Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Massive argument with boyfriend - was I unreasonable?

359 replies

SarahLooo124 · 01/06/2022 10:14

Hello,
We've been together 4 years, hardly argue and overall very happy together.

Last night, he had to go to hospital (nothing serious, but he felt some pain in his stomach area); I'd never been to A and E before so I didn't realise just how long waiting times were apart from what I hear on the news.
So I waited in the car as he said he'll be about 2 hours and i wasn't allowed to sit in with him (fair enough)<. 6 hours later, it's 11:30pm,I'm still waiting in the car, haven't eaten since breakfast, and my phone was about to die.

I quickly rang him asking how long he'll be and he said he doesn't know. For some reason I snapped on the phone and said (I admit in a bitchy way) that he'll have to come back on his own tomorrow then as I can't wait in this car any longer.

2 minutes later, he comes running to the car saying he was just about to see the Dr but he had to tell the Dr he had to go and the Dr was worried about his stomach. He called me an autistic bitch because I didn't just get out the car and walk to the cafe in the hospital and that I make everything complicated and he feels like my babysitter. (I'm not autistic btw).

I snapped back that it was his idea for me to come and that he said I could wait with him, and if I'd have known it'd be sitting in a car, I'd have waited in the house.

This was in quite shouty voices.

But I feel absolutely awful that he has to go back tonight. I look back and think I could've just carried on waiting in the car but in the moment, I just snapped.

OP posts:
Christinatherabbit · 01/06/2022 12:49

I think personally as soon as they told me earlier in the evening I couldn't wait inside the hospital I would have called an uber/taxi/bus and gone home. But hindsight is a wonderful thing. I do think you made a really bad decision sitting out there for some many hours and then being cross with him for that but it's done now. I am so impatient I would have lost my mind after 2 hours so I totally understand why you snapped.

Onwards22 · 01/06/2022 12:47

Why do people keep saying bollocks like this? One day dh was driving home from work and got a pain in his chest, he diverted to a&e he had a pulmonary embolism. I was having a miscarriage I felt hot and sick, I just knew something wasn't right, so I drove to hospital. I had sepsis. A&e doesn't mean you have to be unconscious.

I agree.

It’s very dangerous for so many posters to say that if he can drive or has had the pain before then it’s not an emergency.

If posters think he was in the wrong then that’s fine (not sure how) but please do not say he shouldn’t have gone to A&E at that moment as you have no idea.

I’m glad when I was having pains in my side I didn’t start a thread on here as I would have ended up dead.

I had been having the pains for a while, had been seen by doctors and I drove myself to A&E. I also had at least a 4 hour wait in A&E.
But I was admitted straight away and was told that if I had left it another day I may not have survived.

diddl · 01/06/2022 12:46

and that I make everything complicated and he feels like my babysitter.

Then why is he with you I wonder?

He's the idiot who didn't think to take you home before going to A&E or to tell you that the Dr was about to see him but came running out instead!

Octomore · 01/06/2022 12:45

This is insane.

If it was a non-emergency, he shouldn't have been in A&E in the first place.

But if it was an emergency, you shouldn't have told him to leave, and he shouldn't have left and then guilt-tripped you.

But regardless of whether it was an emergency or not, you should have just made your own way home, by taxi or public transport or whatever. There was never any need for you to wait for him for even 1 hour, let alone 6hrs.

It sounds like you both need to grow up.

pigsDOfly · 01/06/2022 12:44

I find it very hard to believe that after waiting 6 hours he walked out when the doctor was standing in front of him saying that he, the doctor, was very worried about the pain, especially given that the doctor hadn't even had time to examine him; bit of guilt tripping going on there from the sound of it.

Spohn · 01/06/2022 12:43

Doesn’t sound very aspirational-the name calling and arguing, but you’ve each apologised, so what were you hoping for from this thread?

How is an ‘irritating’ sore tummy an issue for accident and emergency though?

