Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Live-in nanny hints

133 replies

AdifferentGoat · 01/06/2022 08:43

Wasn't sure how to title this. I have a good nanny and currently she takes care of my toddler DD when I'm working (father isn't around much and we are currently going through a contentious divorce). So, as far as wages go, she's paid a decent amount and she had her own room/bathroom(given) and I pay for her food (she is welcome to eat anything in the fridge & pantry plus I buy her items she needs) alongside basic toiletries and of course health insurance. I mention the above not to reiterate some kind of 'generosity' on my part but more-so, to give context as to my dilemma.

Recently, she's been dropping hints as to things she needs but can't afford. She doesn't explicitly say she cannot afford them but more-so will say something like: I'd love to replace my contact lens but it's XXX amount of dollars. This will be followed by a sigh and she'll resume whatever she was doing. To be fair, she hasn't done this too often but it's made me uncomfortable. Naturally, I don't want her walking around half-blind but having had experience with a previous nanny who kept asking for more and more, I'm a bit cagey about a slippery slope. Now, I wouldn't have minded if she'd asked me directly and while I could afford it, I'm somewhat hesitant. Am I being unreasonable here? A part of me feels bad like she was waiting for me to offer up paying for her contact lens but another part is wondering why she's asking me? Has anyone faced this and how do you deal with it? Is this the nature of having a nanny? Is there hope out there that I can find a nanny that won't inevitably ask for loans and my buying her things. At risk of sounding redundant, yes I could afford it but there is a part of me that just feels I keep being asked for things or maybe I'm misreading the situation and she was just informing me that the cost was too high.

I know I'm also a bit high-strung these days with my ongoing divorce proceedings.

I know it's a pretty silly problem.

OP posts:
JustLyra · 01/06/2022 13:01

AdifferentGoat · 01/06/2022 11:47

So to answer a few questions, she has over thirty years of experience (along those lines). She came with glowing references so aside from calling two of her employers, I figured we were set (there was a time urgency too). She is a professional nanny and has been doing it for so very long that I felt quite at ease. Further, our communication was great. I know salary seems a lot but I do think where we live in the US plays a role (cost of living is high) and that factored in with her experience level alongside covid and the amazing repercussions. It all added up.

I suppose I wouldn't have even raised an issue if not for the hints. That and she's never done one overnight. I asked for the occasional overnight as I was working 16 hours one time (incredibly unusual at all, it was just a very time sensitive project) and I'd come home at midnight and sure she had the baby sleeping but I was shattered and had to be up 6 am the next morning and assumed she'd at the minimum do overnight so I could rest that night at least! I didn't think much of it them but I kind of think she should have at least offered especially considering the 'extras' I have given. Maybe this makes me sound a little tit for tat but surely it's not crazy unusual to do a overnight here and there?

Her usual routine with DD is breakfast and potter about, a walk and a little play and then it's nap time! During this time she does some of her work/rests and then I'm usually back and take over. DD will wake but she doesn't really take initiative to make lunch for her (sometimes but these days it's very hohum). I end up standing awkwardly around and end up usually doing it myself (which I am happy to) but it's hard as sometimes I'll have calls or just need even 30 minutes to myself. I'll take DD out then and/or play with her or just hang out. She will...I don't know? Sometimes she will take her out to the park around five and occasionally bathe her but it's more a request. Honestly I don't expect this around the clock, it does somewhat feel like I am "asking" her to do things. I do know she loves DD and I have never seen anything to give me concern but I think she's just...not all there??

I don't know where I am going with this but just explaining

Just for clarity - please tell me you did speak to her previous employers? Rather than just accepting written references she had?

An experienced nanny shouldn’t need asked or prompted to do, well, nannying tasks.

easyday · 01/06/2022 12:57

Jeez. £46k and she can't afford trainers or contact lenses? She's taking you for a mug.
You give her room and board and a great wage. I don't even see why you are providing basic health stuff - she should pay for anything personal, be that shampoo or trainers or whatever.
My sister has a nanny and pays her nothing like that but does provide her with a runaround car and probably her phone. Anything else is her responsibility.

