothing to earn their positions, the people haven’t voted them into power and there’s no mechanism for their removal if they turn out to be unsuitable. I think we should be able to choose our head of state and I don’t think it should be a lifelong gig. So I would vote to become a republic.