RuthW · 01/06/2022 12:39

You were unreasonable to wait for him in the first place. You should have dropped him off and he could ring when needing picking up. It was never going to be two hours and could have been 12 or he could even have been admitted.

billy1966 · 01/06/2022 12:39

He changed his mind on a whim when going shopping to go to a&e, and told you to wait in the car.

No emergency whatsoever.
But happily thought he'd be in and out and you should while away your time.

Is he usually such a selfish arse?

6 hours in the car? No wonder you snapped.

I think the argument was born of frustration but he's some twat for dragging you into something so unnecessarily.

You should have driven obviously.
But he just decides to change his mind mid journey and screw you.

Who the hell gets out of an emerging room in two hours for a non emergency.

You have my sympathy OP.

diddl · 01/06/2022 12:37

Onwards22 · 01/06/2022 12:09

That aside, what would have been the big deal if you had left-the car would still have been there for him to get home!

No OP told him he needed to leave A&E to drive her home and that he should go to A&E the next day instead.

Well I guess that would have been the time to tell Op that the Dr was about to see him!

Rubyroseyposey · 01/06/2022 12:37

I don't understand why you would be fine with sitting in the car even for 2 hours? Better of staying at home.

He didn't need to leave a&e, you could have gone to a cafe. I am not sure why he left after having waited so long, tbh.

catandcoffee · 01/06/2022 12:37

You sat for 6 Hours in car and you think you're in the wrong.

I think you deserve a medal for waiting so long. your boyfriend is a fully grown adult and shouldn't have put you in that position.

Maybe he suffers with health anxiety, and that's why no one can find anything wrong with him.
Ignore all the people on here taking you down. Your boyfriend should not be 'popping ' to A+E either. He's using it like his personal GP.

He should be apologising to you leaving you alone in a car for so long.

Choopi · 01/06/2022 12:35

If he’s ill enough for A&E how is he well enough to drive?

Why do people keep saying bollocks like this? One day dh was driving home from work and got a pain in his chest, he diverted to a&e he had a pulmonary embolism. I was having a miscarriage I felt hot and sick, I just knew something wasn't right, so I drove to hospital. I had sepsis. A&e doesn't mean you have to be unconscious.

In both dh and mine cases we both knew that something wasn't right, we didn't know what it was because we aren't Drs but we both knew that we needed to get seen fast. We live somewhere with limited transport options(2 taxis in the whole town and no buses). Sitting around hoping someone would come to our rescue wasn't really an option.

Knittingchamp · 01/06/2022 12:34

Tbh I think you both had classic hangriness - hungry plus angry due to horribly low blood sugar. Plus your boyfriend felt really Ill. I'd say big apology both sides, meant genuinely, recognition this was the hunger and frustration talking, and go from there.

WibblyWobblyJane · 01/06/2022 12:31

Emmelina · 01/06/2022 12:20

While he was wrong to call you that, it’s also not his fault you had to wait so long without food. You drove, you’re an adult. I assume you can source your own nourishment. A simple text “I’m going to find food, my battery is about to die so if I’m not back before you’re out just wait for me.” would have made this all the nicer.

OP didn't drive. It's his car and she's not insured to drive it. OP's main failure is just going along passively and allowing someone else to put her in a situation where she ultimately felt unsafe.

But you learn about people as time goes on. My DH would not leave me sitting in a car for hours on end. He would have planned ahead in the event it took hours. I would have done so, too, or at least have figured out a plan B before it got dark. But that's after being caught in enough situations where I eventually decided I cannot fully depend on others when it comes to my own safety.

ps: love your name!

Fenella123 · 01/06/2022 12:27

Oh goodness, you and your BF were tired, hungry, ill, stressed, and you had a bit of a spat directly because of this.

You read so many things on here where the row is the tip of an iceberg of conflict, but this, genuinely, seems to be a case where a couple should just kiss and make up.