Wiglio · 01/06/2022 12:54

Apple I’ve reported this for removal

Wiglio · 01/06/2022 12:50

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

TreadLightly3 · 01/06/2022 12:48

Hello lovely lady @AdifferentGoat I’m so happy to hear you are escaping your awful marriage and getting the life you deserve. Yes your nanny is taking the piss. If she keeps asking for things I would sit her down and have a frank conversation about it - ask her whether she thinks she isn’t paid enough when it’s over the market rate as you said, and if you don’t want to do that, just stop responding to the hints. She keeps doing it because she knows it works. So stop. Start dropping your own hints about how expensive things are these days and start making enquiries about getting a new nanny. She sounds like she’ll just get increasingly grabby and will never have enough from you. Good luck xx

ichifanny · 01/06/2022 12:17

To be honest I’d get her to be a live out nanny if she won’t even help out of hours , what benefit to you is there having her live in ?

Tistheseason17 · 01/06/2022 12:14

She is a nanny.
She should be bathing, feeding, playing with and nurturing your child as well as doing laundry and tidying up without being asked to. It's her job.

You are not required to cook her dinner or clean up after her.

She has got a nice job with a decent mum and she's a CF as she knows it's coming to an end.

She is not a poorly paid au pair who should be bought extras.

Personally, I'd sit her down and explain that she earns more than you from a take home perspective and she needs to manage her personal expenditure. You are not obliged to pay for sports shoes for the park and you expect her not to be asked to do her job - no other employer would allow an employee to not do what is expected.

Kanaloa · 01/06/2022 12:00

Gosh usually on mn I’m the first one to wade in and criticise someone for hiring an aupair and expecting a nanny, taking advantage of childcare staff etc. But this is a well paid professional nanny, not your niece who is helping you out for a few weeks! You don’t need to buy your nanny’s toiletries and you certainly shouldn’t be buying her sports shoes and contact lenses. It’s really inappropriate. Does she seem appropriate and professional otherwise? I’d have thought it was pretty inappropriate to accept/ask for gifts from your employer.

ErickBroch · 01/06/2022 11:55

100% CF - you are generous so she is hoping you will pay for even more bits.

Bonjovispjs · 01/06/2022 11:55

I have thirty years experience with glowing references too, but still don't earn that! I don't behave like that either, I do everything in my job description and more besides without complaining as I'm happy to 'muck in'

AdifferentGoat · 01/06/2022 11:47

So to answer a few questions, she has over thirty years of experience (along those lines). She came with glowing references so aside from calling two of her employers, I figured we were set (there was a time urgency too). She is a professional nanny and has been doing it for so very long that I felt quite at ease. Further, our communication was great. I know salary seems a lot but I do think where we live in the US plays a role (cost of living is high) and that factored in with her experience level alongside covid and the amazing repercussions. It all added up.

I suppose I wouldn't have even raised an issue if not for the hints. That and she's never done one overnight. I asked for the occasional overnight as I was working 16 hours one time (incredibly unusual at all, it was just a very time sensitive project) and I'd come home at midnight and sure she had the baby sleeping but I was shattered and had to be up 6 am the next morning and assumed she'd at the minimum do overnight so I could rest that night at least! I didn't think much of it them but I kind of think she should have at least offered especially considering the 'extras' I have given. Maybe this makes me sound a little tit for tat but surely it's not crazy unusual to do a overnight here and there?

Her usual routine with DD is breakfast and potter about, a walk and a little play and then it's nap time! During this time she does some of her work/rests and then I'm usually back and take over. DD will wake but she doesn't really take initiative to make lunch for her (sometimes but these days it's very hohum). I end up standing awkwardly around and end up usually doing it myself (which I am happy to) but it's hard as sometimes I'll have calls or just need even 30 minutes to myself. I'll take DD out then and/or play with her or just hang out. She will...I don't know? Sometimes she will take her out to the park around five and occasionally bathe her but it's more a request. Honestly I don't expect this around the clock, it does somewhat feel like I am "asking" her to do things. I do know she loves DD and I have never seen anything to give me concern but I think she's just...not all there??

I don't know where I am going with this but just explaining

OP posts:
AdifferentGoat · 01/06/2022 11:35

moose62 · 01/06/2022 11:09

When DD goes to nursery why don't you get a younger, more adaptable and helpful nanny on a reduced salary. Your soon to be ex probably won't care as it will be saving money.