One of the things I've learned as I got older was to apologize quickly and profusely if I snap because I'm tired/peckish/wound up. Believe me, that 30 seconds of grovelling saves sooooo much time and trouble!

Emmelina · 01/06/2022 12:23

Sorry, lost track of what was what in the million posts! You didn’t drive, but the suggestion is that you are able.

HelenHywater · 01/06/2022 12:23

It's very odd, I agree with pp on that. Deciding mid supermarket shop to go to A&E. You sitting in the car for 6 hours - you should just have gone home straight away. And yes, you could have got a cab home - gone into reception and ordered an Uber or phone the taxi line that is in most A&E reception areas.

And I don't understand his illness either really. If you need A&E, its urgent, so why is he waiting until tonight to go back? I assume he's gone to work. In which case he doesn't need A&E.

Emmelina · 01/06/2022 12:20

While he was wrong to call you that, it’s also not his fault you had to wait so long without food. You drove, you’re an adult. I assume you can source your own nourishment. A simple text “I’m going to find food, my battery is about to die so if I’m not back before you’re out just wait for me.” would have made this all the nicer.

Onwards22 · 01/06/2022 12:20

This was not the onset of a new, sudden, urgent pain. So he is using A&E to diagnose an ongoing issue. I am not judging that, but he could have planned this and he really did not need OP there waiting.

Yes he’s been having pain for a while but the pain in that instance was enough for him to go to A&E straight away.

OP was free to have a sleep, go home, go for a walk, go to a cafe, go shopping etc etc but he had to stay in one place, with the same charge on his phone as her and in pain.

People are acting like he was at a pub having fun - he wasn’t.
He would have been way more bored and fed up than her after waiting 6 hours.

If he forced OP to stay then I’d have sympathy but she could have gone home.

I have had to go to A&E before after ongoing problems and doctors appointments and I ended up being admitted with serious kidney failure.

I don’t think it’s fair to dismiss his pain just because he’s had this pain before.

LittleBearPad · 01/06/2022 12:18

You sat for 6 hours in a car and only got cheesed off when it was dark and your phone was out of power. You could have got a bus or taxi hours before.

Unless you’ve (and he) been living under a rock you were being unreasonable to think he’d be out in an hour or so and if he thought he’d be driving home it’s questionable that he needed to go to A&E in the first place.

SuziSecondLaw · 01/06/2022 12:16

I've only read the first post, not the follow-ups, but it just sounds like you were both really fed up and stressed and you both did and said things you didn't mean. I think you're both in the wrong really.. But also kinda understandable in the situation as it was.

BadNomad · 01/06/2022 12:16

They we’re having a normal day out going to the shops when he felt this pain. The pain was severe enough that he thought he should go straight to A&E and not get any of his stuff - you can’t plan that.

@Onwards22

No. This was not new pain. He had spent the day thinking about if he would go to A&E or not because he wasn't getting answers from other doctors. If so, the OP was going to drop him off, then pick him up again later in her car. He decided he wasn't going to go to A&E. But then when he was driving them to get groceries in his car, he changed his mind and took them both to A&E instead and said she could wait with him and it would only be for a couple of hours.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/06/2022 12:15

I don’t think your sound that unreasonable, just far too passive until things go to a point where your blood sugar was low, you were a bit soooked and you snapped.

His dithering about whether to go was the initial problem but I’d have said “I’ll drive anyway just in case”. Just in case he became too ill to drive for one thing.

Id also have made sure I picked up some food before committing to going to the hospital, as waits are always very long.

Afrer that Id have kept in touch within the waiting time to see how it was going and to judge if you needed to look for food / a taxi home before it got really late. In other words, don’t leave things so long you end up desperate and snapping - both of you needed to think ahead!

Antarcticant · 01/06/2022 12:14

He was obviously OK to drive himself there, so there was no reason for the OP to accompany him at all.

Mamapep · 01/06/2022 12:10

Why did you have to wait in the car? Why did he have to come back tomorrow? Drop him off, wait for him to call you.