Thats what I am thinking. My work involves travel at times so it would be hard to get babysitting at short notice. That and for all his spewing, I cannot relay on ex at all. There have just been too many incidences in which he said he would babysit and bailed last second due to a work "crisis". I can't afford this kind of money and further, even though ex has already said he's fine with continuing to pay for DD's nanny, I assume anything could change..

OP posts:
HalfGerman · 01/06/2022 11:34

Me too @MaryBeardsShoes - full-time teacher with an Oxford degree, Cambridge postgrad, and over ten years’ experience and I don’t earn that! 😂

TabithaTittlemouse · 01/06/2022 11:29

She is taking you for a ride!

Practice blank face when she makes these hints or even better join in and hint that you can’t cope without the vintage wine.

MaryBeardsShoes · 01/06/2022 11:14

£46k fuck me I need to change career.

LapinR0se · 01/06/2022 11:10

Which country are you in and which country is she from?

moose62 · 01/06/2022 11:09

When DD goes to nursery why don't you get a younger, more adaptable and helpful nanny on a reduced salary. Your soon to be ex probably won't care as it will be saving money.

Skinnermarink · 01/06/2022 11:07

And this is someone you trust and pay to look after your child… all very odd.

Bonjovispjs · 01/06/2022 11:06

Wow, I can't believe what you're paying her, I've been a professional nanny for 30 years and I'm on £40,000 but I live out and have obviously worked my way up to that over the years! What you're doing and putting up with just doesn't make sense!

Skinnermarink · 01/06/2022 11:02

Well it beggars belief to be honest. In 15 years of high-end nannying I’ve never come across anything like it.

AdifferentGoat · 01/06/2022 10:52

violetbunny · 01/06/2022 10:38

I think the problem is you've set a precedent. In buying her the shoes, you've told her through your behaviour that if she wants something and hints at it, you may buy it for her. Stop being so generous and she will likely stop the hinting.

You are absolutely right. I still remember where I was standing the day I offered to buy the shoes. She walked out of her room and I recall telling her it was a pleasant day and herself and DD should go to the park and enjoy it. It was then, she looked down at her feet and said it is very difficult to walk without sports shoes.

It really is my fault when I think about it. I suppose I was looking it as just making her comfortable? Also, all the "lost" looks because she cannot figure out how to "transport" herself to some place she needed to go to and was "scared" to hail down a cab or take a bus as it was very late at night. Maybe she is that hapless? Who knows. It's just awkward when someone tells you how they "don't know something" and feel lost and what do they do? She knows I live on my computer. Maybe she's that technologically unaware? Very confusing indeed. However doesn't change reality that I have to take ownership of this and try and shift it somehow.

It's very late where I am but I'm working on a plan re a chat about budgeting for her

OP posts:
SleeplessInEngland · 01/06/2022 10:42

Let her hint till the cows come home. She can easily afford that with her wage and lack of rent/bills.

Onwards22 · 01/06/2022 10:41

I was just thinking I couldn’t imagine walking around work moaning about my roles that are in my job description and how I can’t afford contact lenses in ear shot of my boss.

Then I realised I have one of these at my work!
Constantly moans about every little thing.
She asked us recently if she could do lunch duty every day (school) as she needs the extra money and then complained about not being able to sit and eat her lunch at the normal time. We said we’d be happy to take our duties back as we could do with the money too but she said no.
And there’s loads of examples where she just moans - I think some people like people to feel sorry for them and are just moaners.

Although she doesn’t hint for money to buy things which would actually push me over the edge!

Just hold your ground OP. It won’t be long until your DD is old enough to not need her anymore.

Off to find a job that pays £46k whilst looking after a cute baby.

violetbunny · 01/06/2022 10:38

I think the problem is you've set a precedent. In buying her the shoes, you've told her through your behaviour that if she wants something and hints at it, you may buy it for her. Stop being so generous and she will likely stop the hinting.

AdifferentGoat · 01/06/2022 10:34

ElenaSt · 01/06/2022 10:14

I would really hate that. She's obviously trying to push our luck and the hinting is extremely manipulative.

Every time she hints I would I ask her if she needs any help making a spreadsheet for budgeting her finances.

I'm afraid to ask her this. She may say she can't see a spreadsheet now that I'm effectively forcing her to work half-blind 😀

I will bring it up though as it seems rather insane that she polishes through her wages. Maybe she's bad with money or loses track?

OP posts: